The Influence of Popular Conceptions of National and Constitutional Identity on the Position of Marginalized or Minority Groups Within a Nation State. A Legal, Empirical, and Comparative Analysis of Four Jurisdictions Through the Prism of Gender

The Influence of Popular Conceptions of National and Constitutional Identity on the Position of Marginalized or Minority Groups Within a Nation State. A Legal, Empirical, and Comparative Analysis of Four Jurisdictions Through the Prism of Gender

Abstract: What influence might popular conceptions of national and constitutional identity have on the position of marginalized or minority groups within that system? This article investigates whether there may be a relationship between the two, on the basis of a legal, empirical, and comparative analysis of four jurisdictions (Poland, Hungary, Uruguay and Argentina) through the prism of gender. The literature suggests the presence of populist rhetoric in the domestic politics of each state. However, they are distinct in potentially relevant ways, including differing regional human rights frameworks. The case studies demonstrate the potential for national and constitutional identity to function in an exclusionary manner; the apparent capacity of political parties to amplify this exclusionary potential by advancing highly traditional narratives of identity, or linking identity to contentious social issues; and the limited efficacy of human rights mechanisms in mitigating the impact of informal influences.

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Gagliardi,Silvia, Carolan,Eoin, Banerjee,Somsubhra, Iglesias Seifert,Demian Ernesto, Rodríguez Gutiérrez,Daniela
Format: Digital revista
Language:English
Published: Universidad Adolfo Ibáñez. Facultad de Derecho. 2024
Online Access:http://www.scielo.cl/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S0719-91122024000100158
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
id oai:scielo:S0719-91122024000100158
record_format ojs
spelling oai:scielo:S0719-911220240001001582024-07-10The Influence of Popular Conceptions of National and Constitutional Identity on the Position of Marginalized or Minority Groups Within a Nation State. A Legal, Empirical, and Comparative Analysis of Four Jurisdictions Through the Prism of GenderGagliardi,SilviaCarolan,EoinBanerjee,SomsubhraIglesias Seifert,Demian ErnestoRodríguez Gutiérrez,Daniela Constitutional identity Minorities Human rights Gender Abstract: What influence might popular conceptions of national and constitutional identity have on the position of marginalized or minority groups within that system? This article investigates whether there may be a relationship between the two, on the basis of a legal, empirical, and comparative analysis of four jurisdictions (Poland, Hungary, Uruguay and Argentina) through the prism of gender. The literature suggests the presence of populist rhetoric in the domestic politics of each state. However, they are distinct in potentially relevant ways, including differing regional human rights frameworks. The case studies demonstrate the potential for national and constitutional identity to function in an exclusionary manner; the apparent capacity of political parties to amplify this exclusionary potential by advancing highly traditional narratives of identity, or linking identity to contentious social issues; and the limited efficacy of human rights mechanisms in mitigating the impact of informal influences.info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccessUniversidad Adolfo Ibáñez. Facultad de Derecho.Latin american legal studies v.12 n.1 20242024-01-01text/htmlhttp://www.scielo.cl/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S0719-91122024000100158en10.15691/0719-9112vol12n1a5
institution SCIELO
collection OJS
country Chile
countrycode CL
component Revista
access En linea
databasecode rev-scielo-cl
tag revista
region America del Sur
libraryname SciELO
language English
format Digital
author Gagliardi,Silvia
Carolan,Eoin
Banerjee,Somsubhra
Iglesias Seifert,Demian Ernesto
Rodríguez Gutiérrez,Daniela
spellingShingle Gagliardi,Silvia
Carolan,Eoin
Banerjee,Somsubhra
Iglesias Seifert,Demian Ernesto
Rodríguez Gutiérrez,Daniela
The Influence of Popular Conceptions of National and Constitutional Identity on the Position of Marginalized or Minority Groups Within a Nation State. A Legal, Empirical, and Comparative Analysis of Four Jurisdictions Through the Prism of Gender
author_facet Gagliardi,Silvia
Carolan,Eoin
Banerjee,Somsubhra
Iglesias Seifert,Demian Ernesto
Rodríguez Gutiérrez,Daniela
author_sort Gagliardi,Silvia
title The Influence of Popular Conceptions of National and Constitutional Identity on the Position of Marginalized or Minority Groups Within a Nation State. A Legal, Empirical, and Comparative Analysis of Four Jurisdictions Through the Prism of Gender
title_short The Influence of Popular Conceptions of National and Constitutional Identity on the Position of Marginalized or Minority Groups Within a Nation State. A Legal, Empirical, and Comparative Analysis of Four Jurisdictions Through the Prism of Gender
title_full The Influence of Popular Conceptions of National and Constitutional Identity on the Position of Marginalized or Minority Groups Within a Nation State. A Legal, Empirical, and Comparative Analysis of Four Jurisdictions Through the Prism of Gender
title_fullStr The Influence of Popular Conceptions of National and Constitutional Identity on the Position of Marginalized or Minority Groups Within a Nation State. A Legal, Empirical, and Comparative Analysis of Four Jurisdictions Through the Prism of Gender
title_full_unstemmed The Influence of Popular Conceptions of National and Constitutional Identity on the Position of Marginalized or Minority Groups Within a Nation State. A Legal, Empirical, and Comparative Analysis of Four Jurisdictions Through the Prism of Gender
title_sort influence of popular conceptions of national and constitutional identity on the position of marginalized or minority groups within a nation state. a legal, empirical, and comparative analysis of four jurisdictions through the prism of gender
description Abstract: What influence might popular conceptions of national and constitutional identity have on the position of marginalized or minority groups within that system? This article investigates whether there may be a relationship between the two, on the basis of a legal, empirical, and comparative analysis of four jurisdictions (Poland, Hungary, Uruguay and Argentina) through the prism of gender. The literature suggests the presence of populist rhetoric in the domestic politics of each state. However, they are distinct in potentially relevant ways, including differing regional human rights frameworks. The case studies demonstrate the potential for national and constitutional identity to function in an exclusionary manner; the apparent capacity of political parties to amplify this exclusionary potential by advancing highly traditional narratives of identity, or linking identity to contentious social issues; and the limited efficacy of human rights mechanisms in mitigating the impact of informal influences.
publisher Universidad Adolfo Ibáñez. Facultad de Derecho.
publishDate 2024
url http://www.scielo.cl/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S0719-91122024000100158
work_keys_str_mv AT gagliardisilvia theinfluenceofpopularconceptionsofnationalandconstitutionalidentityonthepositionofmarginalizedorminoritygroupswithinanationstatealegalempiricalandcomparativeanalysisoffourjurisdictionsthroughtheprismofgender
AT carolaneoin theinfluenceofpopularconceptionsofnationalandconstitutionalidentityonthepositionofmarginalizedorminoritygroupswithinanationstatealegalempiricalandcomparativeanalysisoffourjurisdictionsthroughtheprismofgender
AT banerjeesomsubhra theinfluenceofpopularconceptionsofnationalandconstitutionalidentityonthepositionofmarginalizedorminoritygroupswithinanationstatealegalempiricalandcomparativeanalysisoffourjurisdictionsthroughtheprismofgender
AT iglesiasseifertdemianernesto theinfluenceofpopularconceptionsofnationalandconstitutionalidentityonthepositionofmarginalizedorminoritygroupswithinanationstatealegalempiricalandcomparativeanalysisoffourjurisdictionsthroughtheprismofgender
AT rodriguezgutierrezdaniela theinfluenceofpopularconceptionsofnationalandconstitutionalidentityonthepositionofmarginalizedorminoritygroupswithinanationstatealegalempiricalandcomparativeanalysisoffourjurisdictionsthroughtheprismofgender
AT gagliardisilvia influenceofpopularconceptionsofnationalandconstitutionalidentityonthepositionofmarginalizedorminoritygroupswithinanationstatealegalempiricalandcomparativeanalysisoffourjurisdictionsthroughtheprismofgender
AT carolaneoin influenceofpopularconceptionsofnationalandconstitutionalidentityonthepositionofmarginalizedorminoritygroupswithinanationstatealegalempiricalandcomparativeanalysisoffourjurisdictionsthroughtheprismofgender
AT banerjeesomsubhra influenceofpopularconceptionsofnationalandconstitutionalidentityonthepositionofmarginalizedorminoritygroupswithinanationstatealegalempiricalandcomparativeanalysisoffourjurisdictionsthroughtheprismofgender
AT iglesiasseifertdemianernesto influenceofpopularconceptionsofnationalandconstitutionalidentityonthepositionofmarginalizedorminoritygroupswithinanationstatealegalempiricalandcomparativeanalysisoffourjurisdictionsthroughtheprismofgender
AT rodriguezgutierrezdaniela influenceofpopularconceptionsofnationalandconstitutionalidentityonthepositionofmarginalizedorminoritygroupswithinanationstatealegalempiricalandcomparativeanalysisoffourjurisdictionsthroughtheprismofgender
_version_ 1806044645771182080

Similar Items