No more nutmegging with nutmeg : Analytical fingerprints for distinction of quality from low-grade nutmeg products

Quality nutmeg is characterized by a delicate aroma. Next to quality nutmeg, other – lower - grades exist on the market, such as extracted material (spent) or ground shell or dried fruit pulp. Strong fluctuations in the price of nutmeg lead to rapid changes in market dynamics and marketing opportunities, and unfortunately results in illegal commingle of ground quality nutmeg with low-grade material. In this study, we examined fingerprints of volatile and non-volatile compounds of high quality and low-grade nutmeg material by Proton Transfer Reaction Mass Spectrometry and Flow Infusion ElectroSpray Ionization Mass Spectrometry, respectively. They were compared with data from classical measurements such as total ash, acid insoluble ash, moisture and volatile oil contents. Differences in composition were examined by univariate and multivariate statistical methods. Furthermore, one-class classification models for quality nutmeg were estimated using different algorithms and their performances were examined with quality nutmeg and low-grade material, as well as mixtures thereof. Distinct differences between quality nutmeg and low-grade nutmeg samples were observed for both their volatile and non-volatile fingerprints. Intensities of volatiles and non-volatiles are highly correlated, but this phenomenon diminishes gradually and even reverses with rising molecular mass of the non-volatiles. Results showed that both techniques allowed a nearly 100% correct prediction of quality nutmeg and low-grade nutmeg samples. Therefore, both approaches are promising and with further database extension, they may become a valuable addition to the analytical authentication toolbox in addition to the classical methods and help to detect future ‘nutmeggers’.

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: van Ruth, Saskia M., Silvis, Isabelle C.J., Alewijn, Martin, Liu, Ningjing, Jansen, Marc, Luning, Pieternel A.
Format: Article/Letter to editor biblioteca
Language:English
Subjects:Adulteration, Aroma, FI-ESI-MS, Fraud, PTR-MS, Spices,
Online Access:https://research.wur.nl/en/publications/no-more-nutmegging-with-nutmeg-analytical-fingerprints-for-distin
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
id dig-wur-nl-wurpubs-545411
record_format koha
spelling dig-wur-nl-wurpubs-5454112025-01-15 van Ruth, Saskia M. Silvis, Isabelle C.J. Alewijn, Martin Liu, Ningjing Jansen, Marc Luning, Pieternel A. Article/Letter to editor Food Control 98 (2019) ISSN: 0956-7135 No more nutmegging with nutmeg : Analytical fingerprints for distinction of quality from low-grade nutmeg products 2019 Quality nutmeg is characterized by a delicate aroma. Next to quality nutmeg, other – lower - grades exist on the market, such as extracted material (spent) or ground shell or dried fruit pulp. Strong fluctuations in the price of nutmeg lead to rapid changes in market dynamics and marketing opportunities, and unfortunately results in illegal commingle of ground quality nutmeg with low-grade material. In this study, we examined fingerprints of volatile and non-volatile compounds of high quality and low-grade nutmeg material by Proton Transfer Reaction Mass Spectrometry and Flow Infusion ElectroSpray Ionization Mass Spectrometry, respectively. They were compared with data from classical measurements such as total ash, acid insoluble ash, moisture and volatile oil contents. Differences in composition were examined by univariate and multivariate statistical methods. Furthermore, one-class classification models for quality nutmeg were estimated using different algorithms and their performances were examined with quality nutmeg and low-grade material, as well as mixtures thereof. Distinct differences between quality nutmeg and low-grade nutmeg samples were observed for both their volatile and non-volatile fingerprints. Intensities of volatiles and non-volatiles are highly correlated, but this phenomenon diminishes gradually and even reverses with rising molecular mass of the non-volatiles. Results showed that both techniques allowed a nearly 100% correct prediction of quality nutmeg and low-grade nutmeg samples. Therefore, both approaches are promising and with further database extension, they may become a valuable addition to the analytical authentication toolbox in addition to the classical methods and help to detect future ‘nutmeggers’. en application/pdf https://research.wur.nl/en/publications/no-more-nutmegging-with-nutmeg-analytical-fingerprints-for-distin 10.1016/j.foodcont.2018.12.005 https://edepot.wur.nl/467887 Adulteration Aroma FI-ESI-MS Fraud PTR-MS Spices https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ Wageningen University & Research
institution WUR NL
collection DSpace
country Países bajos
countrycode NL
component Bibliográfico
access En linea
databasecode dig-wur-nl
tag biblioteca
region Europa del Oeste
libraryname WUR Library Netherlands
language English
topic Adulteration
Aroma
FI-ESI-MS
Fraud
PTR-MS
Spices
Adulteration
Aroma
FI-ESI-MS
Fraud
PTR-MS
Spices
spellingShingle Adulteration
Aroma
FI-ESI-MS
Fraud
PTR-MS
Spices
Adulteration
Aroma
FI-ESI-MS
Fraud
PTR-MS
Spices
van Ruth, Saskia M.
Silvis, Isabelle C.J.
Alewijn, Martin
Liu, Ningjing
Jansen, Marc
Luning, Pieternel A.
No more nutmegging with nutmeg : Analytical fingerprints for distinction of quality from low-grade nutmeg products
description Quality nutmeg is characterized by a delicate aroma. Next to quality nutmeg, other – lower - grades exist on the market, such as extracted material (spent) or ground shell or dried fruit pulp. Strong fluctuations in the price of nutmeg lead to rapid changes in market dynamics and marketing opportunities, and unfortunately results in illegal commingle of ground quality nutmeg with low-grade material. In this study, we examined fingerprints of volatile and non-volatile compounds of high quality and low-grade nutmeg material by Proton Transfer Reaction Mass Spectrometry and Flow Infusion ElectroSpray Ionization Mass Spectrometry, respectively. They were compared with data from classical measurements such as total ash, acid insoluble ash, moisture and volatile oil contents. Differences in composition were examined by univariate and multivariate statistical methods. Furthermore, one-class classification models for quality nutmeg were estimated using different algorithms and their performances were examined with quality nutmeg and low-grade material, as well as mixtures thereof. Distinct differences between quality nutmeg and low-grade nutmeg samples were observed for both their volatile and non-volatile fingerprints. Intensities of volatiles and non-volatiles are highly correlated, but this phenomenon diminishes gradually and even reverses with rising molecular mass of the non-volatiles. Results showed that both techniques allowed a nearly 100% correct prediction of quality nutmeg and low-grade nutmeg samples. Therefore, both approaches are promising and with further database extension, they may become a valuable addition to the analytical authentication toolbox in addition to the classical methods and help to detect future ‘nutmeggers’.
format Article/Letter to editor
topic_facet Adulteration
Aroma
FI-ESI-MS
Fraud
PTR-MS
Spices
author van Ruth, Saskia M.
Silvis, Isabelle C.J.
Alewijn, Martin
Liu, Ningjing
Jansen, Marc
Luning, Pieternel A.
author_facet van Ruth, Saskia M.
Silvis, Isabelle C.J.
Alewijn, Martin
Liu, Ningjing
Jansen, Marc
Luning, Pieternel A.
author_sort van Ruth, Saskia M.
title No more nutmegging with nutmeg : Analytical fingerprints for distinction of quality from low-grade nutmeg products
title_short No more nutmegging with nutmeg : Analytical fingerprints for distinction of quality from low-grade nutmeg products
title_full No more nutmegging with nutmeg : Analytical fingerprints for distinction of quality from low-grade nutmeg products
title_fullStr No more nutmegging with nutmeg : Analytical fingerprints for distinction of quality from low-grade nutmeg products
title_full_unstemmed No more nutmegging with nutmeg : Analytical fingerprints for distinction of quality from low-grade nutmeg products
title_sort no more nutmegging with nutmeg : analytical fingerprints for distinction of quality from low-grade nutmeg products
url https://research.wur.nl/en/publications/no-more-nutmegging-with-nutmeg-analytical-fingerprints-for-distin
work_keys_str_mv AT vanruthsaskiam nomorenutmeggingwithnutmeganalyticalfingerprintsfordistinctionofqualityfromlowgradenutmegproducts
AT silvisisabellecj nomorenutmeggingwithnutmeganalyticalfingerprintsfordistinctionofqualityfromlowgradenutmegproducts
AT alewijnmartin nomorenutmeggingwithnutmeganalyticalfingerprintsfordistinctionofqualityfromlowgradenutmegproducts
AT liuningjing nomorenutmeggingwithnutmeganalyticalfingerprintsfordistinctionofqualityfromlowgradenutmegproducts
AT jansenmarc nomorenutmeggingwithnutmeganalyticalfingerprintsfordistinctionofqualityfromlowgradenutmegproducts
AT luningpieternela nomorenutmeggingwithnutmeganalyticalfingerprintsfordistinctionofqualityfromlowgradenutmegproducts
_version_ 1822268250847707136