The accuracy of the Montenegro skin test for leishmaniasis in PCR-negative patients

Abstract INTRODUCTION: As highly specific molecular biology-based techniques may not be sensitive enough for the diagnosis of American tegumentary leishmaniasis (ATL), clinicians frequently rely on immunological tests before treatment initiation. Hence, the correct combination of diagnostic tests is imperative for ATL diagnosis. We aimed to evaluate the accuracy of the Montenegro (Leishmanin) skin test (MST) in polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-negative patients to accurately detect ATL. METHODS: Patients with a clinical picture compatible with ATL were divided into ATL (confirmed by lesion smear, culture indirect immunofluorescence, and/or histopathology) and no-ATL (diseases that can mimic leishmaniasis) groups. Conventional PCR for the minicircle kDNA of Leishmania was performed, and the MST was carried out for PCR-negative patients. RESULTS: Ninety-nine patients were included in this study, including 79 diagnosed with ATL (6 with mucocutaneous leishmaniasis) and 20 without ATL (no-ATL group). The MST showed a high sensitivity of 90.0% (95% confidence interval [CI] = 69.90-97.21) in PCR-negative patients that was 10% higher than the sensitivity reported in PCR-positive population (79.66%; 95% CI = 67.73-87.96). CONCLUSIONS: One of the most important reasons for PCR negativity among patients with active ATL is the presence of a strong cellular immunological response, especially in chronic and mucocutaneous leishmaniasis. This reinforces the considerable utility of the tests that detect cellular responses against Leishmania antigens such as the MST in PCR-negative patients when the performance in screening situations is questionable.

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Pinheiro,Ana Bárbara Sapienza, Kurizky,Patricia Shu, Ferreira,Marina de Freitas, Mota,Marco Antonio de Souza, Ribeiro,Jaqueline Santos, Oliveira Filho,Edson Zuza de, Souza,Carlos Augusto, Barroso,Daniel Holanda, Sampaio,Raimunda Nonata Ribeiro, Gomes,Ciro Martins
Format: Digital revista
Language:English
Published: Sociedade Brasileira de Medicina Tropical - SBMT 2020
Online Access:http://old.scielo.br/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S0037-86822020000100318
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
id oai:scielo:S0037-86822020000100318
record_format ojs
spelling oai:scielo:S0037-868220200001003182020-04-24The accuracy of the Montenegro skin test for leishmaniasis in PCR-negative patientsPinheiro,Ana Bárbara SapienzaKurizky,Patricia ShuFerreira,Marina de FreitasMota,Marco Antonio de SouzaRibeiro,Jaqueline SantosOliveira Filho,Edson Zuza deSouza,Carlos AugustoBarroso,Daniel HolandaSampaio,Raimunda Nonata RibeiroGomes,Ciro Martins Leishmaniasis Cutaneous Mucocutaneous Diagnosis Abstract INTRODUCTION: As highly specific molecular biology-based techniques may not be sensitive enough for the diagnosis of American tegumentary leishmaniasis (ATL), clinicians frequently rely on immunological tests before treatment initiation. Hence, the correct combination of diagnostic tests is imperative for ATL diagnosis. We aimed to evaluate the accuracy of the Montenegro (Leishmanin) skin test (MST) in polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-negative patients to accurately detect ATL. METHODS: Patients with a clinical picture compatible with ATL were divided into ATL (confirmed by lesion smear, culture indirect immunofluorescence, and/or histopathology) and no-ATL (diseases that can mimic leishmaniasis) groups. Conventional PCR for the minicircle kDNA of Leishmania was performed, and the MST was carried out for PCR-negative patients. RESULTS: Ninety-nine patients were included in this study, including 79 diagnosed with ATL (6 with mucocutaneous leishmaniasis) and 20 without ATL (no-ATL group). The MST showed a high sensitivity of 90.0% (95% confidence interval [CI] = 69.90-97.21) in PCR-negative patients that was 10% higher than the sensitivity reported in PCR-positive population (79.66%; 95% CI = 67.73-87.96). CONCLUSIONS: One of the most important reasons for PCR negativity among patients with active ATL is the presence of a strong cellular immunological response, especially in chronic and mucocutaneous leishmaniasis. This reinforces the considerable utility of the tests that detect cellular responses against Leishmania antigens such as the MST in PCR-negative patients when the performance in screening situations is questionable.info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccessSociedade Brasileira de Medicina Tropical - SBMTRevista da Sociedade Brasileira de Medicina Tropical v.53 20202020-01-01info:eu-repo/semantics/articletext/htmlhttp://old.scielo.br/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S0037-86822020000100318en10.1590/0037-8682-0433-2019
institution SCIELO
collection OJS
country Brasil
countrycode BR
component Revista
access En linea
databasecode rev-scielo-br
tag revista
region America del Sur
libraryname SciELO
language English
format Digital
author Pinheiro,Ana Bárbara Sapienza
Kurizky,Patricia Shu
Ferreira,Marina de Freitas
Mota,Marco Antonio de Souza
Ribeiro,Jaqueline Santos
Oliveira Filho,Edson Zuza de
Souza,Carlos Augusto
Barroso,Daniel Holanda
Sampaio,Raimunda Nonata Ribeiro
Gomes,Ciro Martins
spellingShingle Pinheiro,Ana Bárbara Sapienza
Kurizky,Patricia Shu
Ferreira,Marina de Freitas
Mota,Marco Antonio de Souza
Ribeiro,Jaqueline Santos
Oliveira Filho,Edson Zuza de
Souza,Carlos Augusto
Barroso,Daniel Holanda
Sampaio,Raimunda Nonata Ribeiro
Gomes,Ciro Martins
The accuracy of the Montenegro skin test for leishmaniasis in PCR-negative patients
author_facet Pinheiro,Ana Bárbara Sapienza
Kurizky,Patricia Shu
Ferreira,Marina de Freitas
Mota,Marco Antonio de Souza
Ribeiro,Jaqueline Santos
Oliveira Filho,Edson Zuza de
Souza,Carlos Augusto
Barroso,Daniel Holanda
Sampaio,Raimunda Nonata Ribeiro
Gomes,Ciro Martins
author_sort Pinheiro,Ana Bárbara Sapienza
title The accuracy of the Montenegro skin test for leishmaniasis in PCR-negative patients
title_short The accuracy of the Montenegro skin test for leishmaniasis in PCR-negative patients
title_full The accuracy of the Montenegro skin test for leishmaniasis in PCR-negative patients
title_fullStr The accuracy of the Montenegro skin test for leishmaniasis in PCR-negative patients
title_full_unstemmed The accuracy of the Montenegro skin test for leishmaniasis in PCR-negative patients
title_sort accuracy of the montenegro skin test for leishmaniasis in pcr-negative patients
description Abstract INTRODUCTION: As highly specific molecular biology-based techniques may not be sensitive enough for the diagnosis of American tegumentary leishmaniasis (ATL), clinicians frequently rely on immunological tests before treatment initiation. Hence, the correct combination of diagnostic tests is imperative for ATL diagnosis. We aimed to evaluate the accuracy of the Montenegro (Leishmanin) skin test (MST) in polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-negative patients to accurately detect ATL. METHODS: Patients with a clinical picture compatible with ATL were divided into ATL (confirmed by lesion smear, culture indirect immunofluorescence, and/or histopathology) and no-ATL (diseases that can mimic leishmaniasis) groups. Conventional PCR for the minicircle kDNA of Leishmania was performed, and the MST was carried out for PCR-negative patients. RESULTS: Ninety-nine patients were included in this study, including 79 diagnosed with ATL (6 with mucocutaneous leishmaniasis) and 20 without ATL (no-ATL group). The MST showed a high sensitivity of 90.0% (95% confidence interval [CI] = 69.90-97.21) in PCR-negative patients that was 10% higher than the sensitivity reported in PCR-positive population (79.66%; 95% CI = 67.73-87.96). CONCLUSIONS: One of the most important reasons for PCR negativity among patients with active ATL is the presence of a strong cellular immunological response, especially in chronic and mucocutaneous leishmaniasis. This reinforces the considerable utility of the tests that detect cellular responses against Leishmania antigens such as the MST in PCR-negative patients when the performance in screening situations is questionable.
publisher Sociedade Brasileira de Medicina Tropical - SBMT
publishDate 2020
url http://old.scielo.br/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S0037-86822020000100318
work_keys_str_mv AT pinheiroanabarbarasapienza theaccuracyofthemontenegroskintestforleishmaniasisinpcrnegativepatients
AT kurizkypatriciashu theaccuracyofthemontenegroskintestforleishmaniasisinpcrnegativepatients
AT ferreiramarinadefreitas theaccuracyofthemontenegroskintestforleishmaniasisinpcrnegativepatients
AT motamarcoantoniodesouza theaccuracyofthemontenegroskintestforleishmaniasisinpcrnegativepatients
AT ribeirojaquelinesantos theaccuracyofthemontenegroskintestforleishmaniasisinpcrnegativepatients
AT oliveirafilhoedsonzuzade theaccuracyofthemontenegroskintestforleishmaniasisinpcrnegativepatients
AT souzacarlosaugusto theaccuracyofthemontenegroskintestforleishmaniasisinpcrnegativepatients
AT barrosodanielholanda theaccuracyofthemontenegroskintestforleishmaniasisinpcrnegativepatients
AT sampaioraimundanonataribeiro theaccuracyofthemontenegroskintestforleishmaniasisinpcrnegativepatients
AT gomesciromartins theaccuracyofthemontenegroskintestforleishmaniasisinpcrnegativepatients
AT pinheiroanabarbarasapienza accuracyofthemontenegroskintestforleishmaniasisinpcrnegativepatients
AT kurizkypatriciashu accuracyofthemontenegroskintestforleishmaniasisinpcrnegativepatients
AT ferreiramarinadefreitas accuracyofthemontenegroskintestforleishmaniasisinpcrnegativepatients
AT motamarcoantoniodesouza accuracyofthemontenegroskintestforleishmaniasisinpcrnegativepatients
AT ribeirojaquelinesantos accuracyofthemontenegroskintestforleishmaniasisinpcrnegativepatients
AT oliveirafilhoedsonzuzade accuracyofthemontenegroskintestforleishmaniasisinpcrnegativepatients
AT souzacarlosaugusto accuracyofthemontenegroskintestforleishmaniasisinpcrnegativepatients
AT barrosodanielholanda accuracyofthemontenegroskintestforleishmaniasisinpcrnegativepatients
AT sampaioraimundanonataribeiro accuracyofthemontenegroskintestforleishmaniasisinpcrnegativepatients
AT gomesciromartins accuracyofthemontenegroskintestforleishmaniasisinpcrnegativepatients
_version_ 1756380677656281088