Conceptual and Methodological Elements for Cumulative Environmental Effects Assessment (CEEA) in Subtropical Forests. The Case of Eastern Salta, Argentina

Northern Argentina experienced an unprecedented deforestation rate of xerophitic forests as a consequence of agricultural expansion. In the Province of Salta, 26% of the forest were removed between 1977 and 2008. At the end of 2007, just before the No. 26331 Law of Native Forest Protection was voted by the Congress, the highest annual rate of deforestation was registered, reaching a value of 2.1%. Regarding this situation, indigenous people of Eastern Salta along with the “criollos” (local small ranchers) appealed to the National Supreme Court of Justice for legal protection. The Court requested the province to elaborate a Cumulative Environmental Effects Assessment (CEEA) regarding the process of logging and deforestation in four departments of Salta Province (San Martín, Rivadavia, Santa Victoria, and Orán). The aim of this work is to present a conceptual framework to conduct a CEEA in eastern Salta and to present the evidences and existing methodologies to characterize the impacts of deforestation. The conceptual framework suggested depends on the quantitative characterization of the changes in the provision level of key ecosystem services as a function of the stress and/or disturbance level (in this case deforestation). Based on the literature and our own data, the effects of deforestation on four key ecosystem services have been assessed: C dynamics, energy balance and greenhouse gases emissions, water dynamics and landscape structure. Deforestation produced emissions of 2000 t of CH4, 200 t of N2O, above 20 Gg of C/year, a 1.1 watt/m2 reduction in reflected radiation and 4400 TJ radiative energy emissions caused by deforestation fires, increases in the risk of soil salinization and landscape fragmentation. Considering these aspects of the structure and functioning of the ecosystems provides objective elements to evaluate management alternatives and to elaborate monitoring programmes. To consider such management and monitoring alternatives arises technical challenges but also institutional and political ones.

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Paruelo, José M., Verón, Santiago R., Volante, José N., Seghezzo, Lucas, Vallejos, María, Aguiar, Sebastián, Amdan, Laura, Baldassini, Pablo, Ciuffolif, Lucía, Huykman, Natalia, Davanzo, Bárbara, González, Eliana, Landesmann , Jennifer, Picardi, Daniela
Format: Digital revista
Language:spa
Published: Asociación Argentina de Ecología 2011
Online Access:https://ojs.ecologiaaustral.com.ar/index.php/Ecologia_Austral/article/view/1283
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
id rev-ecoaus-article-1283
record_format ojs
institution AUSTRAL
collection OJS
country Argentina
countrycode AR
component Revista
access En linea
databasecode rev-ecoaus
tag revista
region America del Sur
libraryname Asociación Argentina de Ecología
language spa
format Digital
author Paruelo, José M.
Verón, Santiago R.
Volante, José N.
Seghezzo, Lucas
Vallejos, María
Aguiar, Sebastián
Amdan, Laura
Baldassini, Pablo
Ciuffolif, Lucía
Huykman, Natalia
Davanzo, Bárbara
González, Eliana
Landesmann , Jennifer
Picardi, Daniela
spellingShingle Paruelo, José M.
Verón, Santiago R.
Volante, José N.
Seghezzo, Lucas
Vallejos, María
Aguiar, Sebastián
Amdan, Laura
Baldassini, Pablo
Ciuffolif, Lucía
Huykman, Natalia
Davanzo, Bárbara
González, Eliana
Landesmann , Jennifer
Picardi, Daniela
Conceptual and Methodological Elements for Cumulative Environmental Effects Assessment (CEEA) in Subtropical Forests. The Case of Eastern Salta, Argentina
author_facet Paruelo, José M.
Verón, Santiago R.
Volante, José N.
Seghezzo, Lucas
Vallejos, María
Aguiar, Sebastián
Amdan, Laura
Baldassini, Pablo
Ciuffolif, Lucía
Huykman, Natalia
Davanzo, Bárbara
González, Eliana
Landesmann , Jennifer
Picardi, Daniela
author_sort Paruelo, José M.
title Conceptual and Methodological Elements for Cumulative Environmental Effects Assessment (CEEA) in Subtropical Forests. The Case of Eastern Salta, Argentina
title_short Conceptual and Methodological Elements for Cumulative Environmental Effects Assessment (CEEA) in Subtropical Forests. The Case of Eastern Salta, Argentina
title_full Conceptual and Methodological Elements for Cumulative Environmental Effects Assessment (CEEA) in Subtropical Forests. The Case of Eastern Salta, Argentina
title_fullStr Conceptual and Methodological Elements for Cumulative Environmental Effects Assessment (CEEA) in Subtropical Forests. The Case of Eastern Salta, Argentina
title_full_unstemmed Conceptual and Methodological Elements for Cumulative Environmental Effects Assessment (CEEA) in Subtropical Forests. The Case of Eastern Salta, Argentina
title_sort conceptual and methodological elements for cumulative environmental effects assessment (ceea) in subtropical forests. the case of eastern salta, argentina
description Northern Argentina experienced an unprecedented deforestation rate of xerophitic forests as a consequence of agricultural expansion. In the Province of Salta, 26% of the forest were removed between 1977 and 2008. At the end of 2007, just before the No. 26331 Law of Native Forest Protection was voted by the Congress, the highest annual rate of deforestation was registered, reaching a value of 2.1%. Regarding this situation, indigenous people of Eastern Salta along with the “criollos” (local small ranchers) appealed to the National Supreme Court of Justice for legal protection. The Court requested the province to elaborate a Cumulative Environmental Effects Assessment (CEEA) regarding the process of logging and deforestation in four departments of Salta Province (San Martín, Rivadavia, Santa Victoria, and Orán). The aim of this work is to present a conceptual framework to conduct a CEEA in eastern Salta and to present the evidences and existing methodologies to characterize the impacts of deforestation. The conceptual framework suggested depends on the quantitative characterization of the changes in the provision level of key ecosystem services as a function of the stress and/or disturbance level (in this case deforestation). Based on the literature and our own data, the effects of deforestation on four key ecosystem services have been assessed: C dynamics, energy balance and greenhouse gases emissions, water dynamics and landscape structure. Deforestation produced emissions of 2000 t of CH4, 200 t of N2O, above 20 Gg of C/year, a 1.1 watt/m2 reduction in reflected radiation and 4400 TJ radiative energy emissions caused by deforestation fires, increases in the risk of soil salinization and landscape fragmentation. Considering these aspects of the structure and functioning of the ecosystems provides objective elements to evaluate management alternatives and to elaborate monitoring programmes. To consider such management and monitoring alternatives arises technical challenges but also institutional and political ones.
publisher Asociación Argentina de Ecología
publishDate 2011
url https://ojs.ecologiaaustral.com.ar/index.php/Ecologia_Austral/article/view/1283
work_keys_str_mv AT paruelojosem conceptualandmethodologicalelementsforcumulativeenvironmentaleffectsassessmentceeainsubtropicalforeststhecaseofeasternsaltaargentina
AT veronsantiagor conceptualandmethodologicalelementsforcumulativeenvironmentaleffectsassessmentceeainsubtropicalforeststhecaseofeasternsaltaargentina
AT volantejosen conceptualandmethodologicalelementsforcumulativeenvironmentaleffectsassessmentceeainsubtropicalforeststhecaseofeasternsaltaargentina
AT seghezzolucas conceptualandmethodologicalelementsforcumulativeenvironmentaleffectsassessmentceeainsubtropicalforeststhecaseofeasternsaltaargentina
AT vallejosmaria conceptualandmethodologicalelementsforcumulativeenvironmentaleffectsassessmentceeainsubtropicalforeststhecaseofeasternsaltaargentina
AT aguiarsebastian conceptualandmethodologicalelementsforcumulativeenvironmentaleffectsassessmentceeainsubtropicalforeststhecaseofeasternsaltaargentina
AT amdanlaura conceptualandmethodologicalelementsforcumulativeenvironmentaleffectsassessmentceeainsubtropicalforeststhecaseofeasternsaltaargentina
AT baldassinipablo conceptualandmethodologicalelementsforcumulativeenvironmentaleffectsassessmentceeainsubtropicalforeststhecaseofeasternsaltaargentina
AT ciuffoliflucia conceptualandmethodologicalelementsforcumulativeenvironmentaleffectsassessmentceeainsubtropicalforeststhecaseofeasternsaltaargentina
AT huykmannatalia conceptualandmethodologicalelementsforcumulativeenvironmentaleffectsassessmentceeainsubtropicalforeststhecaseofeasternsaltaargentina
AT davanzobarbara conceptualandmethodologicalelementsforcumulativeenvironmentaleffectsassessmentceeainsubtropicalforeststhecaseofeasternsaltaargentina
AT gonzalezeliana conceptualandmethodologicalelementsforcumulativeenvironmentaleffectsassessmentceeainsubtropicalforeststhecaseofeasternsaltaargentina
AT landesmannjennifer conceptualandmethodologicalelementsforcumulativeenvironmentaleffectsassessmentceeainsubtropicalforeststhecaseofeasternsaltaargentina
AT picardidaniela conceptualandmethodologicalelementsforcumulativeenvironmentaleffectsassessmentceeainsubtropicalforeststhecaseofeasternsaltaargentina
AT paruelojosem elementosconceptualesymetodologicosparalaevaluaciondeimpactosambientalesacumulativoseiaacenbosquessubtropicaleselcasodelestedesaltaargentina
AT veronsantiagor elementosconceptualesymetodologicosparalaevaluaciondeimpactosambientalesacumulativoseiaacenbosquessubtropicaleselcasodelestedesaltaargentina
AT volantejosen elementosconceptualesymetodologicosparalaevaluaciondeimpactosambientalesacumulativoseiaacenbosquessubtropicaleselcasodelestedesaltaargentina
AT seghezzolucas elementosconceptualesymetodologicosparalaevaluaciondeimpactosambientalesacumulativoseiaacenbosquessubtropicaleselcasodelestedesaltaargentina
AT vallejosmaria elementosconceptualesymetodologicosparalaevaluaciondeimpactosambientalesacumulativoseiaacenbosquessubtropicaleselcasodelestedesaltaargentina
AT aguiarsebastian elementosconceptualesymetodologicosparalaevaluaciondeimpactosambientalesacumulativoseiaacenbosquessubtropicaleselcasodelestedesaltaargentina
AT amdanlaura elementosconceptualesymetodologicosparalaevaluaciondeimpactosambientalesacumulativoseiaacenbosquessubtropicaleselcasodelestedesaltaargentina
AT baldassinipablo elementosconceptualesymetodologicosparalaevaluaciondeimpactosambientalesacumulativoseiaacenbosquessubtropicaleselcasodelestedesaltaargentina
AT ciuffoliflucia elementosconceptualesymetodologicosparalaevaluaciondeimpactosambientalesacumulativoseiaacenbosquessubtropicaleselcasodelestedesaltaargentina
AT huykmannatalia elementosconceptualesymetodologicosparalaevaluaciondeimpactosambientalesacumulativoseiaacenbosquessubtropicaleselcasodelestedesaltaargentina
AT davanzobarbara elementosconceptualesymetodologicosparalaevaluaciondeimpactosambientalesacumulativoseiaacenbosquessubtropicaleselcasodelestedesaltaargentina
AT gonzalezeliana elementosconceptualesymetodologicosparalaevaluaciondeimpactosambientalesacumulativoseiaacenbosquessubtropicaleselcasodelestedesaltaargentina
AT landesmannjennifer elementosconceptualesymetodologicosparalaevaluaciondeimpactosambientalesacumulativoseiaacenbosquessubtropicaleselcasodelestedesaltaargentina
AT picardidaniela elementosconceptualesymetodologicosparalaevaluaciondeimpactosambientalesacumulativoseiaacenbosquessubtropicaleselcasodelestedesaltaargentina
_version_ 1787234031808544768
spelling rev-ecoaus-article-12832023-11-02T20:57:32Z Conceptual and Methodological Elements for Cumulative Environmental Effects Assessment (CEEA) in Subtropical Forests. The Case of Eastern Salta, Argentina Elementos conceptuales y metodológicos para la Evaluación de Impactos Ambientales Acumulativos (EIAAc) en bosques subtropicales. El caso del este de Salta, Argentina Paruelo, José M. Verón, Santiago R. Volante, José N. Seghezzo, Lucas Vallejos, María Aguiar, Sebastián Amdan, Laura Baldassini, Pablo Ciuffolif, Lucía Huykman, Natalia Davanzo, Bárbara González, Eliana Landesmann , Jennifer Picardi, Daniela deforestation evapotranspiration landscape fragmentation carbon gains greenhouse gases land use change deforestación evapotranspiración fragmentación del paisaje ganancias de carbono gases efecto invernadero cambio en el uso del suelo Northern Argentina experienced an unprecedented deforestation rate of xerophitic forests as a consequence of agricultural expansion. In the Province of Salta, 26% of the forest were removed between 1977 and 2008. At the end of 2007, just before the No. 26331 Law of Native Forest Protection was voted by the Congress, the highest annual rate of deforestation was registered, reaching a value of 2.1%. Regarding this situation, indigenous people of Eastern Salta along with the “criollos” (local small ranchers) appealed to the National Supreme Court of Justice for legal protection. The Court requested the province to elaborate a Cumulative Environmental Effects Assessment (CEEA) regarding the process of logging and deforestation in four departments of Salta Province (San Martín, Rivadavia, Santa Victoria, and Orán). The aim of this work is to present a conceptual framework to conduct a CEEA in eastern Salta and to present the evidences and existing methodologies to characterize the impacts of deforestation. The conceptual framework suggested depends on the quantitative characterization of the changes in the provision level of key ecosystem services as a function of the stress and/or disturbance level (in this case deforestation). Based on the literature and our own data, the effects of deforestation on four key ecosystem services have been assessed: C dynamics, energy balance and greenhouse gases emissions, water dynamics and landscape structure. Deforestation produced emissions of 2000 t of CH4, 200 t of N2O, above 20 Gg of C/year, a 1.1 watt/m2 reduction in reflected radiation and 4400 TJ radiative energy emissions caused by deforestation fires, increases in the risk of soil salinization and landscape fragmentation. Considering these aspects of the structure and functioning of the ecosystems provides objective elements to evaluate management alternatives and to elaborate monitoring programmes. To consider such management and monitoring alternatives arises technical challenges but also institutional and political ones. En el norte argentino se ha producido una fuerte expansión agropecuaria a costa del desmonte de bosques xerofíticos. En la Provincia de Salta, entre 1977 y 2008 se desmontó 26% del total de bosques existentes. A fines de 2007, frente a la inminente sanción de la Ley No 26331 de Presupuestos Mínimos de Protección Ambiental de los Bosques Nativos, se registra el valor más alto de la historia con una tasa de desmonte de 2.1%. Frente a esta situación, comunidades originarias y criollas del este de Salta presentaron un recurso de amparo a la Corte Suprema de Justicia de la Nación, la cual solicitó a esta provincia la elaboración de una Evaluación de Impacto Ambiental Acumulativo (EIAAc) de los procesos de tala y desmonte en 4 departamentos. Los objetivos de este trabajo son proponer un marco conceptual para la EIAAc en el este de Salta y presentar evidencias y metodologías disponibles para la caracterización de esos impactos a partir de datos propios y de la literatura. El marco conceptual propuesto se basa en la cuantificación de los cambios en los niveles de provisión de servicios ecosistémicos (SE) en función de los factores de estrés y perturbación más importantes. Se analizaron los efectos del desmonte sobre cuatro SE clave: dinámica del C, balance de energía y emisión de gases con efecto invernadero (GEI), dinámica del agua y estructura del paisaje. Los desmontes generan emisiones de C superiores a 20 Gg C/año, disminuciones en la reflectancia de 1.1 watt/m2 , emisiones de 2000 t de CH4, 200 t de N2O y 4400 TJ de energía radiativa por fuegos, aumentos del riesgo de salinización de suelos y fragmentación del paisaje. La consideración de estos aspectos provee elementos objetivos para la evaluación de alternativas de manejo y la elaboración de planes de seguimiento. Esto plantea no sólo desafíos técnicos sino también institucionales y políticos. Asociación Argentina de Ecología 2011-08-01 info:eu-repo/semantics/article info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion Review Revisión application/pdf https://ojs.ecologiaaustral.com.ar/index.php/Ecologia_Austral/article/view/1283 Ecología Austral; Vol. 21 No. 2 (2011): August 2011, Pages 121-229; 163-178 Ecología Austral; Vol. 21 Núm. 2 (2011): August 2011, Pages 121-229; 163-178 1667-782X 0327-5477 spa https://ojs.ecologiaaustral.com.ar/index.php/Ecologia_Austral/article/view/1283/653 Derechos de autor 2020 José M. Paruelo, Santiago R. Verón, José N. Volante, Lucas Seghezzo, María Vallejos, Sebastián Aguiar, Laura Amdan, Pablo Baldassini, Lucía Ciuffolif, Natalia Huykman, Bárbara Davanzo, Eliana González, Jennifer Landesmann , Daniela Picardi https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/