How Accurately are Household Surveys Measuring the Size and Inequalities for the LGBT Population in Bogota, Colombia? Evidence from a List Experiment
This paper studies whether household surveys precisely identify the LGBT population and are suitable to measure labor market discrimination in Colombia. We first quantify the size of the LGBT population and estimate labor market inequalities from these data, highlighting potential pitfalls from using this approach. We then present findings from a list experiment in Bogotá, Colombia. Results show that household surveys underestimate the size of the LGBT population and may yield biased estimates of labor market inequalities. While survey estimates range between 1-4%, we find that LGBT people constitutes around 12-22% of the total population. We find heterogeneous reporting by sex, age groups, educational attainment, and marital status. Our findings suggest that while current measurement practices are a step forward for the LGBT populations statistical visibility, additional steps are required before household surveys may be used to consistently estimate discrimination and guide policy responses to protect this population.
Main Author: | |
---|---|
Other Authors: | |
Language: | English |
Published: |
Inter-American Development Bank
|
Subjects: | Labor Market Outcome, LGBT, Household Survey, Gender Identity, Women, Equality, Labor Market, Population Aging, Gender Discrimination, C90 - Design of Experiments: General, D10 - Household Behavior and Family Economics: General, J10 - Demographic Economics: General, J21 - Labor Force and Employment Size and Structure, J70 - Labor Discrimination: General, population;measurement;discrimination;household surveys;list experiment;LGBT population, |
Online Access: | http://dx.doi.org/10.18235/0004721 https://publications.iadb.org/en/how-accurately-are-household-surveys-measuring-size-and-inequalities-lgbt-population-bogota |
Tags: |
Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
|
id |
dig-bid-node-33261 |
---|---|
record_format |
koha |
spelling |
dig-bid-node-332612023-03-13T21:54:01ZHow Accurately are Household Surveys Measuring the Size and Inequalities for the LGBT Population in Bogota, Colombia? Evidence from a List Experiment 2023-01-30T00:01:00+0000 http://dx.doi.org/10.18235/0004721 https://publications.iadb.org/en/how-accurately-are-household-surveys-measuring-size-and-inequalities-lgbt-population-bogota Inter-American Development Bank Labor Market Outcome LGBT Household Survey Gender Identity Women Equality Labor Market Population Aging Gender Discrimination C90 - Design of Experiments: General D10 - Household Behavior and Family Economics: General J10 - Demographic Economics: General J21 - Labor Force and Employment Size and Structure J70 - Labor Discrimination: General population;measurement;discrimination;household surveys;list experiment;LGBT population This paper studies whether household surveys precisely identify the LGBT population and are suitable to measure labor market discrimination in Colombia. We first quantify the size of the LGBT population and estimate labor market inequalities from these data, highlighting potential pitfalls from using this approach. We then present findings from a list experiment in Bogotá, Colombia. Results show that household surveys underestimate the size of the LGBT population and may yield biased estimates of labor market inequalities. While survey estimates range between 1-4%, we find that LGBT people constitutes around 12-22% of the total population. We find heterogeneous reporting by sex, age groups, educational attainment, and marital status. Our findings suggest that while current measurement practices are a step forward for the LGBT populations statistical visibility, additional steps are required before household surveys may be used to consistently estimate discrimination and guide policy responses to protect this population. Inter-American Development Bank Andrés Ham Angela Guarin Juanita Ruiz Monserrat Bustelo Verónica Frisancho Karen Martinez IDB Publications Colombia Latin America and the Caribbean en |
institution |
BID |
collection |
DSpace |
country |
Estados Unidos |
countrycode |
US |
component |
Bibliográfico |
access |
En linea |
databasecode |
dig-bid |
tag |
biblioteca |
region |
America del Norte |
libraryname |
Biblioteca Felipe Herrera del BID |
language |
English |
topic |
Labor Market Outcome LGBT Household Survey Gender Identity Women Equality Labor Market Population Aging Gender Discrimination C90 - Design of Experiments: General D10 - Household Behavior and Family Economics: General J10 - Demographic Economics: General J21 - Labor Force and Employment Size and Structure J70 - Labor Discrimination: General population;measurement;discrimination;household surveys;list experiment;LGBT population Labor Market Outcome LGBT Household Survey Gender Identity Women Equality Labor Market Population Aging Gender Discrimination C90 - Design of Experiments: General D10 - Household Behavior and Family Economics: General J10 - Demographic Economics: General J21 - Labor Force and Employment Size and Structure J70 - Labor Discrimination: General population;measurement;discrimination;household surveys;list experiment;LGBT population |
spellingShingle |
Labor Market Outcome LGBT Household Survey Gender Identity Women Equality Labor Market Population Aging Gender Discrimination C90 - Design of Experiments: General D10 - Household Behavior and Family Economics: General J10 - Demographic Economics: General J21 - Labor Force and Employment Size and Structure J70 - Labor Discrimination: General population;measurement;discrimination;household surveys;list experiment;LGBT population Labor Market Outcome LGBT Household Survey Gender Identity Women Equality Labor Market Population Aging Gender Discrimination C90 - Design of Experiments: General D10 - Household Behavior and Family Economics: General J10 - Demographic Economics: General J21 - Labor Force and Employment Size and Structure J70 - Labor Discrimination: General population;measurement;discrimination;household surveys;list experiment;LGBT population Inter-American Development Bank How Accurately are Household Surveys Measuring the Size and Inequalities for the LGBT Population in Bogota, Colombia? Evidence from a List Experiment |
description |
This paper studies whether household surveys precisely identify the LGBT population and are suitable to measure labor market discrimination in Colombia. We first quantify the size of the LGBT population and estimate labor market inequalities from these data, highlighting potential pitfalls from using this approach. We then present findings from a list experiment in Bogotá, Colombia. Results show that household surveys underestimate the size of the LGBT population and may yield biased estimates of labor market inequalities. While survey estimates range between 1-4%, we find that LGBT people constitutes around 12-22% of the total population. We find heterogeneous reporting by sex, age groups, educational attainment, and marital status. Our findings suggest that while current measurement practices are a step forward for the LGBT populations statistical visibility, additional steps are required before household surveys may be used to consistently estimate discrimination and guide policy responses to protect this population. |
author2 |
Andrés Ham |
author_facet |
Andrés Ham Inter-American Development Bank |
topic_facet |
Labor Market Outcome LGBT Household Survey Gender Identity Women Equality Labor Market Population Aging Gender Discrimination C90 - Design of Experiments: General D10 - Household Behavior and Family Economics: General J10 - Demographic Economics: General J21 - Labor Force and Employment Size and Structure J70 - Labor Discrimination: General population;measurement;discrimination;household surveys;list experiment;LGBT population |
author |
Inter-American Development Bank |
author_sort |
Inter-American Development Bank |
title |
How Accurately are Household Surveys Measuring the Size and Inequalities for the LGBT Population in Bogota, Colombia? Evidence from a List Experiment |
title_short |
How Accurately are Household Surveys Measuring the Size and Inequalities for the LGBT Population in Bogota, Colombia? Evidence from a List Experiment |
title_full |
How Accurately are Household Surveys Measuring the Size and Inequalities for the LGBT Population in Bogota, Colombia? Evidence from a List Experiment |
title_fullStr |
How Accurately are Household Surveys Measuring the Size and Inequalities for the LGBT Population in Bogota, Colombia? Evidence from a List Experiment |
title_full_unstemmed |
How Accurately are Household Surveys Measuring the Size and Inequalities for the LGBT Population in Bogota, Colombia? Evidence from a List Experiment |
title_sort |
how accurately are household surveys measuring the size and inequalities for the lgbt population in bogota, colombia? evidence from a list experiment |
publisher |
Inter-American Development Bank |
url |
http://dx.doi.org/10.18235/0004721 https://publications.iadb.org/en/how-accurately-are-household-surveys-measuring-size-and-inequalities-lgbt-population-bogota |
work_keys_str_mv |
AT interamericandevelopmentbank howaccuratelyarehouseholdsurveysmeasuringthesizeandinequalitiesforthelgbtpopulationinbogotacolombiaevidencefromalistexperiment |
_version_ |
1809108387285172224 |