Is the naturally derived insecticide Spinosad® compatible with insect natural enemies?

Spinosad† (Dow Agrosciences) is a neurotoxic insecticide produced by fermentation of an actinomycete. Spinosad is classified as an environmentally and toxicologically reduced risk material and has been embraced by IPM practitioners as a biorational pesticide. We examined the available information on the impact of spinosad on natural enemies and classified mortality responses to spinosad using the IOBC laboratory and field scales that run from 1 (harmless) to 4 (harmful). In total, there were 228 observations on 52 species of natural enemies, of which 162 involved predators (27 species) and 66 involved parasitoids (25 species). Overall, 71% (42/ 59) of laboratory studies and 79% (81/103) of field-type studies on predators gave a class 1 result (not harmful). Hymenopteran parasitoids are significantly more susceptible to spinosad than predatory insects with 78% (35/45) of laboratory studies and 86% (18/21) of field-type studies returning a moderately harmful or harmful result. Predators generally suffer insignificant sub-lethal effects following exposure to spinosad, whereas parasitoids often show sub-lethal effects including loss of reproductive capacity, reduced longevity, etc. All studies agree that spinosad residues degrade quickly in the field, with little residual toxicity at 3 /7 days postapplication. We also examined the importance of route of exposure, species-specific and stagespecific susceptibility and we make recommendations for future studies. We conclude that for conservation of predator populations, spinosad represents one of the most judicious insecticides available but the use of this product should be evaluated carefully in situations where conservation of parasitoid populations is of prime concern.

Bibliographic Details

Main Authors:	Williams, Trevor Doctor autor/a 5446, Valle Mora, Javier Francisco Maestro autor/a 10513, Viñuela, Elisa autor/a
Format:	Texto biblioteca
Language:	eng
Subjects:	Espinosad, Insecticidas de origen vegetal, Enemigos naturales, Insecticidas, Toxicología,
Online Access:	http://www.trevorwilliams.info/Williams_spinosad_BST_2003.pdf
Tags:	Add Tag No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!