Species-Enriched Grass–Clover Mixtures Can Promote Bumblebee Abundance Compared with Intensively Managed Conventional Pastures

(1) Land use intensification has led to serious declines in biodiversity, including in forage production systems for dairy cows. Agri-environmental schemes, such as enriching grasslands in floral species, were shown to be an effective tool to promote biodiversity in higher trophic levels. Here, we studied an innovative pasture-based dairy production system with floral-species-en-hanced temporary grasslands, with respect to the effect on wild bee abundance and species richness. (2) We studied three grass–clover mixtures with perennial ryegrass and clover species with different levels of plant diversity for flower cover and wild bees. The grass-clover pastures were rotationally stocked with cattle and parts of the pastures were excluded from grazing. Intensively managed conventional permanent grasslands were studied as the common land use type. Wild bees were caught by sweep netting. Wild bee diversity was analysed with a general linear mixed model. For species richness, an incidence-based coverage estimator was calculated. (3) In total, 541 wild bees from 10 species were found. No wild bees were caught on the conventional grasslands. Wild bee abundance and species richness did not differ among the three grass-clover mixtures, but with in-creasing flower cover of white clover (Trifolium repens), wild bee abundance increased. Except for one solitary wild bee individual, the recorded community exclusively consisted of bumblebees. While generalist species that are commonly found on farmland dominated, rare long-tongued bumblebees made up 10% on the grazed sites of the multispecies mixture and made up 20% on the ungrazed strips of the binary mixture and multispecies mixture. (4) We conclude that multispecies mixtures can provide resources for generalist bumblebee species, especially when compared with conventional grasslands that offer no resources. Considering that the multispecies mixture has been also shown to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and nitrate leaching, while maintaining high forage yields, our findings add to the potential to promote a wide range of ecosystem services. Yet, should their full potential be enfolded, grazing should partially be excluded, and the mixture should be extended by plant species with more open flowers, suitable for solitary wild bees.

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Beye, Henriette, Taube, Friedhelm, Lange, Katharina, Hasler, Mario, Kluß, Christof, Loges, Ralf, Diekötter, Tim
Format: Article/Letter to editor biblioteca
Language:English
Subjects:agri-environmental schemes, agrobiodiversity, dairy systems, ecological farming, ecological intensification, flower-visiting insects, ley grassland, multifunctionality, pollinator decline, wild bees,
Online Access:https://research.wur.nl/en/publications/species-enriched-grassclover-mixtures-can-promote-bumblebee-abund
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
id dig-wur-nl-wurpubs-597734
record_format koha
spelling dig-wur-nl-wurpubs-5977342024-12-04 Beye, Henriette Taube, Friedhelm Lange, Katharina Hasler, Mario Kluß, Christof Loges, Ralf Diekötter, Tim Article/Letter to editor Agronomy 12 (2022) 5 ISSN: 2073-4395 Species-Enriched Grass–Clover Mixtures Can Promote Bumblebee Abundance Compared with Intensively Managed Conventional Pastures 2022 (1) Land use intensification has led to serious declines in biodiversity, including in forage production systems for dairy cows. Agri-environmental schemes, such as enriching grasslands in floral species, were shown to be an effective tool to promote biodiversity in higher trophic levels. Here, we studied an innovative pasture-based dairy production system with floral-species-en-hanced temporary grasslands, with respect to the effect on wild bee abundance and species richness. (2) We studied three grass–clover mixtures with perennial ryegrass and clover species with different levels of plant diversity for flower cover and wild bees. The grass-clover pastures were rotationally stocked with cattle and parts of the pastures were excluded from grazing. Intensively managed conventional permanent grasslands were studied as the common land use type. Wild bees were caught by sweep netting. Wild bee diversity was analysed with a general linear mixed model. For species richness, an incidence-based coverage estimator was calculated. (3) In total, 541 wild bees from 10 species were found. No wild bees were caught on the conventional grasslands. Wild bee abundance and species richness did not differ among the three grass-clover mixtures, but with in-creasing flower cover of white clover (Trifolium repens), wild bee abundance increased. Except for one solitary wild bee individual, the recorded community exclusively consisted of bumblebees. While generalist species that are commonly found on farmland dominated, rare long-tongued bumblebees made up 10% on the grazed sites of the multispecies mixture and made up 20% on the ungrazed strips of the binary mixture and multispecies mixture. (4) We conclude that multispecies mixtures can provide resources for generalist bumblebee species, especially when compared with conventional grasslands that offer no resources. Considering that the multispecies mixture has been also shown to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and nitrate leaching, while maintaining high forage yields, our findings add to the potential to promote a wide range of ecosystem services. Yet, should their full potential be enfolded, grazing should partially be excluded, and the mixture should be extended by plant species with more open flowers, suitable for solitary wild bees. en application/pdf https://research.wur.nl/en/publications/species-enriched-grassclover-mixtures-can-promote-bumblebee-abund 10.3390/agronomy12051080 https://edepot.wur.nl/570432 agri-environmental schemes agrobiodiversity dairy systems ecological farming ecological intensification flower-visiting insects ley grassland multifunctionality pollinator decline wild bees https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ Wageningen University & Research
institution WUR NL
collection DSpace
country Países bajos
countrycode NL
component Bibliográfico
access En linea
databasecode dig-wur-nl
tag biblioteca
region Europa del Oeste
libraryname WUR Library Netherlands
language English
topic agri-environmental schemes
agrobiodiversity
dairy systems
ecological farming
ecological intensification
flower-visiting insects
ley grassland
multifunctionality
pollinator decline
wild bees
agri-environmental schemes
agrobiodiversity
dairy systems
ecological farming
ecological intensification
flower-visiting insects
ley grassland
multifunctionality
pollinator decline
wild bees
spellingShingle agri-environmental schemes
agrobiodiversity
dairy systems
ecological farming
ecological intensification
flower-visiting insects
ley grassland
multifunctionality
pollinator decline
wild bees
agri-environmental schemes
agrobiodiversity
dairy systems
ecological farming
ecological intensification
flower-visiting insects
ley grassland
multifunctionality
pollinator decline
wild bees
Beye, Henriette
Taube, Friedhelm
Lange, Katharina
Hasler, Mario
Kluß, Christof
Loges, Ralf
Diekötter, Tim
Species-Enriched Grass–Clover Mixtures Can Promote Bumblebee Abundance Compared with Intensively Managed Conventional Pastures
description (1) Land use intensification has led to serious declines in biodiversity, including in forage production systems for dairy cows. Agri-environmental schemes, such as enriching grasslands in floral species, were shown to be an effective tool to promote biodiversity in higher trophic levels. Here, we studied an innovative pasture-based dairy production system with floral-species-en-hanced temporary grasslands, with respect to the effect on wild bee abundance and species richness. (2) We studied three grass–clover mixtures with perennial ryegrass and clover species with different levels of plant diversity for flower cover and wild bees. The grass-clover pastures were rotationally stocked with cattle and parts of the pastures were excluded from grazing. Intensively managed conventional permanent grasslands were studied as the common land use type. Wild bees were caught by sweep netting. Wild bee diversity was analysed with a general linear mixed model. For species richness, an incidence-based coverage estimator was calculated. (3) In total, 541 wild bees from 10 species were found. No wild bees were caught on the conventional grasslands. Wild bee abundance and species richness did not differ among the three grass-clover mixtures, but with in-creasing flower cover of white clover (Trifolium repens), wild bee abundance increased. Except for one solitary wild bee individual, the recorded community exclusively consisted of bumblebees. While generalist species that are commonly found on farmland dominated, rare long-tongued bumblebees made up 10% on the grazed sites of the multispecies mixture and made up 20% on the ungrazed strips of the binary mixture and multispecies mixture. (4) We conclude that multispecies mixtures can provide resources for generalist bumblebee species, especially when compared with conventional grasslands that offer no resources. Considering that the multispecies mixture has been also shown to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and nitrate leaching, while maintaining high forage yields, our findings add to the potential to promote a wide range of ecosystem services. Yet, should their full potential be enfolded, grazing should partially be excluded, and the mixture should be extended by plant species with more open flowers, suitable for solitary wild bees.
format Article/Letter to editor
topic_facet agri-environmental schemes
agrobiodiversity
dairy systems
ecological farming
ecological intensification
flower-visiting insects
ley grassland
multifunctionality
pollinator decline
wild bees
author Beye, Henriette
Taube, Friedhelm
Lange, Katharina
Hasler, Mario
Kluß, Christof
Loges, Ralf
Diekötter, Tim
author_facet Beye, Henriette
Taube, Friedhelm
Lange, Katharina
Hasler, Mario
Kluß, Christof
Loges, Ralf
Diekötter, Tim
author_sort Beye, Henriette
title Species-Enriched Grass–Clover Mixtures Can Promote Bumblebee Abundance Compared with Intensively Managed Conventional Pastures
title_short Species-Enriched Grass–Clover Mixtures Can Promote Bumblebee Abundance Compared with Intensively Managed Conventional Pastures
title_full Species-Enriched Grass–Clover Mixtures Can Promote Bumblebee Abundance Compared with Intensively Managed Conventional Pastures
title_fullStr Species-Enriched Grass–Clover Mixtures Can Promote Bumblebee Abundance Compared with Intensively Managed Conventional Pastures
title_full_unstemmed Species-Enriched Grass–Clover Mixtures Can Promote Bumblebee Abundance Compared with Intensively Managed Conventional Pastures
title_sort species-enriched grass–clover mixtures can promote bumblebee abundance compared with intensively managed conventional pastures
url https://research.wur.nl/en/publications/species-enriched-grassclover-mixtures-can-promote-bumblebee-abund
work_keys_str_mv AT beyehenriette speciesenrichedgrassclovermixturescanpromotebumblebeeabundancecomparedwithintensivelymanagedconventionalpastures
AT taubefriedhelm speciesenrichedgrassclovermixturescanpromotebumblebeeabundancecomparedwithintensivelymanagedconventionalpastures
AT langekatharina speciesenrichedgrassclovermixturescanpromotebumblebeeabundancecomparedwithintensivelymanagedconventionalpastures
AT haslermario speciesenrichedgrassclovermixturescanpromotebumblebeeabundancecomparedwithintensivelymanagedconventionalpastures
AT klußchristof speciesenrichedgrassclovermixturescanpromotebumblebeeabundancecomparedwithintensivelymanagedconventionalpastures
AT logesralf speciesenrichedgrassclovermixturescanpromotebumblebeeabundancecomparedwithintensivelymanagedconventionalpastures
AT diekottertim speciesenrichedgrassclovermixturescanpromotebumblebeeabundancecomparedwithintensivelymanagedconventionalpastures
_version_ 1819142797915062272