Effects of clayish and sandy soils on the growth of Prosopis argentina and P. alpataco seedlings

Prosopis alpataco Burk. and P. argentina Phil. occupy areas with different soil characteristics within the arid zone of Argentina. Prosopis alpataco occurs in periodically flooded, clayish and saline soils, whereas P. argentina occurs in non-saline sand dunes. The capability to occupy these different habitats might be related to the presence of different adaptive features in these two species. We analyzed seedling growth of both species on clayish and sandy soils. Their emergence percentages, seedling height, biomass, and leaf area were measured in a factorial experiment (species x soils) carried out in a greenhouse. Both species showed a higher growth rate (height, biomass, leaf area and number of leaves and shoot-root ratios) in clayish soils. In sandy soils, the growth rate of P. alpataco was lower than that of P. argentina, indicating that the detrimental effects of sandy soils were greater for P. alpataco. We suggest that soil effects on growth could be due to the differences in nutrient (especially nitrogen) availability, and that P. argentina shows adaptations to sandy soils which are absent in P. alpataco. These results could explain the exclusion of P. alpataco from sandy soils but not that of P. argentina from clayish soils. Exclusion of this last species should be associated with other environmental factors like flooding or salinity, or with biological factors such as competition.

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Villagra, Pablo E., Cavagnaro, Juan B.
Format: Digital revista
Language:eng
Published: Asociación Argentina de Ecología 2000
Online Access:https://ojs.ecologiaaustral.com.ar/index.php/Ecologia_Austral/article/view/1587
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
id rev-ecoaus-article-1587
record_format ojs
spelling rev-ecoaus-article-15872021-01-13T23:16:41Z Effects of clayish and sandy soils on the growth of Prosopis argentina and P. alpataco seedlings Efecto de los suelos arcillosos y arenosos en el crecimiento de plántulas de Prosopis argentina y P. alpataco Villagra, Pablo E. Cavagnaro, Juan B. Prosopis alpataco Burk. and P. argentina Phil. occupy areas with different soil characteristics within the arid zone of Argentina. Prosopis alpataco occurs in periodically flooded, clayish and saline soils, whereas P. argentina occurs in non-saline sand dunes. The capability to occupy these different habitats might be related to the presence of different adaptive features in these two species. We analyzed seedling growth of both species on clayish and sandy soils. Their emergence percentages, seedling height, biomass, and leaf area were measured in a factorial experiment (species x soils) carried out in a greenhouse. Both species showed a higher growth rate (height, biomass, leaf area and number of leaves and shoot-root ratios) in clayish soils. In sandy soils, the growth rate of P. alpataco was lower than that of P. argentina, indicating that the detrimental effects of sandy soils were greater for P. alpataco. We suggest that soil effects on growth could be due to the differences in nutrient (especially nitrogen) availability, and that P. argentina shows adaptations to sandy soils which are absent in P. alpataco. These results could explain the exclusion of P. alpataco from sandy soils but not that of P. argentina from clayish soils. Exclusion of this last species should be associated with other environmental factors like flooding or salinity, or with biological factors such as competition. Prosopis alpataco Burk. y P. argentina Phil. ocupan áreas con características edáficas diferentes dentro de la zona árida Argentina. Prosopis alpataco se encuentra en suelos arcillosos y salinos, sometidos a inundaciones esporádicas, mientras que P. argentina se encuentra en los suelos arenosos, no salinos, de los médanos. La capacidad de ocupar estos ambientes estaría relacionada con la presencia de diferentes adaptaciones en estas dos especies. En este trabajo, analizamos comparativamente el crecimiento de plántulas de ambas especies en suelos arenosos y arcillosos. El porcentaje de emergencia, la altura, la biomasa y el área foliar de las plántulas fueron medidos en un experimento factorial (especies x suelos) llevado a cabo en condiciones de invernáculo. Las dos especies muestran una mayor velocidad de crecimiento en (altura, biomasa, área foliar, número de hojas y relación vástago-raíz) en suelos arcillosos. En suelos arenosos, la tasa de crecimiento de P. alpataco fue menor que el de P. argentina, indicando que el efecto perjudicial de los suelos arenosos fue mayor en P. alpataco. Sugerimos que los efectos del suelo sobre el crecimiento podrían deberse a las diferencias en la disponibilidad de nutrientes, especialmente nitrógeno, y que P. argentina tiene adaptaciones a los suelos arenosos que están ausentes en P. alpataco. Estos resultados podrían explicar la exclusión de P. alpataco de los suelos arenosos pero no la exclusión de P. argentina de los suelos arcillosos. En este caso la exclusión debe relacionarse con otros factores como el anegamiento, la salinidad o con el efecto de interacciones biológicas como la competencia. Asociación Argentina de Ecología 2000-12-01 info:eu-repo/semantics/article info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion Artículos application/pdf https://ojs.ecologiaaustral.com.ar/index.php/Ecologia_Austral/article/view/1587 Ecología Austral; Vol. 10 No. 2 (2000); 113-121 Ecología Austral; Vol. 10 Núm. 2 (2000); 113-121 0327-5477 1667-7838 eng https://ojs.ecologiaaustral.com.ar/index.php/Ecologia_Austral/article/view/1587/921 Derechos de autor 2021 Ecología Austral
institution AUSTRAL
collection OJS
country Argentina
countrycode AR
component Revista
access En linea
databasecode rev-ecoaus
tag revista
region America del Sur
libraryname Asociación Argentina de Ecología
language eng
format Digital
author Villagra, Pablo E.
Cavagnaro, Juan B.
spellingShingle Villagra, Pablo E.
Cavagnaro, Juan B.
Effects of clayish and sandy soils on the growth of Prosopis argentina and P. alpataco seedlings
author_facet Villagra, Pablo E.
Cavagnaro, Juan B.
author_sort Villagra, Pablo E.
title Effects of clayish and sandy soils on the growth of Prosopis argentina and P. alpataco seedlings
title_short Effects of clayish and sandy soils on the growth of Prosopis argentina and P. alpataco seedlings
title_full Effects of clayish and sandy soils on the growth of Prosopis argentina and P. alpataco seedlings
title_fullStr Effects of clayish and sandy soils on the growth of Prosopis argentina and P. alpataco seedlings
title_full_unstemmed Effects of clayish and sandy soils on the growth of Prosopis argentina and P. alpataco seedlings
title_sort effects of clayish and sandy soils on the growth of prosopis argentina and p. alpataco seedlings
description Prosopis alpataco Burk. and P. argentina Phil. occupy areas with different soil characteristics within the arid zone of Argentina. Prosopis alpataco occurs in periodically flooded, clayish and saline soils, whereas P. argentina occurs in non-saline sand dunes. The capability to occupy these different habitats might be related to the presence of different adaptive features in these two species. We analyzed seedling growth of both species on clayish and sandy soils. Their emergence percentages, seedling height, biomass, and leaf area were measured in a factorial experiment (species x soils) carried out in a greenhouse. Both species showed a higher growth rate (height, biomass, leaf area and number of leaves and shoot-root ratios) in clayish soils. In sandy soils, the growth rate of P. alpataco was lower than that of P. argentina, indicating that the detrimental effects of sandy soils were greater for P. alpataco. We suggest that soil effects on growth could be due to the differences in nutrient (especially nitrogen) availability, and that P. argentina shows adaptations to sandy soils which are absent in P. alpataco. These results could explain the exclusion of P. alpataco from sandy soils but not that of P. argentina from clayish soils. Exclusion of this last species should be associated with other environmental factors like flooding or salinity, or with biological factors such as competition.
publisher Asociación Argentina de Ecología
publishDate 2000
url https://ojs.ecologiaaustral.com.ar/index.php/Ecologia_Austral/article/view/1587
work_keys_str_mv AT villagrapabloe effectsofclayishandsandysoilsonthegrowthofprosopisargentinaandpalpatacoseedlings
AT cavagnarojuanb effectsofclayishandsandysoilsonthegrowthofprosopisargentinaandpalpatacoseedlings
AT villagrapabloe efectodelossuelosarcillososyarenososenelcrecimientodeplantulasdeprosopisargentinaypalpataco
AT cavagnarojuanb efectodelossuelosarcillososyarenososenelcrecimientodeplantulasdeprosopisargentinaypalpataco
_version_ 1755912506995376128