Gender gap in perspectives of the impacts of degradation and restoration on ecosystem services in Ethiopia

The importance of land restoration has garnered increasing attention on the global stage through large-scale initiatives such as the Bonn Challenge. However, policies and strategies are often gender-blind and designed in compliance with entrenched social hierarchies, exacerbating pre-existing social inequalities that affect restoration initiatives. The challenge of developing gender-responsive policies and initiatives is accentuated by a persistent lack of sex-disaggregated data concerning men's and women's differing perceptions and experiences. This study aims to help fill this gap by capturing the differences in men and women's perceptions of ecosystem services before and after restoration interventions in Ethiopia. Towards that end, in October 2021, we collected data from fifty-nine (59) paired husband-wife households and six gender-segregated focus group discussions in two regions of Ethiopia: Amhara and Southern Nations, and Nationalities and Peoples (SNNP). Kendall's concordance analysis established a strong degree of disagreement between men's and women's ratings of restoration outcomes for most indicators. Men attributed degradation to landscape conditions and natural forces, while women considered the lack of appropriate restoration strategies as a precursor for accelerated degradation. The study also reveals that men tended to benefit more than women from enhanced ecosystem services post-restoration, with increased labour and land management burdens often falling on the shoulders of women. Based on these findings, we argue that including men's and women's perspectives from the earliest planning phases of restoration initiatives is essential to ensure greater equity in benefit-sharing, mitigate trade-offs for women, and build more nuanced, just and successful approaches to restoration.

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Mponela, Powell, Aynekulu, Ermias, Ebrahim, Mohammed, Abate, Tsion, Abera, Wuletawu, Zaremba, Haley, Elias, Marlène, Tamene, Lulseged D
Format: Journal Article biblioteca
Language:English
Published: Wiley 2023-09
Subjects:ecosystem services, gender, landscape restoration, degradation, development,
Online Access:https://hdl.handle.net/10568/130611
https://doi.org/10.1002/ldr.4764
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
id dig-cgspace-10568-130611
record_format koha
spelling dig-cgspace-10568-1306112023-10-05T14:49:38Z Gender gap in perspectives of the impacts of degradation and restoration on ecosystem services in Ethiopia Mponela, Powell Aynekulu, Ermias Ebrahim, Mohammed Abate, Tsion Abera, Wuletawu Zaremba, Haley Elias, Marlène Tamene, Lulseged D ecosystem services gender landscape restoration degradation development The importance of land restoration has garnered increasing attention on the global stage through large-scale initiatives such as the Bonn Challenge. However, policies and strategies are often gender-blind and designed in compliance with entrenched social hierarchies, exacerbating pre-existing social inequalities that affect restoration initiatives. The challenge of developing gender-responsive policies and initiatives is accentuated by a persistent lack of sex-disaggregated data concerning men's and women's differing perceptions and experiences. This study aims to help fill this gap by capturing the differences in men and women's perceptions of ecosystem services before and after restoration interventions in Ethiopia. Towards that end, in October 2021, we collected data from fifty-nine (59) paired husband-wife households and six gender-segregated focus group discussions in two regions of Ethiopia: Amhara and Southern Nations, and Nationalities and Peoples (SNNP). Kendall's concordance analysis established a strong degree of disagreement between men's and women's ratings of restoration outcomes for most indicators. Men attributed degradation to landscape conditions and natural forces, while women considered the lack of appropriate restoration strategies as a precursor for accelerated degradation. The study also reveals that men tended to benefit more than women from enhanced ecosystem services post-restoration, with increased labour and land management burdens often falling on the shoulders of women. Based on these findings, we argue that including men's and women's perspectives from the earliest planning phases of restoration initiatives is essential to ensure greater equity in benefit-sharing, mitigate trade-offs for women, and build more nuanced, just and successful approaches to restoration. 2023-09 2023-06-02T16:56:34Z 2023-06-02T16:56:34Z Journal Article Mponela P, Aynekulu E, Ebrahim M, Abate T, Abera W, Zaremba H, Elias M, Tamene L. 2023. Gender gap in perspectives of the impacts of degradation and restoration on ecosystem services in Ethiopia. Land Degradation and Development 1–14. 1099-145X https://hdl.handle.net/10568/130611 https://doi.org/10.1002/ldr.4764 en CC-BY-4.0 Open Access 1-14 Wiley Land Degradation and Development
institution CGIAR
collection DSpace
country Francia
countrycode FR
component Bibliográfico
access En linea
databasecode dig-cgspace
tag biblioteca
region Europa del Oeste
libraryname Biblioteca del CGIAR
language English
topic ecosystem services
gender
landscape restoration
degradation
development
ecosystem services
gender
landscape restoration
degradation
development
spellingShingle ecosystem services
gender
landscape restoration
degradation
development
ecosystem services
gender
landscape restoration
degradation
development
Mponela, Powell
Aynekulu, Ermias
Ebrahim, Mohammed
Abate, Tsion
Abera, Wuletawu
Zaremba, Haley
Elias, Marlène
Tamene, Lulseged D
Gender gap in perspectives of the impacts of degradation and restoration on ecosystem services in Ethiopia
description The importance of land restoration has garnered increasing attention on the global stage through large-scale initiatives such as the Bonn Challenge. However, policies and strategies are often gender-blind and designed in compliance with entrenched social hierarchies, exacerbating pre-existing social inequalities that affect restoration initiatives. The challenge of developing gender-responsive policies and initiatives is accentuated by a persistent lack of sex-disaggregated data concerning men's and women's differing perceptions and experiences. This study aims to help fill this gap by capturing the differences in men and women's perceptions of ecosystem services before and after restoration interventions in Ethiopia. Towards that end, in October 2021, we collected data from fifty-nine (59) paired husband-wife households and six gender-segregated focus group discussions in two regions of Ethiopia: Amhara and Southern Nations, and Nationalities and Peoples (SNNP). Kendall's concordance analysis established a strong degree of disagreement between men's and women's ratings of restoration outcomes for most indicators. Men attributed degradation to landscape conditions and natural forces, while women considered the lack of appropriate restoration strategies as a precursor for accelerated degradation. The study also reveals that men tended to benefit more than women from enhanced ecosystem services post-restoration, with increased labour and land management burdens often falling on the shoulders of women. Based on these findings, we argue that including men's and women's perspectives from the earliest planning phases of restoration initiatives is essential to ensure greater equity in benefit-sharing, mitigate trade-offs for women, and build more nuanced, just and successful approaches to restoration.
format Journal Article
topic_facet ecosystem services
gender
landscape restoration
degradation
development
author Mponela, Powell
Aynekulu, Ermias
Ebrahim, Mohammed
Abate, Tsion
Abera, Wuletawu
Zaremba, Haley
Elias, Marlène
Tamene, Lulseged D
author_facet Mponela, Powell
Aynekulu, Ermias
Ebrahim, Mohammed
Abate, Tsion
Abera, Wuletawu
Zaremba, Haley
Elias, Marlène
Tamene, Lulseged D
author_sort Mponela, Powell
title Gender gap in perspectives of the impacts of degradation and restoration on ecosystem services in Ethiopia
title_short Gender gap in perspectives of the impacts of degradation and restoration on ecosystem services in Ethiopia
title_full Gender gap in perspectives of the impacts of degradation and restoration on ecosystem services in Ethiopia
title_fullStr Gender gap in perspectives of the impacts of degradation and restoration on ecosystem services in Ethiopia
title_full_unstemmed Gender gap in perspectives of the impacts of degradation and restoration on ecosystem services in Ethiopia
title_sort gender gap in perspectives of the impacts of degradation and restoration on ecosystem services in ethiopia
publisher Wiley
publishDate 2023-09
url https://hdl.handle.net/10568/130611
https://doi.org/10.1002/ldr.4764
work_keys_str_mv AT mponelapowell gendergapinperspectivesoftheimpactsofdegradationandrestorationonecosystemservicesinethiopia
AT aynekuluermias gendergapinperspectivesoftheimpactsofdegradationandrestorationonecosystemservicesinethiopia
AT ebrahimmohammed gendergapinperspectivesoftheimpactsofdegradationandrestorationonecosystemservicesinethiopia
AT abatetsion gendergapinperspectivesoftheimpactsofdegradationandrestorationonecosystemservicesinethiopia
AT aberawuletawu gendergapinperspectivesoftheimpactsofdegradationandrestorationonecosystemservicesinethiopia
AT zarembahaley gendergapinperspectivesoftheimpactsofdegradationandrestorationonecosystemservicesinethiopia
AT eliasmarlene gendergapinperspectivesoftheimpactsofdegradationandrestorationonecosystemservicesinethiopia
AT tamenelulsegedd gendergapinperspectivesoftheimpactsofdegradationandrestorationonecosystemservicesinethiopia
_version_ 1781882295557292032