Braden scale has low reliability in different patients under care in intensive care unit

SUMMARY OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to assess the inter-reliability of the Braden scale and its subscales for different patients assisted in the intensive care unit. We hypothesized that the Braden scale has low reliability in different populations. METHODS: This reliability study involved the Braden scale in intensive care unit of a hospital. A total of 200 patients were admitted to the intensive care unit in four different groups: neurological patients, sepsis, elderly, and adults affected by trauma. The Braden scale is a tool composed of six subscales for patient assessment: sensory perception, humidity, activity, mobility, nutrition, and friction. The total score was also calculated. The Braden scale was applied by two different nurses with an interval of 20–30 min between applications. RESULTS: For all populations, kappa values considered unsuitable were observed for most categories of the Braden scale, ranging from 0.06–0.25. Only for the total Braden scale score was moderate reliability identified in all groups evaluated, with intraclass correlation coefficient values ranging from 0.48–0.75. CONCLUSIONS: Braden scale is not a reliable tool to be used in the intensive care unit, and we do not recommend the use of this scale to assess the risk of developing pressure injury.

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Veiga,Thalita Pereira, Rêgo,Adriana Sousa, Montenegro,Widlani Sousa, Ferreira,Patrícia Rodrigues, Rocha,Daniel Santos, Felipe,Ilana Mírian Almeida, Santos-de-Araújo,Aldair Darlan, Mendes,Renata Gonçalves, Tavarez,Rudys Rodolfo de Jesus, Bassi-Dibai,Daniela
Format: Digital revista
Language:English
Published: Associação Médica Brasileira 2022
Online Access:http://old.scielo.br/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S0104-42302022000901221
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
id oai:scielo:S0104-42302022000901221
record_format ojs
spelling oai:scielo:S0104-423020220009012212022-11-23Braden scale has low reliability in different patients under care in intensive care unitVeiga,Thalita PereiraRêgo,Adriana SousaMontenegro,Widlani SousaFerreira,Patrícia RodriguesRocha,Daniel SantosFelipe,Ilana Mírian AlmeidaSantos-de-Araújo,Aldair DarlanMendes,Renata GonçalvesTavarez,Rudys Rodolfo de JesusBassi-Dibai,Daniela Risk assessment Validation study Intensive care unit Pressure injuries SUMMARY OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to assess the inter-reliability of the Braden scale and its subscales for different patients assisted in the intensive care unit. We hypothesized that the Braden scale has low reliability in different populations. METHODS: This reliability study involved the Braden scale in intensive care unit of a hospital. A total of 200 patients were admitted to the intensive care unit in four different groups: neurological patients, sepsis, elderly, and adults affected by trauma. The Braden scale is a tool composed of six subscales for patient assessment: sensory perception, humidity, activity, mobility, nutrition, and friction. The total score was also calculated. The Braden scale was applied by two different nurses with an interval of 20–30 min between applications. RESULTS: For all populations, kappa values considered unsuitable were observed for most categories of the Braden scale, ranging from 0.06–0.25. Only for the total Braden scale score was moderate reliability identified in all groups evaluated, with intraclass correlation coefficient values ranging from 0.48–0.75. CONCLUSIONS: Braden scale is not a reliable tool to be used in the intensive care unit, and we do not recommend the use of this scale to assess the risk of developing pressure injury.info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccessAssociação Médica BrasileiraRevista da Associação Médica Brasileira v.68 n.9 20222022-09-01info:eu-repo/semantics/articletext/htmlhttp://old.scielo.br/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S0104-42302022000901221en10.1590/1806-9282.20220249
institution SCIELO
collection OJS
country Brasil
countrycode BR
component Revista
access En linea
databasecode rev-scielo-br
tag revista
region America del Sur
libraryname SciELO
language English
format Digital
author Veiga,Thalita Pereira
Rêgo,Adriana Sousa
Montenegro,Widlani Sousa
Ferreira,Patrícia Rodrigues
Rocha,Daniel Santos
Felipe,Ilana Mírian Almeida
Santos-de-Araújo,Aldair Darlan
Mendes,Renata Gonçalves
Tavarez,Rudys Rodolfo de Jesus
Bassi-Dibai,Daniela
spellingShingle Veiga,Thalita Pereira
Rêgo,Adriana Sousa
Montenegro,Widlani Sousa
Ferreira,Patrícia Rodrigues
Rocha,Daniel Santos
Felipe,Ilana Mírian Almeida
Santos-de-Araújo,Aldair Darlan
Mendes,Renata Gonçalves
Tavarez,Rudys Rodolfo de Jesus
Bassi-Dibai,Daniela
Braden scale has low reliability in different patients under care in intensive care unit
author_facet Veiga,Thalita Pereira
Rêgo,Adriana Sousa
Montenegro,Widlani Sousa
Ferreira,Patrícia Rodrigues
Rocha,Daniel Santos
Felipe,Ilana Mírian Almeida
Santos-de-Araújo,Aldair Darlan
Mendes,Renata Gonçalves
Tavarez,Rudys Rodolfo de Jesus
Bassi-Dibai,Daniela
author_sort Veiga,Thalita Pereira
title Braden scale has low reliability in different patients under care in intensive care unit
title_short Braden scale has low reliability in different patients under care in intensive care unit
title_full Braden scale has low reliability in different patients under care in intensive care unit
title_fullStr Braden scale has low reliability in different patients under care in intensive care unit
title_full_unstemmed Braden scale has low reliability in different patients under care in intensive care unit
title_sort braden scale has low reliability in different patients under care in intensive care unit
description SUMMARY OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to assess the inter-reliability of the Braden scale and its subscales for different patients assisted in the intensive care unit. We hypothesized that the Braden scale has low reliability in different populations. METHODS: This reliability study involved the Braden scale in intensive care unit of a hospital. A total of 200 patients were admitted to the intensive care unit in four different groups: neurological patients, sepsis, elderly, and adults affected by trauma. The Braden scale is a tool composed of six subscales for patient assessment: sensory perception, humidity, activity, mobility, nutrition, and friction. The total score was also calculated. The Braden scale was applied by two different nurses with an interval of 20–30 min between applications. RESULTS: For all populations, kappa values considered unsuitable were observed for most categories of the Braden scale, ranging from 0.06–0.25. Only for the total Braden scale score was moderate reliability identified in all groups evaluated, with intraclass correlation coefficient values ranging from 0.48–0.75. CONCLUSIONS: Braden scale is not a reliable tool to be used in the intensive care unit, and we do not recommend the use of this scale to assess the risk of developing pressure injury.
publisher Associação Médica Brasileira
publishDate 2022
url http://old.scielo.br/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S0104-42302022000901221
work_keys_str_mv AT veigathalitapereira bradenscalehaslowreliabilityindifferentpatientsundercareinintensivecareunit
AT regoadrianasousa bradenscalehaslowreliabilityindifferentpatientsundercareinintensivecareunit
AT montenegrowidlanisousa bradenscalehaslowreliabilityindifferentpatientsundercareinintensivecareunit
AT ferreirapatriciarodrigues bradenscalehaslowreliabilityindifferentpatientsundercareinintensivecareunit
AT rochadanielsantos bradenscalehaslowreliabilityindifferentpatientsundercareinintensivecareunit
AT felipeilanamirianalmeida bradenscalehaslowreliabilityindifferentpatientsundercareinintensivecareunit
AT santosdearaujoaldairdarlan bradenscalehaslowreliabilityindifferentpatientsundercareinintensivecareunit
AT mendesrenatagoncalves bradenscalehaslowreliabilityindifferentpatientsundercareinintensivecareunit
AT tavarezrudysrodolfodejesus bradenscalehaslowreliabilityindifferentpatientsundercareinintensivecareunit
AT bassidibaidaniela bradenscalehaslowreliabilityindifferentpatientsundercareinintensivecareunit
_version_ 1756471952659185664