Vitamin A: Moving the food-based approach forward

Food-based approaches to combating vitamin A deficiency continue to be largely ignored by governments and donors. This may be partly because the way of viewing them has largely been informed by the community which supports supplementation. Food-based approaches may be perceived as competitive or distracting and are thus slandered, for example claiming they are unproven or even ineffective. To the contrary, it is the supplementation approach that fails to improve vitamin A status and is even lack ing in proof of impact on young child mortality in real life settings. A wide variety of common and indigenous foods are proven effective in improving vitamin A status even in short-term trials. Food based approaches are complex to implement and to evaluate and take time to mature and exert impact. But unlike supplementation, they reach all members of the community, are safe for pregnant women, have no side effects, are sustainable, and confer a wide range of benefits in addition to improving vi tamin A status. Food-based approaches are also often portrayed as being expensive, but this is only true from a “donor-centric” way of viewing costs. From the point of view of host countries, communities and families who grow vitamin A rich foods, the economic benefits are likely to outweigh the costs. The 1992 ICN called for the elimination of vitamin A deficiency. The urgency of this call may have provided an excuse for the rapid implementation of supplementation programs in over 100 countries while very few have implemented national foodbased approaches. It is thus important that ICN 2 instead call for the replacement of supplementation programs with sustainable food-based approaches. It should call on countries to assign responsibility and funding to specific individuals or organizations who are then given benchmarks and are held accountable to meet them. Donors could greatly assist by funding simple dietary assessment and other components of national plans for making this shift.

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Author: Greiner, T.
Format: Document biblioteca
Language:English
Published: FAO/WHO ; 2013
Online Access:https://openknowledge.fao.org/handle/20.500.14283/AS565E
http://www.fao.org/3/a-as565e.pdf
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
id dig-fao-it-20.500.14283-AS565E
record_format koha
spelling dig-fao-it-20.500.14283-AS565E2024-03-16T15:50:45Z Vitamin A: Moving the food-based approach forward Vitamin A: Moving the food-based approach forward Greiner, T. Food-based approaches to combating vitamin A deficiency continue to be largely ignored by governments and donors. This may be partly because the way of viewing them has largely been informed by the community which supports supplementation. Food-based approaches may be perceived as competitive or distracting and are thus slandered, for example claiming they are unproven or even ineffective. To the contrary, it is the supplementation approach that fails to improve vitamin A status and is even lack ing in proof of impact on young child mortality in real life settings. A wide variety of common and indigenous foods are proven effective in improving vitamin A status even in short-term trials. Food based approaches are complex to implement and to evaluate and take time to mature and exert impact. But unlike supplementation, they reach all members of the community, are safe for pregnant women, have no side effects, are sustainable, and confer a wide range of benefits in addition to improving vi tamin A status. Food-based approaches are also often portrayed as being expensive, but this is only true from a “donor-centric” way of viewing costs. From the point of view of host countries, communities and families who grow vitamin A rich foods, the economic benefits are likely to outweigh the costs. The 1992 ICN called for the elimination of vitamin A deficiency. The urgency of this call may have provided an excuse for the rapid implementation of supplementation programs in over 100 countries while very few have implemented national foodbased approaches. It is thus important that ICN 2 instead call for the replacement of supplementation programs with sustainable food-based approaches. It should call on countries to assign responsibility and funding to specific individuals or organizations who are then given benchmarks and are held accountable to meet them. Donors could greatly assist by funding simple dietary assessment and other components of national plans for making this shift. 2023-04-27T11:21:58Z 2023-04-27T11:21:58Z 2013 2018-01-09T14:24:39.0000000Z Document https://openknowledge.fao.org/handle/20.500.14283/AS565E http://www.fao.org/3/a-as565e.pdf English FAO 69 p. application/pdf FAO/WHO ;
institution FAO IT
collection DSpace
country Italia
countrycode IT
component Bibliográfico
access En linea
databasecode dig-fao-it
tag biblioteca
region Europa del Sur
libraryname David Lubin Memorial Library of FAO
language English
description Food-based approaches to combating vitamin A deficiency continue to be largely ignored by governments and donors. This may be partly because the way of viewing them has largely been informed by the community which supports supplementation. Food-based approaches may be perceived as competitive or distracting and are thus slandered, for example claiming they are unproven or even ineffective. To the contrary, it is the supplementation approach that fails to improve vitamin A status and is even lack ing in proof of impact on young child mortality in real life settings. A wide variety of common and indigenous foods are proven effective in improving vitamin A status even in short-term trials. Food based approaches are complex to implement and to evaluate and take time to mature and exert impact. But unlike supplementation, they reach all members of the community, are safe for pregnant women, have no side effects, are sustainable, and confer a wide range of benefits in addition to improving vi tamin A status. Food-based approaches are also often portrayed as being expensive, but this is only true from a “donor-centric” way of viewing costs. From the point of view of host countries, communities and families who grow vitamin A rich foods, the economic benefits are likely to outweigh the costs. The 1992 ICN called for the elimination of vitamin A deficiency. The urgency of this call may have provided an excuse for the rapid implementation of supplementation programs in over 100 countries while very few have implemented national foodbased approaches. It is thus important that ICN 2 instead call for the replacement of supplementation programs with sustainable food-based approaches. It should call on countries to assign responsibility and funding to specific individuals or organizations who are then given benchmarks and are held accountable to meet them. Donors could greatly assist by funding simple dietary assessment and other components of national plans for making this shift.
format Document
author Greiner, T.
spellingShingle Greiner, T.
Vitamin A: Moving the food-based approach forward
author_facet Greiner, T.
author_sort Greiner, T.
title Vitamin A: Moving the food-based approach forward
title_short Vitamin A: Moving the food-based approach forward
title_full Vitamin A: Moving the food-based approach forward
title_fullStr Vitamin A: Moving the food-based approach forward
title_full_unstemmed Vitamin A: Moving the food-based approach forward
title_sort vitamin a: moving the food-based approach forward
publisher FAO/WHO ;
publishDate 2013
url https://openknowledge.fao.org/handle/20.500.14283/AS565E
http://www.fao.org/3/a-as565e.pdf
work_keys_str_mv AT greinert vitaminamovingthefoodbasedapproachforward
_version_ 1799259635439370240