True insights or ticking boxes?. Rapid assessment of rights-based management in artisanal fisheries

Rights-based fisheries management (RBFM) seeks to create market incentives to reduce competition, avoid overexploitation, and increase economic efficiency. Particularly for artisanal fisheries, however, assumptions of RBFM may not be met and its use needs to be carefully considered. This study applies an existing tool (SEASALT) to evaluate the strength of RBFM based on attributes of security, exclusivity, fish mortality, scale, responsibility, limitations, and transferability. Results for 17 fisheries in Mexico show a positive (nonsignificant) relationship between the strength of RBFM and stock status, and no effect on prices or landed value. Real-world fisheries governance systems are much more complex than the simple linkages between attributes implied in SEASALT, but results highlight pre-existing monitoring and enforcement capacity as essential for successful RBFM. Transitions to RBFM may strengthen this capacity, but likely cannot create it where it does not already exist. Based on our find-ings, RBFM strategies may benefit from group quotas with limited transferability to avoid negative social outcomes from consolidation or rent capture by intermediaries; this could potentially build on the latent capacity of traditional community associa-tions common in many artisanal fisheries.

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Cisneros Montemayor, Andrés M. autor, Aceves Bueno, Eréndira autora, Amezcua Castro, Sergio autor, Apolinar Romo, Alejandra autora, Cisneros Soberanis, Frida autora, Cuevas Gómez, Gabriela Alejandra Maestra autora 15729, Cruz León, Ingrid C. autora, De La Cruz González, Javier autor, Espinoza Tenorio, Alejandro Doctor autor 12322, García Lozano, Alejandro autor, González Espinosa, Pedro C. autor, Cisneros Mata, Miguel A. autor
Format: Texto biblioteca
Language:eng
Subjects:Pesca artesanal, Gestión pesquera basada en derechos, Administración de la industria pesquera, Derechos de propiedad, Desarrollo económico,
Online Access:https://doi.org/10.1111/fme.12627
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
id KOHA-OAI-ECOSUR:64273
record_format koha
spelling KOHA-OAI-ECOSUR:642732024-03-12T12:56:26ZTrue insights or ticking boxes?. Rapid assessment of rights-based management in artisanal fisheries Cisneros Montemayor, Andrés M. autor Aceves Bueno, Eréndira autora Amezcua Castro, Sergio autor Apolinar Romo, Alejandra autora Cisneros Soberanis, Frida autora Cuevas Gómez, Gabriela Alejandra Maestra autora 15729 Cruz León, Ingrid C. autora De La Cruz González, Javier autor Espinoza Tenorio, Alejandro Doctor autor 12322 García Lozano, Alejandro autor González Espinosa, Pedro C. autor Cisneros Mata, Miguel A. autor textengRights-based fisheries management (RBFM) seeks to create market incentives to reduce competition, avoid overexploitation, and increase economic efficiency. Particularly for artisanal fisheries, however, assumptions of RBFM may not be met and its use needs to be carefully considered. This study applies an existing tool (SEASALT) to evaluate the strength of RBFM based on attributes of security, exclusivity, fish mortality, scale, responsibility, limitations, and transferability. Results for 17 fisheries in Mexico show a positive (nonsignificant) relationship between the strength of RBFM and stock status, and no effect on prices or landed value. Real-world fisheries governance systems are much more complex than the simple linkages between attributes implied in SEASALT, but results highlight pre-existing monitoring and enforcement capacity as essential for successful RBFM. Transitions to RBFM may strengthen this capacity, but likely cannot create it where it does not already exist. Based on our find-ings, RBFM strategies may benefit from group quotas with limited transferability to avoid negative social outcomes from consolidation or rent capture by intermediaries; this could potentially build on the latent capacity of traditional community associa-tions common in many artisanal fisheries.Rights-based fisheries management (RBFM) seeks to create market incentives to reduce competition, avoid overexploitation, and increase economic efficiency. Particularly for artisanal fisheries, however, assumptions of RBFM may not be met and its use needs to be carefully considered. This study applies an existing tool (SEASALT) to evaluate the strength of RBFM based on attributes of security, exclusivity, fish mortality, scale, responsibility, limitations, and transferability. Results for 17 fisheries in Mexico show a positive (nonsignificant) relationship between the strength of RBFM and stock status, and no effect on prices or landed value. Real-world fisheries governance systems are much more complex than the simple linkages between attributes implied in SEASALT, but results highlight pre-existing monitoring and enforcement capacity as essential for successful RBFM. Transitions to RBFM may strengthen this capacity, but likely cannot create it where it does not already exist. Based on our find-ings, RBFM strategies may benefit from group quotas with limited transferability to avoid negative social outcomes from consolidation or rent capture by intermediaries; this could potentially build on the latent capacity of traditional community associa-tions common in many artisanal fisheries.Pesca artesanalGestión pesquera basada en derechosAdministración de la industria pesqueraDerechos de propiedadDesarrollo económicoFisheries Management and Ecologyhttps://doi.org/10.1111/fme.12627Acceso en línea sin restricciones
institution ECOSUR
collection Koha
country México
countrycode MX
component Bibliográfico
access En linea
En linea
databasecode cat-ecosur
tag biblioteca
region America del Norte
libraryname Sistema de Información Bibliotecario de ECOSUR (SIBE)
language eng
topic Pesca artesanal
Gestión pesquera basada en derechos
Administración de la industria pesquera
Derechos de propiedad
Desarrollo económico
Pesca artesanal
Gestión pesquera basada en derechos
Administración de la industria pesquera
Derechos de propiedad
Desarrollo económico
spellingShingle Pesca artesanal
Gestión pesquera basada en derechos
Administración de la industria pesquera
Derechos de propiedad
Desarrollo económico
Pesca artesanal
Gestión pesquera basada en derechos
Administración de la industria pesquera
Derechos de propiedad
Desarrollo económico
Cisneros Montemayor, Andrés M. autor
Aceves Bueno, Eréndira autora
Amezcua Castro, Sergio autor
Apolinar Romo, Alejandra autora
Cisneros Soberanis, Frida autora
Cuevas Gómez, Gabriela Alejandra Maestra autora 15729
Cruz León, Ingrid C. autora
De La Cruz González, Javier autor
Espinoza Tenorio, Alejandro Doctor autor 12322
García Lozano, Alejandro autor
González Espinosa, Pedro C. autor
Cisneros Mata, Miguel A. autor
True insights or ticking boxes?. Rapid assessment of rights-based management in artisanal fisheries
description Rights-based fisheries management (RBFM) seeks to create market incentives to reduce competition, avoid overexploitation, and increase economic efficiency. Particularly for artisanal fisheries, however, assumptions of RBFM may not be met and its use needs to be carefully considered. This study applies an existing tool (SEASALT) to evaluate the strength of RBFM based on attributes of security, exclusivity, fish mortality, scale, responsibility, limitations, and transferability. Results for 17 fisheries in Mexico show a positive (nonsignificant) relationship between the strength of RBFM and stock status, and no effect on prices or landed value. Real-world fisheries governance systems are much more complex than the simple linkages between attributes implied in SEASALT, but results highlight pre-existing monitoring and enforcement capacity as essential for successful RBFM. Transitions to RBFM may strengthen this capacity, but likely cannot create it where it does not already exist. Based on our find-ings, RBFM strategies may benefit from group quotas with limited transferability to avoid negative social outcomes from consolidation or rent capture by intermediaries; this could potentially build on the latent capacity of traditional community associa-tions common in many artisanal fisheries.
format Texto
topic_facet Pesca artesanal
Gestión pesquera basada en derechos
Administración de la industria pesquera
Derechos de propiedad
Desarrollo económico
author Cisneros Montemayor, Andrés M. autor
Aceves Bueno, Eréndira autora
Amezcua Castro, Sergio autor
Apolinar Romo, Alejandra autora
Cisneros Soberanis, Frida autora
Cuevas Gómez, Gabriela Alejandra Maestra autora 15729
Cruz León, Ingrid C. autora
De La Cruz González, Javier autor
Espinoza Tenorio, Alejandro Doctor autor 12322
García Lozano, Alejandro autor
González Espinosa, Pedro C. autor
Cisneros Mata, Miguel A. autor
author_facet Cisneros Montemayor, Andrés M. autor
Aceves Bueno, Eréndira autora
Amezcua Castro, Sergio autor
Apolinar Romo, Alejandra autora
Cisneros Soberanis, Frida autora
Cuevas Gómez, Gabriela Alejandra Maestra autora 15729
Cruz León, Ingrid C. autora
De La Cruz González, Javier autor
Espinoza Tenorio, Alejandro Doctor autor 12322
García Lozano, Alejandro autor
González Espinosa, Pedro C. autor
Cisneros Mata, Miguel A. autor
author_sort Cisneros Montemayor, Andrés M. autor
title True insights or ticking boxes?. Rapid assessment of rights-based management in artisanal fisheries
title_short True insights or ticking boxes?. Rapid assessment of rights-based management in artisanal fisheries
title_full True insights or ticking boxes?. Rapid assessment of rights-based management in artisanal fisheries
title_fullStr True insights or ticking boxes?. Rapid assessment of rights-based management in artisanal fisheries
title_full_unstemmed True insights or ticking boxes?. Rapid assessment of rights-based management in artisanal fisheries
title_sort true insights or ticking boxes?. rapid assessment of rights-based management in artisanal fisheries
url https://doi.org/10.1111/fme.12627
work_keys_str_mv AT cisnerosmontemayorandresmautor trueinsightsortickingboxesrapidassessmentofrightsbasedmanagementinartisanalfisheries
AT acevesbuenoerendiraautora trueinsightsortickingboxesrapidassessmentofrightsbasedmanagementinartisanalfisheries
AT amezcuacastrosergioautor trueinsightsortickingboxesrapidassessmentofrightsbasedmanagementinartisanalfisheries
AT apolinarromoalejandraautora trueinsightsortickingboxesrapidassessmentofrightsbasedmanagementinartisanalfisheries
AT cisnerossoberanisfridaautora trueinsightsortickingboxesrapidassessmentofrightsbasedmanagementinartisanalfisheries
AT cuevasgomezgabrielaalejandramaestraautora15729 trueinsightsortickingboxesrapidassessmentofrightsbasedmanagementinartisanalfisheries
AT cruzleoningridcautora trueinsightsortickingboxesrapidassessmentofrightsbasedmanagementinartisanalfisheries
AT delacruzgonzalezjavierautor trueinsightsortickingboxesrapidassessmentofrightsbasedmanagementinartisanalfisheries
AT espinozatenorioalejandrodoctorautor12322 trueinsightsortickingboxesrapidassessmentofrightsbasedmanagementinartisanalfisheries
AT garcialozanoalejandroautor trueinsightsortickingboxesrapidassessmentofrightsbasedmanagementinartisanalfisheries
AT gonzalezespinosapedrocautor trueinsightsortickingboxesrapidassessmentofrightsbasedmanagementinartisanalfisheries
AT cisnerosmatamiguelaautor trueinsightsortickingboxesrapidassessmentofrightsbasedmanagementinartisanalfisheries
_version_ 1794792504239849472