Spatial heterogeneity in plant–soil feedbacks alters competitive interactions between two grassland plant species

The effects of plants on soil vary greatly between plant species and in mixed plant communities this can lead to spatial variation in plant-soil feedback (PSF) effects. Such spatial effects are thought to influence plant species coexistence, but the empirical evidence for this hypothesis is limited. Here, we investigate how spatial heterogeneity in PSFs influences plant growth and competition. The experiment was carried out with high and low nutrient soils to examine how these effects depend on soil fertility. We collected soil from field plots planted for three years with monocultures of Anthoxanthum odoratum and Centaurea jacea and tested the performance of the two species in a greenhouse experiment in heterogeneous soils consisting of patches of “own” and “foreign” soils and in soils where the “own” and “foreign” soils were mixed homogeneously. In the test phase, plants were grown in monocultures and in 1:1 mixtures in live or sterilized soils. Overall, A. odoratum in monocultures produced less aboveground biomass in heterogeneous soils than in homogeneous soils. Centaurea jacea produced less belowground biomass in live heterogeneous soils than in live homogeneous soils, but there was no difference between sterile heterogeneous and homogeneous soils. The belowground biomass per patch varied more in pots with live heterogeneous soils than in pots with live homogeneous soils for both plant species, but there was no difference between pots with sterile heterogeneous and homogeneous soils. In pots with plant mixtures, the difference in aboveground biomass between the two competing species tended to be smaller in heterogeneous than in homogeneous soils. In pots with heterogeneous soils, both plant species grown in mixtures produced more aboveground biomass in “foreign” soil patches than in “own” soil patches. The responses of plants to heterogeneous PSFs were not different between low and high nutrient soils. Our results show that spatially heterogeneous PSFs can influence plant performance and competition via reducing the growth inequality between the two competing species by allowing selective growth in foreign soil patches, independent of initial soil nutrient availability. Such effect may slow down exclusion processes and thus promote the coexistence of competing species at the local scale in mixed plant communities. A plain language summary is available for this article.

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Xue, Wei, Berendse, Frank, Bezemer, T.M.
Format: Article/Letter to editor biblioteca
Language:English
Subjects:intra- and interspecific competition, patchy distribution, plant–plant interactions, plant–soil feedback, plant–soil interactions, soil heterogeneity, soil nutrient, soil origin,
Online Access:https://research.wur.nl/en/publications/spatial-heterogeneity-in-plantsoil-feedbacks-alters-competitive-i
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
id dig-wur-nl-wurpubs-539681
record_format koha
spelling dig-wur-nl-wurpubs-5396812024-12-04 Xue, Wei Berendse, Frank Bezemer, T.M. Article/Letter to editor Functional Ecology 32 (2018) 8 ISSN: 0269-8463 Spatial heterogeneity in plant–soil feedbacks alters competitive interactions between two grassland plant species 2018 The effects of plants on soil vary greatly between plant species and in mixed plant communities this can lead to spatial variation in plant-soil feedback (PSF) effects. Such spatial effects are thought to influence plant species coexistence, but the empirical evidence for this hypothesis is limited. Here, we investigate how spatial heterogeneity in PSFs influences plant growth and competition. The experiment was carried out with high and low nutrient soils to examine how these effects depend on soil fertility. We collected soil from field plots planted for three years with monocultures of Anthoxanthum odoratum and Centaurea jacea and tested the performance of the two species in a greenhouse experiment in heterogeneous soils consisting of patches of “own” and “foreign” soils and in soils where the “own” and “foreign” soils were mixed homogeneously. In the test phase, plants were grown in monocultures and in 1:1 mixtures in live or sterilized soils. Overall, A. odoratum in monocultures produced less aboveground biomass in heterogeneous soils than in homogeneous soils. Centaurea jacea produced less belowground biomass in live heterogeneous soils than in live homogeneous soils, but there was no difference between sterile heterogeneous and homogeneous soils. The belowground biomass per patch varied more in pots with live heterogeneous soils than in pots with live homogeneous soils for both plant species, but there was no difference between pots with sterile heterogeneous and homogeneous soils. In pots with plant mixtures, the difference in aboveground biomass between the two competing species tended to be smaller in heterogeneous than in homogeneous soils. In pots with heterogeneous soils, both plant species grown in mixtures produced more aboveground biomass in “foreign” soil patches than in “own” soil patches. The responses of plants to heterogeneous PSFs were not different between low and high nutrient soils. Our results show that spatially heterogeneous PSFs can influence plant performance and competition via reducing the growth inequality between the two competing species by allowing selective growth in foreign soil patches, independent of initial soil nutrient availability. Such effect may slow down exclusion processes and thus promote the coexistence of competing species at the local scale in mixed plant communities. A plain language summary is available for this article. en application/pdf https://research.wur.nl/en/publications/spatial-heterogeneity-in-plantsoil-feedbacks-alters-competitive-i 10.1111/1365-2435.13124 https://edepot.wur.nl/457716 intra- and interspecific competition patchy distribution plant–plant interactions plant–soil feedback plant–soil interactions soil heterogeneity soil nutrient soil origin https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ Wageningen University & Research
institution WUR NL
collection DSpace
country Países bajos
countrycode NL
component Bibliográfico
access En linea
databasecode dig-wur-nl
tag biblioteca
region Europa del Oeste
libraryname WUR Library Netherlands
language English
topic intra- and interspecific competition
patchy distribution
plant–plant interactions
plant–soil feedback
plant–soil interactions
soil heterogeneity
soil nutrient
soil origin
intra- and interspecific competition
patchy distribution
plant–plant interactions
plant–soil feedback
plant–soil interactions
soil heterogeneity
soil nutrient
soil origin
spellingShingle intra- and interspecific competition
patchy distribution
plant–plant interactions
plant–soil feedback
plant–soil interactions
soil heterogeneity
soil nutrient
soil origin
intra- and interspecific competition
patchy distribution
plant–plant interactions
plant–soil feedback
plant–soil interactions
soil heterogeneity
soil nutrient
soil origin
Xue, Wei
Berendse, Frank
Bezemer, T.M.
Spatial heterogeneity in plant–soil feedbacks alters competitive interactions between two grassland plant species
description The effects of plants on soil vary greatly between plant species and in mixed plant communities this can lead to spatial variation in plant-soil feedback (PSF) effects. Such spatial effects are thought to influence plant species coexistence, but the empirical evidence for this hypothesis is limited. Here, we investigate how spatial heterogeneity in PSFs influences plant growth and competition. The experiment was carried out with high and low nutrient soils to examine how these effects depend on soil fertility. We collected soil from field plots planted for three years with monocultures of Anthoxanthum odoratum and Centaurea jacea and tested the performance of the two species in a greenhouse experiment in heterogeneous soils consisting of patches of “own” and “foreign” soils and in soils where the “own” and “foreign” soils were mixed homogeneously. In the test phase, plants were grown in monocultures and in 1:1 mixtures in live or sterilized soils. Overall, A. odoratum in monocultures produced less aboveground biomass in heterogeneous soils than in homogeneous soils. Centaurea jacea produced less belowground biomass in live heterogeneous soils than in live homogeneous soils, but there was no difference between sterile heterogeneous and homogeneous soils. The belowground biomass per patch varied more in pots with live heterogeneous soils than in pots with live homogeneous soils for both plant species, but there was no difference between pots with sterile heterogeneous and homogeneous soils. In pots with plant mixtures, the difference in aboveground biomass between the two competing species tended to be smaller in heterogeneous than in homogeneous soils. In pots with heterogeneous soils, both plant species grown in mixtures produced more aboveground biomass in “foreign” soil patches than in “own” soil patches. The responses of plants to heterogeneous PSFs were not different between low and high nutrient soils. Our results show that spatially heterogeneous PSFs can influence plant performance and competition via reducing the growth inequality between the two competing species by allowing selective growth in foreign soil patches, independent of initial soil nutrient availability. Such effect may slow down exclusion processes and thus promote the coexistence of competing species at the local scale in mixed plant communities. A plain language summary is available for this article.
format Article/Letter to editor
topic_facet intra- and interspecific competition
patchy distribution
plant–plant interactions
plant–soil feedback
plant–soil interactions
soil heterogeneity
soil nutrient
soil origin
author Xue, Wei
Berendse, Frank
Bezemer, T.M.
author_facet Xue, Wei
Berendse, Frank
Bezemer, T.M.
author_sort Xue, Wei
title Spatial heterogeneity in plant–soil feedbacks alters competitive interactions between two grassland plant species
title_short Spatial heterogeneity in plant–soil feedbacks alters competitive interactions between two grassland plant species
title_full Spatial heterogeneity in plant–soil feedbacks alters competitive interactions between two grassland plant species
title_fullStr Spatial heterogeneity in plant–soil feedbacks alters competitive interactions between two grassland plant species
title_full_unstemmed Spatial heterogeneity in plant–soil feedbacks alters competitive interactions between two grassland plant species
title_sort spatial heterogeneity in plant–soil feedbacks alters competitive interactions between two grassland plant species
url https://research.wur.nl/en/publications/spatial-heterogeneity-in-plantsoil-feedbacks-alters-competitive-i
work_keys_str_mv AT xuewei spatialheterogeneityinplantsoilfeedbacksalterscompetitiveinteractionsbetweentwograsslandplantspecies
AT berendsefrank spatialheterogeneityinplantsoilfeedbacksalterscompetitiveinteractionsbetweentwograsslandplantspecies
AT bezemertm spatialheterogeneityinplantsoilfeedbacksalterscompetitiveinteractionsbetweentwograsslandplantspecies
_version_ 1819146703578595328