Is There a Farm-Size Productivity Relationship in African Agriculture? Evidence from Rwanda

Whether the negative relationship between farm size and productivity that is confirmed in a large global literature holds in Africa is of considerable policy relevance. This paper revisits this issue and examines potential causes of the inverse productivity relationship in Rwanda, where policy makers consider land fragmentation and small farm sizes to be key bottlenecks for the growth of the agricultural sector. Nationwide plot-level data from Rwanda point toward a constant returns to scale crop production function and a strong negative relationship between farm size and output per hectare as well as intensity of labor use that is robust across specifications. The inverse relationship continues to hold if profits with family labor valued at shadow wages are used, but disappears if family labor is rather valued at village-level market wage rates. These findings imply that, in Rwanda, labor market imperfections, rather than other unobserved factors, seem to be a key reason for the inverse farm-size productivity relationship.

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Ali, Daniel Ayalew, Deininger, Klaus
Language:English
en_US
Published: World Bank, Washington, DC 2014-02
Subjects:ADVERSE EFFECTS, AGRICULTURAL DEVELOPMENT, AGRICULTURAL ECONOMICS, AGRICULTURAL GROWTH, AGRICULTURAL LAND, AGRICULTURAL PLOTS, AGRICULTURAL PRACTICE, AGRICULTURAL PRODUCTION, AGRICULTURAL SECTOR, AGRICULTURE, CHEMICAL FERTILIZER, CLASSIFICATION, CLIMATE, CLIMATE CHANGE, CLIMATIC CONDITIONS, COMPETITIVE LABOR MARKETS, CONSERVATION, CONSOLIDATION, CROP, CROP CHOICE, CROP MIX, CROP OUTPUT, CROP PRODUCTION, CROP TYPE, CROPS, DATA COLLECTION, DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS, DEVELOPMENT STRATEGIES, ECONOMETRIC EVIDENCE, ECONOMICS, EMPLOYMENT, EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES, EROSION, EXTENSION, FACTOR MARKETS, FAMILY LABOR, FARM, FARM EMPLOYMENT, FARM FAMILY, FARM HOUSEHOLD, FARM MANAGEMENT, FARM SIZE, FARMERS, FARMING, FARMS, FERTILIZER, FERTILIZER USE, FINANCIAL MARKETS, FIXED COSTS, FLOODING, GENDER, GROSS PROFIT, GROSS REVENUE, INCOME, INNOVATIONS, INSURANCE, INTEGRATION, LABOR DEMAND, LABOR MARKET, LABOR MARKETS, LABOUR, LABOUR SUPPLY, LAND REFORM, LAND RESOURCES, LAND USE, LAND VALUE, LAND YIELDS, MARKET WAGE, MARKET WAGES, NATURAL RESOURCES, NET PROFIT, OUTPUTS, PERFECT MARKETS, PESTICIDE USE, PESTS, PH, PLANTATION, PLOTS, POLITICAL ECONOMY, PRODUCTION PROCESS, PRODUCTIVITY, PROFITABILITY, PROPERTY RIGHTS, PUBLIC SERVICES, R&D, RANGES, RESOURCE ALLOCATION, RICE, RURAL DEVELOPMENT, RURAL LABOR, SAND, SKILLED LABOR, SOIL CONSERVATION, SOILS, TOPOGRAPHY, TRANSACTION COSTS, WAGE RATES, WAGES, WETLAND, WORKING CAPITAL,
Online Access:http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2014/02/18910978/farm-size-productivity-relationship-african-griculture-evidence-rwanda
https://hdl.handle.net/10986/17304
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
id dig-okr-1098617304
record_format koha
spelling dig-okr-10986173042024-08-08T14:09:23Z Is There a Farm-Size Productivity Relationship in African Agriculture? Evidence from Rwanda Ali, Daniel Ayalew Deininger, Klaus ADVERSE EFFECTS AGRICULTURAL DEVELOPMENT AGRICULTURAL ECONOMICS AGRICULTURAL GROWTH AGRICULTURAL LAND AGRICULTURAL PLOTS AGRICULTURAL PRACTICE AGRICULTURAL PRODUCTION AGRICULTURAL SECTOR AGRICULTURE CHEMICAL FERTILIZER CLASSIFICATION CLIMATE CLIMATE CHANGE CLIMATIC CONDITIONS COMPETITIVE LABOR MARKETS CONSERVATION CONSOLIDATION CROP CROP CHOICE CROP MIX CROP OUTPUT CROP PRODUCTION CROP TYPE CROPS DATA COLLECTION DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS DEVELOPMENT STRATEGIES ECONOMETRIC EVIDENCE ECONOMICS EMPLOYMENT EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES EROSION EXTENSION FACTOR MARKETS FAMILY LABOR FARM FARM EMPLOYMENT FARM FAMILY FARM HOUSEHOLD FARM MANAGEMENT FARM SIZE FARMERS FARMING FARMS FERTILIZER FERTILIZER USE FINANCIAL MARKETS FIXED COSTS FLOODING GENDER GROSS PROFIT GROSS REVENUE INCOME INNOVATIONS INSURANCE INTEGRATION LABOR DEMAND LABOR MARKET LABOR MARKETS LABOUR LABOUR SUPPLY LAND REFORM LAND RESOURCES LAND USE LAND VALUE LAND YIELDS MARKET WAGE MARKET WAGES NATURAL RESOURCES NET PROFIT OUTPUTS PERFECT MARKETS PESTICIDE USE PESTS PH PLANTATION PLOTS POLITICAL ECONOMY PRODUCTION PROCESS PRODUCTIVITY PROFITABILITY PROPERTY RIGHTS PUBLIC SERVICES R&D RANGES RESOURCE ALLOCATION RICE RURAL DEVELOPMENT RURAL LABOR SAND SKILLED LABOR SOIL CONSERVATION SOILS TOPOGRAPHY TRANSACTION COSTS WAGE RATES WAGES WETLAND WORKING CAPITAL Whether the negative relationship between farm size and productivity that is confirmed in a large global literature holds in Africa is of considerable policy relevance. This paper revisits this issue and examines potential causes of the inverse productivity relationship in Rwanda, where policy makers consider land fragmentation and small farm sizes to be key bottlenecks for the growth of the agricultural sector. Nationwide plot-level data from Rwanda point toward a constant returns to scale crop production function and a strong negative relationship between farm size and output per hectare as well as intensity of labor use that is robust across specifications. The inverse relationship continues to hold if profits with family labor valued at shadow wages are used, but disappears if family labor is rather valued at village-level market wage rates. These findings imply that, in Rwanda, labor market imperfections, rather than other unobserved factors, seem to be a key reason for the inverse farm-size productivity relationship. 2014-03-18T20:01:10Z 2014-03-18T20:01:10Z 2014-02 http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2014/02/18910978/farm-size-productivity-relationship-african-griculture-evidence-rwanda https://hdl.handle.net/10986/17304 English en_US Policy Research Working Paper;No. 6770 CC BY 3.0 IGO http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/igo/ application/pdf text/plain World Bank, Washington, DC
institution Banco Mundial
collection DSpace
country Estados Unidos
countrycode US
component Bibliográfico
access En linea
databasecode dig-okr
tag biblioteca
region America del Norte
libraryname Biblioteca del Banco Mundial
language English
en_US
topic ADVERSE EFFECTS
AGRICULTURAL DEVELOPMENT
AGRICULTURAL ECONOMICS
AGRICULTURAL GROWTH
AGRICULTURAL LAND
AGRICULTURAL PLOTS
AGRICULTURAL PRACTICE
AGRICULTURAL PRODUCTION
AGRICULTURAL SECTOR
AGRICULTURE
CHEMICAL FERTILIZER
CLASSIFICATION
CLIMATE
CLIMATE CHANGE
CLIMATIC CONDITIONS
COMPETITIVE LABOR MARKETS
CONSERVATION
CONSOLIDATION
CROP
CROP CHOICE
CROP MIX
CROP OUTPUT
CROP PRODUCTION
CROP TYPE
CROPS
DATA COLLECTION
DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS
DEVELOPMENT STRATEGIES
ECONOMETRIC EVIDENCE
ECONOMICS
EMPLOYMENT
EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES
EROSION
EXTENSION
FACTOR MARKETS
FAMILY LABOR
FARM
FARM EMPLOYMENT
FARM FAMILY
FARM HOUSEHOLD
FARM MANAGEMENT
FARM SIZE
FARMERS
FARMING
FARMS
FERTILIZER
FERTILIZER USE
FINANCIAL MARKETS
FIXED COSTS
FLOODING
GENDER
GROSS PROFIT
GROSS REVENUE
INCOME
INNOVATIONS
INSURANCE
INTEGRATION
LABOR DEMAND
LABOR MARKET
LABOR MARKETS
LABOUR
LABOUR SUPPLY
LAND REFORM
LAND RESOURCES
LAND USE
LAND VALUE
LAND YIELDS
MARKET WAGE
MARKET WAGES
NATURAL RESOURCES
NET PROFIT
OUTPUTS
PERFECT MARKETS
PESTICIDE USE
PESTS
PH
PLANTATION
PLOTS
POLITICAL ECONOMY
PRODUCTION PROCESS
PRODUCTIVITY
PROFITABILITY
PROPERTY RIGHTS
PUBLIC SERVICES
R&D
RANGES
RESOURCE ALLOCATION
RICE
RURAL DEVELOPMENT
RURAL LABOR
SAND
SKILLED LABOR
SOIL CONSERVATION
SOILS
TOPOGRAPHY
TRANSACTION COSTS
WAGE RATES
WAGES
WETLAND
WORKING CAPITAL
ADVERSE EFFECTS
AGRICULTURAL DEVELOPMENT
AGRICULTURAL ECONOMICS
AGRICULTURAL GROWTH
AGRICULTURAL LAND
AGRICULTURAL PLOTS
AGRICULTURAL PRACTICE
AGRICULTURAL PRODUCTION
AGRICULTURAL SECTOR
AGRICULTURE
CHEMICAL FERTILIZER
CLASSIFICATION
CLIMATE
CLIMATE CHANGE
CLIMATIC CONDITIONS
COMPETITIVE LABOR MARKETS
CONSERVATION
CONSOLIDATION
CROP
CROP CHOICE
CROP MIX
CROP OUTPUT
CROP PRODUCTION
CROP TYPE
CROPS
DATA COLLECTION
DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS
DEVELOPMENT STRATEGIES
ECONOMETRIC EVIDENCE
ECONOMICS
EMPLOYMENT
EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES
EROSION
EXTENSION
FACTOR MARKETS
FAMILY LABOR
FARM
FARM EMPLOYMENT
FARM FAMILY
FARM HOUSEHOLD
FARM MANAGEMENT
FARM SIZE
FARMERS
FARMING
FARMS
FERTILIZER
FERTILIZER USE
FINANCIAL MARKETS
FIXED COSTS
FLOODING
GENDER
GROSS PROFIT
GROSS REVENUE
INCOME
INNOVATIONS
INSURANCE
INTEGRATION
LABOR DEMAND
LABOR MARKET
LABOR MARKETS
LABOUR
LABOUR SUPPLY
LAND REFORM
LAND RESOURCES
LAND USE
LAND VALUE
LAND YIELDS
MARKET WAGE
MARKET WAGES
NATURAL RESOURCES
NET PROFIT
OUTPUTS
PERFECT MARKETS
PESTICIDE USE
PESTS
PH
PLANTATION
PLOTS
POLITICAL ECONOMY
PRODUCTION PROCESS
PRODUCTIVITY
PROFITABILITY
PROPERTY RIGHTS
PUBLIC SERVICES
R&D
RANGES
RESOURCE ALLOCATION
RICE
RURAL DEVELOPMENT
RURAL LABOR
SAND
SKILLED LABOR
SOIL CONSERVATION
SOILS
TOPOGRAPHY
TRANSACTION COSTS
WAGE RATES
WAGES
WETLAND
WORKING CAPITAL
spellingShingle ADVERSE EFFECTS
AGRICULTURAL DEVELOPMENT
AGRICULTURAL ECONOMICS
AGRICULTURAL GROWTH
AGRICULTURAL LAND
AGRICULTURAL PLOTS
AGRICULTURAL PRACTICE
AGRICULTURAL PRODUCTION
AGRICULTURAL SECTOR
AGRICULTURE
CHEMICAL FERTILIZER
CLASSIFICATION
CLIMATE
CLIMATE CHANGE
CLIMATIC CONDITIONS
COMPETITIVE LABOR MARKETS
CONSERVATION
CONSOLIDATION
CROP
CROP CHOICE
CROP MIX
CROP OUTPUT
CROP PRODUCTION
CROP TYPE
CROPS
DATA COLLECTION
DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS
DEVELOPMENT STRATEGIES
ECONOMETRIC EVIDENCE
ECONOMICS
EMPLOYMENT
EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES
EROSION
EXTENSION
FACTOR MARKETS
FAMILY LABOR
FARM
FARM EMPLOYMENT
FARM FAMILY
FARM HOUSEHOLD
FARM MANAGEMENT
FARM SIZE
FARMERS
FARMING
FARMS
FERTILIZER
FERTILIZER USE
FINANCIAL MARKETS
FIXED COSTS
FLOODING
GENDER
GROSS PROFIT
GROSS REVENUE
INCOME
INNOVATIONS
INSURANCE
INTEGRATION
LABOR DEMAND
LABOR MARKET
LABOR MARKETS
LABOUR
LABOUR SUPPLY
LAND REFORM
LAND RESOURCES
LAND USE
LAND VALUE
LAND YIELDS
MARKET WAGE
MARKET WAGES
NATURAL RESOURCES
NET PROFIT
OUTPUTS
PERFECT MARKETS
PESTICIDE USE
PESTS
PH
PLANTATION
PLOTS
POLITICAL ECONOMY
PRODUCTION PROCESS
PRODUCTIVITY
PROFITABILITY
PROPERTY RIGHTS
PUBLIC SERVICES
R&D
RANGES
RESOURCE ALLOCATION
RICE
RURAL DEVELOPMENT
RURAL LABOR
SAND
SKILLED LABOR
SOIL CONSERVATION
SOILS
TOPOGRAPHY
TRANSACTION COSTS
WAGE RATES
WAGES
WETLAND
WORKING CAPITAL
ADVERSE EFFECTS
AGRICULTURAL DEVELOPMENT
AGRICULTURAL ECONOMICS
AGRICULTURAL GROWTH
AGRICULTURAL LAND
AGRICULTURAL PLOTS
AGRICULTURAL PRACTICE
AGRICULTURAL PRODUCTION
AGRICULTURAL SECTOR
AGRICULTURE
CHEMICAL FERTILIZER
CLASSIFICATION
CLIMATE
CLIMATE CHANGE
CLIMATIC CONDITIONS
COMPETITIVE LABOR MARKETS
CONSERVATION
CONSOLIDATION
CROP
CROP CHOICE
CROP MIX
CROP OUTPUT
CROP PRODUCTION
CROP TYPE
CROPS
DATA COLLECTION
DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS
DEVELOPMENT STRATEGIES
ECONOMETRIC EVIDENCE
ECONOMICS
EMPLOYMENT
EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES
EROSION
EXTENSION
FACTOR MARKETS
FAMILY LABOR
FARM
FARM EMPLOYMENT
FARM FAMILY
FARM HOUSEHOLD
FARM MANAGEMENT
FARM SIZE
FARMERS
FARMING
FARMS
FERTILIZER
FERTILIZER USE
FINANCIAL MARKETS
FIXED COSTS
FLOODING
GENDER
GROSS PROFIT
GROSS REVENUE
INCOME
INNOVATIONS
INSURANCE
INTEGRATION
LABOR DEMAND
LABOR MARKET
LABOR MARKETS
LABOUR
LABOUR SUPPLY
LAND REFORM
LAND RESOURCES
LAND USE
LAND VALUE
LAND YIELDS
MARKET WAGE
MARKET WAGES
NATURAL RESOURCES
NET PROFIT
OUTPUTS
PERFECT MARKETS
PESTICIDE USE
PESTS
PH
PLANTATION
PLOTS
POLITICAL ECONOMY
PRODUCTION PROCESS
PRODUCTIVITY
PROFITABILITY
PROPERTY RIGHTS
PUBLIC SERVICES
R&D
RANGES
RESOURCE ALLOCATION
RICE
RURAL DEVELOPMENT
RURAL LABOR
SAND
SKILLED LABOR
SOIL CONSERVATION
SOILS
TOPOGRAPHY
TRANSACTION COSTS
WAGE RATES
WAGES
WETLAND
WORKING CAPITAL
Ali, Daniel Ayalew
Deininger, Klaus
Is There a Farm-Size Productivity Relationship in African Agriculture? Evidence from Rwanda
description Whether the negative relationship between farm size and productivity that is confirmed in a large global literature holds in Africa is of considerable policy relevance. This paper revisits this issue and examines potential causes of the inverse productivity relationship in Rwanda, where policy makers consider land fragmentation and small farm sizes to be key bottlenecks for the growth of the agricultural sector. Nationwide plot-level data from Rwanda point toward a constant returns to scale crop production function and a strong negative relationship between farm size and output per hectare as well as intensity of labor use that is robust across specifications. The inverse relationship continues to hold if profits with family labor valued at shadow wages are used, but disappears if family labor is rather valued at village-level market wage rates. These findings imply that, in Rwanda, labor market imperfections, rather than other unobserved factors, seem to be a key reason for the inverse farm-size productivity relationship.
topic_facet ADVERSE EFFECTS
AGRICULTURAL DEVELOPMENT
AGRICULTURAL ECONOMICS
AGRICULTURAL GROWTH
AGRICULTURAL LAND
AGRICULTURAL PLOTS
AGRICULTURAL PRACTICE
AGRICULTURAL PRODUCTION
AGRICULTURAL SECTOR
AGRICULTURE
CHEMICAL FERTILIZER
CLASSIFICATION
CLIMATE
CLIMATE CHANGE
CLIMATIC CONDITIONS
COMPETITIVE LABOR MARKETS
CONSERVATION
CONSOLIDATION
CROP
CROP CHOICE
CROP MIX
CROP OUTPUT
CROP PRODUCTION
CROP TYPE
CROPS
DATA COLLECTION
DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS
DEVELOPMENT STRATEGIES
ECONOMETRIC EVIDENCE
ECONOMICS
EMPLOYMENT
EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES
EROSION
EXTENSION
FACTOR MARKETS
FAMILY LABOR
FARM
FARM EMPLOYMENT
FARM FAMILY
FARM HOUSEHOLD
FARM MANAGEMENT
FARM SIZE
FARMERS
FARMING
FARMS
FERTILIZER
FERTILIZER USE
FINANCIAL MARKETS
FIXED COSTS
FLOODING
GENDER
GROSS PROFIT
GROSS REVENUE
INCOME
INNOVATIONS
INSURANCE
INTEGRATION
LABOR DEMAND
LABOR MARKET
LABOR MARKETS
LABOUR
LABOUR SUPPLY
LAND REFORM
LAND RESOURCES
LAND USE
LAND VALUE
LAND YIELDS
MARKET WAGE
MARKET WAGES
NATURAL RESOURCES
NET PROFIT
OUTPUTS
PERFECT MARKETS
PESTICIDE USE
PESTS
PH
PLANTATION
PLOTS
POLITICAL ECONOMY
PRODUCTION PROCESS
PRODUCTIVITY
PROFITABILITY
PROPERTY RIGHTS
PUBLIC SERVICES
R&D
RANGES
RESOURCE ALLOCATION
RICE
RURAL DEVELOPMENT
RURAL LABOR
SAND
SKILLED LABOR
SOIL CONSERVATION
SOILS
TOPOGRAPHY
TRANSACTION COSTS
WAGE RATES
WAGES
WETLAND
WORKING CAPITAL
author Ali, Daniel Ayalew
Deininger, Klaus
author_facet Ali, Daniel Ayalew
Deininger, Klaus
author_sort Ali, Daniel Ayalew
title Is There a Farm-Size Productivity Relationship in African Agriculture? Evidence from Rwanda
title_short Is There a Farm-Size Productivity Relationship in African Agriculture? Evidence from Rwanda
title_full Is There a Farm-Size Productivity Relationship in African Agriculture? Evidence from Rwanda
title_fullStr Is There a Farm-Size Productivity Relationship in African Agriculture? Evidence from Rwanda
title_full_unstemmed Is There a Farm-Size Productivity Relationship in African Agriculture? Evidence from Rwanda
title_sort is there a farm-size productivity relationship in african agriculture? evidence from rwanda
publisher World Bank, Washington, DC
publishDate 2014-02
url http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2014/02/18910978/farm-size-productivity-relationship-african-griculture-evidence-rwanda
https://hdl.handle.net/10986/17304
work_keys_str_mv AT alidanielayalew isthereafarmsizeproductivityrelationshipinafricanagricultureevidencefromrwanda
AT deiningerklaus isthereafarmsizeproductivityrelationshipinafricanagricultureevidencefromrwanda
_version_ 1807155371756748800