Will an exotic, competitive egg parasitoid displace a native larval parasitoid?

Fopius arisanus Soman (Hymenoptera: Braconidae) is a generalist tephritid egg parasitoid from the Indo-Pacific region introduced to Brazil in 2012 to control the exotic fruit fly pest Bactrocera carambolae Drew & Hancock (Diptera: Tephritidae) in the northern region. Doryctobracon areolatus Szépligeti (Hymenoptera: Braconidae) is a native generalist parasitoid of second instar larval fruit flies from Central and South America. Because both species of fruit fly parasitoids share some genera of fruit fly hosts, we evaluated if the commercial release of F. arisanus could cause adverse effects (e.g., competitive displacement) on the native parasitoid. Host preference and competitive ability were compared using as hosts the native Anastrepha fraterculus Wiedemann (Diptera: Tephritidae) and the exotic Ceratitis capitata Wiedemann (Diptera: Tephritidae) fruit fly species. To evaluate host preference, choice and no-choice experiments were conducted with lines of F. arisanus reared from each of the hosts. Laboratory studies showed that F. arisanus accepted only 2-3% of the native hosts compared to 34-41% of the exotic hosts under no choice conditions, with similar results when given a choice of native and exotic hosts. The field cage choice study showed similar results when F. arisanus was reared on the exotic host, but when reared on the native host, F. arisanus parasitized more of the native host than when reared on the exotic host. However, both lines of the parasitoid preferred the exotic host. To evaluate competitive ability, experiments with both species together and separate were conducted in the laboratory and in field cages. Both experiments showed that F. arisanus had no measurable detrimental effect on the native parasitoid in either the native or exotic host. Indeed, the native parasitoid was consistently the superior competitor in native host even though it parasitized larvae while F. arisanus is an egg parasitoid. These results indicated that F. arisanus interacted minimally with the native parasitoid on the native host, and while it interacted with the native parasitoid on the exotic host, it did not detrimentally affect it. Thus, F. arisanus is unlikely to cause adverse effects on the native parasitoid, D. areolatus in Brazil.

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: PARANHOS, B. A. G., NAVA, D. E., SÁ, L. A., NICHOLAS, N., MORELLI, R., PONCIO, S.
Other Authors: BEATRIZ AGUIAR GIORDANO PARANHOS, CPATSA
Format: Anais e Proceedings de eventos biblioteca
Language:Ingles
English
Published: In: INTERNATIONAL CONGRESS OF ENTOMOLOGY,, 26., 2022, Helsinki. Entomology for our planet: book of abstracts. Kuopio: UEF, 2022. 2023-01-23
Subjects:Hospedeiros nativos, Mosca das Frutas, Ceratitis Capitata, Praga, Insects, Fopius arisanus,
Online Access:http://www.alice.cnptia.embrapa.br/alice/handle/doc/1151146
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
id dig-alice-doc-1151146
record_format koha
spelling dig-alice-doc-11511462023-01-23T15:01:20Z Will an exotic, competitive egg parasitoid displace a native larval parasitoid? PARANHOS, B. A. G. NAVA, D. E. SÁ, L. A. NICHOLAS, N. MORELLI, R. PONCIO, S. BEATRIZ AGUIAR GIORDANO PARANHOS, CPATSA Hospedeiros nativos Mosca das Frutas Ceratitis Capitata Praga Insects Fopius arisanus Fopius arisanus Soman (Hymenoptera: Braconidae) is a generalist tephritid egg parasitoid from the Indo-Pacific region introduced to Brazil in 2012 to control the exotic fruit fly pest Bactrocera carambolae Drew & Hancock (Diptera: Tephritidae) in the northern region. Doryctobracon areolatus Szépligeti (Hymenoptera: Braconidae) is a native generalist parasitoid of second instar larval fruit flies from Central and South America. Because both species of fruit fly parasitoids share some genera of fruit fly hosts, we evaluated if the commercial release of F. arisanus could cause adverse effects (e.g., competitive displacement) on the native parasitoid. Host preference and competitive ability were compared using as hosts the native Anastrepha fraterculus Wiedemann (Diptera: Tephritidae) and the exotic Ceratitis capitata Wiedemann (Diptera: Tephritidae) fruit fly species. To evaluate host preference, choice and no-choice experiments were conducted with lines of F. arisanus reared from each of the hosts. Laboratory studies showed that F. arisanus accepted only 2-3% of the native hosts compared to 34-41% of the exotic hosts under no choice conditions, with similar results when given a choice of native and exotic hosts. The field cage choice study showed similar results when F. arisanus was reared on the exotic host, but when reared on the native host, F. arisanus parasitized more of the native host than when reared on the exotic host. However, both lines of the parasitoid preferred the exotic host. To evaluate competitive ability, experiments with both species together and separate were conducted in the laboratory and in field cages. Both experiments showed that F. arisanus had no measurable detrimental effect on the native parasitoid in either the native or exotic host. Indeed, the native parasitoid was consistently the superior competitor in native host even though it parasitized larvae while F. arisanus is an egg parasitoid. These results indicated that F. arisanus interacted minimally with the native parasitoid on the native host, and while it interacted with the native parasitoid on the exotic host, it did not detrimentally affect it. Thus, F. arisanus is unlikely to cause adverse effects on the native parasitoid, D. areolatus in Brazil. Edited by Heikki M. T. Hokkanen; Ingeborg Menzler-Hokkanen. 2023-01-23T15:01:20Z 2023-01-23T15:01:20Z 2023-01-23 2022 Anais e Proceedings de eventos http://www.alice.cnptia.embrapa.br/alice/handle/doc/1151146 Ingles en openAccess p. 602. In: INTERNATIONAL CONGRESS OF ENTOMOLOGY,, 26., 2022, Helsinki. Entomology for our planet: book of abstracts. Kuopio: UEF, 2022.
institution EMBRAPA
collection DSpace
country Brasil
countrycode BR
component Bibliográfico
access En linea
databasecode dig-alice
tag biblioteca
region America del Sur
libraryname Sistema de bibliotecas de EMBRAPA
language Ingles
English
topic Hospedeiros nativos
Mosca das Frutas
Ceratitis Capitata
Praga
Insects
Fopius arisanus
Hospedeiros nativos
Mosca das Frutas
Ceratitis Capitata
Praga
Insects
Fopius arisanus
spellingShingle Hospedeiros nativos
Mosca das Frutas
Ceratitis Capitata
Praga
Insects
Fopius arisanus
Hospedeiros nativos
Mosca das Frutas
Ceratitis Capitata
Praga
Insects
Fopius arisanus
PARANHOS, B. A. G.
NAVA, D. E.
SÁ, L. A.
NICHOLAS, N.
MORELLI, R.
PONCIO, S.
Will an exotic, competitive egg parasitoid displace a native larval parasitoid?
description Fopius arisanus Soman (Hymenoptera: Braconidae) is a generalist tephritid egg parasitoid from the Indo-Pacific region introduced to Brazil in 2012 to control the exotic fruit fly pest Bactrocera carambolae Drew & Hancock (Diptera: Tephritidae) in the northern region. Doryctobracon areolatus Szépligeti (Hymenoptera: Braconidae) is a native generalist parasitoid of second instar larval fruit flies from Central and South America. Because both species of fruit fly parasitoids share some genera of fruit fly hosts, we evaluated if the commercial release of F. arisanus could cause adverse effects (e.g., competitive displacement) on the native parasitoid. Host preference and competitive ability were compared using as hosts the native Anastrepha fraterculus Wiedemann (Diptera: Tephritidae) and the exotic Ceratitis capitata Wiedemann (Diptera: Tephritidae) fruit fly species. To evaluate host preference, choice and no-choice experiments were conducted with lines of F. arisanus reared from each of the hosts. Laboratory studies showed that F. arisanus accepted only 2-3% of the native hosts compared to 34-41% of the exotic hosts under no choice conditions, with similar results when given a choice of native and exotic hosts. The field cage choice study showed similar results when F. arisanus was reared on the exotic host, but when reared on the native host, F. arisanus parasitized more of the native host than when reared on the exotic host. However, both lines of the parasitoid preferred the exotic host. To evaluate competitive ability, experiments with both species together and separate were conducted in the laboratory and in field cages. Both experiments showed that F. arisanus had no measurable detrimental effect on the native parasitoid in either the native or exotic host. Indeed, the native parasitoid was consistently the superior competitor in native host even though it parasitized larvae while F. arisanus is an egg parasitoid. These results indicated that F. arisanus interacted minimally with the native parasitoid on the native host, and while it interacted with the native parasitoid on the exotic host, it did not detrimentally affect it. Thus, F. arisanus is unlikely to cause adverse effects on the native parasitoid, D. areolatus in Brazil.
author2 BEATRIZ AGUIAR GIORDANO PARANHOS, CPATSA
author_facet BEATRIZ AGUIAR GIORDANO PARANHOS, CPATSA
PARANHOS, B. A. G.
NAVA, D. E.
SÁ, L. A.
NICHOLAS, N.
MORELLI, R.
PONCIO, S.
format Anais e Proceedings de eventos
topic_facet Hospedeiros nativos
Mosca das Frutas
Ceratitis Capitata
Praga
Insects
Fopius arisanus
author PARANHOS, B. A. G.
NAVA, D. E.
SÁ, L. A.
NICHOLAS, N.
MORELLI, R.
PONCIO, S.
author_sort PARANHOS, B. A. G.
title Will an exotic, competitive egg parasitoid displace a native larval parasitoid?
title_short Will an exotic, competitive egg parasitoid displace a native larval parasitoid?
title_full Will an exotic, competitive egg parasitoid displace a native larval parasitoid?
title_fullStr Will an exotic, competitive egg parasitoid displace a native larval parasitoid?
title_full_unstemmed Will an exotic, competitive egg parasitoid displace a native larval parasitoid?
title_sort will an exotic, competitive egg parasitoid displace a native larval parasitoid?
publisher In: INTERNATIONAL CONGRESS OF ENTOMOLOGY,, 26., 2022, Helsinki. Entomology for our planet: book of abstracts. Kuopio: UEF, 2022.
publishDate 2023-01-23
url http://www.alice.cnptia.embrapa.br/alice/handle/doc/1151146
work_keys_str_mv AT paranhosbag willanexoticcompetitiveeggparasitoiddisplaceanativelarvalparasitoid
AT navade willanexoticcompetitiveeggparasitoiddisplaceanativelarvalparasitoid
AT sala willanexoticcompetitiveeggparasitoiddisplaceanativelarvalparasitoid
AT nicholasn willanexoticcompetitiveeggparasitoiddisplaceanativelarvalparasitoid
AT morellir willanexoticcompetitiveeggparasitoiddisplaceanativelarvalparasitoid
AT poncios willanexoticcompetitiveeggparasitoiddisplaceanativelarvalparasitoid
_version_ 1756029008152100864