Is climate a stronger driver of tree growth than disturbance? A comment on Toledo et al. (2011)
1. A recent article published by Toledo et al. (2011b) investigates the effects of spatial variations in climate and soil, and of logging disturbance, on tree and forest growth in Bolivia. It concludes that climate is the strongest driver of tree and forest growth and that climate change may therefore have large consequences for forest productivity and carbon sequestration. However, serious methodological and conceptual discrepancies have been found that challenge these conclusions. 2. Because of an errant coding of 'time after logging' in the regression analysis, and because floristic changes induced by logging could not be incorporated into the analysis, the effect of logging on the average diameter growth is likely to have been strongly underestimated. 3. Basal area growth was improperly calculated as basal area change, and it displayed surprisingly high values, even among unlogged plots. We hypothesize that either these plots may be actually located in secondary forests recovering from past logging, or measurement biases may have hampered the data set. 4. Regardless of climate-growth relationships established across these plots, any inference concerning the potential effects of climate change on forest growth would require a specific quantitative assessment. 5. Synthesis. It is critical to re-assess the relative weight of climate and logging disturbance as driving factors of tree and forest growth, and to find an explanation for the very high basal area increment reported among the unlogged plots. We provide specific recommendations for further analyses of this and similar data sets.
Main Authors: | , , , |
---|---|
Format: | article biblioteca |
Language: | eng |
Subjects: | P40 - Météorologie et climatologie, F62 - Physiologie végétale - Croissance et développement, K10 - Production forestière, forêt tropicale, changement climatique, croissance, dendrométrie, exploitation forestière, évaluation de l'impact, http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_24904, http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_1666, http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_3394, http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_16209, http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_7775, http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_37938, http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_331403, |
Online Access: | http://agritrop.cirad.fr/565408/ http://agritrop.cirad.fr/565408/1/document_565408.pdf |
Tags: |
Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
|
id |
dig-cirad-fr-565408 |
---|---|
record_format |
koha |
spelling |
dig-cirad-fr-5654082024-01-28T20:42:52Z http://agritrop.cirad.fr/565408/ http://agritrop.cirad.fr/565408/ Is climate a stronger driver of tree growth than disturbance? A comment on Toledo et al. (2011). Ferry Bruno, Bontemps Jean-Daniel, Blanc Lilian, Baraloto Christopher. 2012. Journal of Ecology, 100 (5) : 1065-1068.https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2745.2011.01895.x <https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2745.2011.01895.x> Is climate a stronger driver of tree growth than disturbance? A comment on Toledo et al. (2011) Ferry, Bruno Bontemps, Jean-Daniel Blanc, Lilian Baraloto, Christopher eng 2012 Journal of Ecology P40 - Météorologie et climatologie F62 - Physiologie végétale - Croissance et développement K10 - Production forestière forêt tropicale changement climatique croissance dendrométrie exploitation forestière évaluation de l'impact http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_24904 http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_1666 http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_3394 http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_16209 http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_7775 http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_37938 Bolivie (État plurinational de) http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_331403 1. A recent article published by Toledo et al. (2011b) investigates the effects of spatial variations in climate and soil, and of logging disturbance, on tree and forest growth in Bolivia. It concludes that climate is the strongest driver of tree and forest growth and that climate change may therefore have large consequences for forest productivity and carbon sequestration. However, serious methodological and conceptual discrepancies have been found that challenge these conclusions. 2. Because of an errant coding of 'time after logging' in the regression analysis, and because floristic changes induced by logging could not be incorporated into the analysis, the effect of logging on the average diameter growth is likely to have been strongly underestimated. 3. Basal area growth was improperly calculated as basal area change, and it displayed surprisingly high values, even among unlogged plots. We hypothesize that either these plots may be actually located in secondary forests recovering from past logging, or measurement biases may have hampered the data set. 4. Regardless of climate-growth relationships established across these plots, any inference concerning the potential effects of climate change on forest growth would require a specific quantitative assessment. 5. Synthesis. It is critical to re-assess the relative weight of climate and logging disturbance as driving factors of tree and forest growth, and to find an explanation for the very high basal area increment reported among the unlogged plots. We provide specific recommendations for further analyses of this and similar data sets. article info:eu-repo/semantics/article Journal Article info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion http://agritrop.cirad.fr/565408/1/document_565408.pdf application/pdf Cirad license info:eu-repo/semantics/restrictedAccess https://agritrop.cirad.fr/mention_legale.html https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2745.2011.01895.x 10.1111/j.1365-2745.2011.01895.x http://catalogue-bibliotheques.cirad.fr/cgi-bin/koha/opac-detail.pl?biblionumber=215436 info:eu-repo/semantics/altIdentifier/doi/10.1111/j.1365-2745.2011.01895.x info:eu-repo/semantics/altIdentifier/purl/https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2745.2011.01895.x |
institution |
CIRAD FR |
collection |
DSpace |
country |
Francia |
countrycode |
FR |
component |
Bibliográfico |
access |
En linea |
databasecode |
dig-cirad-fr |
tag |
biblioteca |
region |
Europa del Oeste |
libraryname |
Biblioteca del CIRAD Francia |
language |
eng |
topic |
P40 - Météorologie et climatologie F62 - Physiologie végétale - Croissance et développement K10 - Production forestière forêt tropicale changement climatique croissance dendrométrie exploitation forestière évaluation de l'impact http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_24904 http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_1666 http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_3394 http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_16209 http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_7775 http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_37938 http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_331403 P40 - Météorologie et climatologie F62 - Physiologie végétale - Croissance et développement K10 - Production forestière forêt tropicale changement climatique croissance dendrométrie exploitation forestière évaluation de l'impact http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_24904 http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_1666 http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_3394 http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_16209 http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_7775 http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_37938 http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_331403 |
spellingShingle |
P40 - Météorologie et climatologie F62 - Physiologie végétale - Croissance et développement K10 - Production forestière forêt tropicale changement climatique croissance dendrométrie exploitation forestière évaluation de l'impact http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_24904 http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_1666 http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_3394 http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_16209 http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_7775 http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_37938 http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_331403 P40 - Météorologie et climatologie F62 - Physiologie végétale - Croissance et développement K10 - Production forestière forêt tropicale changement climatique croissance dendrométrie exploitation forestière évaluation de l'impact http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_24904 http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_1666 http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_3394 http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_16209 http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_7775 http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_37938 http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_331403 Ferry, Bruno Bontemps, Jean-Daniel Blanc, Lilian Baraloto, Christopher Is climate a stronger driver of tree growth than disturbance? A comment on Toledo et al. (2011) |
description |
1. A recent article published by Toledo et al. (2011b) investigates the effects of spatial variations in climate and soil, and of logging disturbance, on tree and forest growth in Bolivia. It concludes that climate is the strongest driver of tree and forest growth and that climate change may therefore have large consequences for forest productivity and carbon sequestration. However, serious methodological and conceptual discrepancies have been found that challenge these conclusions. 2. Because of an errant coding of 'time after logging' in the regression analysis, and because floristic changes induced by logging could not be incorporated into the analysis, the effect of logging on the average diameter growth is likely to have been strongly underestimated. 3. Basal area growth was improperly calculated as basal area change, and it displayed surprisingly high values, even among unlogged plots. We hypothesize that either these plots may be actually located in secondary forests recovering from past logging, or measurement biases may have hampered the data set. 4. Regardless of climate-growth relationships established across these plots, any inference concerning the potential effects of climate change on forest growth would require a specific quantitative assessment. 5. Synthesis. It is critical to re-assess the relative weight of climate and logging disturbance as driving factors of tree and forest growth, and to find an explanation for the very high basal area increment reported among the unlogged plots. We provide specific recommendations for further analyses of this and similar data sets. |
format |
article |
topic_facet |
P40 - Météorologie et climatologie F62 - Physiologie végétale - Croissance et développement K10 - Production forestière forêt tropicale changement climatique croissance dendrométrie exploitation forestière évaluation de l'impact http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_24904 http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_1666 http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_3394 http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_16209 http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_7775 http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_37938 http://aims.fao.org/aos/agrovoc/c_331403 |
author |
Ferry, Bruno Bontemps, Jean-Daniel Blanc, Lilian Baraloto, Christopher |
author_facet |
Ferry, Bruno Bontemps, Jean-Daniel Blanc, Lilian Baraloto, Christopher |
author_sort |
Ferry, Bruno |
title |
Is climate a stronger driver of tree growth than disturbance? A comment on Toledo et al. (2011) |
title_short |
Is climate a stronger driver of tree growth than disturbance? A comment on Toledo et al. (2011) |
title_full |
Is climate a stronger driver of tree growth than disturbance? A comment on Toledo et al. (2011) |
title_fullStr |
Is climate a stronger driver of tree growth than disturbance? A comment on Toledo et al. (2011) |
title_full_unstemmed |
Is climate a stronger driver of tree growth than disturbance? A comment on Toledo et al. (2011) |
title_sort |
is climate a stronger driver of tree growth than disturbance? a comment on toledo et al. (2011) |
url |
http://agritrop.cirad.fr/565408/ http://agritrop.cirad.fr/565408/1/document_565408.pdf |
work_keys_str_mv |
AT ferrybruno isclimateastrongerdriveroftreegrowththandisturbanceacommentontoledoetal2011 AT bontempsjeandaniel isclimateastrongerdriveroftreegrowththandisturbanceacommentontoledoetal2011 AT blanclilian isclimateastrongerdriveroftreegrowththandisturbanceacommentontoledoetal2011 AT baralotochristopher isclimateastrongerdriveroftreegrowththandisturbanceacommentontoledoetal2011 |
_version_ |
1792498274276474880 |