Beyond connecting the dots : A multi-scale, multi-resolution approach to marine habitat mapping

Conflicts of interests between economic and nature conservation stakeholders are increasingly common in coastal seas, inducing a growing need for evidence-based marine spatial planning. This requires accurate, high-resolution habitat maps showing the spatial distribution of benthic assemblages and enabling intersections of habitats and anthropogenic activities. However, such detailed maps are often not available because relevant biological data are scarce or poorly integrated. Instead, physiotope maps, solely based on abiotic variables, are now often used in marine spatial planning. Here, we investigated how pointwise, relatively sparse biological data can be integrated with gridded, high-resolution environmental data into informative habitat maps, using the intensively used southern North Sea as a case-study. We first conducted hierarchical clustering to identify discrete biological assemblages for three faunal groups: demersal fish, epifauna, and endobenthos. Using Random Forest models with high-resolution abiotic predictors, we then interpolated the distribution of these assemblages to high resolution grids. Finally, we quantified different anthropogenic pressures for each habitat. Habitat maps comprised a different number of habitats between faunal groups (6, 13, and 10 for demersal fish, epifauna, and endobenthos respectively) but showed similar spatial patterns for each group. Several of these ‘fauna-inclusive’ habitats resembled physiotopes, but substantial differences were also observed, especially when few (6; demersal fish) or most (13; epifauna) physiotopes were delineated. Demersal fishing and offshore wind farms (OWFs) were clearly associated with specific habitats, resulting in unequal anthropogenic pressure between different habitats. Natura-2000 areas were not specifically associated with demersal fishing, but OWFs were situated mostly inside these protected areas. We thus conclude that habitat maps derived from biological datasets that cover relevant faunal groups should be included more in ecology-inclusive marine spatial planning, instead of only using physiotope maps based on abiotic variables. This allows better balancing of nature conservation and socio-economic interests in continental shelf seas.

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: van der Reijden, Karin J., Govers, Laura L., Koop, Leo, Damveld, Johan H., Herman, Peter M.J., Mestdagh, Sebastiaan, Piet, Gerjan, Rijnsdorp, Adriaan D., Dinesen, Grete E., Snellen, Mirjam, Olff, Han
Format: Article/Letter to editor biblioteca
Language:English
Subjects:Benthic faunal assemblages, Demersal fisheries, Hierarchical clustering, Marine Spatial Planning, Marine habitat mapping, Physiotopes,
Online Access:https://research.wur.nl/en/publications/beyond-connecting-the-dots-a-multi-scale-multi-resolution-approac
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
id dig-wur-nl-wurpubs-584515
record_format koha
spelling dig-wur-nl-wurpubs-5845152025-01-14 van der Reijden, Karin J. Govers, Laura L. Koop, Leo Damveld, Johan H. Herman, Peter M.J. Mestdagh, Sebastiaan Piet, Gerjan Rijnsdorp, Adriaan D. Dinesen, Grete E. Snellen, Mirjam Olff, Han Article/Letter to editor Ecological Indicators 128 (2021) ISSN: 1470-160X Beyond connecting the dots : A multi-scale, multi-resolution approach to marine habitat mapping 2021 Conflicts of interests between economic and nature conservation stakeholders are increasingly common in coastal seas, inducing a growing need for evidence-based marine spatial planning. This requires accurate, high-resolution habitat maps showing the spatial distribution of benthic assemblages and enabling intersections of habitats and anthropogenic activities. However, such detailed maps are often not available because relevant biological data are scarce or poorly integrated. Instead, physiotope maps, solely based on abiotic variables, are now often used in marine spatial planning. Here, we investigated how pointwise, relatively sparse biological data can be integrated with gridded, high-resolution environmental data into informative habitat maps, using the intensively used southern North Sea as a case-study. We first conducted hierarchical clustering to identify discrete biological assemblages for three faunal groups: demersal fish, epifauna, and endobenthos. Using Random Forest models with high-resolution abiotic predictors, we then interpolated the distribution of these assemblages to high resolution grids. Finally, we quantified different anthropogenic pressures for each habitat. Habitat maps comprised a different number of habitats between faunal groups (6, 13, and 10 for demersal fish, epifauna, and endobenthos respectively) but showed similar spatial patterns for each group. Several of these ‘fauna-inclusive’ habitats resembled physiotopes, but substantial differences were also observed, especially when few (6; demersal fish) or most (13; epifauna) physiotopes were delineated. Demersal fishing and offshore wind farms (OWFs) were clearly associated with specific habitats, resulting in unequal anthropogenic pressure between different habitats. Natura-2000 areas were not specifically associated with demersal fishing, but OWFs were situated mostly inside these protected areas. We thus conclude that habitat maps derived from biological datasets that cover relevant faunal groups should be included more in ecology-inclusive marine spatial planning, instead of only using physiotope maps based on abiotic variables. This allows better balancing of nature conservation and socio-economic interests in continental shelf seas. en application/pdf https://research.wur.nl/en/publications/beyond-connecting-the-dots-a-multi-scale-multi-resolution-approac 10.1016/j.ecolind.2021.107849 https://edepot.wur.nl/550030 Benthic faunal assemblages Demersal fisheries Hierarchical clustering Marine Spatial Planning Marine habitat mapping Physiotopes https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ Wageningen University & Research
institution WUR NL
collection DSpace
country Países bajos
countrycode NL
component Bibliográfico
access En linea
databasecode dig-wur-nl
tag biblioteca
region Europa del Oeste
libraryname WUR Library Netherlands
language English
topic Benthic faunal assemblages
Demersal fisheries
Hierarchical clustering
Marine Spatial Planning
Marine habitat mapping
Physiotopes
Benthic faunal assemblages
Demersal fisheries
Hierarchical clustering
Marine Spatial Planning
Marine habitat mapping
Physiotopes
spellingShingle Benthic faunal assemblages
Demersal fisheries
Hierarchical clustering
Marine Spatial Planning
Marine habitat mapping
Physiotopes
Benthic faunal assemblages
Demersal fisheries
Hierarchical clustering
Marine Spatial Planning
Marine habitat mapping
Physiotopes
van der Reijden, Karin J.
Govers, Laura L.
Koop, Leo
Damveld, Johan H.
Herman, Peter M.J.
Mestdagh, Sebastiaan
Piet, Gerjan
Rijnsdorp, Adriaan D.
Dinesen, Grete E.
Snellen, Mirjam
Olff, Han
Beyond connecting the dots : A multi-scale, multi-resolution approach to marine habitat mapping
description Conflicts of interests between economic and nature conservation stakeholders are increasingly common in coastal seas, inducing a growing need for evidence-based marine spatial planning. This requires accurate, high-resolution habitat maps showing the spatial distribution of benthic assemblages and enabling intersections of habitats and anthropogenic activities. However, such detailed maps are often not available because relevant biological data are scarce or poorly integrated. Instead, physiotope maps, solely based on abiotic variables, are now often used in marine spatial planning. Here, we investigated how pointwise, relatively sparse biological data can be integrated with gridded, high-resolution environmental data into informative habitat maps, using the intensively used southern North Sea as a case-study. We first conducted hierarchical clustering to identify discrete biological assemblages for three faunal groups: demersal fish, epifauna, and endobenthos. Using Random Forest models with high-resolution abiotic predictors, we then interpolated the distribution of these assemblages to high resolution grids. Finally, we quantified different anthropogenic pressures for each habitat. Habitat maps comprised a different number of habitats between faunal groups (6, 13, and 10 for demersal fish, epifauna, and endobenthos respectively) but showed similar spatial patterns for each group. Several of these ‘fauna-inclusive’ habitats resembled physiotopes, but substantial differences were also observed, especially when few (6; demersal fish) or most (13; epifauna) physiotopes were delineated. Demersal fishing and offshore wind farms (OWFs) were clearly associated with specific habitats, resulting in unequal anthropogenic pressure between different habitats. Natura-2000 areas were not specifically associated with demersal fishing, but OWFs were situated mostly inside these protected areas. We thus conclude that habitat maps derived from biological datasets that cover relevant faunal groups should be included more in ecology-inclusive marine spatial planning, instead of only using physiotope maps based on abiotic variables. This allows better balancing of nature conservation and socio-economic interests in continental shelf seas.
format Article/Letter to editor
topic_facet Benthic faunal assemblages
Demersal fisheries
Hierarchical clustering
Marine Spatial Planning
Marine habitat mapping
Physiotopes
author van der Reijden, Karin J.
Govers, Laura L.
Koop, Leo
Damveld, Johan H.
Herman, Peter M.J.
Mestdagh, Sebastiaan
Piet, Gerjan
Rijnsdorp, Adriaan D.
Dinesen, Grete E.
Snellen, Mirjam
Olff, Han
author_facet van der Reijden, Karin J.
Govers, Laura L.
Koop, Leo
Damveld, Johan H.
Herman, Peter M.J.
Mestdagh, Sebastiaan
Piet, Gerjan
Rijnsdorp, Adriaan D.
Dinesen, Grete E.
Snellen, Mirjam
Olff, Han
author_sort van der Reijden, Karin J.
title Beyond connecting the dots : A multi-scale, multi-resolution approach to marine habitat mapping
title_short Beyond connecting the dots : A multi-scale, multi-resolution approach to marine habitat mapping
title_full Beyond connecting the dots : A multi-scale, multi-resolution approach to marine habitat mapping
title_fullStr Beyond connecting the dots : A multi-scale, multi-resolution approach to marine habitat mapping
title_full_unstemmed Beyond connecting the dots : A multi-scale, multi-resolution approach to marine habitat mapping
title_sort beyond connecting the dots : a multi-scale, multi-resolution approach to marine habitat mapping
url https://research.wur.nl/en/publications/beyond-connecting-the-dots-a-multi-scale-multi-resolution-approac
work_keys_str_mv AT vanderreijdenkarinj beyondconnectingthedotsamultiscalemultiresolutionapproachtomarinehabitatmapping
AT goverslaural beyondconnectingthedotsamultiscalemultiresolutionapproachtomarinehabitatmapping
AT koopleo beyondconnectingthedotsamultiscalemultiresolutionapproachtomarinehabitatmapping
AT damveldjohanh beyondconnectingthedotsamultiscalemultiresolutionapproachtomarinehabitatmapping
AT hermanpetermj beyondconnectingthedotsamultiscalemultiresolutionapproachtomarinehabitatmapping
AT mestdaghsebastiaan beyondconnectingthedotsamultiscalemultiresolutionapproachtomarinehabitatmapping
AT pietgerjan beyondconnectingthedotsamultiscalemultiresolutionapproachtomarinehabitatmapping
AT rijnsdorpadriaand beyondconnectingthedotsamultiscalemultiresolutionapproachtomarinehabitatmapping
AT dinesengretee beyondconnectingthedotsamultiscalemultiresolutionapproachtomarinehabitatmapping
AT snellenmirjam beyondconnectingthedotsamultiscalemultiresolutionapproachtomarinehabitatmapping
AT olffhan beyondconnectingthedotsamultiscalemultiresolutionapproachtomarinehabitatmapping
_version_ 1822266549191311360