Democracia e eficiência: a difícil relação entre política e economia no debate contemporâneo

Democracy and efficiency: hard relations between politics and economy. Many economists see politics as an irrational activity. They also think state action usually generates market inefficiencies and democratic institutions, such as elections, often work as obstacles to sound economic measures. Showing that vision has been embedded into the main currents of economic thought since the last century, we also argue those ideas are exported to great part of contemporary political science, including the area of public policies. Examining the literature, we show that rational choice political scientists, as the economists, claim governability and effective decisions will be guaranteed mainly through concentrated arenas or through insulated arrangements able to protect policy makers from political interference. In other words, governability depends on the reduction of the political arenas. On the contrary, we reject this technocratic solution of splitting politics from economy. With the support of classical pluralist thinkers, we stand another conception, arguing politics is the privileged social space for building interests and values in an institutionalized way. The difficulties to surpass current international crises since 2008 reveal this is a crucial problem: reducing politics would prevent societies from improving institutional solutions which are the only ones able to give space to emerging conflicts and, then, reach eventual consensus around them.

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Loureiro,Maria Rita, Abrucio,Fernando Luiz
Format: Digital revista
Language:Portuguese
Published: Centro de Economia Política 2012
Online Access:http://old.scielo.br/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S0101-31572012000400005
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
id oai:scielo:S0101-31572012000400005
record_format ojs
spelling oai:scielo:S0101-315720120004000052013-01-21Democracia e eficiência: a difícil relação entre política e economia no debate contemporâneoLoureiro,Maria RitaAbrucio,Fernando Luiz democracy economic efficiency mainstream economics political science rational choice theory Democracy and efficiency: hard relations between politics and economy. Many economists see politics as an irrational activity. They also think state action usually generates market inefficiencies and democratic institutions, such as elections, often work as obstacles to sound economic measures. Showing that vision has been embedded into the main currents of economic thought since the last century, we also argue those ideas are exported to great part of contemporary political science, including the area of public policies. Examining the literature, we show that rational choice political scientists, as the economists, claim governability and effective decisions will be guaranteed mainly through concentrated arenas or through insulated arrangements able to protect policy makers from political interference. In other words, governability depends on the reduction of the political arenas. On the contrary, we reject this technocratic solution of splitting politics from economy. With the support of classical pluralist thinkers, we stand another conception, arguing politics is the privileged social space for building interests and values in an institutionalized way. The difficulties to surpass current international crises since 2008 reveal this is a crucial problem: reducing politics would prevent societies from improving institutional solutions which are the only ones able to give space to emerging conflicts and, then, reach eventual consensus around them.info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccessCentro de Economia PolíticaBrazilian Journal of Political Economy v.32 n.4 20122012-12-01info:eu-repo/semantics/articletext/htmlhttp://old.scielo.br/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S0101-31572012000400005pt10.1590/S0101-31572012000400005
institution SCIELO
collection OJS
country Brasil
countrycode BR
component Revista
access En linea
databasecode rev-scielo-br
tag revista
region America del Sur
libraryname SciELO
language Portuguese
format Digital
author Loureiro,Maria Rita
Abrucio,Fernando Luiz
spellingShingle Loureiro,Maria Rita
Abrucio,Fernando Luiz
Democracia e eficiência: a difícil relação entre política e economia no debate contemporâneo
author_facet Loureiro,Maria Rita
Abrucio,Fernando Luiz
author_sort Loureiro,Maria Rita
title Democracia e eficiência: a difícil relação entre política e economia no debate contemporâneo
title_short Democracia e eficiência: a difícil relação entre política e economia no debate contemporâneo
title_full Democracia e eficiência: a difícil relação entre política e economia no debate contemporâneo
title_fullStr Democracia e eficiência: a difícil relação entre política e economia no debate contemporâneo
title_full_unstemmed Democracia e eficiência: a difícil relação entre política e economia no debate contemporâneo
title_sort democracia e eficiência: a difícil relação entre política e economia no debate contemporâneo
description Democracy and efficiency: hard relations between politics and economy. Many economists see politics as an irrational activity. They also think state action usually generates market inefficiencies and democratic institutions, such as elections, often work as obstacles to sound economic measures. Showing that vision has been embedded into the main currents of economic thought since the last century, we also argue those ideas are exported to great part of contemporary political science, including the area of public policies. Examining the literature, we show that rational choice political scientists, as the economists, claim governability and effective decisions will be guaranteed mainly through concentrated arenas or through insulated arrangements able to protect policy makers from political interference. In other words, governability depends on the reduction of the political arenas. On the contrary, we reject this technocratic solution of splitting politics from economy. With the support of classical pluralist thinkers, we stand another conception, arguing politics is the privileged social space for building interests and values in an institutionalized way. The difficulties to surpass current international crises since 2008 reveal this is a crucial problem: reducing politics would prevent societies from improving institutional solutions which are the only ones able to give space to emerging conflicts and, then, reach eventual consensus around them.
publisher Centro de Economia Política
publishDate 2012
url http://old.scielo.br/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S0101-31572012000400005
work_keys_str_mv AT loureiromariarita democraciaeeficienciaadificilrelacaoentrepoliticaeeconomianodebatecontemporaneo
AT abruciofernandoluiz democraciaeeficienciaadificilrelacaoentrepoliticaeeconomianodebatecontemporaneo
_version_ 1756392979969343488