SMEs, Age, and Jobs

The subject of which firms are the key employers—and which of these create or destroy jobs at a faster rate—is eminently important for academics and policy makers. The relative importance of small versus large firms and old versus young firms has in particular been extensively debated and studied. Nevertheless, the results often hinge on the questions that are asked. Moreover, the categorical definitions used to define firm size and age, and the nature and coverage of the data used have important effects. This paper lays out the relevant definitions and metrics that are central to the debate, reviewing the main findings to date on the subject (with particular emphasis on results in developing economies). The paper adds updated results for 117 developing economies using the World Bank’s Enterprise Survey Data, finding that (i) small and medium enterprises and older establishments are the dominant employers in the nonagricultural private sector labor force in developing economies, and (ii) net job creation is negatively correlated with establishment age and, although the effect of size is also negative, its significance is sensitive to the definition and methods used.

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Aga, Gemechu, Francis, David C., Rodriguez Meza, Jorge
Format: Working Paper biblioteca
Language:English
en_US
Published: World Bank, Washington, DC 2015-11
Subjects:JOBS, EMPLOYMENT, JOB CREATION RATE, MOTIVATION, ECONOMIC GROWTH, ACCOUNTING, NET JOB CREATION, PRODUCTION, EMPLOYMENT SHARE, FIRM SURVEY, INCOME, SERVICE SECTOR, FIRM DYNAMICS, MEDIUM ENTERPRISES, TOTAL LABOR FORCE, INFORMATION, CROSS- SECTIONAL DATA, LABOR FORCE, SURVIVAL RATE, JOB GENERATION, MANUFACTURERS, JOB, AGE CATEGORIES, EFFECTS, EMPLOYMENT POTENTIAL, LABOR STATISTICS, MERGERS, FIRM SIZE, TRAINING PROGRAMS, EMPLOYMENT SIZE, DRIVERS, SMALL BUSINESS, EMPLOYMENT LEVEL, FIRM EXIT, TRAINING, EMPLOYMENT LEVELS, DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS, MANUFACTURING ESTABLISHMENTS, FIRM LEVEL, WORKER, PREVIOUS STUDIES, FARM EMPLOYMENT, LABOR PRODUCTIVITY, NON-FARM EMPLOYMENT, PRODUCTIVITY, JOB LOSS, JOB CHURNING, MARKETS, FIRM, ORGANIZATIONS, BUSINESS CYCLE, DOMINANT EMPLOYERS, LABOR, ENTERPRISES, TOTAL EMPLOYMENT, EMPLOYMENT CREATION, PREVIOUS RESULTS, EFFICIENCY, SIZE OF FIRMS, SMALL ENTERPRISE, SHOP, FIRM ENTRY, AVERAGE EMPLOYMENT SIZE, SMALL FIRM, FIRMS, WORKERS, JOB DESTRUCTION RATES, POLICIES, OWNERSHIP STRUCTURE, SMALL ENTERPRISES, TURNOVER, VALUE, PLANT SIZE, NET EMPLOYMENT, STATE-OWNED ENTERPRISES, JOB CREATION RATES, AGE GROUPS, CO-OPERATIVES, PRIVATE FIRMS, ENTERPRISE, PRODUCTIVE FIRMS, EMPLOYMENT GROWTH, JOB CREATION, PRIVATE SECTOR, DOWNWARD BIAS, MARKET, JOB FLOWS, ECONOMIC THEORY, EMPLOYERS, ECONOMICS, EXPANSION, JOB DESTRUCTION, THEORY, FIRM” LEVEL, SECURITY, RISK, JOB DESTRUCTION RATE, CONTRACTING, BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT, EMPLOYEE, INNOVATION, EMPLOYMENT DYNAMICS, LENDING, LABOUR REGULATION, SMALL FIRMS, SUPPLIERS, FIRM GROWTH, ENTREPRENEURSHIP, LABOUR, EMPLOYMENT GROWTH RATE, SMALL BUSINESSES, SME, EMPLOYEES,
Online Access:http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2015/11/25462713/smes-age-jobs-review-literature-metrics-evidence
https://hdl.handle.net/10986/23455
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
id dig-okr-1098623455
record_format koha
spelling dig-okr-10986234552024-08-07T20:11:50Z SMEs, Age, and Jobs A Review of the Literature, Metrics, and Evidence Aga, Gemechu Francis, David C. Rodriguez Meza, Jorge JOBS EMPLOYMENT JOB CREATION RATE MOTIVATION ECONOMIC GROWTH ACCOUNTING NET JOB CREATION PRODUCTION EMPLOYMENT SHARE FIRM SURVEY INCOME SERVICE SECTOR FIRM DYNAMICS MEDIUM ENTERPRISES TOTAL LABOR FORCE INFORMATION CROSS- SECTIONAL DATA LABOR FORCE SURVIVAL RATE JOB GENERATION MANUFACTURERS JOB AGE CATEGORIES EFFECTS EMPLOYMENT POTENTIAL LABOR STATISTICS MERGERS FIRM SIZE TRAINING PROGRAMS EMPLOYMENT SIZE DRIVERS SMALL BUSINESS EMPLOYMENT LEVEL FIRM EXIT TRAINING EMPLOYMENT LEVELS DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS MANUFACTURING ESTABLISHMENTS FIRM LEVEL WORKER PREVIOUS STUDIES FARM EMPLOYMENT LABOR PRODUCTIVITY NON-FARM EMPLOYMENT PRODUCTIVITY JOB LOSS JOB CHURNING MARKETS FIRM ORGANIZATIONS BUSINESS CYCLE DOMINANT EMPLOYERS LABOR ENTERPRISES TOTAL EMPLOYMENT EMPLOYMENT CREATION PREVIOUS RESULTS EFFICIENCY SIZE OF FIRMS SMALL ENTERPRISE SHOP FIRM ENTRY AVERAGE EMPLOYMENT SIZE SMALL FIRM FIRMS WORKERS JOB DESTRUCTION RATES POLICIES OWNERSHIP STRUCTURE SMALL ENTERPRISES TURNOVER VALUE PLANT SIZE NET EMPLOYMENT STATE-OWNED ENTERPRISES JOB CREATION RATES AGE GROUPS CO-OPERATIVES PRIVATE FIRMS ENTERPRISE PRODUCTIVE FIRMS EMPLOYMENT GROWTH JOB CREATION PRIVATE SECTOR DOWNWARD BIAS MARKET JOB FLOWS ECONOMIC THEORY EMPLOYERS ECONOMICS EXPANSION JOB DESTRUCTION THEORY FIRM” LEVEL SECURITY RISK JOB DESTRUCTION RATE CONTRACTING BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT EMPLOYEE INNOVATION EMPLOYMENT DYNAMICS LENDING LABOUR REGULATION SMALL FIRMS SUPPLIERS FIRM GROWTH ENTREPRENEURSHIP LABOUR EMPLOYMENT GROWTH RATE SMALL BUSINESSES SME EMPLOYEES The subject of which firms are the key employers—and which of these create or destroy jobs at a faster rate—is eminently important for academics and policy makers. The relative importance of small versus large firms and old versus young firms has in particular been extensively debated and studied. Nevertheless, the results often hinge on the questions that are asked. Moreover, the categorical definitions used to define firm size and age, and the nature and coverage of the data used have important effects. This paper lays out the relevant definitions and metrics that are central to the debate, reviewing the main findings to date on the subject (with particular emphasis on results in developing economies). The paper adds updated results for 117 developing economies using the World Bank’s Enterprise Survey Data, finding that (i) small and medium enterprises and older establishments are the dominant employers in the nonagricultural private sector labor force in developing economies, and (ii) net job creation is negatively correlated with establishment age and, although the effect of size is also negative, its significance is sensitive to the definition and methods used. 2015-12-18T20:52:15Z 2015-12-18T20:52:15Z 2015-11 Working Paper Document de travail Documento de trabajo http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2015/11/25462713/smes-age-jobs-review-literature-metrics-evidence https://hdl.handle.net/10986/23455 English en_US Policy Research Working Paper;No. 7493 CC BY 3.0 IGO http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/igo/ World Bank application/pdf text/plain World Bank, Washington, DC
institution Banco Mundial
collection DSpace
country Estados Unidos
countrycode US
component Bibliográfico
access En linea
databasecode dig-okr
tag biblioteca
region America del Norte
libraryname Biblioteca del Banco Mundial
language English
en_US
topic JOBS
EMPLOYMENT
JOB CREATION RATE
MOTIVATION
ECONOMIC GROWTH
ACCOUNTING
NET JOB CREATION
PRODUCTION
EMPLOYMENT SHARE
FIRM SURVEY
INCOME
SERVICE SECTOR
FIRM DYNAMICS
MEDIUM ENTERPRISES
TOTAL LABOR FORCE
INFORMATION
CROSS- SECTIONAL DATA
LABOR FORCE
SURVIVAL RATE
JOB GENERATION
MANUFACTURERS
JOB
AGE CATEGORIES
EFFECTS
EMPLOYMENT POTENTIAL
LABOR STATISTICS
MERGERS
FIRM SIZE
TRAINING PROGRAMS
EMPLOYMENT SIZE
DRIVERS
SMALL BUSINESS
EMPLOYMENT LEVEL
FIRM EXIT
TRAINING
EMPLOYMENT LEVELS
DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS
MANUFACTURING ESTABLISHMENTS
FIRM LEVEL
WORKER
PREVIOUS STUDIES
FARM EMPLOYMENT
LABOR PRODUCTIVITY
NON-FARM EMPLOYMENT
PRODUCTIVITY
JOB LOSS
JOB CHURNING
MARKETS
FIRM
ORGANIZATIONS
BUSINESS CYCLE
DOMINANT EMPLOYERS
LABOR
ENTERPRISES
TOTAL EMPLOYMENT
EMPLOYMENT CREATION
PREVIOUS RESULTS
EFFICIENCY
SIZE OF FIRMS
SMALL ENTERPRISE
SHOP
FIRM ENTRY
AVERAGE EMPLOYMENT SIZE
SMALL FIRM
FIRMS
WORKERS
JOB DESTRUCTION RATES
POLICIES
OWNERSHIP STRUCTURE
SMALL ENTERPRISES
TURNOVER
VALUE
PLANT SIZE
NET EMPLOYMENT
STATE-OWNED ENTERPRISES
JOB CREATION RATES
AGE GROUPS
CO-OPERATIVES
PRIVATE FIRMS
ENTERPRISE
PRODUCTIVE FIRMS
EMPLOYMENT GROWTH
JOB CREATION
PRIVATE SECTOR
DOWNWARD BIAS
MARKET
JOB FLOWS
ECONOMIC THEORY
EMPLOYERS
ECONOMICS
EXPANSION
JOB DESTRUCTION
THEORY
FIRM” LEVEL
SECURITY
RISK
JOB DESTRUCTION RATE
CONTRACTING
BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT
EMPLOYEE
INNOVATION
EMPLOYMENT DYNAMICS
LENDING
LABOUR REGULATION
SMALL FIRMS
SUPPLIERS
FIRM GROWTH
ENTREPRENEURSHIP
LABOUR
EMPLOYMENT GROWTH RATE
SMALL BUSINESSES
SME
EMPLOYEES
JOBS
EMPLOYMENT
JOB CREATION RATE
MOTIVATION
ECONOMIC GROWTH
ACCOUNTING
NET JOB CREATION
PRODUCTION
EMPLOYMENT SHARE
FIRM SURVEY
INCOME
SERVICE SECTOR
FIRM DYNAMICS
MEDIUM ENTERPRISES
TOTAL LABOR FORCE
INFORMATION
CROSS- SECTIONAL DATA
LABOR FORCE
SURVIVAL RATE
JOB GENERATION
MANUFACTURERS
JOB
AGE CATEGORIES
EFFECTS
EMPLOYMENT POTENTIAL
LABOR STATISTICS
MERGERS
FIRM SIZE
TRAINING PROGRAMS
EMPLOYMENT SIZE
DRIVERS
SMALL BUSINESS
EMPLOYMENT LEVEL
FIRM EXIT
TRAINING
EMPLOYMENT LEVELS
DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS
MANUFACTURING ESTABLISHMENTS
FIRM LEVEL
WORKER
PREVIOUS STUDIES
FARM EMPLOYMENT
LABOR PRODUCTIVITY
NON-FARM EMPLOYMENT
PRODUCTIVITY
JOB LOSS
JOB CHURNING
MARKETS
FIRM
ORGANIZATIONS
BUSINESS CYCLE
DOMINANT EMPLOYERS
LABOR
ENTERPRISES
TOTAL EMPLOYMENT
EMPLOYMENT CREATION
PREVIOUS RESULTS
EFFICIENCY
SIZE OF FIRMS
SMALL ENTERPRISE
SHOP
FIRM ENTRY
AVERAGE EMPLOYMENT SIZE
SMALL FIRM
FIRMS
WORKERS
JOB DESTRUCTION RATES
POLICIES
OWNERSHIP STRUCTURE
SMALL ENTERPRISES
TURNOVER
VALUE
PLANT SIZE
NET EMPLOYMENT
STATE-OWNED ENTERPRISES
JOB CREATION RATES
AGE GROUPS
CO-OPERATIVES
PRIVATE FIRMS
ENTERPRISE
PRODUCTIVE FIRMS
EMPLOYMENT GROWTH
JOB CREATION
PRIVATE SECTOR
DOWNWARD BIAS
MARKET
JOB FLOWS
ECONOMIC THEORY
EMPLOYERS
ECONOMICS
EXPANSION
JOB DESTRUCTION
THEORY
FIRM” LEVEL
SECURITY
RISK
JOB DESTRUCTION RATE
CONTRACTING
BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT
EMPLOYEE
INNOVATION
EMPLOYMENT DYNAMICS
LENDING
LABOUR REGULATION
SMALL FIRMS
SUPPLIERS
FIRM GROWTH
ENTREPRENEURSHIP
LABOUR
EMPLOYMENT GROWTH RATE
SMALL BUSINESSES
SME
EMPLOYEES
spellingShingle JOBS
EMPLOYMENT
JOB CREATION RATE
MOTIVATION
ECONOMIC GROWTH
ACCOUNTING
NET JOB CREATION
PRODUCTION
EMPLOYMENT SHARE
FIRM SURVEY
INCOME
SERVICE SECTOR
FIRM DYNAMICS
MEDIUM ENTERPRISES
TOTAL LABOR FORCE
INFORMATION
CROSS- SECTIONAL DATA
LABOR FORCE
SURVIVAL RATE
JOB GENERATION
MANUFACTURERS
JOB
AGE CATEGORIES
EFFECTS
EMPLOYMENT POTENTIAL
LABOR STATISTICS
MERGERS
FIRM SIZE
TRAINING PROGRAMS
EMPLOYMENT SIZE
DRIVERS
SMALL BUSINESS
EMPLOYMENT LEVEL
FIRM EXIT
TRAINING
EMPLOYMENT LEVELS
DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS
MANUFACTURING ESTABLISHMENTS
FIRM LEVEL
WORKER
PREVIOUS STUDIES
FARM EMPLOYMENT
LABOR PRODUCTIVITY
NON-FARM EMPLOYMENT
PRODUCTIVITY
JOB LOSS
JOB CHURNING
MARKETS
FIRM
ORGANIZATIONS
BUSINESS CYCLE
DOMINANT EMPLOYERS
LABOR
ENTERPRISES
TOTAL EMPLOYMENT
EMPLOYMENT CREATION
PREVIOUS RESULTS
EFFICIENCY
SIZE OF FIRMS
SMALL ENTERPRISE
SHOP
FIRM ENTRY
AVERAGE EMPLOYMENT SIZE
SMALL FIRM
FIRMS
WORKERS
JOB DESTRUCTION RATES
POLICIES
OWNERSHIP STRUCTURE
SMALL ENTERPRISES
TURNOVER
VALUE
PLANT SIZE
NET EMPLOYMENT
STATE-OWNED ENTERPRISES
JOB CREATION RATES
AGE GROUPS
CO-OPERATIVES
PRIVATE FIRMS
ENTERPRISE
PRODUCTIVE FIRMS
EMPLOYMENT GROWTH
JOB CREATION
PRIVATE SECTOR
DOWNWARD BIAS
MARKET
JOB FLOWS
ECONOMIC THEORY
EMPLOYERS
ECONOMICS
EXPANSION
JOB DESTRUCTION
THEORY
FIRM” LEVEL
SECURITY
RISK
JOB DESTRUCTION RATE
CONTRACTING
BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT
EMPLOYEE
INNOVATION
EMPLOYMENT DYNAMICS
LENDING
LABOUR REGULATION
SMALL FIRMS
SUPPLIERS
FIRM GROWTH
ENTREPRENEURSHIP
LABOUR
EMPLOYMENT GROWTH RATE
SMALL BUSINESSES
SME
EMPLOYEES
JOBS
EMPLOYMENT
JOB CREATION RATE
MOTIVATION
ECONOMIC GROWTH
ACCOUNTING
NET JOB CREATION
PRODUCTION
EMPLOYMENT SHARE
FIRM SURVEY
INCOME
SERVICE SECTOR
FIRM DYNAMICS
MEDIUM ENTERPRISES
TOTAL LABOR FORCE
INFORMATION
CROSS- SECTIONAL DATA
LABOR FORCE
SURVIVAL RATE
JOB GENERATION
MANUFACTURERS
JOB
AGE CATEGORIES
EFFECTS
EMPLOYMENT POTENTIAL
LABOR STATISTICS
MERGERS
FIRM SIZE
TRAINING PROGRAMS
EMPLOYMENT SIZE
DRIVERS
SMALL BUSINESS
EMPLOYMENT LEVEL
FIRM EXIT
TRAINING
EMPLOYMENT LEVELS
DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS
MANUFACTURING ESTABLISHMENTS
FIRM LEVEL
WORKER
PREVIOUS STUDIES
FARM EMPLOYMENT
LABOR PRODUCTIVITY
NON-FARM EMPLOYMENT
PRODUCTIVITY
JOB LOSS
JOB CHURNING
MARKETS
FIRM
ORGANIZATIONS
BUSINESS CYCLE
DOMINANT EMPLOYERS
LABOR
ENTERPRISES
TOTAL EMPLOYMENT
EMPLOYMENT CREATION
PREVIOUS RESULTS
EFFICIENCY
SIZE OF FIRMS
SMALL ENTERPRISE
SHOP
FIRM ENTRY
AVERAGE EMPLOYMENT SIZE
SMALL FIRM
FIRMS
WORKERS
JOB DESTRUCTION RATES
POLICIES
OWNERSHIP STRUCTURE
SMALL ENTERPRISES
TURNOVER
VALUE
PLANT SIZE
NET EMPLOYMENT
STATE-OWNED ENTERPRISES
JOB CREATION RATES
AGE GROUPS
CO-OPERATIVES
PRIVATE FIRMS
ENTERPRISE
PRODUCTIVE FIRMS
EMPLOYMENT GROWTH
JOB CREATION
PRIVATE SECTOR
DOWNWARD BIAS
MARKET
JOB FLOWS
ECONOMIC THEORY
EMPLOYERS
ECONOMICS
EXPANSION
JOB DESTRUCTION
THEORY
FIRM” LEVEL
SECURITY
RISK
JOB DESTRUCTION RATE
CONTRACTING
BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT
EMPLOYEE
INNOVATION
EMPLOYMENT DYNAMICS
LENDING
LABOUR REGULATION
SMALL FIRMS
SUPPLIERS
FIRM GROWTH
ENTREPRENEURSHIP
LABOUR
EMPLOYMENT GROWTH RATE
SMALL BUSINESSES
SME
EMPLOYEES
Aga, Gemechu
Francis, David C.
Rodriguez Meza, Jorge
SMEs, Age, and Jobs
description The subject of which firms are the key employers—and which of these create or destroy jobs at a faster rate—is eminently important for academics and policy makers. The relative importance of small versus large firms and old versus young firms has in particular been extensively debated and studied. Nevertheless, the results often hinge on the questions that are asked. Moreover, the categorical definitions used to define firm size and age, and the nature and coverage of the data used have important effects. This paper lays out the relevant definitions and metrics that are central to the debate, reviewing the main findings to date on the subject (with particular emphasis on results in developing economies). The paper adds updated results for 117 developing economies using the World Bank’s Enterprise Survey Data, finding that (i) small and medium enterprises and older establishments are the dominant employers in the nonagricultural private sector labor force in developing economies, and (ii) net job creation is negatively correlated with establishment age and, although the effect of size is also negative, its significance is sensitive to the definition and methods used.
format Working Paper
topic_facet JOBS
EMPLOYMENT
JOB CREATION RATE
MOTIVATION
ECONOMIC GROWTH
ACCOUNTING
NET JOB CREATION
PRODUCTION
EMPLOYMENT SHARE
FIRM SURVEY
INCOME
SERVICE SECTOR
FIRM DYNAMICS
MEDIUM ENTERPRISES
TOTAL LABOR FORCE
INFORMATION
CROSS- SECTIONAL DATA
LABOR FORCE
SURVIVAL RATE
JOB GENERATION
MANUFACTURERS
JOB
AGE CATEGORIES
EFFECTS
EMPLOYMENT POTENTIAL
LABOR STATISTICS
MERGERS
FIRM SIZE
TRAINING PROGRAMS
EMPLOYMENT SIZE
DRIVERS
SMALL BUSINESS
EMPLOYMENT LEVEL
FIRM EXIT
TRAINING
EMPLOYMENT LEVELS
DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS
MANUFACTURING ESTABLISHMENTS
FIRM LEVEL
WORKER
PREVIOUS STUDIES
FARM EMPLOYMENT
LABOR PRODUCTIVITY
NON-FARM EMPLOYMENT
PRODUCTIVITY
JOB LOSS
JOB CHURNING
MARKETS
FIRM
ORGANIZATIONS
BUSINESS CYCLE
DOMINANT EMPLOYERS
LABOR
ENTERPRISES
TOTAL EMPLOYMENT
EMPLOYMENT CREATION
PREVIOUS RESULTS
EFFICIENCY
SIZE OF FIRMS
SMALL ENTERPRISE
SHOP
FIRM ENTRY
AVERAGE EMPLOYMENT SIZE
SMALL FIRM
FIRMS
WORKERS
JOB DESTRUCTION RATES
POLICIES
OWNERSHIP STRUCTURE
SMALL ENTERPRISES
TURNOVER
VALUE
PLANT SIZE
NET EMPLOYMENT
STATE-OWNED ENTERPRISES
JOB CREATION RATES
AGE GROUPS
CO-OPERATIVES
PRIVATE FIRMS
ENTERPRISE
PRODUCTIVE FIRMS
EMPLOYMENT GROWTH
JOB CREATION
PRIVATE SECTOR
DOWNWARD BIAS
MARKET
JOB FLOWS
ECONOMIC THEORY
EMPLOYERS
ECONOMICS
EXPANSION
JOB DESTRUCTION
THEORY
FIRM” LEVEL
SECURITY
RISK
JOB DESTRUCTION RATE
CONTRACTING
BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT
EMPLOYEE
INNOVATION
EMPLOYMENT DYNAMICS
LENDING
LABOUR REGULATION
SMALL FIRMS
SUPPLIERS
FIRM GROWTH
ENTREPRENEURSHIP
LABOUR
EMPLOYMENT GROWTH RATE
SMALL BUSINESSES
SME
EMPLOYEES
author Aga, Gemechu
Francis, David C.
Rodriguez Meza, Jorge
author_facet Aga, Gemechu
Francis, David C.
Rodriguez Meza, Jorge
author_sort Aga, Gemechu
title SMEs, Age, and Jobs
title_short SMEs, Age, and Jobs
title_full SMEs, Age, and Jobs
title_fullStr SMEs, Age, and Jobs
title_full_unstemmed SMEs, Age, and Jobs
title_sort smes, age, and jobs
publisher World Bank, Washington, DC
publishDate 2015-11
url http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2015/11/25462713/smes-age-jobs-review-literature-metrics-evidence
https://hdl.handle.net/10986/23455
work_keys_str_mv AT agagemechu smesageandjobs
AT francisdavidc smesageandjobs
AT rodriguezmezajorge smesageandjobs
AT agagemechu areviewoftheliteraturemetricsandevidence
AT francisdavidc areviewoftheliteraturemetricsandevidence
AT rodriguezmezajorge areviewoftheliteraturemetricsandevidence
_version_ 1809106294649389056