I Do Not Exist. Problems for Dynamic Semantics
Abstract According to dynamic semantics, what is said by an utterance of a sentence is determined by how the common ground is affected by the acceptance of such utterance. It has been claimed that dynamic semantics offers an account of what is said by an utterance in a context that excels that of traditional static semantics. Assertions of negative existential constructions, of the form ‘X does not exist’, are a case in point. These assertions traditionally pose a problem for philosophers of language. A recent proposal, owed to Clapp (2008), argues that static semantics is unable to solve the problem and offers a dynamic semantics account that promises to succeed. In this paper I want to challenge this account and, more generally, the scope of the dynamic semantics framework. I will offer a counterexample, inspired by “answering machine” uses of indexical and demonstrative expressions, to show how dynamic semantics fails. I conclude by considering the merits of both static and dynamic accounts.
Main Author: | García Ramírez,Eduardo |
---|---|
Format: | Digital revista |
Language: | English |
Published: |
Universidad Panamericana, Facultad de Filosofía
2019
|
Online Access: | http://www.scielo.org.mx/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S0188-66492019000100393 |
Tags: |
Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
|
Similar Items
-
Ontology matching for dynamic publication in semantic portals
by: Lachtim,Fernanda Aparecida, et al.
Published: (2009) -
Interoperability through emergent semantics a semiotic dynamics approach
by: Steels, Luc, et al.
Published: (2006) -
Psyllid host-plants (Hemiptera: Psylloidea): resolving a semantic problem.
by: BURCKHARDT, D., et al.
Published: (2014-04-10) -
On the existence of solution to an optimization problem.
by: GARAGORRY, F.
Published: (2010-07-05) -
The species problem in Cannabis. v.1: Science. v.2: Semantics
by: 119747 Small, E., et al.
Published: (1979)