Latin America’s Growth : Looking through the Demand Glass

This paper revisits the historical roots of Latin America’s disappointing growth using a novel macro and trade-based growth decomposition and a simple model of industrialization in a commodities-exporting country with a large informal sector. The approach suggests the need to better qualify two opposite narratives: that the post-1982 (“neoliberal”) reforms have failed, and it is time to look back to the import substitution industrialization era for policy inspiration; and that the post-1982 reforms went in the right direction but must be completed to unleash significant productivity gains. Both can be misleading because they downplay the role of demand. The apparent “miracle” of import substitution industrialization does not provide a realistic point of comparison because it reflected an unsustainable, demand-induced boost in productivity. And the gains expected from Washington Consensus-style reforms alone can be overstated because they are derived from overly restrictive assumptions on demand. By allowing demand to play a more central role, the paper finds a close and revealing relationship between the growth patterns followed by Latin American countries, the quality of their macroeconomic policies, the nature of their trade, and the segmentation of their labor markets. Going forward, the policy agenda calls for an outwardly oriented growth strategy, supported by a more proactive role for the state that promotes not only efficiency in supply, but also the appeal to demand.

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: de la Torre, Augusto, Ize, Alain
Format: Working Paper biblioteca
Language:English
English
Published: World Bank, Washington, DC 2022-11
Subjects:GROWTH, CONVERGENCE, IMPORT SUBSTITUTING INDUSTRIALIZATION, COMMODITY DEPENDENCE, NATURAL RESOURCE CURSE, EXPORT DIVERSIFICATION, PARADOX OF PLENTY, NATURAL RESOURCE WEALTH,
Online Access:http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/099546311082288505/IDU068d946b1072ad0489c0a6e20b03936c7dc30
http://hdl.handle.net/10986/38286
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
id dig-okr-1098638286
record_format koha
spelling dig-okr-10986382862022-11-16T19:31:57Z Latin America’s Growth : Looking through the Demand Glass de la Torre, Augusto Ize, Alain GROWTH CONVERGENCE IMPORT SUBSTITUTING INDUSTRIALIZATION COMMODITY DEPENDENCE NATURAL RESOURCE CURSE EXPORT DIVERSIFICATION PARADOX OF PLENTY NATURAL RESOURCE WEALTH This paper revisits the historical roots of Latin America’s disappointing growth using a novel macro and trade-based growth decomposition and a simple model of industrialization in a commodities-exporting country with a large informal sector. The approach suggests the need to better qualify two opposite narratives: that the post-1982 (“neoliberal”) reforms have failed, and it is time to look back to the import substitution industrialization era for policy inspiration; and that the post-1982 reforms went in the right direction but must be completed to unleash significant productivity gains. Both can be misleading because they downplay the role of demand. The apparent “miracle” of import substitution industrialization does not provide a realistic point of comparison because it reflected an unsustainable, demand-induced boost in productivity. And the gains expected from Washington Consensus-style reforms alone can be overstated because they are derived from overly restrictive assumptions on demand. By allowing demand to play a more central role, the paper finds a close and revealing relationship between the growth patterns followed by Latin American countries, the quality of their macroeconomic policies, the nature of their trade, and the segmentation of their labor markets. Going forward, the policy agenda calls for an outwardly oriented growth strategy, supported by a more proactive role for the state that promotes not only efficiency in supply, but also the appeal to demand. 2022-11-08T22:52:10Z 2022-11-08T22:52:10Z 2022-11 Working Paper http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/099546311082288505/IDU068d946b1072ad0489c0a6e20b03936c7dc30 http://hdl.handle.net/10986/38286 English en Policy Research Working Papers;10227 CC BY 3.0 IGO http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/igo World Bank World Bank, Washington, DC Policy Research Working Paper Publications & Research Latin America & Caribbean
institution Banco Mundial
collection DSpace
country Estados Unidos
countrycode US
component Bibliográfico
access En linea
databasecode dig-okr
tag biblioteca
region America del Norte
libraryname Biblioteca del Banco Mundial
language English
English
topic GROWTH
CONVERGENCE
IMPORT SUBSTITUTING INDUSTRIALIZATION
COMMODITY DEPENDENCE
NATURAL RESOURCE CURSE
EXPORT DIVERSIFICATION
PARADOX OF PLENTY
NATURAL RESOURCE WEALTH
GROWTH
CONVERGENCE
IMPORT SUBSTITUTING INDUSTRIALIZATION
COMMODITY DEPENDENCE
NATURAL RESOURCE CURSE
EXPORT DIVERSIFICATION
PARADOX OF PLENTY
NATURAL RESOURCE WEALTH
spellingShingle GROWTH
CONVERGENCE
IMPORT SUBSTITUTING INDUSTRIALIZATION
COMMODITY DEPENDENCE
NATURAL RESOURCE CURSE
EXPORT DIVERSIFICATION
PARADOX OF PLENTY
NATURAL RESOURCE WEALTH
GROWTH
CONVERGENCE
IMPORT SUBSTITUTING INDUSTRIALIZATION
COMMODITY DEPENDENCE
NATURAL RESOURCE CURSE
EXPORT DIVERSIFICATION
PARADOX OF PLENTY
NATURAL RESOURCE WEALTH
de la Torre, Augusto
Ize, Alain
Latin America’s Growth : Looking through the Demand Glass
description This paper revisits the historical roots of Latin America’s disappointing growth using a novel macro and trade-based growth decomposition and a simple model of industrialization in a commodities-exporting country with a large informal sector. The approach suggests the need to better qualify two opposite narratives: that the post-1982 (“neoliberal”) reforms have failed, and it is time to look back to the import substitution industrialization era for policy inspiration; and that the post-1982 reforms went in the right direction but must be completed to unleash significant productivity gains. Both can be misleading because they downplay the role of demand. The apparent “miracle” of import substitution industrialization does not provide a realistic point of comparison because it reflected an unsustainable, demand-induced boost in productivity. And the gains expected from Washington Consensus-style reforms alone can be overstated because they are derived from overly restrictive assumptions on demand. By allowing demand to play a more central role, the paper finds a close and revealing relationship between the growth patterns followed by Latin American countries, the quality of their macroeconomic policies, the nature of their trade, and the segmentation of their labor markets. Going forward, the policy agenda calls for an outwardly oriented growth strategy, supported by a more proactive role for the state that promotes not only efficiency in supply, but also the appeal to demand.
format Working Paper
topic_facet GROWTH
CONVERGENCE
IMPORT SUBSTITUTING INDUSTRIALIZATION
COMMODITY DEPENDENCE
NATURAL RESOURCE CURSE
EXPORT DIVERSIFICATION
PARADOX OF PLENTY
NATURAL RESOURCE WEALTH
author de la Torre, Augusto
Ize, Alain
author_facet de la Torre, Augusto
Ize, Alain
author_sort de la Torre, Augusto
title Latin America’s Growth : Looking through the Demand Glass
title_short Latin America’s Growth : Looking through the Demand Glass
title_full Latin America’s Growth : Looking through the Demand Glass
title_fullStr Latin America’s Growth : Looking through the Demand Glass
title_full_unstemmed Latin America’s Growth : Looking through the Demand Glass
title_sort latin america’s growth : looking through the demand glass
publisher World Bank, Washington, DC
publishDate 2022-11
url http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/099546311082288505/IDU068d946b1072ad0489c0a6e20b03936c7dc30
http://hdl.handle.net/10986/38286
work_keys_str_mv AT delatorreaugusto latinamericasgrowthlookingthroughthedemandglass
AT izealain latinamericasgrowthlookingthroughthedemandglass
_version_ 1756576219796602880