Separation of digesta fractions complicates estimation of ileal digestibility using marker methods with Cr2O3 and Co-EDTA in broiler chickens

Marker methodologies to measure ileal and total tract digestibilities of diets varying in content and degradability of dietary fiber in broiler chickens were evaluated. Chromium sesquioxide (Cr2O3) and cobalt-ethylenediamine tetraacetic acid (Co-EDTA) were used as markers of solid and soluble fractions, respectively, and compared with digestibility values obtained with the total collection method. Groups of broilers (n = 17, 11 broilers/group) were assigned to a low-fiber diet or 1 of 2 high-fiber diets, the latter 2 containing 35% rapeseed meal (RSM). Pectolytic enzymes were added to one RSM diet to improve degradability of the fiber fraction. Excreta were quantitatively collected for 96 h, and contents from ileum and ceca were collected at slaughter at 29, 30, or 31 d of age. Chromium recovery in excreta ranged between 86 and 95%, whereas cobalt recovery was considerably lower (66 to 70%). Chromium:cobalt ratio was higher in ileal digesta than in feed. Hardly any chromium was found in the ceca, indicating that separation of the marker and specific digesta fractions occurs. Estimates of apparent total tract digestibility (ATTD) were lower when calculated using the marker method compared with the total collection method, particularly in high-fiber diets. Using Cr2O3 as a marker, differences were relatively small and effects due to enzyme addition were generally similar. Using Co-EDTA as a marker, ATTD of all components were lower compared with values obtained using the collection method (3 to 45 percentage units, P <0.001), likely related to the low Co recovery. When estimating apparent ileal digestibility (AID), separation of marker and digesta resulted in unrealistically high estimates for the digestibility of nonglucose polysaccharides (54 to 66%), exceeding ATTD values by 16 to 42 percentage units. Moreover, the effect of pectolytic enzyme addition on the AID of nonglucose polysaccharides was in the opposite direction when compared with total collection. The data illustrate that fractionation of digesta, particularly in high-fiber diets, complicates accurate AID measurements in broilers, regardless of the choice of markers used.

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: de Vries, S., Kwakkel, R.P., Pustjens, A.M., Kabel, M.A., Hendriks, W.H., Gerrits, W.J.J.
Format: Article/Letter to editor biblioteca
Language:English
Subjects:amino-acids, atomic-absorption spectrophotometry, avian ceca, carboxy methyl cellulose, feed ingredients, food, gastrointestinal transit-time, nonstarch polysaccharides, soluble polysaccharide, tract,
Online Access:https://research.wur.nl/en/publications/separation-of-digesta-fractions-complicates-estimation-of-ileal-d
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
id dig-wur-nl-wurpubs-456706
record_format koha
spelling dig-wur-nl-wurpubs-4567062024-12-04 de Vries, S. Kwakkel, R.P. Pustjens, A.M. Kabel, M.A. Hendriks, W.H. Gerrits, W.J.J. Article/Letter to editor Poultry Science 93 (2014) 8 ISSN: 0032-5791 Separation of digesta fractions complicates estimation of ileal digestibility using marker methods with Cr2O3 and Co-EDTA in broiler chickens 2014 Marker methodologies to measure ileal and total tract digestibilities of diets varying in content and degradability of dietary fiber in broiler chickens were evaluated. Chromium sesquioxide (Cr2O3) and cobalt-ethylenediamine tetraacetic acid (Co-EDTA) were used as markers of solid and soluble fractions, respectively, and compared with digestibility values obtained with the total collection method. Groups of broilers (n = 17, 11 broilers/group) were assigned to a low-fiber diet or 1 of 2 high-fiber diets, the latter 2 containing 35% rapeseed meal (RSM). Pectolytic enzymes were added to one RSM diet to improve degradability of the fiber fraction. Excreta were quantitatively collected for 96 h, and contents from ileum and ceca were collected at slaughter at 29, 30, or 31 d of age. Chromium recovery in excreta ranged between 86 and 95%, whereas cobalt recovery was considerably lower (66 to 70%). Chromium:cobalt ratio was higher in ileal digesta than in feed. Hardly any chromium was found in the ceca, indicating that separation of the marker and specific digesta fractions occurs. Estimates of apparent total tract digestibility (ATTD) were lower when calculated using the marker method compared with the total collection method, particularly in high-fiber diets. Using Cr2O3 as a marker, differences were relatively small and effects due to enzyme addition were generally similar. Using Co-EDTA as a marker, ATTD of all components were lower compared with values obtained using the collection method (3 to 45 percentage units, P <0.001), likely related to the low Co recovery. When estimating apparent ileal digestibility (AID), separation of marker and digesta resulted in unrealistically high estimates for the digestibility of nonglucose polysaccharides (54 to 66%), exceeding ATTD values by 16 to 42 percentage units. Moreover, the effect of pectolytic enzyme addition on the AID of nonglucose polysaccharides was in the opposite direction when compared with total collection. The data illustrate that fractionation of digesta, particularly in high-fiber diets, complicates accurate AID measurements in broilers, regardless of the choice of markers used. en application/pdf https://research.wur.nl/en/publications/separation-of-digesta-fractions-complicates-estimation-of-ileal-d 10.3382/ps.2013-03845 https://edepot.wur.nl/313998 amino-acids atomic-absorption spectrophotometry avian ceca carboxy methyl cellulose feed ingredients food gastrointestinal transit-time nonstarch polysaccharides soluble polysaccharide tract https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ Wageningen University & Research
institution WUR NL
collection DSpace
country Países bajos
countrycode NL
component Bibliográfico
access En linea
databasecode dig-wur-nl
tag biblioteca
region Europa del Oeste
libraryname WUR Library Netherlands
language English
topic amino-acids
atomic-absorption spectrophotometry
avian ceca
carboxy methyl cellulose
feed ingredients
food
gastrointestinal transit-time
nonstarch polysaccharides
soluble polysaccharide
tract
amino-acids
atomic-absorption spectrophotometry
avian ceca
carboxy methyl cellulose
feed ingredients
food
gastrointestinal transit-time
nonstarch polysaccharides
soluble polysaccharide
tract
spellingShingle amino-acids
atomic-absorption spectrophotometry
avian ceca
carboxy methyl cellulose
feed ingredients
food
gastrointestinal transit-time
nonstarch polysaccharides
soluble polysaccharide
tract
amino-acids
atomic-absorption spectrophotometry
avian ceca
carboxy methyl cellulose
feed ingredients
food
gastrointestinal transit-time
nonstarch polysaccharides
soluble polysaccharide
tract
de Vries, S.
Kwakkel, R.P.
Pustjens, A.M.
Kabel, M.A.
Hendriks, W.H.
Gerrits, W.J.J.
Separation of digesta fractions complicates estimation of ileal digestibility using marker methods with Cr2O3 and Co-EDTA in broiler chickens
description Marker methodologies to measure ileal and total tract digestibilities of diets varying in content and degradability of dietary fiber in broiler chickens were evaluated. Chromium sesquioxide (Cr2O3) and cobalt-ethylenediamine tetraacetic acid (Co-EDTA) were used as markers of solid and soluble fractions, respectively, and compared with digestibility values obtained with the total collection method. Groups of broilers (n = 17, 11 broilers/group) were assigned to a low-fiber diet or 1 of 2 high-fiber diets, the latter 2 containing 35% rapeseed meal (RSM). Pectolytic enzymes were added to one RSM diet to improve degradability of the fiber fraction. Excreta were quantitatively collected for 96 h, and contents from ileum and ceca were collected at slaughter at 29, 30, or 31 d of age. Chromium recovery in excreta ranged between 86 and 95%, whereas cobalt recovery was considerably lower (66 to 70%). Chromium:cobalt ratio was higher in ileal digesta than in feed. Hardly any chromium was found in the ceca, indicating that separation of the marker and specific digesta fractions occurs. Estimates of apparent total tract digestibility (ATTD) were lower when calculated using the marker method compared with the total collection method, particularly in high-fiber diets. Using Cr2O3 as a marker, differences were relatively small and effects due to enzyme addition were generally similar. Using Co-EDTA as a marker, ATTD of all components were lower compared with values obtained using the collection method (3 to 45 percentage units, P <0.001), likely related to the low Co recovery. When estimating apparent ileal digestibility (AID), separation of marker and digesta resulted in unrealistically high estimates for the digestibility of nonglucose polysaccharides (54 to 66%), exceeding ATTD values by 16 to 42 percentage units. Moreover, the effect of pectolytic enzyme addition on the AID of nonglucose polysaccharides was in the opposite direction when compared with total collection. The data illustrate that fractionation of digesta, particularly in high-fiber diets, complicates accurate AID measurements in broilers, regardless of the choice of markers used.
format Article/Letter to editor
topic_facet amino-acids
atomic-absorption spectrophotometry
avian ceca
carboxy methyl cellulose
feed ingredients
food
gastrointestinal transit-time
nonstarch polysaccharides
soluble polysaccharide
tract
author de Vries, S.
Kwakkel, R.P.
Pustjens, A.M.
Kabel, M.A.
Hendriks, W.H.
Gerrits, W.J.J.
author_facet de Vries, S.
Kwakkel, R.P.
Pustjens, A.M.
Kabel, M.A.
Hendriks, W.H.
Gerrits, W.J.J.
author_sort de Vries, S.
title Separation of digesta fractions complicates estimation of ileal digestibility using marker methods with Cr2O3 and Co-EDTA in broiler chickens
title_short Separation of digesta fractions complicates estimation of ileal digestibility using marker methods with Cr2O3 and Co-EDTA in broiler chickens
title_full Separation of digesta fractions complicates estimation of ileal digestibility using marker methods with Cr2O3 and Co-EDTA in broiler chickens
title_fullStr Separation of digesta fractions complicates estimation of ileal digestibility using marker methods with Cr2O3 and Co-EDTA in broiler chickens
title_full_unstemmed Separation of digesta fractions complicates estimation of ileal digestibility using marker methods with Cr2O3 and Co-EDTA in broiler chickens
title_sort separation of digesta fractions complicates estimation of ileal digestibility using marker methods with cr2o3 and co-edta in broiler chickens
url https://research.wur.nl/en/publications/separation-of-digesta-fractions-complicates-estimation-of-ileal-d
work_keys_str_mv AT devriess separationofdigestafractionscomplicatesestimationofilealdigestibilityusingmarkermethodswithcr2o3andcoedtainbroilerchickens
AT kwakkelrp separationofdigestafractionscomplicatesestimationofilealdigestibilityusingmarkermethodswithcr2o3andcoedtainbroilerchickens
AT pustjensam separationofdigestafractionscomplicatesestimationofilealdigestibilityusingmarkermethodswithcr2o3andcoedtainbroilerchickens
AT kabelma separationofdigestafractionscomplicatesestimationofilealdigestibilityusingmarkermethodswithcr2o3andcoedtainbroilerchickens
AT hendrikswh separationofdigestafractionscomplicatesestimationofilealdigestibilityusingmarkermethodswithcr2o3andcoedtainbroilerchickens
AT gerritswjj separationofdigestafractionscomplicatesestimationofilealdigestibilityusingmarkermethodswithcr2o3andcoedtainbroilerchickens
_version_ 1819148542898339840