The science, policy and practice of nature-based solutions : An interdisciplinary perspective

In this paper, we reflect on the implications for science, policy and practice of the recently introduced concept of Nature-Based Solutions (NBS), with a focus on the European context. First, we analyse NBS in relation to similar concepts, and reflect on its relationship to sustainability as an overarching framework. From this, we derive a set of questions to be addressed and propose a general framework for how these might be addressed in NBS projects by funders, researchers, policy-makers and practitioners. We conclude that: (1) NBS need to be developed and discussed in relation to existing concepts to clarify their added value;(2) When considering and implementing NBS, the ‘relabelling’ of related concepts and the misuse of the concept have to be prevented in order to avoid misunderstanding, duplication and unintended consequences;(3) NBS as currently framed by the European Commission provides an opportunity for: a) transdisciplinary research into the design and implementation of solutions based on nature; and b) overcoming a bias towards development alternatives with narrow perspectives that focus on short-term economic gains and effectiveness;(4) The strength of the NBS concept is its integrative, systemic approach which prevents it from becoming just another “green communication tool” that provides justification for a classical model of natural resource exploitation and management measures.To realise their full potential, NBS must be developed by including the experience of all relevant stakeholders such that ‘solutions’ contribute to achieving all dimensions of sustainability. As NBS are developed, we must also moderate the expectations placed on them since the precedent provided by other initiatives whose aim was to manage nature sustainably demonstrates that we should not expect NBS to be cheap and easy, at least not in the short-term.

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Nesshöver, Carsten, Assmuth, Timo, Irvine, Katherine N., Rusch, Graciela M., Waylen, Kerry A., Delbaere, Ben, Haase, Dagmar, Jones-Walters, Lawrence, Keune, Hans, Kovacs, Eszter, Krauze, Kinga, Külvik, Mart, Rey, Freddy, van Dijk, Jiska, Vistad, Odd Inge, Wilkinson, Mark E., Wittmer, Heidi
Format: Article/Letter to editor biblioteca
Language:English
Subjects:Ecosystem management, Ecosystem services, Environmental governance, Sustainability,
Online Access:https://research.wur.nl/en/publications/the-science-policy-and-practice-of-nature-based-solutions-an-inte
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
id dig-wur-nl-wurpubs-512716
record_format koha
spelling dig-wur-nl-wurpubs-5127162024-12-04 Nesshöver, Carsten Assmuth, Timo Irvine, Katherine N. Rusch, Graciela M. Waylen, Kerry A. Delbaere, Ben Haase, Dagmar Jones-Walters, Lawrence Keune, Hans Kovacs, Eszter Krauze, Kinga Külvik, Mart Rey, Freddy van Dijk, Jiska Vistad, Odd Inge Wilkinson, Mark E. Wittmer, Heidi Article/Letter to editor Science of the Total Environment 579 (2017) ISSN: 0048-9697 The science, policy and practice of nature-based solutions : An interdisciplinary perspective 2017 In this paper, we reflect on the implications for science, policy and practice of the recently introduced concept of Nature-Based Solutions (NBS), with a focus on the European context. First, we analyse NBS in relation to similar concepts, and reflect on its relationship to sustainability as an overarching framework. From this, we derive a set of questions to be addressed and propose a general framework for how these might be addressed in NBS projects by funders, researchers, policy-makers and practitioners. We conclude that: (1) NBS need to be developed and discussed in relation to existing concepts to clarify their added value;(2) When considering and implementing NBS, the ‘relabelling’ of related concepts and the misuse of the concept have to be prevented in order to avoid misunderstanding, duplication and unintended consequences;(3) NBS as currently framed by the European Commission provides an opportunity for: a) transdisciplinary research into the design and implementation of solutions based on nature; and b) overcoming a bias towards development alternatives with narrow perspectives that focus on short-term economic gains and effectiveness;(4) The strength of the NBS concept is its integrative, systemic approach which prevents it from becoming just another “green communication tool” that provides justification for a classical model of natural resource exploitation and management measures.To realise their full potential, NBS must be developed by including the experience of all relevant stakeholders such that ‘solutions’ contribute to achieving all dimensions of sustainability. As NBS are developed, we must also moderate the expectations placed on them since the precedent provided by other initiatives whose aim was to manage nature sustainably demonstrates that we should not expect NBS to be cheap and easy, at least not in the short-term. en application/pdf https://research.wur.nl/en/publications/the-science-policy-and-practice-of-nature-based-solutions-an-inte 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2016.11.106 https://edepot.wur.nl/405533 Ecosystem management Ecosystem services Environmental governance Sustainability https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ Wageningen University & Research
institution WUR NL
collection DSpace
country Países bajos
countrycode NL
component Bibliográfico
access En linea
databasecode dig-wur-nl
tag biblioteca
region Europa del Oeste
libraryname WUR Library Netherlands
language English
topic Ecosystem management
Ecosystem services
Environmental governance
Sustainability
Ecosystem management
Ecosystem services
Environmental governance
Sustainability
spellingShingle Ecosystem management
Ecosystem services
Environmental governance
Sustainability
Ecosystem management
Ecosystem services
Environmental governance
Sustainability
Nesshöver, Carsten
Assmuth, Timo
Irvine, Katherine N.
Rusch, Graciela M.
Waylen, Kerry A.
Delbaere, Ben
Haase, Dagmar
Jones-Walters, Lawrence
Keune, Hans
Kovacs, Eszter
Krauze, Kinga
Külvik, Mart
Rey, Freddy
van Dijk, Jiska
Vistad, Odd Inge
Wilkinson, Mark E.
Wittmer, Heidi
The science, policy and practice of nature-based solutions : An interdisciplinary perspective
description In this paper, we reflect on the implications for science, policy and practice of the recently introduced concept of Nature-Based Solutions (NBS), with a focus on the European context. First, we analyse NBS in relation to similar concepts, and reflect on its relationship to sustainability as an overarching framework. From this, we derive a set of questions to be addressed and propose a general framework for how these might be addressed in NBS projects by funders, researchers, policy-makers and practitioners. We conclude that: (1) NBS need to be developed and discussed in relation to existing concepts to clarify their added value;(2) When considering and implementing NBS, the ‘relabelling’ of related concepts and the misuse of the concept have to be prevented in order to avoid misunderstanding, duplication and unintended consequences;(3) NBS as currently framed by the European Commission provides an opportunity for: a) transdisciplinary research into the design and implementation of solutions based on nature; and b) overcoming a bias towards development alternatives with narrow perspectives that focus on short-term economic gains and effectiveness;(4) The strength of the NBS concept is its integrative, systemic approach which prevents it from becoming just another “green communication tool” that provides justification for a classical model of natural resource exploitation and management measures.To realise their full potential, NBS must be developed by including the experience of all relevant stakeholders such that ‘solutions’ contribute to achieving all dimensions of sustainability. As NBS are developed, we must also moderate the expectations placed on them since the precedent provided by other initiatives whose aim was to manage nature sustainably demonstrates that we should not expect NBS to be cheap and easy, at least not in the short-term.
format Article/Letter to editor
topic_facet Ecosystem management
Ecosystem services
Environmental governance
Sustainability
author Nesshöver, Carsten
Assmuth, Timo
Irvine, Katherine N.
Rusch, Graciela M.
Waylen, Kerry A.
Delbaere, Ben
Haase, Dagmar
Jones-Walters, Lawrence
Keune, Hans
Kovacs, Eszter
Krauze, Kinga
Külvik, Mart
Rey, Freddy
van Dijk, Jiska
Vistad, Odd Inge
Wilkinson, Mark E.
Wittmer, Heidi
author_facet Nesshöver, Carsten
Assmuth, Timo
Irvine, Katherine N.
Rusch, Graciela M.
Waylen, Kerry A.
Delbaere, Ben
Haase, Dagmar
Jones-Walters, Lawrence
Keune, Hans
Kovacs, Eszter
Krauze, Kinga
Külvik, Mart
Rey, Freddy
van Dijk, Jiska
Vistad, Odd Inge
Wilkinson, Mark E.
Wittmer, Heidi
author_sort Nesshöver, Carsten
title The science, policy and practice of nature-based solutions : An interdisciplinary perspective
title_short The science, policy and practice of nature-based solutions : An interdisciplinary perspective
title_full The science, policy and practice of nature-based solutions : An interdisciplinary perspective
title_fullStr The science, policy and practice of nature-based solutions : An interdisciplinary perspective
title_full_unstemmed The science, policy and practice of nature-based solutions : An interdisciplinary perspective
title_sort science, policy and practice of nature-based solutions : an interdisciplinary perspective
url https://research.wur.nl/en/publications/the-science-policy-and-practice-of-nature-based-solutions-an-inte
work_keys_str_mv AT nesshovercarsten thesciencepolicyandpracticeofnaturebasedsolutionsaninterdisciplinaryperspective
AT assmuthtimo thesciencepolicyandpracticeofnaturebasedsolutionsaninterdisciplinaryperspective
AT irvinekatherinen thesciencepolicyandpracticeofnaturebasedsolutionsaninterdisciplinaryperspective
AT ruschgracielam thesciencepolicyandpracticeofnaturebasedsolutionsaninterdisciplinaryperspective
AT waylenkerrya thesciencepolicyandpracticeofnaturebasedsolutionsaninterdisciplinaryperspective
AT delbaereben thesciencepolicyandpracticeofnaturebasedsolutionsaninterdisciplinaryperspective
AT haasedagmar thesciencepolicyandpracticeofnaturebasedsolutionsaninterdisciplinaryperspective
AT joneswalterslawrence thesciencepolicyandpracticeofnaturebasedsolutionsaninterdisciplinaryperspective
AT keunehans thesciencepolicyandpracticeofnaturebasedsolutionsaninterdisciplinaryperspective
AT kovacseszter thesciencepolicyandpracticeofnaturebasedsolutionsaninterdisciplinaryperspective
AT krauzekinga thesciencepolicyandpracticeofnaturebasedsolutionsaninterdisciplinaryperspective
AT kulvikmart thesciencepolicyandpracticeofnaturebasedsolutionsaninterdisciplinaryperspective
AT reyfreddy thesciencepolicyandpracticeofnaturebasedsolutionsaninterdisciplinaryperspective
AT vandijkjiska thesciencepolicyandpracticeofnaturebasedsolutionsaninterdisciplinaryperspective
AT vistadoddinge thesciencepolicyandpracticeofnaturebasedsolutionsaninterdisciplinaryperspective
AT wilkinsonmarke thesciencepolicyandpracticeofnaturebasedsolutionsaninterdisciplinaryperspective
AT wittmerheidi thesciencepolicyandpracticeofnaturebasedsolutionsaninterdisciplinaryperspective
AT nesshovercarsten sciencepolicyandpracticeofnaturebasedsolutionsaninterdisciplinaryperspective
AT assmuthtimo sciencepolicyandpracticeofnaturebasedsolutionsaninterdisciplinaryperspective
AT irvinekatherinen sciencepolicyandpracticeofnaturebasedsolutionsaninterdisciplinaryperspective
AT ruschgracielam sciencepolicyandpracticeofnaturebasedsolutionsaninterdisciplinaryperspective
AT waylenkerrya sciencepolicyandpracticeofnaturebasedsolutionsaninterdisciplinaryperspective
AT delbaereben sciencepolicyandpracticeofnaturebasedsolutionsaninterdisciplinaryperspective
AT haasedagmar sciencepolicyandpracticeofnaturebasedsolutionsaninterdisciplinaryperspective
AT joneswalterslawrence sciencepolicyandpracticeofnaturebasedsolutionsaninterdisciplinaryperspective
AT keunehans sciencepolicyandpracticeofnaturebasedsolutionsaninterdisciplinaryperspective
AT kovacseszter sciencepolicyandpracticeofnaturebasedsolutionsaninterdisciplinaryperspective
AT krauzekinga sciencepolicyandpracticeofnaturebasedsolutionsaninterdisciplinaryperspective
AT kulvikmart sciencepolicyandpracticeofnaturebasedsolutionsaninterdisciplinaryperspective
AT reyfreddy sciencepolicyandpracticeofnaturebasedsolutionsaninterdisciplinaryperspective
AT vandijkjiska sciencepolicyandpracticeofnaturebasedsolutionsaninterdisciplinaryperspective
AT vistadoddinge sciencepolicyandpracticeofnaturebasedsolutionsaninterdisciplinaryperspective
AT wilkinsonmarke sciencepolicyandpracticeofnaturebasedsolutionsaninterdisciplinaryperspective
AT wittmerheidi sciencepolicyandpracticeofnaturebasedsolutionsaninterdisciplinaryperspective
_version_ 1819146936477810688