Optimal search in ex situ collections of wheat genetic resources

This paper develops a theoretical model for analyzing gene bank management decisions regarding the search for traits of economic value in ex situ collections of wheat. The model is applied to data on the probability of finding useful sources of resistance to Russian wheat aphid (Diuraphis noxia) and septoria tritici leaf blotch, using Monte Carlo simulations for sampling distributions, simulations of varietal diffusion paths, and actual cost data from searches. Three specific questions are posed and answered: (1) what is the optimal size of search among genetic resources of a given type for a trait of economic value? (2) what is the value of specialized knowledge about which genetic resources are most likely to display resistance? and (3) how should search resources be allocated across types of genetic resources? Results demonstrate the sensitivity of the optimal size of search to the economic importance of the problem, the probability distributions of the trait in different types of genetic resources, and the cost and time lags associated with transferring the trait into usable breeding material. The cost and time lags involved with conventional pre-breeding techniques imply that in some searches, certain categories of genetic resources (such as landraces) will be systematically ignored. The fact that they may be rarely utilized does not imply that collections of landraces have no value, however, as shown in the case of Russian wheat aphid. Though applied here to data on insect and disease resistance, the model can be adapted to search decisions for other types of traits.

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Gollin, D., Smale, M., Skovmand, B.
Format: Book biblioteca
Language:English
Published: CIMMYT 1998
Subjects:AGRICULTURAL SCIENCES AND BIOTECHNOLOGY, CIMMYT, WHEAT, GENETIC RESOURCES, GERMPLASM, GERMPLASM CONSERVATION, GENE BANKS, GENE POOLS, MANAGEMENT, COST BENEFIT ANALYSIS, ECONOMIC ANALYSIS, SIMULATION MODELS, STATISTICAL METHODS, PLANT BREEDING, PEST RESISTANCE, APHIDOIDEA, DISEASE RESISTANCE, LEAF BLOTCH,
Online Access:http://hdl.handle.net/10883/958
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
id dig-cimmyt-10883-958
record_format koha
spelling dig-cimmyt-10883-9582021-02-09T18:25:21Z Optimal search in ex situ collections of wheat genetic resources Gollin, D. Smale, M. Skovmand, B. AGRICULTURAL SCIENCES AND BIOTECHNOLOGY CIMMYT WHEAT GENETIC RESOURCES GERMPLASM GERMPLASM CONSERVATION GENE BANKS GENE POOLS MANAGEMENT COST BENEFIT ANALYSIS ECONOMIC ANALYSIS SIMULATION MODELS STATISTICAL METHODS PLANT BREEDING PEST RESISTANCE APHIDOIDEA DISEASE RESISTANCE LEAF BLOTCH This paper develops a theoretical model for analyzing gene bank management decisions regarding the search for traits of economic value in ex situ collections of wheat. The model is applied to data on the probability of finding useful sources of resistance to Russian wheat aphid (Diuraphis noxia) and septoria tritici leaf blotch, using Monte Carlo simulations for sampling distributions, simulations of varietal diffusion paths, and actual cost data from searches. Three specific questions are posed and answered: (1) what is the optimal size of search among genetic resources of a given type for a trait of economic value? (2) what is the value of specialized knowledge about which genetic resources are most likely to display resistance? and (3) how should search resources be allocated across types of genetic resources? Results demonstrate the sensitivity of the optimal size of search to the economic importance of the problem, the probability distributions of the trait in different types of genetic resources, and the cost and time lags associated with transferring the trait into usable breeding material. The cost and time lags involved with conventional pre-breeding techniques imply that in some searches, certain categories of genetic resources (such as landraces) will be systematically ignored. The fact that they may be rarely utilized does not imply that collections of landraces have no value, however, as shown in the case of Russian wheat aphid. Though applied here to data on insect and disease resistance, the model can be adapted to search decisions for other types of traits. 34 pages 2012-01-06T05:08:31Z 2012-01-06T05:08:31Z 1998 Book 0258-8587 http://hdl.handle.net/10883/958 English CIMMYT Economics Working Paper CIMMYT manages Intellectual Assets as International Public Goods. The user is free to download, print, store and share this work. In case you want to translate or create any other derivative work and share or distribute such translation/derivative work, please contact CIMMYT-Knowledge-Center@cgiar.org indicating the work you want to use and the kind of use you intend; CIMMYT will contact you with the suitable license for that purpose. Open Access PDF Mexico CIMMYT
institution CIMMYT
collection DSpace
country México
countrycode MX
component Bibliográfico
access En linea
databasecode dig-cimmyt
tag biblioteca
region America del Norte
libraryname CIMMYT Library
language English
topic AGRICULTURAL SCIENCES AND BIOTECHNOLOGY
CIMMYT
WHEAT
GENETIC RESOURCES
GERMPLASM
GERMPLASM CONSERVATION
GENE BANKS
GENE POOLS
MANAGEMENT
COST BENEFIT ANALYSIS
ECONOMIC ANALYSIS
SIMULATION MODELS
STATISTICAL METHODS
PLANT BREEDING
PEST RESISTANCE
APHIDOIDEA
DISEASE RESISTANCE
LEAF BLOTCH
AGRICULTURAL SCIENCES AND BIOTECHNOLOGY
CIMMYT
WHEAT
GENETIC RESOURCES
GERMPLASM
GERMPLASM CONSERVATION
GENE BANKS
GENE POOLS
MANAGEMENT
COST BENEFIT ANALYSIS
ECONOMIC ANALYSIS
SIMULATION MODELS
STATISTICAL METHODS
PLANT BREEDING
PEST RESISTANCE
APHIDOIDEA
DISEASE RESISTANCE
LEAF BLOTCH
spellingShingle AGRICULTURAL SCIENCES AND BIOTECHNOLOGY
CIMMYT
WHEAT
GENETIC RESOURCES
GERMPLASM
GERMPLASM CONSERVATION
GENE BANKS
GENE POOLS
MANAGEMENT
COST BENEFIT ANALYSIS
ECONOMIC ANALYSIS
SIMULATION MODELS
STATISTICAL METHODS
PLANT BREEDING
PEST RESISTANCE
APHIDOIDEA
DISEASE RESISTANCE
LEAF BLOTCH
AGRICULTURAL SCIENCES AND BIOTECHNOLOGY
CIMMYT
WHEAT
GENETIC RESOURCES
GERMPLASM
GERMPLASM CONSERVATION
GENE BANKS
GENE POOLS
MANAGEMENT
COST BENEFIT ANALYSIS
ECONOMIC ANALYSIS
SIMULATION MODELS
STATISTICAL METHODS
PLANT BREEDING
PEST RESISTANCE
APHIDOIDEA
DISEASE RESISTANCE
LEAF BLOTCH
Gollin, D.
Smale, M.
Skovmand, B.
Optimal search in ex situ collections of wheat genetic resources
description This paper develops a theoretical model for analyzing gene bank management decisions regarding the search for traits of economic value in ex situ collections of wheat. The model is applied to data on the probability of finding useful sources of resistance to Russian wheat aphid (Diuraphis noxia) and septoria tritici leaf blotch, using Monte Carlo simulations for sampling distributions, simulations of varietal diffusion paths, and actual cost data from searches. Three specific questions are posed and answered: (1) what is the optimal size of search among genetic resources of a given type for a trait of economic value? (2) what is the value of specialized knowledge about which genetic resources are most likely to display resistance? and (3) how should search resources be allocated across types of genetic resources? Results demonstrate the sensitivity of the optimal size of search to the economic importance of the problem, the probability distributions of the trait in different types of genetic resources, and the cost and time lags associated with transferring the trait into usable breeding material. The cost and time lags involved with conventional pre-breeding techniques imply that in some searches, certain categories of genetic resources (such as landraces) will be systematically ignored. The fact that they may be rarely utilized does not imply that collections of landraces have no value, however, as shown in the case of Russian wheat aphid. Though applied here to data on insect and disease resistance, the model can be adapted to search decisions for other types of traits.
format Book
topic_facet AGRICULTURAL SCIENCES AND BIOTECHNOLOGY
CIMMYT
WHEAT
GENETIC RESOURCES
GERMPLASM
GERMPLASM CONSERVATION
GENE BANKS
GENE POOLS
MANAGEMENT
COST BENEFIT ANALYSIS
ECONOMIC ANALYSIS
SIMULATION MODELS
STATISTICAL METHODS
PLANT BREEDING
PEST RESISTANCE
APHIDOIDEA
DISEASE RESISTANCE
LEAF BLOTCH
author Gollin, D.
Smale, M.
Skovmand, B.
author_facet Gollin, D.
Smale, M.
Skovmand, B.
author_sort Gollin, D.
title Optimal search in ex situ collections of wheat genetic resources
title_short Optimal search in ex situ collections of wheat genetic resources
title_full Optimal search in ex situ collections of wheat genetic resources
title_fullStr Optimal search in ex situ collections of wheat genetic resources
title_full_unstemmed Optimal search in ex situ collections of wheat genetic resources
title_sort optimal search in ex situ collections of wheat genetic resources
publisher CIMMYT
publishDate 1998
url http://hdl.handle.net/10883/958
work_keys_str_mv AT gollind optimalsearchinexsitucollectionsofwheatgeneticresources
AT smalem optimalsearchinexsitucollectionsofwheatgeneticresources
AT skovmandb optimalsearchinexsitucollectionsofwheatgeneticresources
_version_ 1756086333572382720