Potential effects in multi-resolution post-classification change detection

Change detection is one of the primary applications of remote-sensing data, and many techniques have been developed during the past three decades. Although frequently criticized and despite many alternatives, due to its simplicity and intuitive manner, post-classification change detection still remains one of the most applied techniques. Many studies in the field of change detection analysis acknowledge, for instance, the impact of misregistration, inconsistencies in classification schemes or differences in methods for image interpretation. However, there are additional, rarely studied influences that can cause large errors in change detection results, including integrating multi-resolution data, the adjacency effect and the minimum mapping units (MMUs) that are applied to the classification before change detection. This study demonstrates these effects for the complex land cover of the Alvarado mangrove area at the Mexican Gulf Coast, employing 10 m Système Pour l'Observation de la Terre 5 (SPOT-5) high geometric resolution (HRG)‐based and 57 m Landsat Multispectral Scanner (MSS) classifications. As a baseline, the proportion of the fine spatial resolution classes within the coarse spatial resolution cells were derived, from which proportional change matrices were computed.

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Colditz, René R., Acosta Velázquez, Joanna autor/a 12488, Reyes Díaz Gallegos, José Maestro autor/a 14145, Vázquez Lule, Alma Delia autor/a, Rodríguez Zúñiga, María Teresa autor/a, Maeda, Pedro autor/a, Cruz López, María Isabel autor/a, Ressl, Rainer autor/a
Format: Texto biblioteca
Language:eng
Subjects:Manglares, Evaluación del paisaje,
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
id KOHA-OAI-ECOSUR:51363
record_format koha
institution ECOSUR
collection Koha
country México
countrycode MX
component Bibliográfico
access En linea
databasecode cat-ecosur
tag biblioteca
region America del Norte
libraryname Sistema de Información Bibliotecario de ECOSUR (SIBE)
language eng
topic Manglares
Evaluación del paisaje
Manglares
Evaluación del paisaje
spellingShingle Manglares
Evaluación del paisaje
Manglares
Evaluación del paisaje
Colditz, René R.
Acosta Velázquez, Joanna autor/a 12488
Reyes Díaz Gallegos, José Maestro autor/a 14145
Vázquez Lule, Alma Delia autor/a
Rodríguez Zúñiga, María Teresa autor/a
Maeda, Pedro autor/a
Cruz López, María Isabel autor/a
Ressl, Rainer autor/a
Potential effects in multi-resolution post-classification change detection
description Change detection is one of the primary applications of remote-sensing data, and many techniques have been developed during the past three decades. Although frequently criticized and despite many alternatives, due to its simplicity and intuitive manner, post-classification change detection still remains one of the most applied techniques. Many studies in the field of change detection analysis acknowledge, for instance, the impact of misregistration, inconsistencies in classification schemes or differences in methods for image interpretation. However, there are additional, rarely studied influences that can cause large errors in change detection results, including integrating multi-resolution data, the adjacency effect and the minimum mapping units (MMUs) that are applied to the classification before change detection. This study demonstrates these effects for the complex land cover of the Alvarado mangrove area at the Mexican Gulf Coast, employing 10 m Système Pour l'Observation de la Terre 5 (SPOT-5) high geometric resolution (HRG)‐based and 57 m Landsat Multispectral Scanner (MSS) classifications. As a baseline, the proportion of the fine spatial resolution classes within the coarse spatial resolution cells were derived, from which proportional change matrices were computed.
format Texto
topic_facet Manglares
Evaluación del paisaje
author Colditz, René R.
Acosta Velázquez, Joanna autor/a 12488
Reyes Díaz Gallegos, José Maestro autor/a 14145
Vázquez Lule, Alma Delia autor/a
Rodríguez Zúñiga, María Teresa autor/a
Maeda, Pedro autor/a
Cruz López, María Isabel autor/a
Ressl, Rainer autor/a
author_facet Colditz, René R.
Acosta Velázquez, Joanna autor/a 12488
Reyes Díaz Gallegos, José Maestro autor/a 14145
Vázquez Lule, Alma Delia autor/a
Rodríguez Zúñiga, María Teresa autor/a
Maeda, Pedro autor/a
Cruz López, María Isabel autor/a
Ressl, Rainer autor/a
author_sort Colditz, René R.
title Potential effects in multi-resolution post-classification change detection
title_short Potential effects in multi-resolution post-classification change detection
title_full Potential effects in multi-resolution post-classification change detection
title_fullStr Potential effects in multi-resolution post-classification change detection
title_full_unstemmed Potential effects in multi-resolution post-classification change detection
title_sort potential effects in multi-resolution post-classification change detection
work_keys_str_mv AT colditzrener potentialeffectsinmultiresolutionpostclassificationchangedetection
AT acostavelazquezjoannaautora12488 potentialeffectsinmultiresolutionpostclassificationchangedetection
AT reyesdiazgallegosjosemaestroautora14145 potentialeffectsinmultiresolutionpostclassificationchangedetection
AT vazquezlulealmadeliaautora potentialeffectsinmultiresolutionpostclassificationchangedetection
AT rodriguezzunigamariateresaautora potentialeffectsinmultiresolutionpostclassificationchangedetection
AT maedapedroautora potentialeffectsinmultiresolutionpostclassificationchangedetection
AT cruzlopezmariaisabelautora potentialeffectsinmultiresolutionpostclassificationchangedetection
AT resslrainerautora potentialeffectsinmultiresolutionpostclassificationchangedetection
_version_ 1767598497571274752
spelling KOHA-OAI-ECOSUR:513632023-06-01T11:26:23ZPotential effects in multi-resolution post-classification change detection Colditz, René R. Acosta Velázquez, Joanna autor/a 12488 Reyes Díaz Gallegos, José Maestro autor/a 14145 Vázquez Lule, Alma Delia autor/a Rodríguez Zúñiga, María Teresa autor/a Maeda, Pedro autor/a Cruz López, María Isabel autor/a Ressl, Rainer autor/a textengChange detection is one of the primary applications of remote-sensing data, and many techniques have been developed during the past three decades. Although frequently criticized and despite many alternatives, due to its simplicity and intuitive manner, post-classification change detection still remains one of the most applied techniques. Many studies in the field of change detection analysis acknowledge, for instance, the impact of misregistration, inconsistencies in classification schemes or differences in methods for image interpretation. However, there are additional, rarely studied influences that can cause large errors in change detection results, including integrating multi-resolution data, the adjacency effect and the minimum mapping units (MMUs) that are applied to the classification before change detection. This study demonstrates these effects for the complex land cover of the Alvarado mangrove area at the Mexican Gulf Coast, employing 10 m Système Pour l'Observation de la Terre 5 (SPOT-5) high geometric resolution (HRG)‐based and 57 m Landsat Multispectral Scanner (MSS) classifications. As a baseline, the proportion of the fine spatial resolution classes within the coarse spatial resolution cells were derived, from which proportional change matrices were computed.The analysis employs difference measures to compare change matrices and proportional maps. The impact of various tested resampling functions was negligible if coarse resolution data were refined. For coarsening fine spatial resolution data, change matrix comparison was comparatively small but yielded differences of approximately 20% in spatially explicit measures. Incorrect positional alignment indicated differences of up to 5% in the change matrix for a misregistration of 100 m and even higher spatially explicit differences (28%). The discrepancies due to the adjacency effect were rather low. MMUs of 25 ha resulted in differences of up to 36% in the change matrix. The magnitude of the discrepancies of all studied effects depends on the class diversity in the map, and some can also be related to the difference in spatial resolution.Change detection is one of the primary applications of remote-sensing data, and many techniques have been developed during the past three decades. Although frequently criticized and despite many alternatives, due to its simplicity and intuitive manner, post-classification change detection still remains one of the most applied techniques. Many studies in the field of change detection analysis acknowledge, for instance, the impact of misregistration, inconsistencies in classification schemes or differences in methods for image interpretation. However, there are additional, rarely studied influences that can cause large errors in change detection results, including integrating multi-resolution data, the adjacency effect and the minimum mapping units (MMUs) that are applied to the classification before change detection. This study demonstrates these effects for the complex land cover of the Alvarado mangrove area at the Mexican Gulf Coast, employing 10 m Système Pour l'Observation de la Terre 5 (SPOT-5) high geometric resolution (HRG)‐based and 57 m Landsat Multispectral Scanner (MSS) classifications. As a baseline, the proportion of the fine spatial resolution classes within the coarse spatial resolution cells were derived, from which proportional change matrices were computed.The analysis employs difference measures to compare change matrices and proportional maps. The impact of various tested resampling functions was negligible if coarse resolution data were refined. For coarsening fine spatial resolution data, change matrix comparison was comparatively small but yielded differences of approximately 20% in spatially explicit measures. Incorrect positional alignment indicated differences of up to 5% in the change matrix for a misregistration of 100 m and even higher spatially explicit differences (28%). The discrepancies due to the adjacency effect were rather low. MMUs of 25 ha resulted in differences of up to 36% in the change matrix. The magnitude of the discrepancies of all studied effects depends on the class diversity in the map, and some can also be related to the difference in spatial resolution.Adobe Acrobat profesional 6.0 o superiorManglaresEvaluación del paisajeDisponible en líneaInternational Journal of Remote SensingDisponible para usuarios de ECOSUR con su clave de acceso