Currently legislated decreases in nitrogen deposition will yield only limited plant species recovery in European forests

Atmospheric nitrogen (N) pollution is considered responsible for a substantial decline in plant species richness and for altered community structures in terrestrial habitats worldwide. Nitrogen affects habitats through direct toxicity, soil acidification, and in particular by favoring fast-growing species. Pressure from N pollution is decreasing in some areas. In Europe (EU28), overall emissions of NO x declined by more than 50% while NH 3 declined by less than 30% between the years 1990 and 2015, and further decreases may be achieved. The timescale over which these improvements will affect ecosystems is uncertain. Here we use 23 European forest research sites with high quality long-term data on deposition, climate, soil recovery, and understory vegetation to assess benefits of currently legislated N deposition reductions in forest understory vegetation. A dynamic soil model coupled to a statistical plant species niche model was applied with site-based climate and deposition. We use indicators of N deposition and climate warming effects such as the change in the occurrence of oligophilic, acidophilic, and cold-tolerant plant species to compare the present with projections for 2030 and 2050. The decrease in N deposition under current legislation emission (CLE) reduction targets until 2030 is not expected to result in a release from eutrophication. Albeit the model predictions show considerable uncertainty when compared with observations, they indicate that oligophilic forest understory plant species will further decrease. This result is partially due to confounding processes related to climate effects and to major decreases in sulphur deposition and consequent recovery from soil acidification, but shows that decreases in N deposition under CLE will most likely be insufficient to allow recovery from eutrophication.

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Dirnböck, Thomas, Pröll, Gisela, Austnes, Kari, Beloica, Jelena, Beudert, Burkhard, Canullo, Roberto, De Marco, Alessandra, Fornasier, Maria Francesca, Futter, Martyn, Goergen, Klaus, Grandin, Ulf, Holmberg, Maria, Lindroos, Antti Jussi, Mirtl, Michael, Neirynck, Johan, Pecka, Tomasz, Nieminen, Tiina Maileena, Nordbakken, Jørn Frode, Posch, Maximilian, Reinds, Gert Jan, Rowe, Edwin C., Salemaa, Maija, Scheuschner, Thomas, Starlinger, Franz, Uziȩbło, Aldona Katarzyna, Valinia, Salar, Weldon, James, Wamelink, Wieger G.W., Forsius, Martin
Format: Article/Letter to editor biblioteca
Language:English
Subjects:Life Science,
Online Access:https://research.wur.nl/en/publications/currently-legislated-decreases-in-nitrogen-deposition-will-yield-
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
id dig-wur-nl-wurpubs-553489
record_format koha
spelling dig-wur-nl-wurpubs-5534892024-12-04 Dirnböck, Thomas Pröll, Gisela Austnes, Kari Beloica, Jelena Beudert, Burkhard Canullo, Roberto De Marco, Alessandra Fornasier, Maria Francesca Futter, Martyn Goergen, Klaus Grandin, Ulf Holmberg, Maria Lindroos, Antti Jussi Mirtl, Michael Neirynck, Johan Pecka, Tomasz Nieminen, Tiina Maileena Nordbakken, Jørn Frode Posch, Maximilian Reinds, Gert Jan Rowe, Edwin C. Salemaa, Maija Scheuschner, Thomas Starlinger, Franz Uziȩbło, Aldona Katarzyna Valinia, Salar Weldon, James Wamelink, Wieger G.W. Forsius, Martin Article/Letter to editor Environmental Research Letters 13 (2018) 12 ISSN: 1748-9326 Currently legislated decreases in nitrogen deposition will yield only limited plant species recovery in European forests 2018 Atmospheric nitrogen (N) pollution is considered responsible for a substantial decline in plant species richness and for altered community structures in terrestrial habitats worldwide. Nitrogen affects habitats through direct toxicity, soil acidification, and in particular by favoring fast-growing species. Pressure from N pollution is decreasing in some areas. In Europe (EU28), overall emissions of NO x declined by more than 50% while NH 3 declined by less than 30% between the years 1990 and 2015, and further decreases may be achieved. The timescale over which these improvements will affect ecosystems is uncertain. Here we use 23 European forest research sites with high quality long-term data on deposition, climate, soil recovery, and understory vegetation to assess benefits of currently legislated N deposition reductions in forest understory vegetation. A dynamic soil model coupled to a statistical plant species niche model was applied with site-based climate and deposition. We use indicators of N deposition and climate warming effects such as the change in the occurrence of oligophilic, acidophilic, and cold-tolerant plant species to compare the present with projections for 2030 and 2050. The decrease in N deposition under current legislation emission (CLE) reduction targets until 2030 is not expected to result in a release from eutrophication. Albeit the model predictions show considerable uncertainty when compared with observations, they indicate that oligophilic forest understory plant species will further decrease. This result is partially due to confounding processes related to climate effects and to major decreases in sulphur deposition and consequent recovery from soil acidification, but shows that decreases in N deposition under CLE will most likely be insufficient to allow recovery from eutrophication. en application/pdf https://research.wur.nl/en/publications/currently-legislated-decreases-in-nitrogen-deposition-will-yield- 10.1088/1748-9326/aaf26b https://edepot.wur.nl/499729 Life Science https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ Wageningen University & Research
institution WUR NL
collection DSpace
country Países bajos
countrycode NL
component Bibliográfico
access En linea
databasecode dig-wur-nl
tag biblioteca
region Europa del Oeste
libraryname WUR Library Netherlands
language English
topic Life Science
Life Science
spellingShingle Life Science
Life Science
Dirnböck, Thomas
Pröll, Gisela
Austnes, Kari
Beloica, Jelena
Beudert, Burkhard
Canullo, Roberto
De Marco, Alessandra
Fornasier, Maria Francesca
Futter, Martyn
Goergen, Klaus
Grandin, Ulf
Holmberg, Maria
Lindroos, Antti Jussi
Mirtl, Michael
Neirynck, Johan
Pecka, Tomasz
Nieminen, Tiina Maileena
Nordbakken, Jørn Frode
Posch, Maximilian
Reinds, Gert Jan
Rowe, Edwin C.
Salemaa, Maija
Scheuschner, Thomas
Starlinger, Franz
Uziȩbło, Aldona Katarzyna
Valinia, Salar
Weldon, James
Wamelink, Wieger G.W.
Forsius, Martin
Currently legislated decreases in nitrogen deposition will yield only limited plant species recovery in European forests
description Atmospheric nitrogen (N) pollution is considered responsible for a substantial decline in plant species richness and for altered community structures in terrestrial habitats worldwide. Nitrogen affects habitats through direct toxicity, soil acidification, and in particular by favoring fast-growing species. Pressure from N pollution is decreasing in some areas. In Europe (EU28), overall emissions of NO x declined by more than 50% while NH 3 declined by less than 30% between the years 1990 and 2015, and further decreases may be achieved. The timescale over which these improvements will affect ecosystems is uncertain. Here we use 23 European forest research sites with high quality long-term data on deposition, climate, soil recovery, and understory vegetation to assess benefits of currently legislated N deposition reductions in forest understory vegetation. A dynamic soil model coupled to a statistical plant species niche model was applied with site-based climate and deposition. We use indicators of N deposition and climate warming effects such as the change in the occurrence of oligophilic, acidophilic, and cold-tolerant plant species to compare the present with projections for 2030 and 2050. The decrease in N deposition under current legislation emission (CLE) reduction targets until 2030 is not expected to result in a release from eutrophication. Albeit the model predictions show considerable uncertainty when compared with observations, they indicate that oligophilic forest understory plant species will further decrease. This result is partially due to confounding processes related to climate effects and to major decreases in sulphur deposition and consequent recovery from soil acidification, but shows that decreases in N deposition under CLE will most likely be insufficient to allow recovery from eutrophication.
format Article/Letter to editor
topic_facet Life Science
author Dirnböck, Thomas
Pröll, Gisela
Austnes, Kari
Beloica, Jelena
Beudert, Burkhard
Canullo, Roberto
De Marco, Alessandra
Fornasier, Maria Francesca
Futter, Martyn
Goergen, Klaus
Grandin, Ulf
Holmberg, Maria
Lindroos, Antti Jussi
Mirtl, Michael
Neirynck, Johan
Pecka, Tomasz
Nieminen, Tiina Maileena
Nordbakken, Jørn Frode
Posch, Maximilian
Reinds, Gert Jan
Rowe, Edwin C.
Salemaa, Maija
Scheuschner, Thomas
Starlinger, Franz
Uziȩbło, Aldona Katarzyna
Valinia, Salar
Weldon, James
Wamelink, Wieger G.W.
Forsius, Martin
author_facet Dirnböck, Thomas
Pröll, Gisela
Austnes, Kari
Beloica, Jelena
Beudert, Burkhard
Canullo, Roberto
De Marco, Alessandra
Fornasier, Maria Francesca
Futter, Martyn
Goergen, Klaus
Grandin, Ulf
Holmberg, Maria
Lindroos, Antti Jussi
Mirtl, Michael
Neirynck, Johan
Pecka, Tomasz
Nieminen, Tiina Maileena
Nordbakken, Jørn Frode
Posch, Maximilian
Reinds, Gert Jan
Rowe, Edwin C.
Salemaa, Maija
Scheuschner, Thomas
Starlinger, Franz
Uziȩbło, Aldona Katarzyna
Valinia, Salar
Weldon, James
Wamelink, Wieger G.W.
Forsius, Martin
author_sort Dirnböck, Thomas
title Currently legislated decreases in nitrogen deposition will yield only limited plant species recovery in European forests
title_short Currently legislated decreases in nitrogen deposition will yield only limited plant species recovery in European forests
title_full Currently legislated decreases in nitrogen deposition will yield only limited plant species recovery in European forests
title_fullStr Currently legislated decreases in nitrogen deposition will yield only limited plant species recovery in European forests
title_full_unstemmed Currently legislated decreases in nitrogen deposition will yield only limited plant species recovery in European forests
title_sort currently legislated decreases in nitrogen deposition will yield only limited plant species recovery in european forests
url https://research.wur.nl/en/publications/currently-legislated-decreases-in-nitrogen-deposition-will-yield-
work_keys_str_mv AT dirnbockthomas currentlylegislateddecreasesinnitrogendepositionwillyieldonlylimitedplantspeciesrecoveryineuropeanforests
AT prollgisela currentlylegislateddecreasesinnitrogendepositionwillyieldonlylimitedplantspeciesrecoveryineuropeanforests
AT austneskari currentlylegislateddecreasesinnitrogendepositionwillyieldonlylimitedplantspeciesrecoveryineuropeanforests
AT beloicajelena currentlylegislateddecreasesinnitrogendepositionwillyieldonlylimitedplantspeciesrecoveryineuropeanforests
AT beudertburkhard currentlylegislateddecreasesinnitrogendepositionwillyieldonlylimitedplantspeciesrecoveryineuropeanforests
AT canulloroberto currentlylegislateddecreasesinnitrogendepositionwillyieldonlylimitedplantspeciesrecoveryineuropeanforests
AT demarcoalessandra currentlylegislateddecreasesinnitrogendepositionwillyieldonlylimitedplantspeciesrecoveryineuropeanforests
AT fornasiermariafrancesca currentlylegislateddecreasesinnitrogendepositionwillyieldonlylimitedplantspeciesrecoveryineuropeanforests
AT futtermartyn currentlylegislateddecreasesinnitrogendepositionwillyieldonlylimitedplantspeciesrecoveryineuropeanforests
AT goergenklaus currentlylegislateddecreasesinnitrogendepositionwillyieldonlylimitedplantspeciesrecoveryineuropeanforests
AT grandinulf currentlylegislateddecreasesinnitrogendepositionwillyieldonlylimitedplantspeciesrecoveryineuropeanforests
AT holmbergmaria currentlylegislateddecreasesinnitrogendepositionwillyieldonlylimitedplantspeciesrecoveryineuropeanforests
AT lindroosanttijussi currentlylegislateddecreasesinnitrogendepositionwillyieldonlylimitedplantspeciesrecoveryineuropeanforests
AT mirtlmichael currentlylegislateddecreasesinnitrogendepositionwillyieldonlylimitedplantspeciesrecoveryineuropeanforests
AT neirynckjohan currentlylegislateddecreasesinnitrogendepositionwillyieldonlylimitedplantspeciesrecoveryineuropeanforests
AT peckatomasz currentlylegislateddecreasesinnitrogendepositionwillyieldonlylimitedplantspeciesrecoveryineuropeanforests
AT nieminentiinamaileena currentlylegislateddecreasesinnitrogendepositionwillyieldonlylimitedplantspeciesrecoveryineuropeanforests
AT nordbakkenjørnfrode currentlylegislateddecreasesinnitrogendepositionwillyieldonlylimitedplantspeciesrecoveryineuropeanforests
AT poschmaximilian currentlylegislateddecreasesinnitrogendepositionwillyieldonlylimitedplantspeciesrecoveryineuropeanforests
AT reindsgertjan currentlylegislateddecreasesinnitrogendepositionwillyieldonlylimitedplantspeciesrecoveryineuropeanforests
AT roweedwinc currentlylegislateddecreasesinnitrogendepositionwillyieldonlylimitedplantspeciesrecoveryineuropeanforests
AT salemaamaija currentlylegislateddecreasesinnitrogendepositionwillyieldonlylimitedplantspeciesrecoveryineuropeanforests
AT scheuschnerthomas currentlylegislateddecreasesinnitrogendepositionwillyieldonlylimitedplantspeciesrecoveryineuropeanforests
AT starlingerfranz currentlylegislateddecreasesinnitrogendepositionwillyieldonlylimitedplantspeciesrecoveryineuropeanforests
AT uziebłoaldonakatarzyna currentlylegislateddecreasesinnitrogendepositionwillyieldonlylimitedplantspeciesrecoveryineuropeanforests
AT valiniasalar currentlylegislateddecreasesinnitrogendepositionwillyieldonlylimitedplantspeciesrecoveryineuropeanforests
AT weldonjames currentlylegislateddecreasesinnitrogendepositionwillyieldonlylimitedplantspeciesrecoveryineuropeanforests
AT wamelinkwiegergw currentlylegislateddecreasesinnitrogendepositionwillyieldonlylimitedplantspeciesrecoveryineuropeanforests
AT forsiusmartin currentlylegislateddecreasesinnitrogendepositionwillyieldonlylimitedplantspeciesrecoveryineuropeanforests
_version_ 1819146510198112256