Natural Openness and Good Government

The author offers a possibly new interpretation of the connection between openness and good governance, with a conceptual model and some empirical evidence. Assuming that corruption and bad governance reduce international trade and investment more than domestic trade and investment, a "naturally more open economy"-as determined by its size and geography-would devote more resources to building good institutions and would display less corruption in equilibrium. How is "natural openness" defined? By size, geography, and language. France would be more naturally open than Argentina because Argentina is more remote. Ability to speak English facilitates international trade. A country with a long coast tends to be more open than a landlocked country. In the data, "naturally more open economies" do show less corruption even after their level of development is taken into account. "Residual openness"-which could include trade policies-is not important once "natural openness" is accounted for. Moreover, "naturally more open economies" also tend to pay civil servants salaries that are more competitive with those of their private sector counterparts. One implication of this research is that globalization may affect governance: as globalization deepens, the "natural openness" of all countries increases. This raises the opportunity cost of tolerating a given level of corruption and could provide new impetus for countries to fight corruption. These patterns are consistent with the conceptual model.

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Author: Wei, Shang-Jin
Language:English
en_US
Published: World Bank, Washington, DC 2000-08
Subjects:AVERAGE INCOME, BAD GOVERNANCE, BENCHMARK, BILATERAL TRADE, BRIBERY, BUREAUCRACY, BUREAUCRAT, BUREAUCRATIC CORRUPTION, BUREAUCRATIC STRUCTURE, CIVIL RIGHTS, CIVIL SERVANTS, CIVIL SERVICE, COMPETITIVENESS, CONSUMPTION EXPENDITURES, CONTRACT ENFORCEMENT, CONVENTIONAL WISDOM, CORRUPTION, DEMOCRACY, DEMOCRATIC INSTITUTIONS, DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS, DIRECT INVESTMENT, ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT, ECONOMIC PERFORMANCE, ECONOMIC RISK, ECONOMICS LITERATURE, EFFECT OF TRADE, ELASTICITY, EMPIRICAL EVIDENCE, EQUILIBRIUM, EXPECTED UTILITY, EXPENDITURE, EXPORTS, FEDERAL STATES, FEDERALISM, FIGHTING CORRUPTION, FISCAL, FISCAL DECENTRALIZATION, FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT, FOREIGN INVESTORS, FOREIGN TRADE, GDP, GDP PER CAPITA, GINI COEFFICIENT, GOOD GOVERNANCE, GOOD GOVERNMENT, GOVERNMENT OFFICIALS, GOVERNMENT PERFORMANCE, GOVERNMENT POLICIES, GOVERNMENT REVENUES, GROWTH RATE, IMPORTS, INCOME DISTRIBUTION, INCOME EFFECT, INCOME INEQUALITY, INCOME LEVEL, INEQUALITY, INSTITUTION BUILDING, INTERNATIONAL LABOR, INTERNATIONAL TRADE, LESS DEVELOPED COUNTRIES, LOCAL GOVERNMENT, LOCAL GOVERNMENTS, LORENZ CURVE, MARGINAL BENEFITS, MARGINAL COST, NATIONS, OPEN ECONOMIES, OPENNESS, OPPORTUNITY COST, OPTIMIZATION, PER CAPITA INCOME, POLITICAL ECONOMY, POLITICAL RIGHTS, POLITICAL RISK, PUBLIC GOVERNANCE, PUBLIC INSTITUTION, PUBLIC INSTITUTIONS, PUBLIC POLICY, PUBLIC SECTOR, REVERSE CAUSALITY, SOCIAL WELFARE, TAX RATE, TRADE BARRIERS, TRADE POLICIES, TRADING BLOCS, TRANSPARENCY, UTILITY FUNCTION, VOTING, WAGES,
Online Access:http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2000/08/443565/natural-openness-good-government
https://hdl.handle.net/10986/19796
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
id dig-okr-1098619796
record_format koha
spelling dig-okr-10986197962024-08-08T18:08:26Z Natural Openness and Good Government Wei, Shang-Jin AVERAGE INCOME BAD GOVERNANCE BENCHMARK BILATERAL TRADE BRIBERY BUREAUCRACY BUREAUCRAT BUREAUCRATIC CORRUPTION BUREAUCRATIC STRUCTURE CIVIL RIGHTS CIVIL SERVANTS CIVIL SERVICE COMPETITIVENESS CONSUMPTION EXPENDITURES CONTRACT ENFORCEMENT CONVENTIONAL WISDOM CORRUPTION DEMOCRACY DEMOCRATIC INSTITUTIONS DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS DIRECT INVESTMENT ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT ECONOMIC PERFORMANCE ECONOMIC RISK ECONOMICS LITERATURE EFFECT OF TRADE ELASTICITY EMPIRICAL EVIDENCE EQUILIBRIUM EXPECTED UTILITY EXPENDITURE EXPORTS FEDERAL STATES FEDERALISM FIGHTING CORRUPTION FISCAL FISCAL DECENTRALIZATION FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT FOREIGN INVESTORS FOREIGN TRADE GDP GDP PER CAPITA GINI COEFFICIENT GOOD GOVERNANCE GOOD GOVERNMENT GOVERNMENT OFFICIALS GOVERNMENT PERFORMANCE GOVERNMENT POLICIES GOVERNMENT REVENUES GROWTH RATE IMPORTS INCOME DISTRIBUTION INCOME EFFECT INCOME INEQUALITY INCOME LEVEL INEQUALITY INSTITUTION BUILDING INTERNATIONAL LABOR INTERNATIONAL TRADE LESS DEVELOPED COUNTRIES LOCAL GOVERNMENT LOCAL GOVERNMENTS LORENZ CURVE MARGINAL BENEFITS MARGINAL COST NATIONS OPEN ECONOMIES OPENNESS OPPORTUNITY COST OPTIMIZATION PER CAPITA INCOME POLITICAL ECONOMY POLITICAL RIGHTS POLITICAL RISK PUBLIC GOVERNANCE PUBLIC INSTITUTION PUBLIC INSTITUTIONS PUBLIC POLICY PUBLIC SECTOR REVERSE CAUSALITY SOCIAL WELFARE TAX RATE TRADE BARRIERS TRADE POLICIES TRADING BLOCS TRANSPARENCY UTILITY FUNCTION VOTING WAGES The author offers a possibly new interpretation of the connection between openness and good governance, with a conceptual model and some empirical evidence. Assuming that corruption and bad governance reduce international trade and investment more than domestic trade and investment, a "naturally more open economy"-as determined by its size and geography-would devote more resources to building good institutions and would display less corruption in equilibrium. How is "natural openness" defined? By size, geography, and language. France would be more naturally open than Argentina because Argentina is more remote. Ability to speak English facilitates international trade. A country with a long coast tends to be more open than a landlocked country. In the data, "naturally more open economies" do show less corruption even after their level of development is taken into account. "Residual openness"-which could include trade policies-is not important once "natural openness" is accounted for. Moreover, "naturally more open economies" also tend to pay civil servants salaries that are more competitive with those of their private sector counterparts. One implication of this research is that globalization may affect governance: as globalization deepens, the "natural openness" of all countries increases. This raises the opportunity cost of tolerating a given level of corruption and could provide new impetus for countries to fight corruption. These patterns are consistent with the conceptual model. 2014-08-27T21:06:50Z 2014-08-27T21:06:50Z 2000-08 http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2000/08/443565/natural-openness-good-government https://hdl.handle.net/10986/19796 English en_US Policy Research Working Paper;No. 2411 CC BY 3.0 IGO http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/igo/ application/pdf text/plain World Bank, Washington, DC
institution Banco Mundial
collection DSpace
country Estados Unidos
countrycode US
component Bibliográfico
access En linea
databasecode dig-okr
tag biblioteca
region America del Norte
libraryname Biblioteca del Banco Mundial
language English
en_US
topic AVERAGE INCOME
BAD GOVERNANCE
BENCHMARK
BILATERAL TRADE
BRIBERY
BUREAUCRACY
BUREAUCRAT
BUREAUCRATIC CORRUPTION
BUREAUCRATIC STRUCTURE
CIVIL RIGHTS
CIVIL SERVANTS
CIVIL SERVICE
COMPETITIVENESS
CONSUMPTION EXPENDITURES
CONTRACT ENFORCEMENT
CONVENTIONAL WISDOM
CORRUPTION
DEMOCRACY
DEMOCRATIC INSTITUTIONS
DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS
DIRECT INVESTMENT
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
ECONOMIC PERFORMANCE
ECONOMIC RISK
ECONOMICS LITERATURE
EFFECT OF TRADE
ELASTICITY
EMPIRICAL EVIDENCE
EQUILIBRIUM
EXPECTED UTILITY
EXPENDITURE
EXPORTS
FEDERAL STATES
FEDERALISM
FIGHTING CORRUPTION
FISCAL
FISCAL DECENTRALIZATION
FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT
FOREIGN INVESTORS
FOREIGN TRADE
GDP
GDP PER CAPITA
GINI COEFFICIENT
GOOD GOVERNANCE
GOOD GOVERNMENT
GOVERNMENT OFFICIALS
GOVERNMENT PERFORMANCE
GOVERNMENT POLICIES
GOVERNMENT REVENUES
GROWTH RATE
IMPORTS
INCOME DISTRIBUTION
INCOME EFFECT
INCOME INEQUALITY
INCOME LEVEL
INEQUALITY
INSTITUTION BUILDING
INTERNATIONAL LABOR
INTERNATIONAL TRADE
LESS DEVELOPED COUNTRIES
LOCAL GOVERNMENT
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
LORENZ CURVE
MARGINAL BENEFITS
MARGINAL COST
NATIONS
OPEN ECONOMIES
OPENNESS
OPPORTUNITY COST
OPTIMIZATION
PER CAPITA INCOME
POLITICAL ECONOMY
POLITICAL RIGHTS
POLITICAL RISK
PUBLIC GOVERNANCE
PUBLIC INSTITUTION
PUBLIC INSTITUTIONS
PUBLIC POLICY
PUBLIC SECTOR
REVERSE CAUSALITY
SOCIAL WELFARE
TAX RATE
TRADE BARRIERS
TRADE POLICIES
TRADING BLOCS
TRANSPARENCY
UTILITY FUNCTION
VOTING
WAGES
AVERAGE INCOME
BAD GOVERNANCE
BENCHMARK
BILATERAL TRADE
BRIBERY
BUREAUCRACY
BUREAUCRAT
BUREAUCRATIC CORRUPTION
BUREAUCRATIC STRUCTURE
CIVIL RIGHTS
CIVIL SERVANTS
CIVIL SERVICE
COMPETITIVENESS
CONSUMPTION EXPENDITURES
CONTRACT ENFORCEMENT
CONVENTIONAL WISDOM
CORRUPTION
DEMOCRACY
DEMOCRATIC INSTITUTIONS
DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS
DIRECT INVESTMENT
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
ECONOMIC PERFORMANCE
ECONOMIC RISK
ECONOMICS LITERATURE
EFFECT OF TRADE
ELASTICITY
EMPIRICAL EVIDENCE
EQUILIBRIUM
EXPECTED UTILITY
EXPENDITURE
EXPORTS
FEDERAL STATES
FEDERALISM
FIGHTING CORRUPTION
FISCAL
FISCAL DECENTRALIZATION
FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT
FOREIGN INVESTORS
FOREIGN TRADE
GDP
GDP PER CAPITA
GINI COEFFICIENT
GOOD GOVERNANCE
GOOD GOVERNMENT
GOVERNMENT OFFICIALS
GOVERNMENT PERFORMANCE
GOVERNMENT POLICIES
GOVERNMENT REVENUES
GROWTH RATE
IMPORTS
INCOME DISTRIBUTION
INCOME EFFECT
INCOME INEQUALITY
INCOME LEVEL
INEQUALITY
INSTITUTION BUILDING
INTERNATIONAL LABOR
INTERNATIONAL TRADE
LESS DEVELOPED COUNTRIES
LOCAL GOVERNMENT
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
LORENZ CURVE
MARGINAL BENEFITS
MARGINAL COST
NATIONS
OPEN ECONOMIES
OPENNESS
OPPORTUNITY COST
OPTIMIZATION
PER CAPITA INCOME
POLITICAL ECONOMY
POLITICAL RIGHTS
POLITICAL RISK
PUBLIC GOVERNANCE
PUBLIC INSTITUTION
PUBLIC INSTITUTIONS
PUBLIC POLICY
PUBLIC SECTOR
REVERSE CAUSALITY
SOCIAL WELFARE
TAX RATE
TRADE BARRIERS
TRADE POLICIES
TRADING BLOCS
TRANSPARENCY
UTILITY FUNCTION
VOTING
WAGES
spellingShingle AVERAGE INCOME
BAD GOVERNANCE
BENCHMARK
BILATERAL TRADE
BRIBERY
BUREAUCRACY
BUREAUCRAT
BUREAUCRATIC CORRUPTION
BUREAUCRATIC STRUCTURE
CIVIL RIGHTS
CIVIL SERVANTS
CIVIL SERVICE
COMPETITIVENESS
CONSUMPTION EXPENDITURES
CONTRACT ENFORCEMENT
CONVENTIONAL WISDOM
CORRUPTION
DEMOCRACY
DEMOCRATIC INSTITUTIONS
DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS
DIRECT INVESTMENT
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
ECONOMIC PERFORMANCE
ECONOMIC RISK
ECONOMICS LITERATURE
EFFECT OF TRADE
ELASTICITY
EMPIRICAL EVIDENCE
EQUILIBRIUM
EXPECTED UTILITY
EXPENDITURE
EXPORTS
FEDERAL STATES
FEDERALISM
FIGHTING CORRUPTION
FISCAL
FISCAL DECENTRALIZATION
FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT
FOREIGN INVESTORS
FOREIGN TRADE
GDP
GDP PER CAPITA
GINI COEFFICIENT
GOOD GOVERNANCE
GOOD GOVERNMENT
GOVERNMENT OFFICIALS
GOVERNMENT PERFORMANCE
GOVERNMENT POLICIES
GOVERNMENT REVENUES
GROWTH RATE
IMPORTS
INCOME DISTRIBUTION
INCOME EFFECT
INCOME INEQUALITY
INCOME LEVEL
INEQUALITY
INSTITUTION BUILDING
INTERNATIONAL LABOR
INTERNATIONAL TRADE
LESS DEVELOPED COUNTRIES
LOCAL GOVERNMENT
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
LORENZ CURVE
MARGINAL BENEFITS
MARGINAL COST
NATIONS
OPEN ECONOMIES
OPENNESS
OPPORTUNITY COST
OPTIMIZATION
PER CAPITA INCOME
POLITICAL ECONOMY
POLITICAL RIGHTS
POLITICAL RISK
PUBLIC GOVERNANCE
PUBLIC INSTITUTION
PUBLIC INSTITUTIONS
PUBLIC POLICY
PUBLIC SECTOR
REVERSE CAUSALITY
SOCIAL WELFARE
TAX RATE
TRADE BARRIERS
TRADE POLICIES
TRADING BLOCS
TRANSPARENCY
UTILITY FUNCTION
VOTING
WAGES
AVERAGE INCOME
BAD GOVERNANCE
BENCHMARK
BILATERAL TRADE
BRIBERY
BUREAUCRACY
BUREAUCRAT
BUREAUCRATIC CORRUPTION
BUREAUCRATIC STRUCTURE
CIVIL RIGHTS
CIVIL SERVANTS
CIVIL SERVICE
COMPETITIVENESS
CONSUMPTION EXPENDITURES
CONTRACT ENFORCEMENT
CONVENTIONAL WISDOM
CORRUPTION
DEMOCRACY
DEMOCRATIC INSTITUTIONS
DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS
DIRECT INVESTMENT
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
ECONOMIC PERFORMANCE
ECONOMIC RISK
ECONOMICS LITERATURE
EFFECT OF TRADE
ELASTICITY
EMPIRICAL EVIDENCE
EQUILIBRIUM
EXPECTED UTILITY
EXPENDITURE
EXPORTS
FEDERAL STATES
FEDERALISM
FIGHTING CORRUPTION
FISCAL
FISCAL DECENTRALIZATION
FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT
FOREIGN INVESTORS
FOREIGN TRADE
GDP
GDP PER CAPITA
GINI COEFFICIENT
GOOD GOVERNANCE
GOOD GOVERNMENT
GOVERNMENT OFFICIALS
GOVERNMENT PERFORMANCE
GOVERNMENT POLICIES
GOVERNMENT REVENUES
GROWTH RATE
IMPORTS
INCOME DISTRIBUTION
INCOME EFFECT
INCOME INEQUALITY
INCOME LEVEL
INEQUALITY
INSTITUTION BUILDING
INTERNATIONAL LABOR
INTERNATIONAL TRADE
LESS DEVELOPED COUNTRIES
LOCAL GOVERNMENT
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
LORENZ CURVE
MARGINAL BENEFITS
MARGINAL COST
NATIONS
OPEN ECONOMIES
OPENNESS
OPPORTUNITY COST
OPTIMIZATION
PER CAPITA INCOME
POLITICAL ECONOMY
POLITICAL RIGHTS
POLITICAL RISK
PUBLIC GOVERNANCE
PUBLIC INSTITUTION
PUBLIC INSTITUTIONS
PUBLIC POLICY
PUBLIC SECTOR
REVERSE CAUSALITY
SOCIAL WELFARE
TAX RATE
TRADE BARRIERS
TRADE POLICIES
TRADING BLOCS
TRANSPARENCY
UTILITY FUNCTION
VOTING
WAGES
Wei, Shang-Jin
Natural Openness and Good Government
description The author offers a possibly new interpretation of the connection between openness and good governance, with a conceptual model and some empirical evidence. Assuming that corruption and bad governance reduce international trade and investment more than domestic trade and investment, a "naturally more open economy"-as determined by its size and geography-would devote more resources to building good institutions and would display less corruption in equilibrium. How is "natural openness" defined? By size, geography, and language. France would be more naturally open than Argentina because Argentina is more remote. Ability to speak English facilitates international trade. A country with a long coast tends to be more open than a landlocked country. In the data, "naturally more open economies" do show less corruption even after their level of development is taken into account. "Residual openness"-which could include trade policies-is not important once "natural openness" is accounted for. Moreover, "naturally more open economies" also tend to pay civil servants salaries that are more competitive with those of their private sector counterparts. One implication of this research is that globalization may affect governance: as globalization deepens, the "natural openness" of all countries increases. This raises the opportunity cost of tolerating a given level of corruption and could provide new impetus for countries to fight corruption. These patterns are consistent with the conceptual model.
topic_facet AVERAGE INCOME
BAD GOVERNANCE
BENCHMARK
BILATERAL TRADE
BRIBERY
BUREAUCRACY
BUREAUCRAT
BUREAUCRATIC CORRUPTION
BUREAUCRATIC STRUCTURE
CIVIL RIGHTS
CIVIL SERVANTS
CIVIL SERVICE
COMPETITIVENESS
CONSUMPTION EXPENDITURES
CONTRACT ENFORCEMENT
CONVENTIONAL WISDOM
CORRUPTION
DEMOCRACY
DEMOCRATIC INSTITUTIONS
DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS
DIRECT INVESTMENT
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
ECONOMIC PERFORMANCE
ECONOMIC RISK
ECONOMICS LITERATURE
EFFECT OF TRADE
ELASTICITY
EMPIRICAL EVIDENCE
EQUILIBRIUM
EXPECTED UTILITY
EXPENDITURE
EXPORTS
FEDERAL STATES
FEDERALISM
FIGHTING CORRUPTION
FISCAL
FISCAL DECENTRALIZATION
FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT
FOREIGN INVESTORS
FOREIGN TRADE
GDP
GDP PER CAPITA
GINI COEFFICIENT
GOOD GOVERNANCE
GOOD GOVERNMENT
GOVERNMENT OFFICIALS
GOVERNMENT PERFORMANCE
GOVERNMENT POLICIES
GOVERNMENT REVENUES
GROWTH RATE
IMPORTS
INCOME DISTRIBUTION
INCOME EFFECT
INCOME INEQUALITY
INCOME LEVEL
INEQUALITY
INSTITUTION BUILDING
INTERNATIONAL LABOR
INTERNATIONAL TRADE
LESS DEVELOPED COUNTRIES
LOCAL GOVERNMENT
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
LORENZ CURVE
MARGINAL BENEFITS
MARGINAL COST
NATIONS
OPEN ECONOMIES
OPENNESS
OPPORTUNITY COST
OPTIMIZATION
PER CAPITA INCOME
POLITICAL ECONOMY
POLITICAL RIGHTS
POLITICAL RISK
PUBLIC GOVERNANCE
PUBLIC INSTITUTION
PUBLIC INSTITUTIONS
PUBLIC POLICY
PUBLIC SECTOR
REVERSE CAUSALITY
SOCIAL WELFARE
TAX RATE
TRADE BARRIERS
TRADE POLICIES
TRADING BLOCS
TRANSPARENCY
UTILITY FUNCTION
VOTING
WAGES
author Wei, Shang-Jin
author_facet Wei, Shang-Jin
author_sort Wei, Shang-Jin
title Natural Openness and Good Government
title_short Natural Openness and Good Government
title_full Natural Openness and Good Government
title_fullStr Natural Openness and Good Government
title_full_unstemmed Natural Openness and Good Government
title_sort natural openness and good government
publisher World Bank, Washington, DC
publishDate 2000-08
url http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2000/08/443565/natural-openness-good-government
https://hdl.handle.net/10986/19796
work_keys_str_mv AT weishangjin naturalopennessandgoodgovernment
_version_ 1807158895609643008