Integrating parental phenotypic data enhances prediction accuracy of hybrids in wheat traits

Genomic selection (GS) is a methodology that is revolutionizing plant breeding because it can select candidate genotypes without phenotypic evaluation in the field. However, its practical implementation in hybrid prediction remains challenging since many factors affect its accuracy. The main objective of this study was to research the genomic prediction accuracy of wheat hybrids by adding covariates with the hybrid parental phenotypic information to the model. Four types of different models (MA, MB, MC, and MD) with one covariate (same trait to be predicted) (MA_C, MB_C, MC_C, and MD_C) or several covariates (of the same trait and other correlated traits) (MA_AC, MB_AC, MC_AC, and MD_AC) were studied. We found that the four models with parental information outperformed models without parental information in terms of mean square error by at least 14.1% (MA vs. MA_C), 5.5% (MB vs. MB_C), 51.4% (MC vs. MC_C), and 6.4% (MD vs. MD_C) when parental information of the same trait was used and by at least 13.7% (MA vs. MA_AC), 5.3% (MB vs. MB_AC), 55.1% (MC vs. MC_AC), and 6.0% (MD vs. MD_AC) when parental information of the same trait and other correlated traits were used. Our results also show a large gain in prediction accuracy when covariates were considered using the parental phenotypic information, as opposed to marker information. Finally, our results empirically demonstrate that a significant improvement in prediction accuracy was gained by adding parental phenotypic information as covariates; however, this is expensive since, in many breeding programs, the parental phenotypic information is unavailable.

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Montesinos-Lopez, O.A., Bentley, A.R., Saint Pierre, C., Crespo Herrera, L.A., Salinas-Ruiz, J., Valladares-Celis, P.C., Montesinos-Lopez, A., Crossa, J.
Format: Article biblioteca
Language:English
Published: MDPI 2023
Subjects:AGRICULTURAL SCIENCES AND BIOTECHNOLOGY, Genomic Prediction, Parental Information, Prediction Accuracy, Correlated Traits, BREEDING, FORECASTING, WHEAT, GENOMICS, Genetic Resources,
Online Access:https://hdl.handle.net/10883/22537
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
id dig-cimmyt-10883-22537
record_format koha
spelling dig-cimmyt-10883-225372023-12-01T16:20:58Z Integrating parental phenotypic data enhances prediction accuracy of hybrids in wheat traits Montesinos-Lopez, O.A. Bentley, A.R. Saint Pierre, C. Crespo Herrera, L.A. Salinas-Ruiz, J. Valladares-Celis, P.C. Montesinos-Lopez, A. Crossa, J. AGRICULTURAL SCIENCES AND BIOTECHNOLOGY Genomic Prediction Parental Information Prediction Accuracy Correlated Traits BREEDING FORECASTING WHEAT GENOMICS Genetic Resources Genomic selection (GS) is a methodology that is revolutionizing plant breeding because it can select candidate genotypes without phenotypic evaluation in the field. However, its practical implementation in hybrid prediction remains challenging since many factors affect its accuracy. The main objective of this study was to research the genomic prediction accuracy of wheat hybrids by adding covariates with the hybrid parental phenotypic information to the model. Four types of different models (MA, MB, MC, and MD) with one covariate (same trait to be predicted) (MA_C, MB_C, MC_C, and MD_C) or several covariates (of the same trait and other correlated traits) (MA_AC, MB_AC, MC_AC, and MD_AC) were studied. We found that the four models with parental information outperformed models without parental information in terms of mean square error by at least 14.1% (MA vs. MA_C), 5.5% (MB vs. MB_C), 51.4% (MC vs. MC_C), and 6.4% (MD vs. MD_C) when parental information of the same trait was used and by at least 13.7% (MA vs. MA_AC), 5.3% (MB vs. MB_AC), 55.1% (MC vs. MC_AC), and 6.0% (MD vs. MD_AC) when parental information of the same trait and other correlated traits were used. Our results also show a large gain in prediction accuracy when covariates were considered using the parental phenotypic information, as opposed to marker information. Finally, our results empirically demonstrate that a significant improvement in prediction accuracy was gained by adding parental phenotypic information as covariates; however, this is expensive since, in many breeding programs, the parental phenotypic information is unavailable. 2023-03-10T20:10:13Z 2023-03-10T20:10:13Z 2023 Article Published Version https://hdl.handle.net/10883/22537 10.3390/genes14020395 English http://hdl.handle.net/11529/10548129 CIMMYT manages Intellectual Assets as International Public Goods. The user is free to download, print, store and share this work. In case you want to translate or create any other derivative work and share or distribute such translation/derivative work, please contact CIMMYT-Knowledge-Center@cgiar.org indicating the work you want to use and the kind of use you intend; CIMMYT will contact you with the suitable license for that purpose Open Access Basel (Switzerland) MDPI 2 14 2073-4425 Genes 395
institution CIMMYT
collection DSpace
country México
countrycode MX
component Bibliográfico
access En linea
databasecode dig-cimmyt
tag biblioteca
region America del Norte
libraryname CIMMYT Library
language English
topic AGRICULTURAL SCIENCES AND BIOTECHNOLOGY
Genomic Prediction
Parental Information
Prediction Accuracy
Correlated Traits
BREEDING
FORECASTING
WHEAT
GENOMICS
Genetic Resources
AGRICULTURAL SCIENCES AND BIOTECHNOLOGY
Genomic Prediction
Parental Information
Prediction Accuracy
Correlated Traits
BREEDING
FORECASTING
WHEAT
GENOMICS
Genetic Resources
spellingShingle AGRICULTURAL SCIENCES AND BIOTECHNOLOGY
Genomic Prediction
Parental Information
Prediction Accuracy
Correlated Traits
BREEDING
FORECASTING
WHEAT
GENOMICS
Genetic Resources
AGRICULTURAL SCIENCES AND BIOTECHNOLOGY
Genomic Prediction
Parental Information
Prediction Accuracy
Correlated Traits
BREEDING
FORECASTING
WHEAT
GENOMICS
Genetic Resources
Montesinos-Lopez, O.A.
Bentley, A.R.
Saint Pierre, C.
Crespo Herrera, L.A.
Salinas-Ruiz, J.
Valladares-Celis, P.C.
Montesinos-Lopez, A.
Crossa, J.
Integrating parental phenotypic data enhances prediction accuracy of hybrids in wheat traits
description Genomic selection (GS) is a methodology that is revolutionizing plant breeding because it can select candidate genotypes without phenotypic evaluation in the field. However, its practical implementation in hybrid prediction remains challenging since many factors affect its accuracy. The main objective of this study was to research the genomic prediction accuracy of wheat hybrids by adding covariates with the hybrid parental phenotypic information to the model. Four types of different models (MA, MB, MC, and MD) with one covariate (same trait to be predicted) (MA_C, MB_C, MC_C, and MD_C) or several covariates (of the same trait and other correlated traits) (MA_AC, MB_AC, MC_AC, and MD_AC) were studied. We found that the four models with parental information outperformed models without parental information in terms of mean square error by at least 14.1% (MA vs. MA_C), 5.5% (MB vs. MB_C), 51.4% (MC vs. MC_C), and 6.4% (MD vs. MD_C) when parental information of the same trait was used and by at least 13.7% (MA vs. MA_AC), 5.3% (MB vs. MB_AC), 55.1% (MC vs. MC_AC), and 6.0% (MD vs. MD_AC) when parental information of the same trait and other correlated traits were used. Our results also show a large gain in prediction accuracy when covariates were considered using the parental phenotypic information, as opposed to marker information. Finally, our results empirically demonstrate that a significant improvement in prediction accuracy was gained by adding parental phenotypic information as covariates; however, this is expensive since, in many breeding programs, the parental phenotypic information is unavailable.
format Article
topic_facet AGRICULTURAL SCIENCES AND BIOTECHNOLOGY
Genomic Prediction
Parental Information
Prediction Accuracy
Correlated Traits
BREEDING
FORECASTING
WHEAT
GENOMICS
Genetic Resources
author Montesinos-Lopez, O.A.
Bentley, A.R.
Saint Pierre, C.
Crespo Herrera, L.A.
Salinas-Ruiz, J.
Valladares-Celis, P.C.
Montesinos-Lopez, A.
Crossa, J.
author_facet Montesinos-Lopez, O.A.
Bentley, A.R.
Saint Pierre, C.
Crespo Herrera, L.A.
Salinas-Ruiz, J.
Valladares-Celis, P.C.
Montesinos-Lopez, A.
Crossa, J.
author_sort Montesinos-Lopez, O.A.
title Integrating parental phenotypic data enhances prediction accuracy of hybrids in wheat traits
title_short Integrating parental phenotypic data enhances prediction accuracy of hybrids in wheat traits
title_full Integrating parental phenotypic data enhances prediction accuracy of hybrids in wheat traits
title_fullStr Integrating parental phenotypic data enhances prediction accuracy of hybrids in wheat traits
title_full_unstemmed Integrating parental phenotypic data enhances prediction accuracy of hybrids in wheat traits
title_sort integrating parental phenotypic data enhances prediction accuracy of hybrids in wheat traits
publisher MDPI
publishDate 2023
url https://hdl.handle.net/10883/22537
work_keys_str_mv AT montesinoslopezoa integratingparentalphenotypicdataenhancespredictionaccuracyofhybridsinwheattraits
AT bentleyar integratingparentalphenotypicdataenhancespredictionaccuracyofhybridsinwheattraits
AT saintpierrec integratingparentalphenotypicdataenhancespredictionaccuracyofhybridsinwheattraits
AT crespoherrerala integratingparentalphenotypicdataenhancespredictionaccuracyofhybridsinwheattraits
AT salinasruizj integratingparentalphenotypicdataenhancespredictionaccuracyofhybridsinwheattraits
AT valladarescelispc integratingparentalphenotypicdataenhancespredictionaccuracyofhybridsinwheattraits
AT montesinoslopeza integratingparentalphenotypicdataenhancespredictionaccuracyofhybridsinwheattraits
AT crossaj integratingparentalphenotypicdataenhancespredictionaccuracyofhybridsinwheattraits
_version_ 1787233019094892544