A multivariate geostatistical framework for combining multiple indices of abundance for disease vectors and reservoirs: a case study of rattiness in a low-income urban Brazilian community

A key requirement in studies of endemic vector-borne or zoonotic disease is an estimate of the spatial variation in vector or reservoir host abundance. For many vector species, multiple indices of abundance are available, but current approaches to choosing between or combining these indices do not fully exploit the potential inferential benefits that might accrue from modelling their joint spatial distribution. Here, we develop a class of multivariate generalized linear geostatistical models for multiple indices of abundance. We illustrate this novel methodology with a case study on Norway rats in a low-income urban Brazilian community, where rat abundance is a likely risk-factor for human leptospirosis. We combine three indices of rat abundance to draw predictive inferences on a spatially continuous latent process, rattiness, that acts as a proxy for abundance. We show how to explore the association between rattiness and spatially varying environmental factors, evaluate the relative importance of each of the three contributing indices, assess the presence of residual, unexplained spatial variation, and identify rattiness hotspots. The proposed methodology is applicable more generally as a tool for understanding the role of vector or reservoir host abundance in predicting spatial variation in the risk of human disease.

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Eyre, Max T., Soares de Andrade de Carvalho Pereira, Ticiana, Souza, Fabio N., Khalil, Hussein, Hacker, Kathryn P., Serrano, Laura Soledad, Taylor, Joshua Paul, Reis, Mitermayer G., Ko, Albert I., Begon, Mike, Diggle, Peter J., Costa, Federico, Giorgi, Emanuele
Format: info:ar-repo/semantics/artículo biblioteca
Language:eng
Published: The Royal Society Publishing 2020-09-02
Subjects:Zoonosis, Enfermedades Infecciosas, Leptospirosis, Zoonoses, Infectious Diseases, Brazil, Brasil,
Online Access:http://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12123/7965
https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rsif.2020.0398
https://doi.org/10.1098/rsif.2020.0398
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
id oai:localhost:20.500.12123-7965
record_format koha
spelling oai:localhost:20.500.12123-79652020-09-25T11:56:55Z A multivariate geostatistical framework for combining multiple indices of abundance for disease vectors and reservoirs: a case study of rattiness in a low-income urban Brazilian community Eyre, Max T. Soares de Andrade de Carvalho Pereira, Ticiana Souza, Fabio N. Khalil, Hussein Hacker, Kathryn P. Serrano, Laura Soledad Taylor, Joshua Paul Reis, Mitermayer G. Ko, Albert I. Begon, Mike Diggle, Peter J. Costa, Federico Giorgi, Emanuele Zoonosis Enfermedades Infecciosas Leptospirosis Zoonoses Infectious Diseases Brazil Brasil A key requirement in studies of endemic vector-borne or zoonotic disease is an estimate of the spatial variation in vector or reservoir host abundance. For many vector species, multiple indices of abundance are available, but current approaches to choosing between or combining these indices do not fully exploit the potential inferential benefits that might accrue from modelling their joint spatial distribution. Here, we develop a class of multivariate generalized linear geostatistical models for multiple indices of abundance. We illustrate this novel methodology with a case study on Norway rats in a low-income urban Brazilian community, where rat abundance is a likely risk-factor for human leptospirosis. We combine three indices of rat abundance to draw predictive inferences on a spatially continuous latent process, rattiness, that acts as a proxy for abundance. We show how to explore the association between rattiness and spatially varying environmental factors, evaluate the relative importance of each of the three contributing indices, assess the presence of residual, unexplained spatial variation, and identify rattiness hotspots. The proposed methodology is applicable more generally as a tool for understanding the role of vector or reservoir host abundance in predicting spatial variation in the risk of human disease. Estación Experimental Agropecuaria Bariloche Fil: Eyre, Max T. Lancaster University Medical School. Centre for Health Informatics, Computing, and Statistics; Reino Unido Fil: Soares de Andrade de Carvalho Pereira, Ticiana. Universidade Federal da Bahia. Instituto de Saúde Coletiva; Brasil Fil: Souza, Fabio N. Universidade Federal da Bahia. Instituto de Saúde Coletiva; Brasil Fil: Khalil, Hussein. Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences; Suecia Fil: Hacker, Kathryn P. University of Pennsylvania; Estados Unidos Fil: Serrano, Laura Soledad. Instituto Nacional de Tecnología Agropecuaria (INTA). Estación Experimental Agropecuaria Bariloche. Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Cientificas y Tecnicas. Instituto de Investigaciones Forestales y Agropecuarias Bariloche; Argentina Fil: Taylor, Joshua Paul. Instituto Nacional de Tecnología Agropecuaria (INTA). Estación Experimental Agropecuaria Bariloche. Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Cientificas y Tecnicas. Instituto de Investigaciones Forestales y Agropecuarias Bariloche; Argentina Fil: Reis, Mitermayer G. Universidade Federal da Bahia. Instituto de Saúde Coletiva; Brasil Fil: Ko, Albert I. Brazilian Ministry of Health. Oswaldo Cruz Foundation; Brasil Fil: Begon, Mike. University of Liverpool. Department of Evolution, Ecology and Behaviour; Reino Unido Fil: Diggle, Peter J. Lancaster University Medical School. Centre for Health Informatics, Computing, and Statistics; Reino Unido Fil: Costa, Federico. Universidade Federal da Bahia. Instituto de Saúde Coletiva; Brasil Fil: Giorgi, Emanuele. Lancaster University Medical School. Centre for Health Informatics, Computing, and Statistics; Reino Unido 2020-09-25T11:48:09Z 2020-09-25T11:48:09Z 2020-09-02 info:ar-repo/semantics/artículo info:eu-repo/semantics/article info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion http://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12123/7965 https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rsif.2020.0398 1742-5689 1742-5662 https://doi.org/10.1098/rsif.2020.0398 eng info:eu-repo/semantics/restrictedAccess application/pdf The Royal Society Publishing Journal of the Royal Society Interface 17 (170) : 1-21 (septiembre 2020)
institution INTA AR
collection DSpace
country Argentina
countrycode AR
component Bibliográfico
access En linea
databasecode dig-inta-ar
tag biblioteca
region America del Sur
libraryname Biblioteca Central del INTA Argentina
language eng
topic Zoonosis
Enfermedades Infecciosas
Leptospirosis
Zoonoses
Infectious Diseases
Brazil
Brasil
Zoonosis
Enfermedades Infecciosas
Leptospirosis
Zoonoses
Infectious Diseases
Brazil
Brasil
spellingShingle Zoonosis
Enfermedades Infecciosas
Leptospirosis
Zoonoses
Infectious Diseases
Brazil
Brasil
Zoonosis
Enfermedades Infecciosas
Leptospirosis
Zoonoses
Infectious Diseases
Brazil
Brasil
Eyre, Max T.
Soares de Andrade de Carvalho Pereira, Ticiana
Souza, Fabio N.
Khalil, Hussein
Hacker, Kathryn P.
Serrano, Laura Soledad
Taylor, Joshua Paul
Reis, Mitermayer G.
Ko, Albert I.
Begon, Mike
Diggle, Peter J.
Costa, Federico
Giorgi, Emanuele
A multivariate geostatistical framework for combining multiple indices of abundance for disease vectors and reservoirs: a case study of rattiness in a low-income urban Brazilian community
description A key requirement in studies of endemic vector-borne or zoonotic disease is an estimate of the spatial variation in vector or reservoir host abundance. For many vector species, multiple indices of abundance are available, but current approaches to choosing between or combining these indices do not fully exploit the potential inferential benefits that might accrue from modelling their joint spatial distribution. Here, we develop a class of multivariate generalized linear geostatistical models for multiple indices of abundance. We illustrate this novel methodology with a case study on Norway rats in a low-income urban Brazilian community, where rat abundance is a likely risk-factor for human leptospirosis. We combine three indices of rat abundance to draw predictive inferences on a spatially continuous latent process, rattiness, that acts as a proxy for abundance. We show how to explore the association between rattiness and spatially varying environmental factors, evaluate the relative importance of each of the three contributing indices, assess the presence of residual, unexplained spatial variation, and identify rattiness hotspots. The proposed methodology is applicable more generally as a tool for understanding the role of vector or reservoir host abundance in predicting spatial variation in the risk of human disease.
format info:ar-repo/semantics/artículo
topic_facet Zoonosis
Enfermedades Infecciosas
Leptospirosis
Zoonoses
Infectious Diseases
Brazil
Brasil
author Eyre, Max T.
Soares de Andrade de Carvalho Pereira, Ticiana
Souza, Fabio N.
Khalil, Hussein
Hacker, Kathryn P.
Serrano, Laura Soledad
Taylor, Joshua Paul
Reis, Mitermayer G.
Ko, Albert I.
Begon, Mike
Diggle, Peter J.
Costa, Federico
Giorgi, Emanuele
author_facet Eyre, Max T.
Soares de Andrade de Carvalho Pereira, Ticiana
Souza, Fabio N.
Khalil, Hussein
Hacker, Kathryn P.
Serrano, Laura Soledad
Taylor, Joshua Paul
Reis, Mitermayer G.
Ko, Albert I.
Begon, Mike
Diggle, Peter J.
Costa, Federico
Giorgi, Emanuele
author_sort Eyre, Max T.
title A multivariate geostatistical framework for combining multiple indices of abundance for disease vectors and reservoirs: a case study of rattiness in a low-income urban Brazilian community
title_short A multivariate geostatistical framework for combining multiple indices of abundance for disease vectors and reservoirs: a case study of rattiness in a low-income urban Brazilian community
title_full A multivariate geostatistical framework for combining multiple indices of abundance for disease vectors and reservoirs: a case study of rattiness in a low-income urban Brazilian community
title_fullStr A multivariate geostatistical framework for combining multiple indices of abundance for disease vectors and reservoirs: a case study of rattiness in a low-income urban Brazilian community
title_full_unstemmed A multivariate geostatistical framework for combining multiple indices of abundance for disease vectors and reservoirs: a case study of rattiness in a low-income urban Brazilian community
title_sort multivariate geostatistical framework for combining multiple indices of abundance for disease vectors and reservoirs: a case study of rattiness in a low-income urban brazilian community
publisher The Royal Society Publishing
publishDate 2020-09-02
url http://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12123/7965
https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rsif.2020.0398
https://doi.org/10.1098/rsif.2020.0398
work_keys_str_mv AT eyremaxt amultivariategeostatisticalframeworkforcombiningmultipleindicesofabundancefordiseasevectorsandreservoirsacasestudyofrattinessinalowincomeurbanbraziliancommunity
AT soaresdeandradedecarvalhopereiraticiana amultivariategeostatisticalframeworkforcombiningmultipleindicesofabundancefordiseasevectorsandreservoirsacasestudyofrattinessinalowincomeurbanbraziliancommunity
AT souzafabion amultivariategeostatisticalframeworkforcombiningmultipleindicesofabundancefordiseasevectorsandreservoirsacasestudyofrattinessinalowincomeurbanbraziliancommunity
AT khalilhussein amultivariategeostatisticalframeworkforcombiningmultipleindicesofabundancefordiseasevectorsandreservoirsacasestudyofrattinessinalowincomeurbanbraziliancommunity
AT hackerkathrynp amultivariategeostatisticalframeworkforcombiningmultipleindicesofabundancefordiseasevectorsandreservoirsacasestudyofrattinessinalowincomeurbanbraziliancommunity
AT serranolaurasoledad amultivariategeostatisticalframeworkforcombiningmultipleindicesofabundancefordiseasevectorsandreservoirsacasestudyofrattinessinalowincomeurbanbraziliancommunity
AT taylorjoshuapaul amultivariategeostatisticalframeworkforcombiningmultipleindicesofabundancefordiseasevectorsandreservoirsacasestudyofrattinessinalowincomeurbanbraziliancommunity
AT reismitermayerg amultivariategeostatisticalframeworkforcombiningmultipleindicesofabundancefordiseasevectorsandreservoirsacasestudyofrattinessinalowincomeurbanbraziliancommunity
AT koalberti amultivariategeostatisticalframeworkforcombiningmultipleindicesofabundancefordiseasevectorsandreservoirsacasestudyofrattinessinalowincomeurbanbraziliancommunity
AT begonmike amultivariategeostatisticalframeworkforcombiningmultipleindicesofabundancefordiseasevectorsandreservoirsacasestudyofrattinessinalowincomeurbanbraziliancommunity
AT digglepeterj amultivariategeostatisticalframeworkforcombiningmultipleindicesofabundancefordiseasevectorsandreservoirsacasestudyofrattinessinalowincomeurbanbraziliancommunity
AT costafederico amultivariategeostatisticalframeworkforcombiningmultipleindicesofabundancefordiseasevectorsandreservoirsacasestudyofrattinessinalowincomeurbanbraziliancommunity
AT giorgiemanuele amultivariategeostatisticalframeworkforcombiningmultipleindicesofabundancefordiseasevectorsandreservoirsacasestudyofrattinessinalowincomeurbanbraziliancommunity
AT eyremaxt multivariategeostatisticalframeworkforcombiningmultipleindicesofabundancefordiseasevectorsandreservoirsacasestudyofrattinessinalowincomeurbanbraziliancommunity
AT soaresdeandradedecarvalhopereiraticiana multivariategeostatisticalframeworkforcombiningmultipleindicesofabundancefordiseasevectorsandreservoirsacasestudyofrattinessinalowincomeurbanbraziliancommunity
AT souzafabion multivariategeostatisticalframeworkforcombiningmultipleindicesofabundancefordiseasevectorsandreservoirsacasestudyofrattinessinalowincomeurbanbraziliancommunity
AT khalilhussein multivariategeostatisticalframeworkforcombiningmultipleindicesofabundancefordiseasevectorsandreservoirsacasestudyofrattinessinalowincomeurbanbraziliancommunity
AT hackerkathrynp multivariategeostatisticalframeworkforcombiningmultipleindicesofabundancefordiseasevectorsandreservoirsacasestudyofrattinessinalowincomeurbanbraziliancommunity
AT serranolaurasoledad multivariategeostatisticalframeworkforcombiningmultipleindicesofabundancefordiseasevectorsandreservoirsacasestudyofrattinessinalowincomeurbanbraziliancommunity
AT taylorjoshuapaul multivariategeostatisticalframeworkforcombiningmultipleindicesofabundancefordiseasevectorsandreservoirsacasestudyofrattinessinalowincomeurbanbraziliancommunity
AT reismitermayerg multivariategeostatisticalframeworkforcombiningmultipleindicesofabundancefordiseasevectorsandreservoirsacasestudyofrattinessinalowincomeurbanbraziliancommunity
AT koalberti multivariategeostatisticalframeworkforcombiningmultipleindicesofabundancefordiseasevectorsandreservoirsacasestudyofrattinessinalowincomeurbanbraziliancommunity
AT begonmike multivariategeostatisticalframeworkforcombiningmultipleindicesofabundancefordiseasevectorsandreservoirsacasestudyofrattinessinalowincomeurbanbraziliancommunity
AT digglepeterj multivariategeostatisticalframeworkforcombiningmultipleindicesofabundancefordiseasevectorsandreservoirsacasestudyofrattinessinalowincomeurbanbraziliancommunity
AT costafederico multivariategeostatisticalframeworkforcombiningmultipleindicesofabundancefordiseasevectorsandreservoirsacasestudyofrattinessinalowincomeurbanbraziliancommunity
AT giorgiemanuele multivariategeostatisticalframeworkforcombiningmultipleindicesofabundancefordiseasevectorsandreservoirsacasestudyofrattinessinalowincomeurbanbraziliancommunity
_version_ 1756007848844722176