Can the learning of laparoscopic skills be quantified by the measurements of skill parameters performed in a virtual reality simulator?

Purpose To ensure patient safety and surgical efficiency, much emphasis has been placed on the training of laparoscopic skills using virtual reality simulators. The purpose of this study was to determine whether laparoscopic skills can be objectively quantified by measuring specific skill parameters during training in a virtual reality surgical simulator (VRSS). Materials and Methods Ten medical students (with no laparoscopic experience) and ten urology residents (PGY3-5 with limited laparoscopic experience) were recruited to participate in a ten-week training course in basic laparoscopic skills (camera, cutting, peg transfer and clipping skills) on a VRSS. Data were collected from the training sessions. The time that individuals took to complete each task and the errors that they made were analyzed independently. Results The mean time that individuals took to complete tasks was significantly different between the groups (p < 0.05), with the residents being faster than the medical students. The residents' group also completed the tasks with fewer errors. The majority of the subjects in both groups exhibited a significant improvement in their task completion time and error rate. Conclusion The findings in this study demonstrate that laparoscopic skills can be objectively measured in a VRSS based on quantified skill parameters, including the time spent to complete skill tasks and the associated error rate. We conclude that a VRSS is a feasible tool for training and assessing basic laparoscopic skills.

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Sandy,Natascha Silva, Cruz,Jose Arnaldo Shiomi da, Passerotti,Carlo Camargo, Nguyen,Hiep, Reis,Sabrina Thalita dos, Gouveia,Eder Maxwell, Duarte,Ricardo Jordao, Bruschini,Homero, Srougi,Miguel
Format: Digital revista
Language:English
Published: Sociedade Brasileira de Urologia 2013
Online Access:http://old.scielo.br/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S1677-55382013000300371
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
id oai:scielo:S1677-55382013000300371
record_format ojs
spelling oai:scielo:S1677-553820130003003712013-08-16Can the learning of laparoscopic skills be quantified by the measurements of skill parameters performed in a virtual reality simulator?Sandy,Natascha SilvaCruz,Jose Arnaldo Shiomi daPasserotti,Carlo CamargoNguyen,HiepReis,Sabrina Thalita dosGouveia,Eder MaxwellDuarte,Ricardo JordaoBruschini,HomeroSrougi,Miguel Virtual Reality Exposure Therapy Education Laparoscopy Purpose To ensure patient safety and surgical efficiency, much emphasis has been placed on the training of laparoscopic skills using virtual reality simulators. The purpose of this study was to determine whether laparoscopic skills can be objectively quantified by measuring specific skill parameters during training in a virtual reality surgical simulator (VRSS). Materials and Methods Ten medical students (with no laparoscopic experience) and ten urology residents (PGY3-5 with limited laparoscopic experience) were recruited to participate in a ten-week training course in basic laparoscopic skills (camera, cutting, peg transfer and clipping skills) on a VRSS. Data were collected from the training sessions. The time that individuals took to complete each task and the errors that they made were analyzed independently. Results The mean time that individuals took to complete tasks was significantly different between the groups (p < 0.05), with the residents being faster than the medical students. The residents' group also completed the tasks with fewer errors. The majority of the subjects in both groups exhibited a significant improvement in their task completion time and error rate. Conclusion The findings in this study demonstrate that laparoscopic skills can be objectively measured in a VRSS based on quantified skill parameters, including the time spent to complete skill tasks and the associated error rate. We conclude that a VRSS is a feasible tool for training and assessing basic laparoscopic skills. info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccessSociedade Brasileira de UrologiaInternational braz j urol v.39 n.3 20132013-06-01info:eu-repo/semantics/articletext/htmlhttp://old.scielo.br/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S1677-55382013000300371en10.1590/S1677-5538.IBJU.2013.03.10
institution SCIELO
collection OJS
country Brasil
countrycode BR
component Revista
access En linea
databasecode rev-scielo-br
tag revista
region America del Sur
libraryname SciELO
language English
format Digital
author Sandy,Natascha Silva
Cruz,Jose Arnaldo Shiomi da
Passerotti,Carlo Camargo
Nguyen,Hiep
Reis,Sabrina Thalita dos
Gouveia,Eder Maxwell
Duarte,Ricardo Jordao
Bruschini,Homero
Srougi,Miguel
spellingShingle Sandy,Natascha Silva
Cruz,Jose Arnaldo Shiomi da
Passerotti,Carlo Camargo
Nguyen,Hiep
Reis,Sabrina Thalita dos
Gouveia,Eder Maxwell
Duarte,Ricardo Jordao
Bruschini,Homero
Srougi,Miguel
Can the learning of laparoscopic skills be quantified by the measurements of skill parameters performed in a virtual reality simulator?
author_facet Sandy,Natascha Silva
Cruz,Jose Arnaldo Shiomi da
Passerotti,Carlo Camargo
Nguyen,Hiep
Reis,Sabrina Thalita dos
Gouveia,Eder Maxwell
Duarte,Ricardo Jordao
Bruschini,Homero
Srougi,Miguel
author_sort Sandy,Natascha Silva
title Can the learning of laparoscopic skills be quantified by the measurements of skill parameters performed in a virtual reality simulator?
title_short Can the learning of laparoscopic skills be quantified by the measurements of skill parameters performed in a virtual reality simulator?
title_full Can the learning of laparoscopic skills be quantified by the measurements of skill parameters performed in a virtual reality simulator?
title_fullStr Can the learning of laparoscopic skills be quantified by the measurements of skill parameters performed in a virtual reality simulator?
title_full_unstemmed Can the learning of laparoscopic skills be quantified by the measurements of skill parameters performed in a virtual reality simulator?
title_sort can the learning of laparoscopic skills be quantified by the measurements of skill parameters performed in a virtual reality simulator?
description Purpose To ensure patient safety and surgical efficiency, much emphasis has been placed on the training of laparoscopic skills using virtual reality simulators. The purpose of this study was to determine whether laparoscopic skills can be objectively quantified by measuring specific skill parameters during training in a virtual reality surgical simulator (VRSS). Materials and Methods Ten medical students (with no laparoscopic experience) and ten urology residents (PGY3-5 with limited laparoscopic experience) were recruited to participate in a ten-week training course in basic laparoscopic skills (camera, cutting, peg transfer and clipping skills) on a VRSS. Data were collected from the training sessions. The time that individuals took to complete each task and the errors that they made were analyzed independently. Results The mean time that individuals took to complete tasks was significantly different between the groups (p < 0.05), with the residents being faster than the medical students. The residents' group also completed the tasks with fewer errors. The majority of the subjects in both groups exhibited a significant improvement in their task completion time and error rate. Conclusion The findings in this study demonstrate that laparoscopic skills can be objectively measured in a VRSS based on quantified skill parameters, including the time spent to complete skill tasks and the associated error rate. We conclude that a VRSS is a feasible tool for training and assessing basic laparoscopic skills.
publisher Sociedade Brasileira de Urologia
publishDate 2013
url http://old.scielo.br/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S1677-55382013000300371
work_keys_str_mv AT sandynataschasilva canthelearningoflaparoscopicskillsbequantifiedbythemeasurementsofskillparametersperformedinavirtualrealitysimulator
AT cruzjosearnaldoshiomida canthelearningoflaparoscopicskillsbequantifiedbythemeasurementsofskillparametersperformedinavirtualrealitysimulator
AT passerotticarlocamargo canthelearningoflaparoscopicskillsbequantifiedbythemeasurementsofskillparametersperformedinavirtualrealitysimulator
AT nguyenhiep canthelearningoflaparoscopicskillsbequantifiedbythemeasurementsofskillparametersperformedinavirtualrealitysimulator
AT reissabrinathalitados canthelearningoflaparoscopicskillsbequantifiedbythemeasurementsofskillparametersperformedinavirtualrealitysimulator
AT gouveiaedermaxwell canthelearningoflaparoscopicskillsbequantifiedbythemeasurementsofskillparametersperformedinavirtualrealitysimulator
AT duartericardojordao canthelearningoflaparoscopicskillsbequantifiedbythemeasurementsofskillparametersperformedinavirtualrealitysimulator
AT bruschinihomero canthelearningoflaparoscopicskillsbequantifiedbythemeasurementsofskillparametersperformedinavirtualrealitysimulator
AT srougimiguel canthelearningoflaparoscopicskillsbequantifiedbythemeasurementsofskillparametersperformedinavirtualrealitysimulator
_version_ 1756428134735937536