Forest biometric systems in Mexico a systematic review of available models

Biometric systems are the basis of forest management and consist of a set of equations that describe the relationships between forest attributes and dendrometric variables. A systematic review of the state of the art of biometric systems in Mexico was carried out by a Mexican consortium (10 researchers), covering a period of 50 years ca (1970–2019), using the main scientific literature delivered by a systematic search (WoS, Scopus, Scielo, Redalyc) and a targeted search (theses, technical reports, etc.). A single selection criterion was established for the inclusion of information in the analysis: the document had to present at least one of the equations of interest. We found 376 documents containing 2524 equations for volume (69%), diameter (11%), height (9%) and site index (11%). These equations were developed for forest species mainly from temperate regions (88%), such as pine (66%) and oak (9%). Consequently, the Mexican states with the highest number of equations were Durango (28%), Chihuahua (17%), Hidalgo (13%) and Oaxaca (8%). Although large, the number of equations identified concentrated on a relatively small number of models: Schumacher & Hall and Fang et al. for volume; Chapman-Richards and Schumacher for site index and diameter; and Chapman-Richards and the allometric equation for height. An analysis of model fit, measured through R², showed that, on average, the volume, diameter and site index models show high fit (R² = 0.96), although this pattern was more consistent in the volume models. Publication bias was evaluated by means of a funnel plot analysis, with no apparent bias identified. A limitation of our study is that the information obtained is not updated to the present year; however, the 50-year trends allow us to assume that no recent significant changes in the patterns exist. Finally, we highlight the need to assess the predictive ability of the models to ensure accurate estimates to support better forest management decisions.

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: López Martínez, Jorge Omar Doctor autor 12315, Vargas Larreta, Benedicto autor 15120, González, Edgar J. autor, Corral Rivas, José Javier Doctor autor 15121, Aguirre Calderón, Oscar Alberto autor 15205, Treviño Garza, Eduardo Javier autor 15361, De los Santos Posada, Héctor Manuel autor 15210, Martínez Salvador, Martin autor, Zamudio Sánchez, Francisco José autor 15362, Aguirre Calderón, Cristóbal Gerardo autor
Format: Texto biblioteca
Language:eng
Subjects:Ecosistemas forestales, Ordenación forestal,
Online Access:https://www.mdpi.com/1999-4907/13/5/649
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
id KOHA-OAI-ECOSUR:62584
record_format koha
institution ECOSUR
collection Koha
country México
countrycode MX
component Bibliográfico
access En linea
En linea
databasecode cat-ecosur
tag biblioteca
region America del Norte
libraryname Sistema de Información Bibliotecario de ECOSUR (SIBE)
language eng
topic Ecosistemas forestales
Ordenación forestal
Ecosistemas forestales
Ordenación forestal
spellingShingle Ecosistemas forestales
Ordenación forestal
Ecosistemas forestales
Ordenación forestal
López Martínez, Jorge Omar Doctor autor 12315
Vargas Larreta, Benedicto autor 15120
González, Edgar J. autor
Corral Rivas, José Javier Doctor autor 15121
Aguirre Calderón, Oscar Alberto autor 15205
Treviño Garza, Eduardo Javier autor 15361
De los Santos Posada, Héctor Manuel autor 15210
Martínez Salvador, Martin autor
Zamudio Sánchez, Francisco José autor 15362
Aguirre Calderón, Cristóbal Gerardo autor
Forest biometric systems in Mexico a systematic review of available models
description Biometric systems are the basis of forest management and consist of a set of equations that describe the relationships between forest attributes and dendrometric variables. A systematic review of the state of the art of biometric systems in Mexico was carried out by a Mexican consortium (10 researchers), covering a period of 50 years ca (1970–2019), using the main scientific literature delivered by a systematic search (WoS, Scopus, Scielo, Redalyc) and a targeted search (theses, technical reports, etc.). A single selection criterion was established for the inclusion of information in the analysis: the document had to present at least one of the equations of interest. We found 376 documents containing 2524 equations for volume (69%), diameter (11%), height (9%) and site index (11%). These equations were developed for forest species mainly from temperate regions (88%), such as pine (66%) and oak (9%). Consequently, the Mexican states with the highest number of equations were Durango (28%), Chihuahua (17%), Hidalgo (13%) and Oaxaca (8%). Although large, the number of equations identified concentrated on a relatively small number of models: Schumacher & Hall and Fang et al. for volume; Chapman-Richards and Schumacher for site index and diameter; and Chapman-Richards and the allometric equation for height. An analysis of model fit, measured through R², showed that, on average, the volume, diameter and site index models show high fit (R² = 0.96), although this pattern was more consistent in the volume models. Publication bias was evaluated by means of a funnel plot analysis, with no apparent bias identified. A limitation of our study is that the information obtained is not updated to the present year; however, the 50-year trends allow us to assume that no recent significant changes in the patterns exist. Finally, we highlight the need to assess the predictive ability of the models to ensure accurate estimates to support better forest management decisions.
format Texto
topic_facet Ecosistemas forestales
Ordenación forestal
author López Martínez, Jorge Omar Doctor autor 12315
Vargas Larreta, Benedicto autor 15120
González, Edgar J. autor
Corral Rivas, José Javier Doctor autor 15121
Aguirre Calderón, Oscar Alberto autor 15205
Treviño Garza, Eduardo Javier autor 15361
De los Santos Posada, Héctor Manuel autor 15210
Martínez Salvador, Martin autor
Zamudio Sánchez, Francisco José autor 15362
Aguirre Calderón, Cristóbal Gerardo autor
author_facet López Martínez, Jorge Omar Doctor autor 12315
Vargas Larreta, Benedicto autor 15120
González, Edgar J. autor
Corral Rivas, José Javier Doctor autor 15121
Aguirre Calderón, Oscar Alberto autor 15205
Treviño Garza, Eduardo Javier autor 15361
De los Santos Posada, Héctor Manuel autor 15210
Martínez Salvador, Martin autor
Zamudio Sánchez, Francisco José autor 15362
Aguirre Calderón, Cristóbal Gerardo autor
author_sort López Martínez, Jorge Omar Doctor autor 12315
title Forest biometric systems in Mexico a systematic review of available models
title_short Forest biometric systems in Mexico a systematic review of available models
title_full Forest biometric systems in Mexico a systematic review of available models
title_fullStr Forest biometric systems in Mexico a systematic review of available models
title_full_unstemmed Forest biometric systems in Mexico a systematic review of available models
title_sort forest biometric systems in mexico a systematic review of available models
url https://www.mdpi.com/1999-4907/13/5/649
work_keys_str_mv AT lopezmartinezjorgeomardoctorautor12315 forestbiometricsystemsinmexicoasystematicreviewofavailablemodels
AT vargaslarretabenedictoautor15120 forestbiometricsystemsinmexicoasystematicreviewofavailablemodels
AT gonzalezedgarjautor forestbiometricsystemsinmexicoasystematicreviewofavailablemodels
AT corralrivasjosejavierdoctorautor15121 forestbiometricsystemsinmexicoasystematicreviewofavailablemodels
AT aguirrecalderonoscaralbertoautor15205 forestbiometricsystemsinmexicoasystematicreviewofavailablemodels
AT trevinogarzaeduardojavierautor15361 forestbiometricsystemsinmexicoasystematicreviewofavailablemodels
AT delossantosposadahectormanuelautor15210 forestbiometricsystemsinmexicoasystematicreviewofavailablemodels
AT martinezsalvadormartinautor forestbiometricsystemsinmexicoasystematicreviewofavailablemodels
AT zamudiosanchezfranciscojoseautor15362 forestbiometricsystemsinmexicoasystematicreviewofavailablemodels
AT aguirrecalderoncristobalgerardoautor forestbiometricsystemsinmexicoasystematicreviewofavailablemodels
_version_ 1794792339927990272
spelling KOHA-OAI-ECOSUR:625842024-03-11T15:22:47ZForest biometric systems in Mexico a systematic review of available models López Martínez, Jorge Omar Doctor autor 12315 Vargas Larreta, Benedicto autor 15120 González, Edgar J. autor Corral Rivas, José Javier Doctor autor 15121 Aguirre Calderón, Oscar Alberto autor 15205 Treviño Garza, Eduardo Javier autor 15361 De los Santos Posada, Héctor Manuel autor 15210 Martínez Salvador, Martin autor Zamudio Sánchez, Francisco José autor 15362 Aguirre Calderón, Cristóbal Gerardo autor textengBiometric systems are the basis of forest management and consist of a set of equations that describe the relationships between forest attributes and dendrometric variables. A systematic review of the state of the art of biometric systems in Mexico was carried out by a Mexican consortium (10 researchers), covering a period of 50 years ca (1970–2019), using the main scientific literature delivered by a systematic search (WoS, Scopus, Scielo, Redalyc) and a targeted search (theses, technical reports, etc.). A single selection criterion was established for the inclusion of information in the analysis: the document had to present at least one of the equations of interest. We found 376 documents containing 2524 equations for volume (69%), diameter (11%), height (9%) and site index (11%). These equations were developed for forest species mainly from temperate regions (88%), such as pine (66%) and oak (9%). Consequently, the Mexican states with the highest number of equations were Durango (28%), Chihuahua (17%), Hidalgo (13%) and Oaxaca (8%). Although large, the number of equations identified concentrated on a relatively small number of models: Schumacher & Hall and Fang et al. for volume; Chapman-Richards and Schumacher for site index and diameter; and Chapman-Richards and the allometric equation for height. An analysis of model fit, measured through R², showed that, on average, the volume, diameter and site index models show high fit (R² = 0.96), although this pattern was more consistent in the volume models. Publication bias was evaluated by means of a funnel plot analysis, with no apparent bias identified. A limitation of our study is that the information obtained is not updated to the present year; however, the 50-year trends allow us to assume that no recent significant changes in the patterns exist. Finally, we highlight the need to assess the predictive ability of the models to ensure accurate estimates to support better forest management decisions.Biometric systems are the basis of forest management and consist of a set of equations that describe the relationships between forest attributes and dendrometric variables. A systematic review of the state of the art of biometric systems in Mexico was carried out by a Mexican consortium (10 researchers), covering a period of 50 years ca (1970–2019), using the main scientific literature delivered by a systematic search (WoS, Scopus, Scielo, Redalyc) and a targeted search (theses, technical reports, etc.). A single selection criterion was established for the inclusion of information in the analysis: the document had to present at least one of the equations of interest. We found 376 documents containing 2524 equations for volume (69%), diameter (11%), height (9%) and site index (11%). These equations were developed for forest species mainly from temperate regions (88%), such as pine (66%) and oak (9%). Consequently, the Mexican states with the highest number of equations were Durango (28%), Chihuahua (17%), Hidalgo (13%) and Oaxaca (8%). Although large, the number of equations identified concentrated on a relatively small number of models: Schumacher & Hall and Fang et al. for volume; Chapman-Richards and Schumacher for site index and diameter; and Chapman-Richards and the allometric equation for height. An analysis of model fit, measured through R², showed that, on average, the volume, diameter and site index models show high fit (R² = 0.96), although this pattern was more consistent in the volume models. Publication bias was evaluated by means of a funnel plot analysis, with no apparent bias identified. A limitation of our study is that the information obtained is not updated to the present year; however, the 50-year trends allow us to assume that no recent significant changes in the patterns exist. Finally, we highlight the need to assess the predictive ability of the models to ensure accurate estimates to support better forest management decisions.Ecosistemas forestalesOrdenación forestalForestshttps://www.mdpi.com/1999-4907/13/5/649Acceso en línea sin restricciones