Incentives and Teacher Effort : Further Evidence from a Developing Country

Few would contest that teachers are a very important determinant of whether students learn in school. Yet, in the face of compelling evidence that many students are not learning what they are expected to learn, how to improve teacher performance has been the focus of much policy debate in rich and poor countries. This paper examines how incentives, both pecuniary and non-pecuniary, influence teacher effort. Using school survey data from Lao PDR, it estimates new measures of teacher effort, including the number of hours that teachers spend preparing for classes and teacher provision of private tutoring classes outside class hours. The estimation results indicate that teachers increase effort in response to non-pecuniary incentives, such as greater teacher autonomy over teaching materials, and monitoring mechanism, such as the existence of an active parent-teacher association and the ability of school principals to dismiss teachers. Methodologically, the paper provides a detailed derivation of a simultaneous ordinary least squares-probit model with school random effects that can jointly estimate teacher work hours and tutoring provision.

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Dang, Hai-Anh H., King, Elizabeth M.
Format: Policy Research Working Paper biblioteca
Language:English
en_US
Published: World Bank, Washington, DC 2013-11
Subjects:ABSENTEEISM, ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE, ACHIEVEMENT TESTS, ARITHMETIC, AVERAGE NUMBER OF STUDENTS, BOOK RENTAL, CHILDREN, CLASS TEACHING, CLASSES, CLASSROOM, CLASSROOMS, COLLEGE, COLLEGE DEGREE, COLLEGE EDUCATION, COMMUNITY PARTICIPATION, COMMUNITY SCHOOL, CURRICULUM, DECENTRALIZATION, DECENTRALIZATION OF EDUCATION, DEGREES, DEVELOPING TEACHING MATERIALS, DISTRICT EDUCATION, ECONOMIC GROWTH, ECONOMICS OF EDUCATION, EDUCATION FOR ALL, EDUCATION LEVELS, EDUCATION OUTCOMES, EDUCATION REFORMS, EDUCATION SECTOR, EDUCATION STATISTICS, EDUCATION SYSTEM, EDUCATIONAL PLANNING, EDUCATORS, EFFECTIVE EDUCATION, EFFECTIVE TEACHERS, ETHICS, ETHNIC GROUPS, EXAMINATION, EXPENDITURES, FEMALE TEACHER, FEMALE TEACHERS, FUTURE RESEARCH, GRADING, HOMEWORK, HUMAN CAPITAL, HUMAN DEVELOPMENT, HUMAN RESOURCES, INDEXES, INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY, INSTRUCTION, INSTRUCTIONAL METHODS, INTERVENTIONS, ITS, KNOWLEDGE, LEARNING, LEARNING RESULTS, LET, LEVELS OF EDUCATION, LITERACY, LITERACY RATES, LITERATURE, LOWER SECONDARY, LOWER SECONDARY EDUCATION, MATH ACHIEVEMENT, MINISTRY OF EDUCATION, MULTIGRADE TEACHING, NATIONAL SCHOOL, NONGOVERNMENTAL ORGANIZATIONS, NUMBER OF STUDENTS, NUMBER OF TEACHERS, OPEN ACCESS, PAPERS, PARENT- TEACHER ASSOCIATIONS, PARENT-TEACHER ASSOCIATION, PARENTAL PARTICIPATION, POOR PEOPLE, PRIMARY EDUCATION, PRIMARY SCHOOL, PRIMARY SCHOOL TEACHERS, PRIMARY SCHOOLS, PRIMARY STUDENTS, PRIMARY TEACHERS, PRIVATE TUTORING, PUBLIC EXPENDITURE, PUBLIC SCHOOL, PUBLIC SCHOOL TEACHERS, PUPIL ATTENDANCE, PUPIL-TEACHER RATIOS, READING, REMEDIAL EDUCATION, RESEARCH, RESEARCH INSTITUTE, RESEARCHERS, RURAL AREAS, RURAL SCHOOLS, SCHOOL, SCHOOL _TEACHER, SCHOOL ACTIVITIES, SCHOOL CENSUS, SCHOOL CURRICULUM, SCHOOL FACILITIES, SCHOOL FEE, SCHOOL FEES, SCHOOL GOVERNANCE, SCHOOL HOURS, SCHOOL INFRASTRUCTURE, SCHOOL INSPECTORS, SCHOOL LEVEL, SCHOOL LOCATION, SCHOOL PRINCIPALS, SCHOOL PROGRAM, SCHOOL SURVEY, SCHOOL SURVEY DATA, SCHOOL SYSTEM, SCHOOL TEACHERS, SCHOOL VISITS, SCHOOL YEAR, SCHOOLING, SCHOOLS, SCIENCE, SECONDARY EDUCATION, SPORTS, STUDENT, STUDENT ACHIEVEMENT, STUDENT ATTENDANCE, STUDENT DEMAND, STUDENT LEARNING, STUDENT PERFORMANCE, STUDENT-TEACHER RATIO, STUDENTS, STUDIES, STUDY, TEACHER, TEACHER BEHAVIOR, TEACHER CHARACTERISTICS, TEACHER EVALUATION, TEACHER INCENTIVES, TEACHER PAY, TEACHER PERFORMANCE, TEACHER PROMOTION, TEACHER QUALITY, TEACHER RATIO, TEACHER SALARIES, TEACHERS, TEACHING, TEACHING EXPERIENCE, TEACHING MATERIALS, TEACHING METHOD, TEACHING METHODS, TEACHING TOOLS, TENURE, TEST SCORES, TESTING, TEXTBOOK, TEXTBOOKS, TUITION, TUITION FEES, TUTORS, UNIVERSITIES, UNIVERSITY, UPPER SECONDARY, UPPER SECONDARY EDUCATION, VALUES, VOCATIONAL EDUCATION, WOMEN, WORKERS,
Online Access:http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2013/11/18490965/incentives-teacher-effort-further-evidence-developing-country-incentives-teacher-effort-further-evidence-developing-country
http://hdl.handle.net/10986/16920
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
id dig-okr-1098616920
record_format koha
institution Banco Mundial
collection DSpace
country Estados Unidos
countrycode US
component Bibliográfico
access En linea
databasecode dig-okr
tag biblioteca
region America del Norte
libraryname Biblioteca del Banco Mundial
language English
en_US
topic ABSENTEEISM
ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE
ACHIEVEMENT TESTS
ARITHMETIC
AVERAGE NUMBER OF STUDENTS
BOOK RENTAL
CHILDREN
CLASS TEACHING
CLASSES
CLASSROOM
CLASSROOMS
COLLEGE
COLLEGE DEGREE
COLLEGE EDUCATION
COMMUNITY PARTICIPATION
COMMUNITY SCHOOL
CURRICULUM
DECENTRALIZATION
DECENTRALIZATION OF EDUCATION
DEGREES
DEVELOPING TEACHING MATERIALS
DISTRICT EDUCATION
ECONOMIC GROWTH
ECONOMICS OF EDUCATION
EDUCATION FOR ALL
EDUCATION LEVELS
EDUCATION OUTCOMES
EDUCATION REFORMS
EDUCATION SECTOR
EDUCATION STATISTICS
EDUCATION SYSTEM
EDUCATIONAL PLANNING
EDUCATORS
EFFECTIVE EDUCATION
EFFECTIVE TEACHERS
ETHICS
ETHNIC GROUPS
EXAMINATION
EXPENDITURES
FEMALE TEACHER
FEMALE TEACHERS
FUTURE RESEARCH
GRADING
HOMEWORK
HUMAN CAPITAL
HUMAN DEVELOPMENT
HUMAN RESOURCES
INDEXES
INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY
INSTRUCTION
INSTRUCTIONAL METHODS
INTERVENTIONS
ITS
KNOWLEDGE
LEARNING
LEARNING RESULTS
LET
LEVELS OF EDUCATION
LITERACY
LITERACY RATES
LITERATURE
LOWER SECONDARY
LOWER SECONDARY EDUCATION
MATH ACHIEVEMENT
MINISTRY OF EDUCATION
MULTIGRADE TEACHING
NATIONAL SCHOOL
NONGOVERNMENTAL ORGANIZATIONS
NUMBER OF STUDENTS
NUMBER OF TEACHERS
OPEN ACCESS
PAPERS
PARENT- TEACHER ASSOCIATIONS
PARENT-TEACHER ASSOCIATION
PARENTAL PARTICIPATION
POOR PEOPLE
PRIMARY EDUCATION
PRIMARY SCHOOL
PRIMARY SCHOOL TEACHERS
PRIMARY SCHOOLS
PRIMARY STUDENTS
PRIMARY TEACHERS
PRIVATE TUTORING
PUBLIC EXPENDITURE
PUBLIC SCHOOL
PUBLIC SCHOOL TEACHERS
PUPIL ATTENDANCE
PUPIL-TEACHER RATIOS
READING
REMEDIAL EDUCATION
RESEARCH
RESEARCH INSTITUTE
RESEARCHERS
RURAL AREAS
RURAL SCHOOLS
SCHOOL
SCHOOL _TEACHER
SCHOOL ACTIVITIES
SCHOOL CENSUS
SCHOOL CURRICULUM
SCHOOL FACILITIES
SCHOOL FEE
SCHOOL FEES
SCHOOL GOVERNANCE
SCHOOL HOURS
SCHOOL INFRASTRUCTURE
SCHOOL INSPECTORS
SCHOOL LEVEL
SCHOOL LOCATION
SCHOOL PRINCIPALS
SCHOOL PROGRAM
SCHOOL SURVEY
SCHOOL SURVEY DATA
SCHOOL SYSTEM
SCHOOL TEACHERS
SCHOOL VISITS
SCHOOL YEAR
SCHOOLING
SCHOOLS
SCIENCE
SECONDARY EDUCATION
SPORTS
STUDENT
STUDENT ACHIEVEMENT
STUDENT ATTENDANCE
STUDENT DEMAND
STUDENT LEARNING
STUDENT PERFORMANCE
STUDENT-TEACHER RATIO
STUDENTS
STUDIES
STUDY
TEACHER
TEACHER BEHAVIOR
TEACHER CHARACTERISTICS
TEACHER EVALUATION
TEACHER INCENTIVES
TEACHER PAY
TEACHER PERFORMANCE
TEACHER PROMOTION
TEACHER QUALITY
TEACHER RATIO
TEACHER SALARIES
TEACHERS
TEACHING
TEACHING EXPERIENCE
TEACHING MATERIALS
TEACHING METHOD
TEACHING METHODS
TEACHING TOOLS
TENURE
TEST SCORES
TESTING
TEXTBOOK
TEXTBOOKS
TUITION
TUITION FEES
TUTORS
UNIVERSITIES
UNIVERSITY
UPPER SECONDARY
UPPER SECONDARY EDUCATION
VALUES
VOCATIONAL EDUCATION
WOMEN
WORKERS
ABSENTEEISM
ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE
ACHIEVEMENT TESTS
ARITHMETIC
AVERAGE NUMBER OF STUDENTS
BOOK RENTAL
CHILDREN
CLASS TEACHING
CLASSES
CLASSROOM
CLASSROOMS
COLLEGE
COLLEGE DEGREE
COLLEGE EDUCATION
COMMUNITY PARTICIPATION
COMMUNITY SCHOOL
CURRICULUM
DECENTRALIZATION
DECENTRALIZATION OF EDUCATION
DEGREES
DEVELOPING TEACHING MATERIALS
DISTRICT EDUCATION
ECONOMIC GROWTH
ECONOMICS OF EDUCATION
EDUCATION FOR ALL
EDUCATION LEVELS
EDUCATION OUTCOMES
EDUCATION REFORMS
EDUCATION SECTOR
EDUCATION STATISTICS
EDUCATION SYSTEM
EDUCATIONAL PLANNING
EDUCATORS
EFFECTIVE EDUCATION
EFFECTIVE TEACHERS
ETHICS
ETHNIC GROUPS
EXAMINATION
EXPENDITURES
FEMALE TEACHER
FEMALE TEACHERS
FUTURE RESEARCH
GRADING
HOMEWORK
HUMAN CAPITAL
HUMAN DEVELOPMENT
HUMAN RESOURCES
INDEXES
INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY
INSTRUCTION
INSTRUCTIONAL METHODS
INTERVENTIONS
ITS
KNOWLEDGE
LEARNING
LEARNING RESULTS
LET
LEVELS OF EDUCATION
LITERACY
LITERACY RATES
LITERATURE
LOWER SECONDARY
LOWER SECONDARY EDUCATION
MATH ACHIEVEMENT
MINISTRY OF EDUCATION
MULTIGRADE TEACHING
NATIONAL SCHOOL
NONGOVERNMENTAL ORGANIZATIONS
NUMBER OF STUDENTS
NUMBER OF TEACHERS
OPEN ACCESS
PAPERS
PARENT- TEACHER ASSOCIATIONS
PARENT-TEACHER ASSOCIATION
PARENTAL PARTICIPATION
POOR PEOPLE
PRIMARY EDUCATION
PRIMARY SCHOOL
PRIMARY SCHOOL TEACHERS
PRIMARY SCHOOLS
PRIMARY STUDENTS
PRIMARY TEACHERS
PRIVATE TUTORING
PUBLIC EXPENDITURE
PUBLIC SCHOOL
PUBLIC SCHOOL TEACHERS
PUPIL ATTENDANCE
PUPIL-TEACHER RATIOS
READING
REMEDIAL EDUCATION
RESEARCH
RESEARCH INSTITUTE
RESEARCHERS
RURAL AREAS
RURAL SCHOOLS
SCHOOL
SCHOOL _TEACHER
SCHOOL ACTIVITIES
SCHOOL CENSUS
SCHOOL CURRICULUM
SCHOOL FACILITIES
SCHOOL FEE
SCHOOL FEES
SCHOOL GOVERNANCE
SCHOOL HOURS
SCHOOL INFRASTRUCTURE
SCHOOL INSPECTORS
SCHOOL LEVEL
SCHOOL LOCATION
SCHOOL PRINCIPALS
SCHOOL PROGRAM
SCHOOL SURVEY
SCHOOL SURVEY DATA
SCHOOL SYSTEM
SCHOOL TEACHERS
SCHOOL VISITS
SCHOOL YEAR
SCHOOLING
SCHOOLS
SCIENCE
SECONDARY EDUCATION
SPORTS
STUDENT
STUDENT ACHIEVEMENT
STUDENT ATTENDANCE
STUDENT DEMAND
STUDENT LEARNING
STUDENT PERFORMANCE
STUDENT-TEACHER RATIO
STUDENTS
STUDIES
STUDY
TEACHER
TEACHER BEHAVIOR
TEACHER CHARACTERISTICS
TEACHER EVALUATION
TEACHER INCENTIVES
TEACHER PAY
TEACHER PERFORMANCE
TEACHER PROMOTION
TEACHER QUALITY
TEACHER RATIO
TEACHER SALARIES
TEACHERS
TEACHING
TEACHING EXPERIENCE
TEACHING MATERIALS
TEACHING METHOD
TEACHING METHODS
TEACHING TOOLS
TENURE
TEST SCORES
TESTING
TEXTBOOK
TEXTBOOKS
TUITION
TUITION FEES
TUTORS
UNIVERSITIES
UNIVERSITY
UPPER SECONDARY
UPPER SECONDARY EDUCATION
VALUES
VOCATIONAL EDUCATION
WOMEN
WORKERS
spellingShingle ABSENTEEISM
ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE
ACHIEVEMENT TESTS
ARITHMETIC
AVERAGE NUMBER OF STUDENTS
BOOK RENTAL
CHILDREN
CLASS TEACHING
CLASSES
CLASSROOM
CLASSROOMS
COLLEGE
COLLEGE DEGREE
COLLEGE EDUCATION
COMMUNITY PARTICIPATION
COMMUNITY SCHOOL
CURRICULUM
DECENTRALIZATION
DECENTRALIZATION OF EDUCATION
DEGREES
DEVELOPING TEACHING MATERIALS
DISTRICT EDUCATION
ECONOMIC GROWTH
ECONOMICS OF EDUCATION
EDUCATION FOR ALL
EDUCATION LEVELS
EDUCATION OUTCOMES
EDUCATION REFORMS
EDUCATION SECTOR
EDUCATION STATISTICS
EDUCATION SYSTEM
EDUCATIONAL PLANNING
EDUCATORS
EFFECTIVE EDUCATION
EFFECTIVE TEACHERS
ETHICS
ETHNIC GROUPS
EXAMINATION
EXPENDITURES
FEMALE TEACHER
FEMALE TEACHERS
FUTURE RESEARCH
GRADING
HOMEWORK
HUMAN CAPITAL
HUMAN DEVELOPMENT
HUMAN RESOURCES
INDEXES
INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY
INSTRUCTION
INSTRUCTIONAL METHODS
INTERVENTIONS
ITS
KNOWLEDGE
LEARNING
LEARNING RESULTS
LET
LEVELS OF EDUCATION
LITERACY
LITERACY RATES
LITERATURE
LOWER SECONDARY
LOWER SECONDARY EDUCATION
MATH ACHIEVEMENT
MINISTRY OF EDUCATION
MULTIGRADE TEACHING
NATIONAL SCHOOL
NONGOVERNMENTAL ORGANIZATIONS
NUMBER OF STUDENTS
NUMBER OF TEACHERS
OPEN ACCESS
PAPERS
PARENT- TEACHER ASSOCIATIONS
PARENT-TEACHER ASSOCIATION
PARENTAL PARTICIPATION
POOR PEOPLE
PRIMARY EDUCATION
PRIMARY SCHOOL
PRIMARY SCHOOL TEACHERS
PRIMARY SCHOOLS
PRIMARY STUDENTS
PRIMARY TEACHERS
PRIVATE TUTORING
PUBLIC EXPENDITURE
PUBLIC SCHOOL
PUBLIC SCHOOL TEACHERS
PUPIL ATTENDANCE
PUPIL-TEACHER RATIOS
READING
REMEDIAL EDUCATION
RESEARCH
RESEARCH INSTITUTE
RESEARCHERS
RURAL AREAS
RURAL SCHOOLS
SCHOOL
SCHOOL _TEACHER
SCHOOL ACTIVITIES
SCHOOL CENSUS
SCHOOL CURRICULUM
SCHOOL FACILITIES
SCHOOL FEE
SCHOOL FEES
SCHOOL GOVERNANCE
SCHOOL HOURS
SCHOOL INFRASTRUCTURE
SCHOOL INSPECTORS
SCHOOL LEVEL
SCHOOL LOCATION
SCHOOL PRINCIPALS
SCHOOL PROGRAM
SCHOOL SURVEY
SCHOOL SURVEY DATA
SCHOOL SYSTEM
SCHOOL TEACHERS
SCHOOL VISITS
SCHOOL YEAR
SCHOOLING
SCHOOLS
SCIENCE
SECONDARY EDUCATION
SPORTS
STUDENT
STUDENT ACHIEVEMENT
STUDENT ATTENDANCE
STUDENT DEMAND
STUDENT LEARNING
STUDENT PERFORMANCE
STUDENT-TEACHER RATIO
STUDENTS
STUDIES
STUDY
TEACHER
TEACHER BEHAVIOR
TEACHER CHARACTERISTICS
TEACHER EVALUATION
TEACHER INCENTIVES
TEACHER PAY
TEACHER PERFORMANCE
TEACHER PROMOTION
TEACHER QUALITY
TEACHER RATIO
TEACHER SALARIES
TEACHERS
TEACHING
TEACHING EXPERIENCE
TEACHING MATERIALS
TEACHING METHOD
TEACHING METHODS
TEACHING TOOLS
TENURE
TEST SCORES
TESTING
TEXTBOOK
TEXTBOOKS
TUITION
TUITION FEES
TUTORS
UNIVERSITIES
UNIVERSITY
UPPER SECONDARY
UPPER SECONDARY EDUCATION
VALUES
VOCATIONAL EDUCATION
WOMEN
WORKERS
ABSENTEEISM
ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE
ACHIEVEMENT TESTS
ARITHMETIC
AVERAGE NUMBER OF STUDENTS
BOOK RENTAL
CHILDREN
CLASS TEACHING
CLASSES
CLASSROOM
CLASSROOMS
COLLEGE
COLLEGE DEGREE
COLLEGE EDUCATION
COMMUNITY PARTICIPATION
COMMUNITY SCHOOL
CURRICULUM
DECENTRALIZATION
DECENTRALIZATION OF EDUCATION
DEGREES
DEVELOPING TEACHING MATERIALS
DISTRICT EDUCATION
ECONOMIC GROWTH
ECONOMICS OF EDUCATION
EDUCATION FOR ALL
EDUCATION LEVELS
EDUCATION OUTCOMES
EDUCATION REFORMS
EDUCATION SECTOR
EDUCATION STATISTICS
EDUCATION SYSTEM
EDUCATIONAL PLANNING
EDUCATORS
EFFECTIVE EDUCATION
EFFECTIVE TEACHERS
ETHICS
ETHNIC GROUPS
EXAMINATION
EXPENDITURES
FEMALE TEACHER
FEMALE TEACHERS
FUTURE RESEARCH
GRADING
HOMEWORK
HUMAN CAPITAL
HUMAN DEVELOPMENT
HUMAN RESOURCES
INDEXES
INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY
INSTRUCTION
INSTRUCTIONAL METHODS
INTERVENTIONS
ITS
KNOWLEDGE
LEARNING
LEARNING RESULTS
LET
LEVELS OF EDUCATION
LITERACY
LITERACY RATES
LITERATURE
LOWER SECONDARY
LOWER SECONDARY EDUCATION
MATH ACHIEVEMENT
MINISTRY OF EDUCATION
MULTIGRADE TEACHING
NATIONAL SCHOOL
NONGOVERNMENTAL ORGANIZATIONS
NUMBER OF STUDENTS
NUMBER OF TEACHERS
OPEN ACCESS
PAPERS
PARENT- TEACHER ASSOCIATIONS
PARENT-TEACHER ASSOCIATION
PARENTAL PARTICIPATION
POOR PEOPLE
PRIMARY EDUCATION
PRIMARY SCHOOL
PRIMARY SCHOOL TEACHERS
PRIMARY SCHOOLS
PRIMARY STUDENTS
PRIMARY TEACHERS
PRIVATE TUTORING
PUBLIC EXPENDITURE
PUBLIC SCHOOL
PUBLIC SCHOOL TEACHERS
PUPIL ATTENDANCE
PUPIL-TEACHER RATIOS
READING
REMEDIAL EDUCATION
RESEARCH
RESEARCH INSTITUTE
RESEARCHERS
RURAL AREAS
RURAL SCHOOLS
SCHOOL
SCHOOL _TEACHER
SCHOOL ACTIVITIES
SCHOOL CENSUS
SCHOOL CURRICULUM
SCHOOL FACILITIES
SCHOOL FEE
SCHOOL FEES
SCHOOL GOVERNANCE
SCHOOL HOURS
SCHOOL INFRASTRUCTURE
SCHOOL INSPECTORS
SCHOOL LEVEL
SCHOOL LOCATION
SCHOOL PRINCIPALS
SCHOOL PROGRAM
SCHOOL SURVEY
SCHOOL SURVEY DATA
SCHOOL SYSTEM
SCHOOL TEACHERS
SCHOOL VISITS
SCHOOL YEAR
SCHOOLING
SCHOOLS
SCIENCE
SECONDARY EDUCATION
SPORTS
STUDENT
STUDENT ACHIEVEMENT
STUDENT ATTENDANCE
STUDENT DEMAND
STUDENT LEARNING
STUDENT PERFORMANCE
STUDENT-TEACHER RATIO
STUDENTS
STUDIES
STUDY
TEACHER
TEACHER BEHAVIOR
TEACHER CHARACTERISTICS
TEACHER EVALUATION
TEACHER INCENTIVES
TEACHER PAY
TEACHER PERFORMANCE
TEACHER PROMOTION
TEACHER QUALITY
TEACHER RATIO
TEACHER SALARIES
TEACHERS
TEACHING
TEACHING EXPERIENCE
TEACHING MATERIALS
TEACHING METHOD
TEACHING METHODS
TEACHING TOOLS
TENURE
TEST SCORES
TESTING
TEXTBOOK
TEXTBOOKS
TUITION
TUITION FEES
TUTORS
UNIVERSITIES
UNIVERSITY
UPPER SECONDARY
UPPER SECONDARY EDUCATION
VALUES
VOCATIONAL EDUCATION
WOMEN
WORKERS
Dang, Hai-Anh H.
King, Elizabeth M.
Incentives and Teacher Effort : Further Evidence from a Developing Country
description Few would contest that teachers are a very important determinant of whether students learn in school. Yet, in the face of compelling evidence that many students are not learning what they are expected to learn, how to improve teacher performance has been the focus of much policy debate in rich and poor countries. This paper examines how incentives, both pecuniary and non-pecuniary, influence teacher effort. Using school survey data from Lao PDR, it estimates new measures of teacher effort, including the number of hours that teachers spend preparing for classes and teacher provision of private tutoring classes outside class hours. The estimation results indicate that teachers increase effort in response to non-pecuniary incentives, such as greater teacher autonomy over teaching materials, and monitoring mechanism, such as the existence of an active parent-teacher association and the ability of school principals to dismiss teachers. Methodologically, the paper provides a detailed derivation of a simultaneous ordinary least squares-probit model with school random effects that can jointly estimate teacher work hours and tutoring provision.
format Publications & Research :: Policy Research Working Paper
topic_facet ABSENTEEISM
ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE
ACHIEVEMENT TESTS
ARITHMETIC
AVERAGE NUMBER OF STUDENTS
BOOK RENTAL
CHILDREN
CLASS TEACHING
CLASSES
CLASSROOM
CLASSROOMS
COLLEGE
COLLEGE DEGREE
COLLEGE EDUCATION
COMMUNITY PARTICIPATION
COMMUNITY SCHOOL
CURRICULUM
DECENTRALIZATION
DECENTRALIZATION OF EDUCATION
DEGREES
DEVELOPING TEACHING MATERIALS
DISTRICT EDUCATION
ECONOMIC GROWTH
ECONOMICS OF EDUCATION
EDUCATION FOR ALL
EDUCATION LEVELS
EDUCATION OUTCOMES
EDUCATION REFORMS
EDUCATION SECTOR
EDUCATION STATISTICS
EDUCATION SYSTEM
EDUCATIONAL PLANNING
EDUCATORS
EFFECTIVE EDUCATION
EFFECTIVE TEACHERS
ETHICS
ETHNIC GROUPS
EXAMINATION
EXPENDITURES
FEMALE TEACHER
FEMALE TEACHERS
FUTURE RESEARCH
GRADING
HOMEWORK
HUMAN CAPITAL
HUMAN DEVELOPMENT
HUMAN RESOURCES
INDEXES
INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY
INSTRUCTION
INSTRUCTIONAL METHODS
INTERVENTIONS
ITS
KNOWLEDGE
LEARNING
LEARNING RESULTS
LET
LEVELS OF EDUCATION
LITERACY
LITERACY RATES
LITERATURE
LOWER SECONDARY
LOWER SECONDARY EDUCATION
MATH ACHIEVEMENT
MINISTRY OF EDUCATION
MULTIGRADE TEACHING
NATIONAL SCHOOL
NONGOVERNMENTAL ORGANIZATIONS
NUMBER OF STUDENTS
NUMBER OF TEACHERS
OPEN ACCESS
PAPERS
PARENT- TEACHER ASSOCIATIONS
PARENT-TEACHER ASSOCIATION
PARENTAL PARTICIPATION
POOR PEOPLE
PRIMARY EDUCATION
PRIMARY SCHOOL
PRIMARY SCHOOL TEACHERS
PRIMARY SCHOOLS
PRIMARY STUDENTS
PRIMARY TEACHERS
PRIVATE TUTORING
PUBLIC EXPENDITURE
PUBLIC SCHOOL
PUBLIC SCHOOL TEACHERS
PUPIL ATTENDANCE
PUPIL-TEACHER RATIOS
READING
REMEDIAL EDUCATION
RESEARCH
RESEARCH INSTITUTE
RESEARCHERS
RURAL AREAS
RURAL SCHOOLS
SCHOOL
SCHOOL _TEACHER
SCHOOL ACTIVITIES
SCHOOL CENSUS
SCHOOL CURRICULUM
SCHOOL FACILITIES
SCHOOL FEE
SCHOOL FEES
SCHOOL GOVERNANCE
SCHOOL HOURS
SCHOOL INFRASTRUCTURE
SCHOOL INSPECTORS
SCHOOL LEVEL
SCHOOL LOCATION
SCHOOL PRINCIPALS
SCHOOL PROGRAM
SCHOOL SURVEY
SCHOOL SURVEY DATA
SCHOOL SYSTEM
SCHOOL TEACHERS
SCHOOL VISITS
SCHOOL YEAR
SCHOOLING
SCHOOLS
SCIENCE
SECONDARY EDUCATION
SPORTS
STUDENT
STUDENT ACHIEVEMENT
STUDENT ATTENDANCE
STUDENT DEMAND
STUDENT LEARNING
STUDENT PERFORMANCE
STUDENT-TEACHER RATIO
STUDENTS
STUDIES
STUDY
TEACHER
TEACHER BEHAVIOR
TEACHER CHARACTERISTICS
TEACHER EVALUATION
TEACHER INCENTIVES
TEACHER PAY
TEACHER PERFORMANCE
TEACHER PROMOTION
TEACHER QUALITY
TEACHER RATIO
TEACHER SALARIES
TEACHERS
TEACHING
TEACHING EXPERIENCE
TEACHING MATERIALS
TEACHING METHOD
TEACHING METHODS
TEACHING TOOLS
TENURE
TEST SCORES
TESTING
TEXTBOOK
TEXTBOOKS
TUITION
TUITION FEES
TUTORS
UNIVERSITIES
UNIVERSITY
UPPER SECONDARY
UPPER SECONDARY EDUCATION
VALUES
VOCATIONAL EDUCATION
WOMEN
WORKERS
author Dang, Hai-Anh H.
King, Elizabeth M.
author_facet Dang, Hai-Anh H.
King, Elizabeth M.
author_sort Dang, Hai-Anh H.
title Incentives and Teacher Effort : Further Evidence from a Developing Country
title_short Incentives and Teacher Effort : Further Evidence from a Developing Country
title_full Incentives and Teacher Effort : Further Evidence from a Developing Country
title_fullStr Incentives and Teacher Effort : Further Evidence from a Developing Country
title_full_unstemmed Incentives and Teacher Effort : Further Evidence from a Developing Country
title_sort incentives and teacher effort : further evidence from a developing country
publisher World Bank, Washington, DC
publishDate 2013-11
url http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2013/11/18490965/incentives-teacher-effort-further-evidence-developing-country-incentives-teacher-effort-further-evidence-developing-country
http://hdl.handle.net/10986/16920
work_keys_str_mv AT danghaianhh incentivesandteachereffortfurtherevidencefromadevelopingcountry
AT kingelizabethm incentivesandteachereffortfurtherevidencefromadevelopingcountry
_version_ 1756573264758439936
spelling dig-okr-10986169202021-04-23T14:03:33Z Incentives and Teacher Effort : Further Evidence from a Developing Country Dang, Hai-Anh H. King, Elizabeth M. ABSENTEEISM ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE ACHIEVEMENT TESTS ARITHMETIC AVERAGE NUMBER OF STUDENTS BOOK RENTAL CHILDREN CLASS TEACHING CLASSES CLASSROOM CLASSROOMS COLLEGE COLLEGE DEGREE COLLEGE EDUCATION COMMUNITY PARTICIPATION COMMUNITY SCHOOL CURRICULUM DECENTRALIZATION DECENTRALIZATION OF EDUCATION DEGREES DEVELOPING TEACHING MATERIALS DISTRICT EDUCATION ECONOMIC GROWTH ECONOMICS OF EDUCATION EDUCATION FOR ALL EDUCATION LEVELS EDUCATION OUTCOMES EDUCATION REFORMS EDUCATION SECTOR EDUCATION STATISTICS EDUCATION SYSTEM EDUCATIONAL PLANNING EDUCATORS EFFECTIVE EDUCATION EFFECTIVE TEACHERS ETHICS ETHNIC GROUPS EXAMINATION EXPENDITURES FEMALE TEACHER FEMALE TEACHERS FUTURE RESEARCH GRADING HOMEWORK HUMAN CAPITAL HUMAN DEVELOPMENT HUMAN RESOURCES INDEXES INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY INSTRUCTION INSTRUCTIONAL METHODS INTERVENTIONS ITS KNOWLEDGE LEARNING LEARNING RESULTS LET LEVELS OF EDUCATION LITERACY LITERACY RATES LITERATURE LOWER SECONDARY LOWER SECONDARY EDUCATION MATH ACHIEVEMENT MINISTRY OF EDUCATION MULTIGRADE TEACHING NATIONAL SCHOOL NONGOVERNMENTAL ORGANIZATIONS NUMBER OF STUDENTS NUMBER OF TEACHERS OPEN ACCESS PAPERS PARENT- TEACHER ASSOCIATIONS PARENT-TEACHER ASSOCIATION PARENTAL PARTICIPATION POOR PEOPLE PRIMARY EDUCATION PRIMARY SCHOOL PRIMARY SCHOOL TEACHERS PRIMARY SCHOOLS PRIMARY STUDENTS PRIMARY TEACHERS PRIVATE TUTORING PUBLIC EXPENDITURE PUBLIC SCHOOL PUBLIC SCHOOL TEACHERS PUPIL ATTENDANCE PUPIL-TEACHER RATIOS READING REMEDIAL EDUCATION RESEARCH RESEARCH INSTITUTE RESEARCHERS RURAL AREAS RURAL SCHOOLS SCHOOL SCHOOL _TEACHER SCHOOL ACTIVITIES SCHOOL CENSUS SCHOOL CURRICULUM SCHOOL FACILITIES SCHOOL FEE SCHOOL FEES SCHOOL GOVERNANCE SCHOOL HOURS SCHOOL INFRASTRUCTURE SCHOOL INSPECTORS SCHOOL LEVEL SCHOOL LOCATION SCHOOL PRINCIPALS SCHOOL PROGRAM SCHOOL SURVEY SCHOOL SURVEY DATA SCHOOL SYSTEM SCHOOL TEACHERS SCHOOL VISITS SCHOOL YEAR SCHOOLING SCHOOLS SCIENCE SECONDARY EDUCATION SPORTS STUDENT STUDENT ACHIEVEMENT STUDENT ATTENDANCE STUDENT DEMAND STUDENT LEARNING STUDENT PERFORMANCE STUDENT-TEACHER RATIO STUDENTS STUDIES STUDY TEACHER TEACHER BEHAVIOR TEACHER CHARACTERISTICS TEACHER EVALUATION TEACHER INCENTIVES TEACHER PAY TEACHER PERFORMANCE TEACHER PROMOTION TEACHER QUALITY TEACHER RATIO TEACHER SALARIES TEACHERS TEACHING TEACHING EXPERIENCE TEACHING MATERIALS TEACHING METHOD TEACHING METHODS TEACHING TOOLS TENURE TEST SCORES TESTING TEXTBOOK TEXTBOOKS TUITION TUITION FEES TUTORS UNIVERSITIES UNIVERSITY UPPER SECONDARY UPPER SECONDARY EDUCATION VALUES VOCATIONAL EDUCATION WOMEN WORKERS Few would contest that teachers are a very important determinant of whether students learn in school. Yet, in the face of compelling evidence that many students are not learning what they are expected to learn, how to improve teacher performance has been the focus of much policy debate in rich and poor countries. This paper examines how incentives, both pecuniary and non-pecuniary, influence teacher effort. Using school survey data from Lao PDR, it estimates new measures of teacher effort, including the number of hours that teachers spend preparing for classes and teacher provision of private tutoring classes outside class hours. The estimation results indicate that teachers increase effort in response to non-pecuniary incentives, such as greater teacher autonomy over teaching materials, and monitoring mechanism, such as the existence of an active parent-teacher association and the ability of school principals to dismiss teachers. Methodologically, the paper provides a detailed derivation of a simultaneous ordinary least squares-probit model with school random effects that can jointly estimate teacher work hours and tutoring provision. 2014-02-05T15:03:05Z 2014-02-05T15:03:05Z 2013-11 http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2013/11/18490965/incentives-teacher-effort-further-evidence-developing-country-incentives-teacher-effort-further-evidence-developing-country http://hdl.handle.net/10986/16920 English en_US Policy Research Working Paper;No. 6694 CC BY 3.0 IGO http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/igo/ World Bank World Bank, Washington, DC Publications & Research :: Policy Research Working Paper Publications & Research East Asia and Pacific Lao People's Democratic Republic