Tools for Legislative Oversight: An Empirical Investigation
Parliaments are the institutions through which governments are held accountable to the electorate. They have a wide range of tools with which to carry out this oversight function, but until recently little analysis had been undertaken on the characteristics or use of such tools. This paper uses data for 83 countries that was collected in 2001 to investigate whether the oversight potential relates to three variables, namely the form of government (presidential, semi-presidential, or parliamentary), per capita income levels, and the level of democracy. The paper finds that oversight potential is greatly affected by the form of government, per capita income levels, and levels of democracy. Countries with parliamentary forms of government, higher income levels, and which are more democratic have a greater number of oversight tools and greater oversight potential. While the oversight potential follows this general trend, the use of committees of enquiry, interpellations and ombudsman offices follows a different pattern. The use of interpellations as an oversight tool is most common in high income countries, less common in low income countries and least common in middle income countries while the presence of committees of enquiry and of the ombudsman offices is most common in middle income countries, less common in high income countries and least common in low income countries.
Saved in:
| Main Authors: | , |
|---|---|
| Language: | English en_US |
| Published: |
World Bank, Washington, D.C.
2004-09
|
| Subjects: | ACCOUNTABILITY, COMMITTEE HEARINGS, DEMOCRACY, DEMOCRATIC DEVELOPMENT, DEVELOPMENT INDICATORS, ELECTORATE, EXECUTIVE BRANCH, GOOD GOVERNANCE, HIGH INCOME, HIGH INCOME COUNTRIES, INCOME, INCOME LEVELS, LAWS, LEGISLATORS, LOW INCOME, LOW-INCOME COUNTRIES, MIDDLE INCOME COUNTRIES, NATIONAL INCOME, NATIONAL PARLIAMENTS, PARLIAMENT, PER CAPITA INCOME, POLICY RESEARCH, POLITICAL RIGHTS, REPRESENTATIVES, DEMOCRACIES, DEMOCRATIC REGIMES ACCOUNTABILITY, MIDDLE INCOME, PARLIAMENTARIANS, PARLIAMENTARY CONTROL, PARLIAMENTARY OVERSIGHT, PARLIAMENTARY SYSTEMS, PARLIAMENTS, |
| Online Access: | http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2004/09/5124097/tools-legislative-oversight-empirical-investigation https://hdl.handle.net/10986/14143 |
| Tags: |
Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
|
| id |
dig-okr-1098614143 |
|---|---|
| record_format |
koha |
| spelling |
dig-okr-10986141432024-08-08T17:31:41Z Tools for Legislative Oversight: An Empirical Investigation Pelizzo, Riuccardo Stapenhurst, Frederick C. ACCOUNTABILITY COMMITTEE HEARINGS DEMOCRACY DEMOCRATIC DEVELOPMENT DEVELOPMENT INDICATORS ELECTORATE EXECUTIVE BRANCH GOOD GOVERNANCE HIGH INCOME HIGH INCOME COUNTRIES INCOME INCOME LEVELS LAWS LEGISLATORS LOW INCOME LOW-INCOME COUNTRIES MIDDLE INCOME COUNTRIES NATIONAL INCOME NATIONAL PARLIAMENTS PARLIAMENT PER CAPITA INCOME POLICY RESEARCH POLITICAL RIGHTS REPRESENTATIVES DEMOCRACIES DEMOCRATIC REGIMES ACCOUNTABILITY COMMITTEE HEARINGS DEMOCRACY DEMOCRATIC DEVELOPMENT DEVELOPMENT INDICATORS ELECTORATE EXECUTIVE BRANCH GOOD GOVERNANCE HIGH INCOME HIGH INCOME COUNTRIES INCOME INCOME LEVELS LAWS LEGISLATORS LOW INCOME LOW-INCOME COUNTRIES MIDDLE INCOME MIDDLE INCOME COUNTRIES NATIONAL INCOME NATIONAL PARLIAMENTS PARLIAMENT PARLIAMENTARIANS PARLIAMENTARY CONTROL PARLIAMENTARY OVERSIGHT PARLIAMENTARY SYSTEMS PARLIAMENTS PER CAPITA INCOME POLICY RESEARCH POLITICAL RIGHTS REPRESENTATIVES Parliaments are the institutions through which governments are held accountable to the electorate. They have a wide range of tools with which to carry out this oversight function, but until recently little analysis had been undertaken on the characteristics or use of such tools. This paper uses data for 83 countries that was collected in 2001 to investigate whether the oversight potential relates to three variables, namely the form of government (presidential, semi-presidential, or parliamentary), per capita income levels, and the level of democracy. The paper finds that oversight potential is greatly affected by the form of government, per capita income levels, and levels of democracy. Countries with parliamentary forms of government, higher income levels, and which are more democratic have a greater number of oversight tools and greater oversight potential. While the oversight potential follows this general trend, the use of committees of enquiry, interpellations and ombudsman offices follows a different pattern. The use of interpellations as an oversight tool is most common in high income countries, less common in low income countries and least common in middle income countries while the presence of committees of enquiry and of the ombudsman offices is most common in middle income countries, less common in high income countries and least common in low income countries. 2013-06-24T15:43:10Z 2013-06-24T15:43:10Z 2004-09 http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2004/09/5124097/tools-legislative-oversight-empirical-investigation https://hdl.handle.net/10986/14143 English en_US Policy Research Working Paper;No.3388 CC BY 3.0 IGO http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/igo/ World Bank application/pdf text/plain World Bank, Washington, D.C. |
| institution |
Banco Mundial |
| collection |
DSpace |
| country |
Estados Unidos |
| countrycode |
US |
| component |
Bibliográfico |
| access |
En linea |
| databasecode |
dig-okr |
| tag |
biblioteca |
| region |
America del Norte |
| libraryname |
Biblioteca del Banco Mundial |
| language |
English en_US |
| topic |
ACCOUNTABILITY COMMITTEE HEARINGS DEMOCRACY DEMOCRATIC DEVELOPMENT DEVELOPMENT INDICATORS ELECTORATE EXECUTIVE BRANCH GOOD GOVERNANCE HIGH INCOME HIGH INCOME COUNTRIES INCOME INCOME LEVELS LAWS LEGISLATORS LOW INCOME LOW-INCOME COUNTRIES MIDDLE INCOME COUNTRIES NATIONAL INCOME NATIONAL PARLIAMENTS PARLIAMENT PER CAPITA INCOME POLICY RESEARCH POLITICAL RIGHTS REPRESENTATIVES DEMOCRACIES DEMOCRATIC REGIMES ACCOUNTABILITY COMMITTEE HEARINGS DEMOCRACY DEMOCRATIC DEVELOPMENT DEVELOPMENT INDICATORS ELECTORATE EXECUTIVE BRANCH GOOD GOVERNANCE HIGH INCOME HIGH INCOME COUNTRIES INCOME INCOME LEVELS LAWS LEGISLATORS LOW INCOME LOW-INCOME COUNTRIES MIDDLE INCOME MIDDLE INCOME COUNTRIES NATIONAL INCOME NATIONAL PARLIAMENTS PARLIAMENT PARLIAMENTARIANS PARLIAMENTARY CONTROL PARLIAMENTARY OVERSIGHT PARLIAMENTARY SYSTEMS PARLIAMENTS PER CAPITA INCOME POLICY RESEARCH POLITICAL RIGHTS REPRESENTATIVES ACCOUNTABILITY COMMITTEE HEARINGS DEMOCRACY DEMOCRATIC DEVELOPMENT DEVELOPMENT INDICATORS ELECTORATE EXECUTIVE BRANCH GOOD GOVERNANCE HIGH INCOME HIGH INCOME COUNTRIES INCOME INCOME LEVELS LAWS LEGISLATORS LOW INCOME LOW-INCOME COUNTRIES MIDDLE INCOME COUNTRIES NATIONAL INCOME NATIONAL PARLIAMENTS PARLIAMENT PER CAPITA INCOME POLICY RESEARCH POLITICAL RIGHTS REPRESENTATIVES DEMOCRACIES DEMOCRATIC REGIMES ACCOUNTABILITY COMMITTEE HEARINGS DEMOCRACY DEMOCRATIC DEVELOPMENT DEVELOPMENT INDICATORS ELECTORATE EXECUTIVE BRANCH GOOD GOVERNANCE HIGH INCOME HIGH INCOME COUNTRIES INCOME INCOME LEVELS LAWS LEGISLATORS LOW INCOME LOW-INCOME COUNTRIES MIDDLE INCOME MIDDLE INCOME COUNTRIES NATIONAL INCOME NATIONAL PARLIAMENTS PARLIAMENT PARLIAMENTARIANS PARLIAMENTARY CONTROL PARLIAMENTARY OVERSIGHT PARLIAMENTARY SYSTEMS PARLIAMENTS PER CAPITA INCOME POLICY RESEARCH POLITICAL RIGHTS REPRESENTATIVES |
| spellingShingle |
ACCOUNTABILITY COMMITTEE HEARINGS DEMOCRACY DEMOCRATIC DEVELOPMENT DEVELOPMENT INDICATORS ELECTORATE EXECUTIVE BRANCH GOOD GOVERNANCE HIGH INCOME HIGH INCOME COUNTRIES INCOME INCOME LEVELS LAWS LEGISLATORS LOW INCOME LOW-INCOME COUNTRIES MIDDLE INCOME COUNTRIES NATIONAL INCOME NATIONAL PARLIAMENTS PARLIAMENT PER CAPITA INCOME POLICY RESEARCH POLITICAL RIGHTS REPRESENTATIVES DEMOCRACIES DEMOCRATIC REGIMES ACCOUNTABILITY COMMITTEE HEARINGS DEMOCRACY DEMOCRATIC DEVELOPMENT DEVELOPMENT INDICATORS ELECTORATE EXECUTIVE BRANCH GOOD GOVERNANCE HIGH INCOME HIGH INCOME COUNTRIES INCOME INCOME LEVELS LAWS LEGISLATORS LOW INCOME LOW-INCOME COUNTRIES MIDDLE INCOME MIDDLE INCOME COUNTRIES NATIONAL INCOME NATIONAL PARLIAMENTS PARLIAMENT PARLIAMENTARIANS PARLIAMENTARY CONTROL PARLIAMENTARY OVERSIGHT PARLIAMENTARY SYSTEMS PARLIAMENTS PER CAPITA INCOME POLICY RESEARCH POLITICAL RIGHTS REPRESENTATIVES ACCOUNTABILITY COMMITTEE HEARINGS DEMOCRACY DEMOCRATIC DEVELOPMENT DEVELOPMENT INDICATORS ELECTORATE EXECUTIVE BRANCH GOOD GOVERNANCE HIGH INCOME HIGH INCOME COUNTRIES INCOME INCOME LEVELS LAWS LEGISLATORS LOW INCOME LOW-INCOME COUNTRIES MIDDLE INCOME COUNTRIES NATIONAL INCOME NATIONAL PARLIAMENTS PARLIAMENT PER CAPITA INCOME POLICY RESEARCH POLITICAL RIGHTS REPRESENTATIVES DEMOCRACIES DEMOCRATIC REGIMES ACCOUNTABILITY COMMITTEE HEARINGS DEMOCRACY DEMOCRATIC DEVELOPMENT DEVELOPMENT INDICATORS ELECTORATE EXECUTIVE BRANCH GOOD GOVERNANCE HIGH INCOME HIGH INCOME COUNTRIES INCOME INCOME LEVELS LAWS LEGISLATORS LOW INCOME LOW-INCOME COUNTRIES MIDDLE INCOME MIDDLE INCOME COUNTRIES NATIONAL INCOME NATIONAL PARLIAMENTS PARLIAMENT PARLIAMENTARIANS PARLIAMENTARY CONTROL PARLIAMENTARY OVERSIGHT PARLIAMENTARY SYSTEMS PARLIAMENTS PER CAPITA INCOME POLICY RESEARCH POLITICAL RIGHTS REPRESENTATIVES Pelizzo, Riuccardo Stapenhurst, Frederick C. Tools for Legislative Oversight: An Empirical Investigation |
| description |
Parliaments are the institutions through
which governments are held accountable to the electorate.
They have a wide range of tools with which to carry out this
oversight function, but until recently little analysis had
been undertaken on the characteristics or use of such tools.
This paper uses data for 83 countries that was collected in
2001 to investigate whether the oversight potential relates
to three variables, namely the form of government
(presidential, semi-presidential, or parliamentary), per
capita income levels, and the level of democracy. The paper
finds that oversight potential is greatly affected by the
form of government, per capita income levels, and levels of
democracy. Countries with parliamentary forms of government,
higher income levels, and which are more democratic have a
greater number of oversight tools and greater oversight
potential. While the oversight potential follows this
general trend, the use of committees of enquiry,
interpellations and ombudsman offices follows a different
pattern. The use of interpellations as an oversight tool is
most common in high income countries, less common in low
income countries and least common in middle income countries
while the presence of committees of enquiry and of the
ombudsman offices is most common in middle income countries,
less common in high income countries and least common in low
income countries. |
| topic_facet |
ACCOUNTABILITY COMMITTEE HEARINGS DEMOCRACY DEMOCRATIC DEVELOPMENT DEVELOPMENT INDICATORS ELECTORATE EXECUTIVE BRANCH GOOD GOVERNANCE HIGH INCOME HIGH INCOME COUNTRIES INCOME INCOME LEVELS LAWS LEGISLATORS LOW INCOME LOW-INCOME COUNTRIES MIDDLE INCOME COUNTRIES NATIONAL INCOME NATIONAL PARLIAMENTS PARLIAMENT PER CAPITA INCOME POLICY RESEARCH POLITICAL RIGHTS REPRESENTATIVES DEMOCRACIES DEMOCRATIC REGIMES ACCOUNTABILITY COMMITTEE HEARINGS DEMOCRACY DEMOCRATIC DEVELOPMENT DEVELOPMENT INDICATORS ELECTORATE EXECUTIVE BRANCH GOOD GOVERNANCE HIGH INCOME HIGH INCOME COUNTRIES INCOME INCOME LEVELS LAWS LEGISLATORS LOW INCOME LOW-INCOME COUNTRIES MIDDLE INCOME MIDDLE INCOME COUNTRIES NATIONAL INCOME NATIONAL PARLIAMENTS PARLIAMENT PARLIAMENTARIANS PARLIAMENTARY CONTROL PARLIAMENTARY OVERSIGHT PARLIAMENTARY SYSTEMS PARLIAMENTS PER CAPITA INCOME POLICY RESEARCH POLITICAL RIGHTS REPRESENTATIVES |
| author |
Pelizzo, Riuccardo Stapenhurst, Frederick C. |
| author_facet |
Pelizzo, Riuccardo Stapenhurst, Frederick C. |
| author_sort |
Pelizzo, Riuccardo |
| title |
Tools for Legislative Oversight: An Empirical Investigation |
| title_short |
Tools for Legislative Oversight: An Empirical Investigation |
| title_full |
Tools for Legislative Oversight: An Empirical Investigation |
| title_fullStr |
Tools for Legislative Oversight: An Empirical Investigation |
| title_full_unstemmed |
Tools for Legislative Oversight: An Empirical Investigation |
| title_sort |
tools for legislative oversight: an empirical investigation |
| publisher |
World Bank, Washington, D.C. |
| publishDate |
2004-09 |
| url |
http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2004/09/5124097/tools-legislative-oversight-empirical-investigation https://hdl.handle.net/10986/14143 |
| work_keys_str_mv |
AT pelizzoriuccardo toolsforlegislativeoversightanempiricalinvestigation AT stapenhurstfrederickc toolsforlegislativeoversightanempiricalinvestigation |
| _version_ |
1807160173789184000 |