Entrepreneurship Programs in Developing Countries : A Meta Regression Analysis

This paper provides a synthetic and systematic review on the effectiveness of various entrepreneurship programs in developing countries. It adopts a meta-regression analysis using 37 impact evaluation studies that were in the public domain by March 2012, and draws out several lessons on the design of the programs. The paper observes wide variation in program effectiveness across different interventions depending on outcomes, types of beneficiaries, and country context. Overall, entrepreneurship programs have a positive and large impact for youth and on business knowledge and practice, but no immediate translation into business set-up and expansion or increased income. At a disaggregate level by outcome groups, providing a package of training and financing is more effective for labor activities. In addition, financing support appears more effective for women and business training for existing entrepreneurs than other interventions to improve business performance.

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Cho, Yoonyoung, Honorati, Maddalena
Format: Policy Research Working Paper biblioteca
Language:English
en_US
Published: World Bank, Washington, DC 2013-04
Subjects:ACCESS TO BANK ACCOUNT, ACCESS TO CREDIT, ACCESS TO FINANCE, ACCESS TO LOANS, ACCESS TO SAVING, ACCESS TO SAVINGS, ACCOUNTING, ACTIVE LABOR MARKET PROGRAMS, ACTIVE LABOUR MARKET, ACTUARIES, ADVISORY SERVICES, ASSISTANCE TO BUSINESS, BANK ACCOUNT, BANKS, BASIC SKILLS, BEHAVIORAL SCIENCES, BENEFICIARIES, BENEFICIARY, BORROWING, BUSINESS ACTIVITIES, BUSINESS CONFIDENCE, BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT, BUSINESS INCUBATION, BUSINESS LOANS, BUSINESS MANAGEMENT, BUSINESS NETWORKS, BUSINESS OPERATION, BUSINESS OWNERS, BUSINESS SCHOOL, BUSINESS SURVIVAL, BUSINESS TRAINING, CASH TRANSFER, COGNITIVE SKILLS, COLLECTIVE ACTION, CONSUMER, CONSUMER LOANS, CONTRIBUTION, CONTROL GROUPS, CREDIT ACCESS, CREDIT CONSTRAINTS, CREDIT SCORING, CULTURAL FACTORS, CULTURAL NORM, CUSTOMER RELATIONS, DATA COLLECTION, DEBT, DECISION MAKING, DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS, DISCOUNT RATE, DISCRIMINATION, DIVERSIFICATION, EARNINGS, ECONOMIC ANALYSIS, ECONOMIC GROWTH, ECONOMICS, ELECTRICIANS, EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES, EMPLOYMENT PROGRAMS, EMPLOYMENT STATUS, EMPOWERMENT, ENTREPRENEURIAL ACTIVITIES, ENTREPRENEURIAL ACTIVITY, ENTREPRENEURIAL BEHAVIOR, ENTREPRENEURSHIP TRAINING, EQUIPMENT LOAN, EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN, FAMILIES, FARMERS, FEMALE ENTERPRISE, FEMALE ENTERPRISES, FEMALE ENTREPRENEURS, FEMALE ENTREPRENEURSHIP, FEMALE WORKERS, FINANCIAL BEHAVIOR, FINANCIAL CAPITAL, FINANCIAL LITERACY, FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT, FINANCIAL MARKET, FINANCIAL PRODUCTS, FINANCIAL SERVICES, FINANCIAL SKILLS, FINANCIAL STUDIES, FINANCIAL SUPPORT, FINANCIAL TRAINING, GENDER, GENDER DISPARITY, GENDER ROLES, GENERAL POPULATION, GIRLS, GROUP LENDING, HEALTH INSURANCE, HOUSEHOLD INCOME, HOUSEHOLDS, HUMAN DEVELOPMENT, ID, IMPACT EVALUATION, IMPACT EVALUATION DESIGN, INCOME, INCOME GROUPS, INCOME LEVELS, INCOMES, INNOVATION, INSURANCE, INSURANCE SCHEME, INTERNATIONAL BANK, INTERVENTIONS, INVENTORY, JOB CREATION, JOB SEARCH, JOB TRAINING, KNOWLEDGE GAP, LABOR ECONOMICS, LABOR INCOME, LABOR MARKET, LABOR MARKETS, LABOR POLICIES, LABOR RELATIONS, LABOUR, LABOUR MARKET POLICY, LARGE FIRM, LEARNING, LIABILITY, LIFE SKILLS, LOAN, LOAN REPAYMENT, LOW INCOME, LOW-INCOME, MARKET ANALYSIS, MARKETING, MFI, MFIS, MICRO ENTERPRISE, MICRO ENTERPRISE DEVELOPMENT, MICRO-CREDIT, MICRO-ENTREPRENEURS, MICROCREDIT, MICROFINANCE, MORTALITY, MOTIVATION, NEW BUSINESS, OCCUPATIONS, OUTCOME INDICATORS, PERSONALITY, POLICY ENVIRONMENT, POLITICAL ECONOMY, PROBABILITY, PRODUCTIVITY, PROGRAM EFFECTIVENESS, PROGRAM IMPACTS, RECORD KEEPING, REGRESSION ANALYSIS, REPAYMENT, RESOURCE ALLOCATION, RISKY BEHAVIOR, RURAL AREAS, SALARY, SALES, SAVING BEHAVIOR, SAVINGS, SAVINGS ACCOUNTS, SCHOOL FINANCE, SELF EMPLOYED, SELF EMPLOYMENT, SELF HELP, SELF-EMPLOYMENT, SERVICE PROVIDERS, SKILLS TRAINING, SMALL BUSINESS, SMALL BUSINESSES, SMALL ENTERPRISES, SMALL-SCALE ENTREPRENEURS, SMART MONEY, SOCIAL ASSISTANCE, SOCIAL PROTECTION, SOCIAL SERVICES, START-UP, STOCKS, TARGETING, TEACHING, TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE, TECHNICAL SKILLS, TRAINING FOR ENTREPRENEURS, TRAINING PROGRAM, TRAINING PROGRAMS, UNEMPLOYED, UNEMPLOYMENT, UNION, URBAN AREAS, URBAN POPULATION, VALUABLE, VOCATIONAL EDUCATION, VOCATIONAL TRAINING, WAGE, WAGE GAP, WAGE GAPS, WAGE SUBSIDIES, WELL-BEING, WORTH, YOUTH,
Online Access:http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2013/04/17549708/entrepreneurship-programs-developing-countries-meta-regression-analysis
http://hdl.handle.net/10986/13199
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
id dig-okr-1098613199
record_format koha
institution Banco Mundial
collection DSpace
country Estados Unidos
countrycode US
component Bibliográfico
access En linea
databasecode dig-okr
tag biblioteca
region America del Norte
libraryname Biblioteca del Banco Mundial
language English
en_US
topic ACCESS TO BANK ACCOUNT
ACCESS TO CREDIT
ACCESS TO FINANCE
ACCESS TO LOANS
ACCESS TO SAVING
ACCESS TO SAVINGS
ACCOUNTING
ACTIVE LABOR MARKET PROGRAMS
ACTIVE LABOUR MARKET
ACTUARIES
ADVISORY SERVICES
ASSISTANCE TO BUSINESS
BANK ACCOUNT
BANKS
BASIC SKILLS
BEHAVIORAL SCIENCES
BENEFICIARIES
BENEFICIARY
BORROWING
BUSINESS ACTIVITIES
BUSINESS CONFIDENCE
BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT
BUSINESS INCUBATION
BUSINESS LOANS
BUSINESS MANAGEMENT
BUSINESS NETWORKS
BUSINESS OPERATION
BUSINESS OWNERS
BUSINESS SCHOOL
BUSINESS SURVIVAL
BUSINESS TRAINING
CASH TRANSFER
COGNITIVE SKILLS
COLLECTIVE ACTION
CONSUMER
CONSUMER LOANS
CONTRIBUTION
CONTROL GROUPS
CREDIT ACCESS
CREDIT CONSTRAINTS
CREDIT SCORING
CULTURAL FACTORS
CULTURAL NORM
CUSTOMER RELATIONS
DATA COLLECTION
DEBT
DECISION MAKING
DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS
DISCOUNT RATE
DISCRIMINATION
DIVERSIFICATION
EARNINGS
ECONOMIC ANALYSIS
ECONOMIC GROWTH
ECONOMICS
ELECTRICIANS
EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES
EMPLOYMENT PROGRAMS
EMPLOYMENT STATUS
EMPOWERMENT
ENTREPRENEURIAL ACTIVITIES
ENTREPRENEURIAL ACTIVITY
ENTREPRENEURIAL BEHAVIOR
ENTREPRENEURSHIP TRAINING
EQUIPMENT LOAN
EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN
FAMILIES
FARMERS
FEMALE ENTERPRISE
FEMALE ENTERPRISES
FEMALE ENTREPRENEURS
FEMALE ENTREPRENEURSHIP
FEMALE WORKERS
FINANCIAL BEHAVIOR
FINANCIAL CAPITAL
FINANCIAL LITERACY
FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT
FINANCIAL MARKET
FINANCIAL PRODUCTS
FINANCIAL SERVICES
FINANCIAL SKILLS
FINANCIAL STUDIES
FINANCIAL SUPPORT
FINANCIAL TRAINING
GENDER
GENDER DISPARITY
GENDER ROLES
GENERAL POPULATION
GIRLS
GROUP LENDING
HEALTH INSURANCE
HOUSEHOLD INCOME
HOUSEHOLDS
HUMAN DEVELOPMENT
ID
IMPACT EVALUATION
IMPACT EVALUATION DESIGN
INCOME
INCOME GROUPS
INCOME LEVELS
INCOMES
INNOVATION
INSURANCE
INSURANCE SCHEME
INTERNATIONAL BANK
INTERVENTIONS
INVENTORY
JOB CREATION
JOB SEARCH
JOB TRAINING
KNOWLEDGE GAP
LABOR ECONOMICS
LABOR INCOME
LABOR MARKET
LABOR MARKETS
LABOR POLICIES
LABOR RELATIONS
LABOUR
LABOUR MARKET POLICY
LARGE FIRM
LEARNING
LIABILITY
LIFE SKILLS
LOAN
LOAN REPAYMENT
LOW INCOME
LOW-INCOME
MARKET ANALYSIS
MARKETING
MFI
MFIS
MICRO ENTERPRISE
MICRO ENTERPRISE DEVELOPMENT
MICRO-CREDIT
MICRO-ENTREPRENEURS
MICROCREDIT
MICROFINANCE
MORTALITY
MOTIVATION
NEW BUSINESS
OCCUPATIONS
OUTCOME INDICATORS
PERSONALITY
POLICY ENVIRONMENT
POLITICAL ECONOMY
PROBABILITY
PRODUCTIVITY
PROGRAM EFFECTIVENESS
PROGRAM IMPACTS
RECORD KEEPING
REGRESSION ANALYSIS
REPAYMENT
RESOURCE ALLOCATION
RISKY BEHAVIOR
RURAL AREAS
SALARY
SALES
SAVING BEHAVIOR
SAVINGS
SAVINGS ACCOUNTS
SCHOOL FINANCE
SELF EMPLOYED
SELF EMPLOYMENT
SELF HELP
SELF-EMPLOYMENT
SERVICE PROVIDERS
SKILLS TRAINING
SMALL BUSINESS
SMALL BUSINESSES
SMALL ENTERPRISES
SMALL-SCALE ENTREPRENEURS
SMART MONEY
SOCIAL ASSISTANCE
SOCIAL PROTECTION
SOCIAL SERVICES
START-UP
STOCKS
TARGETING
TEACHING
TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE
TECHNICAL SKILLS
TRAINING FOR ENTREPRENEURS
TRAINING PROGRAM
TRAINING PROGRAMS
UNEMPLOYED
UNEMPLOYMENT
UNION
URBAN AREAS
URBAN POPULATION
VALUABLE
VOCATIONAL EDUCATION
VOCATIONAL TRAINING
WAGE
WAGE GAP
WAGE GAPS
WAGE SUBSIDIES
WELL-BEING
WORTH
YOUTH
ACCESS TO BANK ACCOUNT
ACCESS TO CREDIT
ACCESS TO FINANCE
ACCESS TO LOANS
ACCESS TO SAVING
ACCESS TO SAVINGS
ACCOUNTING
ACTIVE LABOR MARKET PROGRAMS
ACTIVE LABOUR MARKET
ACTUARIES
ADVISORY SERVICES
ASSISTANCE TO BUSINESS
BANK ACCOUNT
BANKS
BASIC SKILLS
BEHAVIORAL SCIENCES
BENEFICIARIES
BENEFICIARY
BORROWING
BUSINESS ACTIVITIES
BUSINESS CONFIDENCE
BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT
BUSINESS INCUBATION
BUSINESS LOANS
BUSINESS MANAGEMENT
BUSINESS NETWORKS
BUSINESS OPERATION
BUSINESS OWNERS
BUSINESS SCHOOL
BUSINESS SURVIVAL
BUSINESS TRAINING
CASH TRANSFER
COGNITIVE SKILLS
COLLECTIVE ACTION
CONSUMER
CONSUMER LOANS
CONTRIBUTION
CONTROL GROUPS
CREDIT ACCESS
CREDIT CONSTRAINTS
CREDIT SCORING
CULTURAL FACTORS
CULTURAL NORM
CUSTOMER RELATIONS
DATA COLLECTION
DEBT
DECISION MAKING
DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS
DISCOUNT RATE
DISCRIMINATION
DIVERSIFICATION
EARNINGS
ECONOMIC ANALYSIS
ECONOMIC GROWTH
ECONOMICS
ELECTRICIANS
EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES
EMPLOYMENT PROGRAMS
EMPLOYMENT STATUS
EMPOWERMENT
ENTREPRENEURIAL ACTIVITIES
ENTREPRENEURIAL ACTIVITY
ENTREPRENEURIAL BEHAVIOR
ENTREPRENEURSHIP TRAINING
EQUIPMENT LOAN
EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN
FAMILIES
FARMERS
FEMALE ENTERPRISE
FEMALE ENTERPRISES
FEMALE ENTREPRENEURS
FEMALE ENTREPRENEURSHIP
FEMALE WORKERS
FINANCIAL BEHAVIOR
FINANCIAL CAPITAL
FINANCIAL LITERACY
FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT
FINANCIAL MARKET
FINANCIAL PRODUCTS
FINANCIAL SERVICES
FINANCIAL SKILLS
FINANCIAL STUDIES
FINANCIAL SUPPORT
FINANCIAL TRAINING
GENDER
GENDER DISPARITY
GENDER ROLES
GENERAL POPULATION
GIRLS
GROUP LENDING
HEALTH INSURANCE
HOUSEHOLD INCOME
HOUSEHOLDS
HUMAN DEVELOPMENT
ID
IMPACT EVALUATION
IMPACT EVALUATION DESIGN
INCOME
INCOME GROUPS
INCOME LEVELS
INCOMES
INNOVATION
INSURANCE
INSURANCE SCHEME
INTERNATIONAL BANK
INTERVENTIONS
INVENTORY
JOB CREATION
JOB SEARCH
JOB TRAINING
KNOWLEDGE GAP
LABOR ECONOMICS
LABOR INCOME
LABOR MARKET
LABOR MARKETS
LABOR POLICIES
LABOR RELATIONS
LABOUR
LABOUR MARKET POLICY
LARGE FIRM
LEARNING
LIABILITY
LIFE SKILLS
LOAN
LOAN REPAYMENT
LOW INCOME
LOW-INCOME
MARKET ANALYSIS
MARKETING
MFI
MFIS
MICRO ENTERPRISE
MICRO ENTERPRISE DEVELOPMENT
MICRO-CREDIT
MICRO-ENTREPRENEURS
MICROCREDIT
MICROFINANCE
MORTALITY
MOTIVATION
NEW BUSINESS
OCCUPATIONS
OUTCOME INDICATORS
PERSONALITY
POLICY ENVIRONMENT
POLITICAL ECONOMY
PROBABILITY
PRODUCTIVITY
PROGRAM EFFECTIVENESS
PROGRAM IMPACTS
RECORD KEEPING
REGRESSION ANALYSIS
REPAYMENT
RESOURCE ALLOCATION
RISKY BEHAVIOR
RURAL AREAS
SALARY
SALES
SAVING BEHAVIOR
SAVINGS
SAVINGS ACCOUNTS
SCHOOL FINANCE
SELF EMPLOYED
SELF EMPLOYMENT
SELF HELP
SELF-EMPLOYMENT
SERVICE PROVIDERS
SKILLS TRAINING
SMALL BUSINESS
SMALL BUSINESSES
SMALL ENTERPRISES
SMALL-SCALE ENTREPRENEURS
SMART MONEY
SOCIAL ASSISTANCE
SOCIAL PROTECTION
SOCIAL SERVICES
START-UP
STOCKS
TARGETING
TEACHING
TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE
TECHNICAL SKILLS
TRAINING FOR ENTREPRENEURS
TRAINING PROGRAM
TRAINING PROGRAMS
UNEMPLOYED
UNEMPLOYMENT
UNION
URBAN AREAS
URBAN POPULATION
VALUABLE
VOCATIONAL EDUCATION
VOCATIONAL TRAINING
WAGE
WAGE GAP
WAGE GAPS
WAGE SUBSIDIES
WELL-BEING
WORTH
YOUTH
spellingShingle ACCESS TO BANK ACCOUNT
ACCESS TO CREDIT
ACCESS TO FINANCE
ACCESS TO LOANS
ACCESS TO SAVING
ACCESS TO SAVINGS
ACCOUNTING
ACTIVE LABOR MARKET PROGRAMS
ACTIVE LABOUR MARKET
ACTUARIES
ADVISORY SERVICES
ASSISTANCE TO BUSINESS
BANK ACCOUNT
BANKS
BASIC SKILLS
BEHAVIORAL SCIENCES
BENEFICIARIES
BENEFICIARY
BORROWING
BUSINESS ACTIVITIES
BUSINESS CONFIDENCE
BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT
BUSINESS INCUBATION
BUSINESS LOANS
BUSINESS MANAGEMENT
BUSINESS NETWORKS
BUSINESS OPERATION
BUSINESS OWNERS
BUSINESS SCHOOL
BUSINESS SURVIVAL
BUSINESS TRAINING
CASH TRANSFER
COGNITIVE SKILLS
COLLECTIVE ACTION
CONSUMER
CONSUMER LOANS
CONTRIBUTION
CONTROL GROUPS
CREDIT ACCESS
CREDIT CONSTRAINTS
CREDIT SCORING
CULTURAL FACTORS
CULTURAL NORM
CUSTOMER RELATIONS
DATA COLLECTION
DEBT
DECISION MAKING
DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS
DISCOUNT RATE
DISCRIMINATION
DIVERSIFICATION
EARNINGS
ECONOMIC ANALYSIS
ECONOMIC GROWTH
ECONOMICS
ELECTRICIANS
EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES
EMPLOYMENT PROGRAMS
EMPLOYMENT STATUS
EMPOWERMENT
ENTREPRENEURIAL ACTIVITIES
ENTREPRENEURIAL ACTIVITY
ENTREPRENEURIAL BEHAVIOR
ENTREPRENEURSHIP TRAINING
EQUIPMENT LOAN
EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN
FAMILIES
FARMERS
FEMALE ENTERPRISE
FEMALE ENTERPRISES
FEMALE ENTREPRENEURS
FEMALE ENTREPRENEURSHIP
FEMALE WORKERS
FINANCIAL BEHAVIOR
FINANCIAL CAPITAL
FINANCIAL LITERACY
FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT
FINANCIAL MARKET
FINANCIAL PRODUCTS
FINANCIAL SERVICES
FINANCIAL SKILLS
FINANCIAL STUDIES
FINANCIAL SUPPORT
FINANCIAL TRAINING
GENDER
GENDER DISPARITY
GENDER ROLES
GENERAL POPULATION
GIRLS
GROUP LENDING
HEALTH INSURANCE
HOUSEHOLD INCOME
HOUSEHOLDS
HUMAN DEVELOPMENT
ID
IMPACT EVALUATION
IMPACT EVALUATION DESIGN
INCOME
INCOME GROUPS
INCOME LEVELS
INCOMES
INNOVATION
INSURANCE
INSURANCE SCHEME
INTERNATIONAL BANK
INTERVENTIONS
INVENTORY
JOB CREATION
JOB SEARCH
JOB TRAINING
KNOWLEDGE GAP
LABOR ECONOMICS
LABOR INCOME
LABOR MARKET
LABOR MARKETS
LABOR POLICIES
LABOR RELATIONS
LABOUR
LABOUR MARKET POLICY
LARGE FIRM
LEARNING
LIABILITY
LIFE SKILLS
LOAN
LOAN REPAYMENT
LOW INCOME
LOW-INCOME
MARKET ANALYSIS
MARKETING
MFI
MFIS
MICRO ENTERPRISE
MICRO ENTERPRISE DEVELOPMENT
MICRO-CREDIT
MICRO-ENTREPRENEURS
MICROCREDIT
MICROFINANCE
MORTALITY
MOTIVATION
NEW BUSINESS
OCCUPATIONS
OUTCOME INDICATORS
PERSONALITY
POLICY ENVIRONMENT
POLITICAL ECONOMY
PROBABILITY
PRODUCTIVITY
PROGRAM EFFECTIVENESS
PROGRAM IMPACTS
RECORD KEEPING
REGRESSION ANALYSIS
REPAYMENT
RESOURCE ALLOCATION
RISKY BEHAVIOR
RURAL AREAS
SALARY
SALES
SAVING BEHAVIOR
SAVINGS
SAVINGS ACCOUNTS
SCHOOL FINANCE
SELF EMPLOYED
SELF EMPLOYMENT
SELF HELP
SELF-EMPLOYMENT
SERVICE PROVIDERS
SKILLS TRAINING
SMALL BUSINESS
SMALL BUSINESSES
SMALL ENTERPRISES
SMALL-SCALE ENTREPRENEURS
SMART MONEY
SOCIAL ASSISTANCE
SOCIAL PROTECTION
SOCIAL SERVICES
START-UP
STOCKS
TARGETING
TEACHING
TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE
TECHNICAL SKILLS
TRAINING FOR ENTREPRENEURS
TRAINING PROGRAM
TRAINING PROGRAMS
UNEMPLOYED
UNEMPLOYMENT
UNION
URBAN AREAS
URBAN POPULATION
VALUABLE
VOCATIONAL EDUCATION
VOCATIONAL TRAINING
WAGE
WAGE GAP
WAGE GAPS
WAGE SUBSIDIES
WELL-BEING
WORTH
YOUTH
ACCESS TO BANK ACCOUNT
ACCESS TO CREDIT
ACCESS TO FINANCE
ACCESS TO LOANS
ACCESS TO SAVING
ACCESS TO SAVINGS
ACCOUNTING
ACTIVE LABOR MARKET PROGRAMS
ACTIVE LABOUR MARKET
ACTUARIES
ADVISORY SERVICES
ASSISTANCE TO BUSINESS
BANK ACCOUNT
BANKS
BASIC SKILLS
BEHAVIORAL SCIENCES
BENEFICIARIES
BENEFICIARY
BORROWING
BUSINESS ACTIVITIES
BUSINESS CONFIDENCE
BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT
BUSINESS INCUBATION
BUSINESS LOANS
BUSINESS MANAGEMENT
BUSINESS NETWORKS
BUSINESS OPERATION
BUSINESS OWNERS
BUSINESS SCHOOL
BUSINESS SURVIVAL
BUSINESS TRAINING
CASH TRANSFER
COGNITIVE SKILLS
COLLECTIVE ACTION
CONSUMER
CONSUMER LOANS
CONTRIBUTION
CONTROL GROUPS
CREDIT ACCESS
CREDIT CONSTRAINTS
CREDIT SCORING
CULTURAL FACTORS
CULTURAL NORM
CUSTOMER RELATIONS
DATA COLLECTION
DEBT
DECISION MAKING
DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS
DISCOUNT RATE
DISCRIMINATION
DIVERSIFICATION
EARNINGS
ECONOMIC ANALYSIS
ECONOMIC GROWTH
ECONOMICS
ELECTRICIANS
EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES
EMPLOYMENT PROGRAMS
EMPLOYMENT STATUS
EMPOWERMENT
ENTREPRENEURIAL ACTIVITIES
ENTREPRENEURIAL ACTIVITY
ENTREPRENEURIAL BEHAVIOR
ENTREPRENEURSHIP TRAINING
EQUIPMENT LOAN
EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN
FAMILIES
FARMERS
FEMALE ENTERPRISE
FEMALE ENTERPRISES
FEMALE ENTREPRENEURS
FEMALE ENTREPRENEURSHIP
FEMALE WORKERS
FINANCIAL BEHAVIOR
FINANCIAL CAPITAL
FINANCIAL LITERACY
FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT
FINANCIAL MARKET
FINANCIAL PRODUCTS
FINANCIAL SERVICES
FINANCIAL SKILLS
FINANCIAL STUDIES
FINANCIAL SUPPORT
FINANCIAL TRAINING
GENDER
GENDER DISPARITY
GENDER ROLES
GENERAL POPULATION
GIRLS
GROUP LENDING
HEALTH INSURANCE
HOUSEHOLD INCOME
HOUSEHOLDS
HUMAN DEVELOPMENT
ID
IMPACT EVALUATION
IMPACT EVALUATION DESIGN
INCOME
INCOME GROUPS
INCOME LEVELS
INCOMES
INNOVATION
INSURANCE
INSURANCE SCHEME
INTERNATIONAL BANK
INTERVENTIONS
INVENTORY
JOB CREATION
JOB SEARCH
JOB TRAINING
KNOWLEDGE GAP
LABOR ECONOMICS
LABOR INCOME
LABOR MARKET
LABOR MARKETS
LABOR POLICIES
LABOR RELATIONS
LABOUR
LABOUR MARKET POLICY
LARGE FIRM
LEARNING
LIABILITY
LIFE SKILLS
LOAN
LOAN REPAYMENT
LOW INCOME
LOW-INCOME
MARKET ANALYSIS
MARKETING
MFI
MFIS
MICRO ENTERPRISE
MICRO ENTERPRISE DEVELOPMENT
MICRO-CREDIT
MICRO-ENTREPRENEURS
MICROCREDIT
MICROFINANCE
MORTALITY
MOTIVATION
NEW BUSINESS
OCCUPATIONS
OUTCOME INDICATORS
PERSONALITY
POLICY ENVIRONMENT
POLITICAL ECONOMY
PROBABILITY
PRODUCTIVITY
PROGRAM EFFECTIVENESS
PROGRAM IMPACTS
RECORD KEEPING
REGRESSION ANALYSIS
REPAYMENT
RESOURCE ALLOCATION
RISKY BEHAVIOR
RURAL AREAS
SALARY
SALES
SAVING BEHAVIOR
SAVINGS
SAVINGS ACCOUNTS
SCHOOL FINANCE
SELF EMPLOYED
SELF EMPLOYMENT
SELF HELP
SELF-EMPLOYMENT
SERVICE PROVIDERS
SKILLS TRAINING
SMALL BUSINESS
SMALL BUSINESSES
SMALL ENTERPRISES
SMALL-SCALE ENTREPRENEURS
SMART MONEY
SOCIAL ASSISTANCE
SOCIAL PROTECTION
SOCIAL SERVICES
START-UP
STOCKS
TARGETING
TEACHING
TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE
TECHNICAL SKILLS
TRAINING FOR ENTREPRENEURS
TRAINING PROGRAM
TRAINING PROGRAMS
UNEMPLOYED
UNEMPLOYMENT
UNION
URBAN AREAS
URBAN POPULATION
VALUABLE
VOCATIONAL EDUCATION
VOCATIONAL TRAINING
WAGE
WAGE GAP
WAGE GAPS
WAGE SUBSIDIES
WELL-BEING
WORTH
YOUTH
Cho, Yoonyoung
Honorati, Maddalena
Entrepreneurship Programs in Developing Countries : A Meta Regression Analysis
description This paper provides a synthetic and systematic review on the effectiveness of various entrepreneurship programs in developing countries. It adopts a meta-regression analysis using 37 impact evaluation studies that were in the public domain by March 2012, and draws out several lessons on the design of the programs. The paper observes wide variation in program effectiveness across different interventions depending on outcomes, types of beneficiaries, and country context. Overall, entrepreneurship programs have a positive and large impact for youth and on business knowledge and practice, but no immediate translation into business set-up and expansion or increased income. At a disaggregate level by outcome groups, providing a package of training and financing is more effective for labor activities. In addition, financing support appears more effective for women and business training for existing entrepreneurs than other interventions to improve business performance.
format Publications & Research :: Policy Research Working Paper
topic_facet ACCESS TO BANK ACCOUNT
ACCESS TO CREDIT
ACCESS TO FINANCE
ACCESS TO LOANS
ACCESS TO SAVING
ACCESS TO SAVINGS
ACCOUNTING
ACTIVE LABOR MARKET PROGRAMS
ACTIVE LABOUR MARKET
ACTUARIES
ADVISORY SERVICES
ASSISTANCE TO BUSINESS
BANK ACCOUNT
BANKS
BASIC SKILLS
BEHAVIORAL SCIENCES
BENEFICIARIES
BENEFICIARY
BORROWING
BUSINESS ACTIVITIES
BUSINESS CONFIDENCE
BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT
BUSINESS INCUBATION
BUSINESS LOANS
BUSINESS MANAGEMENT
BUSINESS NETWORKS
BUSINESS OPERATION
BUSINESS OWNERS
BUSINESS SCHOOL
BUSINESS SURVIVAL
BUSINESS TRAINING
CASH TRANSFER
COGNITIVE SKILLS
COLLECTIVE ACTION
CONSUMER
CONSUMER LOANS
CONTRIBUTION
CONTROL GROUPS
CREDIT ACCESS
CREDIT CONSTRAINTS
CREDIT SCORING
CULTURAL FACTORS
CULTURAL NORM
CUSTOMER RELATIONS
DATA COLLECTION
DEBT
DECISION MAKING
DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS
DISCOUNT RATE
DISCRIMINATION
DIVERSIFICATION
EARNINGS
ECONOMIC ANALYSIS
ECONOMIC GROWTH
ECONOMICS
ELECTRICIANS
EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES
EMPLOYMENT PROGRAMS
EMPLOYMENT STATUS
EMPOWERMENT
ENTREPRENEURIAL ACTIVITIES
ENTREPRENEURIAL ACTIVITY
ENTREPRENEURIAL BEHAVIOR
ENTREPRENEURSHIP TRAINING
EQUIPMENT LOAN
EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN
FAMILIES
FARMERS
FEMALE ENTERPRISE
FEMALE ENTERPRISES
FEMALE ENTREPRENEURS
FEMALE ENTREPRENEURSHIP
FEMALE WORKERS
FINANCIAL BEHAVIOR
FINANCIAL CAPITAL
FINANCIAL LITERACY
FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT
FINANCIAL MARKET
FINANCIAL PRODUCTS
FINANCIAL SERVICES
FINANCIAL SKILLS
FINANCIAL STUDIES
FINANCIAL SUPPORT
FINANCIAL TRAINING
GENDER
GENDER DISPARITY
GENDER ROLES
GENERAL POPULATION
GIRLS
GROUP LENDING
HEALTH INSURANCE
HOUSEHOLD INCOME
HOUSEHOLDS
HUMAN DEVELOPMENT
ID
IMPACT EVALUATION
IMPACT EVALUATION DESIGN
INCOME
INCOME GROUPS
INCOME LEVELS
INCOMES
INNOVATION
INSURANCE
INSURANCE SCHEME
INTERNATIONAL BANK
INTERVENTIONS
INVENTORY
JOB CREATION
JOB SEARCH
JOB TRAINING
KNOWLEDGE GAP
LABOR ECONOMICS
LABOR INCOME
LABOR MARKET
LABOR MARKETS
LABOR POLICIES
LABOR RELATIONS
LABOUR
LABOUR MARKET POLICY
LARGE FIRM
LEARNING
LIABILITY
LIFE SKILLS
LOAN
LOAN REPAYMENT
LOW INCOME
LOW-INCOME
MARKET ANALYSIS
MARKETING
MFI
MFIS
MICRO ENTERPRISE
MICRO ENTERPRISE DEVELOPMENT
MICRO-CREDIT
MICRO-ENTREPRENEURS
MICROCREDIT
MICROFINANCE
MORTALITY
MOTIVATION
NEW BUSINESS
OCCUPATIONS
OUTCOME INDICATORS
PERSONALITY
POLICY ENVIRONMENT
POLITICAL ECONOMY
PROBABILITY
PRODUCTIVITY
PROGRAM EFFECTIVENESS
PROGRAM IMPACTS
RECORD KEEPING
REGRESSION ANALYSIS
REPAYMENT
RESOURCE ALLOCATION
RISKY BEHAVIOR
RURAL AREAS
SALARY
SALES
SAVING BEHAVIOR
SAVINGS
SAVINGS ACCOUNTS
SCHOOL FINANCE
SELF EMPLOYED
SELF EMPLOYMENT
SELF HELP
SELF-EMPLOYMENT
SERVICE PROVIDERS
SKILLS TRAINING
SMALL BUSINESS
SMALL BUSINESSES
SMALL ENTERPRISES
SMALL-SCALE ENTREPRENEURS
SMART MONEY
SOCIAL ASSISTANCE
SOCIAL PROTECTION
SOCIAL SERVICES
START-UP
STOCKS
TARGETING
TEACHING
TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE
TECHNICAL SKILLS
TRAINING FOR ENTREPRENEURS
TRAINING PROGRAM
TRAINING PROGRAMS
UNEMPLOYED
UNEMPLOYMENT
UNION
URBAN AREAS
URBAN POPULATION
VALUABLE
VOCATIONAL EDUCATION
VOCATIONAL TRAINING
WAGE
WAGE GAP
WAGE GAPS
WAGE SUBSIDIES
WELL-BEING
WORTH
YOUTH
author Cho, Yoonyoung
Honorati, Maddalena
author_facet Cho, Yoonyoung
Honorati, Maddalena
author_sort Cho, Yoonyoung
title Entrepreneurship Programs in Developing Countries : A Meta Regression Analysis
title_short Entrepreneurship Programs in Developing Countries : A Meta Regression Analysis
title_full Entrepreneurship Programs in Developing Countries : A Meta Regression Analysis
title_fullStr Entrepreneurship Programs in Developing Countries : A Meta Regression Analysis
title_full_unstemmed Entrepreneurship Programs in Developing Countries : A Meta Regression Analysis
title_sort entrepreneurship programs in developing countries : a meta regression analysis
publisher World Bank, Washington, DC
publishDate 2013-04
url http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2013/04/17549708/entrepreneurship-programs-developing-countries-meta-regression-analysis
http://hdl.handle.net/10986/13199
work_keys_str_mv AT choyoonyoung entrepreneurshipprogramsindevelopingcountriesametaregressionanalysis
AT honoratimaddalena entrepreneurshipprogramsindevelopingcountriesametaregressionanalysis
_version_ 1756572719729606656
spelling dig-okr-10986131992021-04-23T14:03:07Z Entrepreneurship Programs in Developing Countries : A Meta Regression Analysis Cho, Yoonyoung Honorati, Maddalena ACCESS TO BANK ACCOUNT ACCESS TO CREDIT ACCESS TO FINANCE ACCESS TO LOANS ACCESS TO SAVING ACCESS TO SAVINGS ACCOUNTING ACTIVE LABOR MARKET PROGRAMS ACTIVE LABOUR MARKET ACTUARIES ADVISORY SERVICES ASSISTANCE TO BUSINESS BANK ACCOUNT BANKS BASIC SKILLS BEHAVIORAL SCIENCES BENEFICIARIES BENEFICIARY BORROWING BUSINESS ACTIVITIES BUSINESS CONFIDENCE BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT BUSINESS INCUBATION BUSINESS LOANS BUSINESS MANAGEMENT BUSINESS NETWORKS BUSINESS OPERATION BUSINESS OWNERS BUSINESS SCHOOL BUSINESS SURVIVAL BUSINESS TRAINING CASH TRANSFER COGNITIVE SKILLS COLLECTIVE ACTION CONSUMER CONSUMER LOANS CONTRIBUTION CONTROL GROUPS CREDIT ACCESS CREDIT CONSTRAINTS CREDIT SCORING CULTURAL FACTORS CULTURAL NORM CUSTOMER RELATIONS DATA COLLECTION DEBT DECISION MAKING DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS DISCOUNT RATE DISCRIMINATION DIVERSIFICATION EARNINGS ECONOMIC ANALYSIS ECONOMIC GROWTH ECONOMICS ELECTRICIANS EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES EMPLOYMENT PROGRAMS EMPLOYMENT STATUS EMPOWERMENT ENTREPRENEURIAL ACTIVITIES ENTREPRENEURIAL ACTIVITY ENTREPRENEURIAL BEHAVIOR ENTREPRENEURSHIP TRAINING EQUIPMENT LOAN EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN FAMILIES FARMERS FEMALE ENTERPRISE FEMALE ENTERPRISES FEMALE ENTREPRENEURS FEMALE ENTREPRENEURSHIP FEMALE WORKERS FINANCIAL BEHAVIOR FINANCIAL CAPITAL FINANCIAL LITERACY FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT FINANCIAL MARKET FINANCIAL PRODUCTS FINANCIAL SERVICES FINANCIAL SKILLS FINANCIAL STUDIES FINANCIAL SUPPORT FINANCIAL TRAINING GENDER GENDER DISPARITY GENDER ROLES GENERAL POPULATION GIRLS GROUP LENDING HEALTH INSURANCE HOUSEHOLD INCOME HOUSEHOLDS HUMAN DEVELOPMENT ID IMPACT EVALUATION IMPACT EVALUATION DESIGN INCOME INCOME GROUPS INCOME LEVELS INCOMES INNOVATION INSURANCE INSURANCE SCHEME INTERNATIONAL BANK INTERVENTIONS INVENTORY JOB CREATION JOB SEARCH JOB TRAINING KNOWLEDGE GAP LABOR ECONOMICS LABOR INCOME LABOR MARKET LABOR MARKETS LABOR POLICIES LABOR RELATIONS LABOUR LABOUR MARKET POLICY LARGE FIRM LEARNING LIABILITY LIFE SKILLS LOAN LOAN REPAYMENT LOW INCOME LOW-INCOME MARKET ANALYSIS MARKETING MFI MFIS MICRO ENTERPRISE MICRO ENTERPRISE DEVELOPMENT MICRO-CREDIT MICRO-ENTREPRENEURS MICROCREDIT MICROFINANCE MORTALITY MOTIVATION NEW BUSINESS OCCUPATIONS OUTCOME INDICATORS PERSONALITY POLICY ENVIRONMENT POLITICAL ECONOMY PROBABILITY PRODUCTIVITY PROGRAM EFFECTIVENESS PROGRAM IMPACTS RECORD KEEPING REGRESSION ANALYSIS REPAYMENT RESOURCE ALLOCATION RISKY BEHAVIOR RURAL AREAS SALARY SALES SAVING BEHAVIOR SAVINGS SAVINGS ACCOUNTS SCHOOL FINANCE SELF EMPLOYED SELF EMPLOYMENT SELF HELP SELF-EMPLOYMENT SERVICE PROVIDERS SKILLS TRAINING SMALL BUSINESS SMALL BUSINESSES SMALL ENTERPRISES SMALL-SCALE ENTREPRENEURS SMART MONEY SOCIAL ASSISTANCE SOCIAL PROTECTION SOCIAL SERVICES START-UP STOCKS TARGETING TEACHING TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE TECHNICAL SKILLS TRAINING FOR ENTREPRENEURS TRAINING PROGRAM TRAINING PROGRAMS UNEMPLOYED UNEMPLOYMENT UNION URBAN AREAS URBAN POPULATION VALUABLE VOCATIONAL EDUCATION VOCATIONAL TRAINING WAGE WAGE GAP WAGE GAPS WAGE SUBSIDIES WELL-BEING WORTH YOUTH This paper provides a synthetic and systematic review on the effectiveness of various entrepreneurship programs in developing countries. It adopts a meta-regression analysis using 37 impact evaluation studies that were in the public domain by March 2012, and draws out several lessons on the design of the programs. The paper observes wide variation in program effectiveness across different interventions depending on outcomes, types of beneficiaries, and country context. Overall, entrepreneurship programs have a positive and large impact for youth and on business knowledge and practice, but no immediate translation into business set-up and expansion or increased income. At a disaggregate level by outcome groups, providing a package of training and financing is more effective for labor activities. In addition, financing support appears more effective for women and business training for existing entrepreneurs than other interventions to improve business performance. 2013-04-18T16:32:49Z 2013-04-18T16:32:49Z 2013-04 http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2013/04/17549708/entrepreneurship-programs-developing-countries-meta-regression-analysis http://hdl.handle.net/10986/13199 English en_US Policy Research Working Paper;No. 6402 CC BY 3.0 IGO http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/igo/ World Bank World Bank, Washington, DC Publications & Research :: Policy Research Working Paper Publications & Research