Diagnosis of management of bacterial wilt and late blight in potato in Ethiopia : A systems thinking perspective

Potato is one of the most important food crops for smallholder farmers in the Ethiopian highlands. Diseases, particularly bacterial wilt (caused by Ralstonia solanacearum) and late blight (caused by Phytophthora infestans), are among the major constraints of potato production, despite continuous efforts to control them. Bacterial wilt and late blight are complex problems with multiple technical and institutional features, involving multiple actors with different perceptions and understanding, not only of the problem but also of possible solutions. Appreciating such complexity, this study adopted a systems thinking perspective. It aimed to explore actors’ understanding of the complex problem situation and its implication for the management of the diseases at a collective level. Using a multi-stakeholder workshop and in-depth interviews, a qualitative study was conducted with actors that are directly or indirectly involved in the management of the two diseases. Results showed that actors essentially overlooked key systemic problems in the management of the two diseases. This is mainly reflected in actors’ tendency to give event-level responses, shift responsibilities and engage in a mutual blaming to the problem of bacterial wilt and late blight. Lack of a preventive disease management culture, limited recognition of interdependencies among activities of actors, power inequalities, and top-down and linear approaches in information and knowledge sharing are identified as key structural problems that are underrated by the actors. We contend that the most appropriate way forward towards the management of both diseases is designing and implementing management strategies that, on the one hand, are preventive of disease epidemics, and, on the other hand, foster horizontal information sharing, learning and collective action among the local actors in the system. Digital platforms, particularly mobile-based technologies, can play a role in catalyzing new forms of information sharing, broader learning, and collaboration among farmers and local actors.

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Damtew, E., Tafesse, Shiferaw, Lie, R., van Mierlo, B., Lemaga, B., Sharma, K., Struik, P.C., Leeuwis, C.
Format: Article/Letter to editor biblioteca
Language:English
Subjects:Bacterial wilt, Complex problems, Disease management, Late blight, Potato, Systems thinking,
Online Access:https://research.wur.nl/en/publications/diagnosis-of-management-of-bacterial-wilt-and-late-blight-in-pota
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
id dig-wur-nl-wurpubs-536452
record_format koha
spelling dig-wur-nl-wurpubs-5364522024-12-04 Damtew, E. Tafesse, Shiferaw Lie, R. van Mierlo, B. Lemaga, B. Sharma, K. Struik, P.C. Leeuwis, C. Article/Letter to editor NJAS - Wageningen Journal of Life Sciences 86-87 (2018) ISSN: 1573-5214 Diagnosis of management of bacterial wilt and late blight in potato in Ethiopia : A systems thinking perspective 2018 Potato is one of the most important food crops for smallholder farmers in the Ethiopian highlands. Diseases, particularly bacterial wilt (caused by Ralstonia solanacearum) and late blight (caused by Phytophthora infestans), are among the major constraints of potato production, despite continuous efforts to control them. Bacterial wilt and late blight are complex problems with multiple technical and institutional features, involving multiple actors with different perceptions and understanding, not only of the problem but also of possible solutions. Appreciating such complexity, this study adopted a systems thinking perspective. It aimed to explore actors’ understanding of the complex problem situation and its implication for the management of the diseases at a collective level. Using a multi-stakeholder workshop and in-depth interviews, a qualitative study was conducted with actors that are directly or indirectly involved in the management of the two diseases. Results showed that actors essentially overlooked key systemic problems in the management of the two diseases. This is mainly reflected in actors’ tendency to give event-level responses, shift responsibilities and engage in a mutual blaming to the problem of bacterial wilt and late blight. Lack of a preventive disease management culture, limited recognition of interdependencies among activities of actors, power inequalities, and top-down and linear approaches in information and knowledge sharing are identified as key structural problems that are underrated by the actors. We contend that the most appropriate way forward towards the management of both diseases is designing and implementing management strategies that, on the one hand, are preventive of disease epidemics, and, on the other hand, foster horizontal information sharing, learning and collective action among the local actors in the system. Digital platforms, particularly mobile-based technologies, can play a role in catalyzing new forms of information sharing, broader learning, and collaboration among farmers and local actors. en application/pdf https://research.wur.nl/en/publications/diagnosis-of-management-of-bacterial-wilt-and-late-blight-in-pota 10.1016/j.njas.2018.03.003 https://edepot.wur.nl/446932 Bacterial wilt Complex problems Disease management Late blight Potato Systems thinking (c) publisher Wageningen University & Research
institution WUR NL
collection DSpace
country Países bajos
countrycode NL
component Bibliográfico
access En linea
databasecode dig-wur-nl
tag biblioteca
region Europa del Oeste
libraryname WUR Library Netherlands
language English
topic Bacterial wilt
Complex problems
Disease management
Late blight
Potato
Systems thinking
Bacterial wilt
Complex problems
Disease management
Late blight
Potato
Systems thinking
spellingShingle Bacterial wilt
Complex problems
Disease management
Late blight
Potato
Systems thinking
Bacterial wilt
Complex problems
Disease management
Late blight
Potato
Systems thinking
Damtew, E.
Tafesse, Shiferaw
Lie, R.
van Mierlo, B.
Lemaga, B.
Sharma, K.
Struik, P.C.
Leeuwis, C.
Diagnosis of management of bacterial wilt and late blight in potato in Ethiopia : A systems thinking perspective
description Potato is one of the most important food crops for smallholder farmers in the Ethiopian highlands. Diseases, particularly bacterial wilt (caused by Ralstonia solanacearum) and late blight (caused by Phytophthora infestans), are among the major constraints of potato production, despite continuous efforts to control them. Bacterial wilt and late blight are complex problems with multiple technical and institutional features, involving multiple actors with different perceptions and understanding, not only of the problem but also of possible solutions. Appreciating such complexity, this study adopted a systems thinking perspective. It aimed to explore actors’ understanding of the complex problem situation and its implication for the management of the diseases at a collective level. Using a multi-stakeholder workshop and in-depth interviews, a qualitative study was conducted with actors that are directly or indirectly involved in the management of the two diseases. Results showed that actors essentially overlooked key systemic problems in the management of the two diseases. This is mainly reflected in actors’ tendency to give event-level responses, shift responsibilities and engage in a mutual blaming to the problem of bacterial wilt and late blight. Lack of a preventive disease management culture, limited recognition of interdependencies among activities of actors, power inequalities, and top-down and linear approaches in information and knowledge sharing are identified as key structural problems that are underrated by the actors. We contend that the most appropriate way forward towards the management of both diseases is designing and implementing management strategies that, on the one hand, are preventive of disease epidemics, and, on the other hand, foster horizontal information sharing, learning and collective action among the local actors in the system. Digital platforms, particularly mobile-based technologies, can play a role in catalyzing new forms of information sharing, broader learning, and collaboration among farmers and local actors.
format Article/Letter to editor
topic_facet Bacterial wilt
Complex problems
Disease management
Late blight
Potato
Systems thinking
author Damtew, E.
Tafesse, Shiferaw
Lie, R.
van Mierlo, B.
Lemaga, B.
Sharma, K.
Struik, P.C.
Leeuwis, C.
author_facet Damtew, E.
Tafesse, Shiferaw
Lie, R.
van Mierlo, B.
Lemaga, B.
Sharma, K.
Struik, P.C.
Leeuwis, C.
author_sort Damtew, E.
title Diagnosis of management of bacterial wilt and late blight in potato in Ethiopia : A systems thinking perspective
title_short Diagnosis of management of bacterial wilt and late blight in potato in Ethiopia : A systems thinking perspective
title_full Diagnosis of management of bacterial wilt and late blight in potato in Ethiopia : A systems thinking perspective
title_fullStr Diagnosis of management of bacterial wilt and late blight in potato in Ethiopia : A systems thinking perspective
title_full_unstemmed Diagnosis of management of bacterial wilt and late blight in potato in Ethiopia : A systems thinking perspective
title_sort diagnosis of management of bacterial wilt and late blight in potato in ethiopia : a systems thinking perspective
url https://research.wur.nl/en/publications/diagnosis-of-management-of-bacterial-wilt-and-late-blight-in-pota
work_keys_str_mv AT damtewe diagnosisofmanagementofbacterialwiltandlateblightinpotatoinethiopiaasystemsthinkingperspective
AT tafesseshiferaw diagnosisofmanagementofbacterialwiltandlateblightinpotatoinethiopiaasystemsthinkingperspective
AT lier diagnosisofmanagementofbacterialwiltandlateblightinpotatoinethiopiaasystemsthinkingperspective
AT vanmierlob diagnosisofmanagementofbacterialwiltandlateblightinpotatoinethiopiaasystemsthinkingperspective
AT lemagab diagnosisofmanagementofbacterialwiltandlateblightinpotatoinethiopiaasystemsthinkingperspective
AT sharmak diagnosisofmanagementofbacterialwiltandlateblightinpotatoinethiopiaasystemsthinkingperspective
AT struikpc diagnosisofmanagementofbacterialwiltandlateblightinpotatoinethiopiaasystemsthinkingperspective
AT leeuwisc diagnosisofmanagementofbacterialwiltandlateblightinpotatoinethiopiaasystemsthinkingperspective
_version_ 1819146450061230080