Consumer Protection Laws and Regulations in Deposit and Loan Services : A Cross-Country Analysis with a New Data Set

Consumer protection and financial literacy can contribute to improved efficiency, transparency, competition, and access in retail financial markets by reducing information asymmetries and power imbalances between providers and users of financial services. Financial consumer protection has gained significance in policy debates, especially since the onset of the financial crisis in 2008. This paper presents the results of a survey on consumer protection regulations in 142 countries. The findings indicate that although consumer protection legislation is in place in the majority of countries, these do not necessarily address the issues specific to financial services. There is some evidence that enforcement powers and monitoring capacity are limited in many countries, obstructing the effective implementation of the existing regulations. Furthermore, independent third party dispute resolution mechanisms are not widespread. The paper also compiles comprehensive information on laws and regulations relevant for consumer protection and discusses a number of challenges related to empirical analyses of financial consumer protection to enable cross-country comparison.

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Ardic, Oya Pinar, Ibrahim, Joyce A., Mylenko, Nataliya
Language:English
Published: 2011-01-01
Subjects:ACCESS TO CREDIT, ACCESS TO FINANCE, ACCESS TO FINANCIAL SERVICES, ACCESSIBILITY, ADVERTISEMENT, ADVERTISEMENTS, ANNUAL PERCENTAGE RATE, ANTI-MONEY LAUNDERING, APR, ARREARS, ASYMMETRIC INFORMATION, ATM, ATMS, AVERAGE BALANCE, BANK ACCOUNTS, BANK CHARGES, BANK DEPOSIT, BANK DEPOSITS, BANK PRODUCT, BANKING ACCOUNT, BANKING SERVICES, BANKING SUPERVISION, BANKS, BASIC BANKING, BEHAVIORAL ECONOMICS, BIASES, BORROWER, BORROWING, BUSINESS LENDING, BUYERS, CALCULATION, CALCULATIONS, CAPITAL MARKET, CASH WITHDRAWALS, CHECKS, COLLECTIVE INVESTMENT SCHEMES, COMMERCIAL BANK, COMMERCIAL BANKS, COMMERCIAL TRANSACTIONS, CONSUMER, CONSUMER ACCESS, CONSUMER BEHAVIOR, CONSUMER COMPLAINTS, CONSUMER CREDIT, CONSUMER CREDIT PRODUCTS, CONSUMER FINANCE, CONSUMER LENDING, CONSUMER LOAN, CONSUMER LOANS, CONSUMER PROTECTION, CONSUMER PROTECTION LAW, CONSUMER PROTECTION LAWS, CONSUMER PROTECTION MEASURES, CONSUMER PROTECTIONS, CONSUMER RIGHTS, CONSUMERS, CONTRIBUTION, COST OF CREDIT, CREDIT ALLOCATIONS, CREDIT BUREAUS, CREDIT CARD, CREDIT CARD ISSUERS, CREDIT CARDS, CREDIT FACILITIES, CREDIT INFORMATION, CREDIT INFORMATION BUREAUS, CREDIT INSTITUTIONS, CREDIT LINE, CREDIT MARKET, CREDIT MARKETS, CREDIT PRODUCTS, CREDIT REPORTING, CREDIT TRANSACTIONS, CREDITOR, CREDITS, CURRENT ACCOUNTS, CUSTOMER SERVICE, DEBT, DEBT COLLECTION, DEBTORS, DEBTS, DEPOSIT, DEPOSIT ACCOUNT, DEPOSIT ACCOUNTS, DEPOSIT INSURANCE, DEPOSITOR, DEPOSITORS, DEPOSITS, DEVELOPING FINANCIAL MARKET, DISCLOSURE OF INFORMATION, DISCLOSURE REQUIREMENT, DISCLOSURE REQUIREMENTS, EARNINGS, ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT, ELECTRONIC BANKING, ELECTRONIC PAYMENTS, ENFORCEMENT MECHANISM, ENFORCEMENT MECHANISMS, EQUAL ACCESS, EXCESSIVE INTEREST RATES, FEDERAL RESERVE, FEDERAL RESERVE BANK, FINANCES, FINANCIAL ACCESS, FINANCIAL ACTIVITY, FINANCIAL ADVISERS, FINANCIAL COMPANIES, FINANCIAL CONCEPTS, FINANCIAL CONSUMER, FINANCIAL CONSUMERS, FINANCIAL CRISIS, FINANCIAL EDUCATION, FINANCIAL EXPERIENCES, FINANCIAL INSTITUTION, FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS, FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS, FINANCIAL LITERACY, FINANCIAL LITERACY PROGRAMS, FINANCIAL MARKET, FINANCIAL MARKETS, FINANCIAL MATTERS, FINANCIAL PRODUCT, FINANCIAL PRODUCTS, FINANCIAL REGULATOR, FINANCIAL REGULATORS, FINANCIAL SECTOR, FINANCIAL SERVICE, FINANCIAL SERVICE PROVIDERS, FINANCIAL SERVICES, FINANCIAL SERVICES INDUSTRY, FINANCIAL SERVICES REGULATION, FINANCIAL STABILITY, FINANCIAL SYSTEM, FINANCIAL TRANSACTIONS, FOREIGN CURRENCY, GENERAL PUBLIC, GOVERNMENT INTERVENTION, GREATER ACCESS, GUARANTORS, HOUSEHOLD FINANCE, HOUSEHOLDS, ID, ILLITERACY, INCOME, INCOME GROUP, INCOME LEVELS, INDEBTEDNESS, INEQUALITY, INFORMATION ASYMMETRIES, INSTITUTIONAL CAPACITY, INSURANCE, INSURANCE COMPANIES, INTEREST RATE, INTEREST RATES, INTERNATIONAL BANK, INVESTING, INVESTMENT COMPANIES, KEY CHALLENGE, LENDERS, LIABILITY, LIFE INSURANCE, LOAN, LOAN CONTRACT, LOAN REPAYMENT, LOAN TERMS, LOW INCOME, LOW-INCOME, LOW-INCOME INDIVIDUALS, MARKETING, MEDIUM ENTERPRISES, MICROFINANCE, MICROFINANCE INSTITUTIONS, MINIMUM BALANCE, MONEY LENDING, MORTGAGE, MORTGAGE CREDIT, MORTGAGE MARKET, MORTGAGES, NATIONAL BANK, OFFICE OF FAIR TRADING, OUTSTANDING BALANCE, OVERDRAFT, PAYMENT SERVICE, PAYMENT SERVICES, PENSION, PENSIONS, PROTECTION OF CONSUMER, PROTECTION OF CONSUMERS, PUBLIC POLICY, PUBLIC-PRIVATE PARTNERSHIPS, REMITTANCE, REPAYMENT, RESEARCH ASSISTANCE, RESERVE BANK, RETAIL CREDIT, RETAIL FINANCIAL MARKETS, RETAIL FINANCIAL SERVICES, RETIREMENT, RETIREMENT SAVINGS, RETIREMENT SAVINGS ACCOUNTS, SALARIES, SALE, SALES, SAVINGS, SAVINGS ACCOUNTS, SCAM, SECURITIES, SOLVENCY, STATE BANK, TOTAL COST, TRANSPARENCY OF INFORMATION, TYPES OF CONSUMER, UNEMPLOYMENT, UNION, UNREGULATED FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS, URBAN DEVELOPMENT, USURY, UTILITY BILLS, WAGES, WEB SITE, WITHDRAWAL, WITHDRAWAL FEES, WORTH,
Online Access:http://www-wds.worldbank.org/external/default/main?menuPK=64187510&pagePK=64193027&piPK=64187937&theSitePK=523679&menuPK=64187510&searchMenuPK=64187283&siteName=WDS&entityID=000158349_20110118134022
https://hdl.handle.net/10986/3308
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
id dig-okr-109863308
record_format koha
institution Banco Mundial
collection DSpace
country Estados Unidos
countrycode US
component Bibliográfico
access En linea
databasecode dig-okr
tag biblioteca
region America del Norte
libraryname Biblioteca del Banco Mundial
language English
topic ACCESS TO CREDIT
ACCESS TO FINANCE
ACCESS TO FINANCIAL SERVICES
ACCESSIBILITY
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENTS
ANNUAL PERCENTAGE RATE
ANTI-MONEY LAUNDERING
APR
ARREARS
ASYMMETRIC INFORMATION
ATM
ATMS
AVERAGE BALANCE
BANK ACCOUNTS
BANK CHARGES
BANK DEPOSIT
BANK DEPOSITS
BANK PRODUCT
BANKING ACCOUNT
BANKING SERVICES
BANKING SUPERVISION
BANKS
BASIC BANKING
BEHAVIORAL ECONOMICS
BIASES
BORROWER
BORROWING
BUSINESS LENDING
BUYERS
CALCULATION
CALCULATIONS
CAPITAL MARKET
CASH WITHDRAWALS
CHECKS
COLLECTIVE INVESTMENT SCHEMES
COMMERCIAL BANK
COMMERCIAL BANKS
COMMERCIAL TRANSACTIONS
CONSUMER
CONSUMER ACCESS
CONSUMER BEHAVIOR
CONSUMER COMPLAINTS
CONSUMER CREDIT
CONSUMER CREDIT PRODUCTS
CONSUMER FINANCE
CONSUMER LENDING
CONSUMER LOAN
CONSUMER LOANS
CONSUMER PROTECTION
CONSUMER PROTECTION LAW
CONSUMER PROTECTION LAWS
CONSUMER PROTECTION MEASURES
CONSUMER PROTECTIONS
CONSUMER RIGHTS
CONSUMERS
CONTRIBUTION
COST OF CREDIT
CREDIT ALLOCATIONS
CREDIT BUREAUS
CREDIT CARD
CREDIT CARD ISSUERS
CREDIT CARDS
CREDIT FACILITIES
CREDIT INFORMATION
CREDIT INFORMATION BUREAUS
CREDIT INSTITUTIONS
CREDIT LINE
CREDIT MARKET
CREDIT MARKETS
CREDIT PRODUCTS
CREDIT REPORTING
CREDIT TRANSACTIONS
CREDITOR
CREDITS
CURRENT ACCOUNTS
CUSTOMER SERVICE
DEBT
DEBT COLLECTION
DEBTORS
DEBTS
DEPOSIT
DEPOSIT ACCOUNT
DEPOSIT ACCOUNTS
DEPOSIT INSURANCE
DEPOSITOR
DEPOSITORS
DEPOSITS
DEVELOPING FINANCIAL MARKET
DISCLOSURE OF INFORMATION
DISCLOSURE REQUIREMENT
DISCLOSURE REQUIREMENTS
EARNINGS
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
ELECTRONIC BANKING
ELECTRONIC PAYMENTS
ENFORCEMENT MECHANISM
ENFORCEMENT MECHANISMS
EQUAL ACCESS
EXCESSIVE INTEREST RATES
FEDERAL RESERVE
FEDERAL RESERVE BANK
FINANCES
FINANCIAL ACCESS
FINANCIAL ACTIVITY
FINANCIAL ADVISERS
FINANCIAL COMPANIES
FINANCIAL CONCEPTS
FINANCIAL CONSUMER
FINANCIAL CONSUMERS
FINANCIAL CRISIS
FINANCIAL EDUCATION
FINANCIAL EXPERIENCES
FINANCIAL INSTITUTION
FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS
FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS
FINANCIAL LITERACY
FINANCIAL LITERACY PROGRAMS
FINANCIAL MARKET
FINANCIAL MARKETS
FINANCIAL MATTERS
FINANCIAL PRODUCT
FINANCIAL PRODUCTS
FINANCIAL REGULATOR
FINANCIAL REGULATORS
FINANCIAL SECTOR
FINANCIAL SERVICE
FINANCIAL SERVICE PROVIDERS
FINANCIAL SERVICES
FINANCIAL SERVICES INDUSTRY
FINANCIAL SERVICES REGULATION
FINANCIAL STABILITY
FINANCIAL SYSTEM
FINANCIAL TRANSACTIONS
FOREIGN CURRENCY
GENERAL PUBLIC
GOVERNMENT INTERVENTION
GREATER ACCESS
GUARANTORS
HOUSEHOLD FINANCE
HOUSEHOLDS
ID
ILLITERACY
INCOME
INCOME GROUP
INCOME LEVELS
INDEBTEDNESS
INEQUALITY
INFORMATION ASYMMETRIES
INSTITUTIONAL CAPACITY
INSURANCE
INSURANCE COMPANIES
INTEREST RATE
INTEREST RATES
INTERNATIONAL BANK
INVESTING
INVESTMENT COMPANIES
KEY CHALLENGE
LENDERS
LIABILITY
LIFE INSURANCE
LOAN
LOAN CONTRACT
LOAN REPAYMENT
LOAN TERMS
LOW INCOME
LOW-INCOME
LOW-INCOME INDIVIDUALS
MARKETING
MEDIUM ENTERPRISES
MICROFINANCE
MICROFINANCE INSTITUTIONS
MINIMUM BALANCE
MONEY LENDING
MORTGAGE
MORTGAGE CREDIT
MORTGAGE MARKET
MORTGAGES
NATIONAL BANK
OFFICE OF FAIR TRADING
OUTSTANDING BALANCE
OVERDRAFT
PAYMENT SERVICE
PAYMENT SERVICES
PENSION
PENSIONS
PROTECTION OF CONSUMER
PROTECTION OF CONSUMERS
PUBLIC POLICY
PUBLIC-PRIVATE PARTNERSHIPS
REMITTANCE
REPAYMENT
RESEARCH ASSISTANCE
RESERVE BANK
RETAIL CREDIT
RETAIL FINANCIAL MARKETS
RETAIL FINANCIAL SERVICES
RETIREMENT
RETIREMENT SAVINGS
RETIREMENT SAVINGS ACCOUNTS
SALARIES
SALE
SALES
SAVINGS
SAVINGS ACCOUNTS
SCAM
SECURITIES
SOLVENCY
STATE BANK
TOTAL COST
TRANSPARENCY OF INFORMATION
TYPES OF CONSUMER
UNEMPLOYMENT
UNION
UNREGULATED FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS
URBAN DEVELOPMENT
USURY
UTILITY BILLS
WAGES
WEB SITE
WITHDRAWAL
WITHDRAWAL FEES
WORTH
ACCESS TO CREDIT
ACCESS TO FINANCE
ACCESS TO FINANCIAL SERVICES
ACCESSIBILITY
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENTS
ANNUAL PERCENTAGE RATE
ANTI-MONEY LAUNDERING
APR
ARREARS
ASYMMETRIC INFORMATION
ATM
ATMS
AVERAGE BALANCE
BANK ACCOUNTS
BANK CHARGES
BANK DEPOSIT
BANK DEPOSITS
BANK PRODUCT
BANKING ACCOUNT
BANKING SERVICES
BANKING SUPERVISION
BANKS
BASIC BANKING
BEHAVIORAL ECONOMICS
BIASES
BORROWER
BORROWING
BUSINESS LENDING
BUYERS
CALCULATION
CALCULATIONS
CAPITAL MARKET
CASH WITHDRAWALS
CHECKS
COLLECTIVE INVESTMENT SCHEMES
COMMERCIAL BANK
COMMERCIAL BANKS
COMMERCIAL TRANSACTIONS
CONSUMER
CONSUMER ACCESS
CONSUMER BEHAVIOR
CONSUMER COMPLAINTS
CONSUMER CREDIT
CONSUMER CREDIT PRODUCTS
CONSUMER FINANCE
CONSUMER LENDING
CONSUMER LOAN
CONSUMER LOANS
CONSUMER PROTECTION
CONSUMER PROTECTION LAW
CONSUMER PROTECTION LAWS
CONSUMER PROTECTION MEASURES
CONSUMER PROTECTIONS
CONSUMER RIGHTS
CONSUMERS
CONTRIBUTION
COST OF CREDIT
CREDIT ALLOCATIONS
CREDIT BUREAUS
CREDIT CARD
CREDIT CARD ISSUERS
CREDIT CARDS
CREDIT FACILITIES
CREDIT INFORMATION
CREDIT INFORMATION BUREAUS
CREDIT INSTITUTIONS
CREDIT LINE
CREDIT MARKET
CREDIT MARKETS
CREDIT PRODUCTS
CREDIT REPORTING
CREDIT TRANSACTIONS
CREDITOR
CREDITS
CURRENT ACCOUNTS
CUSTOMER SERVICE
DEBT
DEBT COLLECTION
DEBTORS
DEBTS
DEPOSIT
DEPOSIT ACCOUNT
DEPOSIT ACCOUNTS
DEPOSIT INSURANCE
DEPOSITOR
DEPOSITORS
DEPOSITS
DEVELOPING FINANCIAL MARKET
DISCLOSURE OF INFORMATION
DISCLOSURE REQUIREMENT
DISCLOSURE REQUIREMENTS
EARNINGS
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
ELECTRONIC BANKING
ELECTRONIC PAYMENTS
ENFORCEMENT MECHANISM
ENFORCEMENT MECHANISMS
EQUAL ACCESS
EXCESSIVE INTEREST RATES
FEDERAL RESERVE
FEDERAL RESERVE BANK
FINANCES
FINANCIAL ACCESS
FINANCIAL ACTIVITY
FINANCIAL ADVISERS
FINANCIAL COMPANIES
FINANCIAL CONCEPTS
FINANCIAL CONSUMER
FINANCIAL CONSUMERS
FINANCIAL CRISIS
FINANCIAL EDUCATION
FINANCIAL EXPERIENCES
FINANCIAL INSTITUTION
FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS
FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS
FINANCIAL LITERACY
FINANCIAL LITERACY PROGRAMS
FINANCIAL MARKET
FINANCIAL MARKETS
FINANCIAL MATTERS
FINANCIAL PRODUCT
FINANCIAL PRODUCTS
FINANCIAL REGULATOR
FINANCIAL REGULATORS
FINANCIAL SECTOR
FINANCIAL SERVICE
FINANCIAL SERVICE PROVIDERS
FINANCIAL SERVICES
FINANCIAL SERVICES INDUSTRY
FINANCIAL SERVICES REGULATION
FINANCIAL STABILITY
FINANCIAL SYSTEM
FINANCIAL TRANSACTIONS
FOREIGN CURRENCY
GENERAL PUBLIC
GOVERNMENT INTERVENTION
GREATER ACCESS
GUARANTORS
HOUSEHOLD FINANCE
HOUSEHOLDS
ID
ILLITERACY
INCOME
INCOME GROUP
INCOME LEVELS
INDEBTEDNESS
INEQUALITY
INFORMATION ASYMMETRIES
INSTITUTIONAL CAPACITY
INSURANCE
INSURANCE COMPANIES
INTEREST RATE
INTEREST RATES
INTERNATIONAL BANK
INVESTING
INVESTMENT COMPANIES
KEY CHALLENGE
LENDERS
LIABILITY
LIFE INSURANCE
LOAN
LOAN CONTRACT
LOAN REPAYMENT
LOAN TERMS
LOW INCOME
LOW-INCOME
LOW-INCOME INDIVIDUALS
MARKETING
MEDIUM ENTERPRISES
MICROFINANCE
MICROFINANCE INSTITUTIONS
MINIMUM BALANCE
MONEY LENDING
MORTGAGE
MORTGAGE CREDIT
MORTGAGE MARKET
MORTGAGES
NATIONAL BANK
OFFICE OF FAIR TRADING
OUTSTANDING BALANCE
OVERDRAFT
PAYMENT SERVICE
PAYMENT SERVICES
PENSION
PENSIONS
PROTECTION OF CONSUMER
PROTECTION OF CONSUMERS
PUBLIC POLICY
PUBLIC-PRIVATE PARTNERSHIPS
REMITTANCE
REPAYMENT
RESEARCH ASSISTANCE
RESERVE BANK
RETAIL CREDIT
RETAIL FINANCIAL MARKETS
RETAIL FINANCIAL SERVICES
RETIREMENT
RETIREMENT SAVINGS
RETIREMENT SAVINGS ACCOUNTS
SALARIES
SALE
SALES
SAVINGS
SAVINGS ACCOUNTS
SCAM
SECURITIES
SOLVENCY
STATE BANK
TOTAL COST
TRANSPARENCY OF INFORMATION
TYPES OF CONSUMER
UNEMPLOYMENT
UNION
UNREGULATED FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS
URBAN DEVELOPMENT
USURY
UTILITY BILLS
WAGES
WEB SITE
WITHDRAWAL
WITHDRAWAL FEES
WORTH
spellingShingle ACCESS TO CREDIT
ACCESS TO FINANCE
ACCESS TO FINANCIAL SERVICES
ACCESSIBILITY
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENTS
ANNUAL PERCENTAGE RATE
ANTI-MONEY LAUNDERING
APR
ARREARS
ASYMMETRIC INFORMATION
ATM
ATMS
AVERAGE BALANCE
BANK ACCOUNTS
BANK CHARGES
BANK DEPOSIT
BANK DEPOSITS
BANK PRODUCT
BANKING ACCOUNT
BANKING SERVICES
BANKING SUPERVISION
BANKS
BASIC BANKING
BEHAVIORAL ECONOMICS
BIASES
BORROWER
BORROWING
BUSINESS LENDING
BUYERS
CALCULATION
CALCULATIONS
CAPITAL MARKET
CASH WITHDRAWALS
CHECKS
COLLECTIVE INVESTMENT SCHEMES
COMMERCIAL BANK
COMMERCIAL BANKS
COMMERCIAL TRANSACTIONS
CONSUMER
CONSUMER ACCESS
CONSUMER BEHAVIOR
CONSUMER COMPLAINTS
CONSUMER CREDIT
CONSUMER CREDIT PRODUCTS
CONSUMER FINANCE
CONSUMER LENDING
CONSUMER LOAN
CONSUMER LOANS
CONSUMER PROTECTION
CONSUMER PROTECTION LAW
CONSUMER PROTECTION LAWS
CONSUMER PROTECTION MEASURES
CONSUMER PROTECTIONS
CONSUMER RIGHTS
CONSUMERS
CONTRIBUTION
COST OF CREDIT
CREDIT ALLOCATIONS
CREDIT BUREAUS
CREDIT CARD
CREDIT CARD ISSUERS
CREDIT CARDS
CREDIT FACILITIES
CREDIT INFORMATION
CREDIT INFORMATION BUREAUS
CREDIT INSTITUTIONS
CREDIT LINE
CREDIT MARKET
CREDIT MARKETS
CREDIT PRODUCTS
CREDIT REPORTING
CREDIT TRANSACTIONS
CREDITOR
CREDITS
CURRENT ACCOUNTS
CUSTOMER SERVICE
DEBT
DEBT COLLECTION
DEBTORS
DEBTS
DEPOSIT
DEPOSIT ACCOUNT
DEPOSIT ACCOUNTS
DEPOSIT INSURANCE
DEPOSITOR
DEPOSITORS
DEPOSITS
DEVELOPING FINANCIAL MARKET
DISCLOSURE OF INFORMATION
DISCLOSURE REQUIREMENT
DISCLOSURE REQUIREMENTS
EARNINGS
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
ELECTRONIC BANKING
ELECTRONIC PAYMENTS
ENFORCEMENT MECHANISM
ENFORCEMENT MECHANISMS
EQUAL ACCESS
EXCESSIVE INTEREST RATES
FEDERAL RESERVE
FEDERAL RESERVE BANK
FINANCES
FINANCIAL ACCESS
FINANCIAL ACTIVITY
FINANCIAL ADVISERS
FINANCIAL COMPANIES
FINANCIAL CONCEPTS
FINANCIAL CONSUMER
FINANCIAL CONSUMERS
FINANCIAL CRISIS
FINANCIAL EDUCATION
FINANCIAL EXPERIENCES
FINANCIAL INSTITUTION
FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS
FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS
FINANCIAL LITERACY
FINANCIAL LITERACY PROGRAMS
FINANCIAL MARKET
FINANCIAL MARKETS
FINANCIAL MATTERS
FINANCIAL PRODUCT
FINANCIAL PRODUCTS
FINANCIAL REGULATOR
FINANCIAL REGULATORS
FINANCIAL SECTOR
FINANCIAL SERVICE
FINANCIAL SERVICE PROVIDERS
FINANCIAL SERVICES
FINANCIAL SERVICES INDUSTRY
FINANCIAL SERVICES REGULATION
FINANCIAL STABILITY
FINANCIAL SYSTEM
FINANCIAL TRANSACTIONS
FOREIGN CURRENCY
GENERAL PUBLIC
GOVERNMENT INTERVENTION
GREATER ACCESS
GUARANTORS
HOUSEHOLD FINANCE
HOUSEHOLDS
ID
ILLITERACY
INCOME
INCOME GROUP
INCOME LEVELS
INDEBTEDNESS
INEQUALITY
INFORMATION ASYMMETRIES
INSTITUTIONAL CAPACITY
INSURANCE
INSURANCE COMPANIES
INTEREST RATE
INTEREST RATES
INTERNATIONAL BANK
INVESTING
INVESTMENT COMPANIES
KEY CHALLENGE
LENDERS
LIABILITY
LIFE INSURANCE
LOAN
LOAN CONTRACT
LOAN REPAYMENT
LOAN TERMS
LOW INCOME
LOW-INCOME
LOW-INCOME INDIVIDUALS
MARKETING
MEDIUM ENTERPRISES
MICROFINANCE
MICROFINANCE INSTITUTIONS
MINIMUM BALANCE
MONEY LENDING
MORTGAGE
MORTGAGE CREDIT
MORTGAGE MARKET
MORTGAGES
NATIONAL BANK
OFFICE OF FAIR TRADING
OUTSTANDING BALANCE
OVERDRAFT
PAYMENT SERVICE
PAYMENT SERVICES
PENSION
PENSIONS
PROTECTION OF CONSUMER
PROTECTION OF CONSUMERS
PUBLIC POLICY
PUBLIC-PRIVATE PARTNERSHIPS
REMITTANCE
REPAYMENT
RESEARCH ASSISTANCE
RESERVE BANK
RETAIL CREDIT
RETAIL FINANCIAL MARKETS
RETAIL FINANCIAL SERVICES
RETIREMENT
RETIREMENT SAVINGS
RETIREMENT SAVINGS ACCOUNTS
SALARIES
SALE
SALES
SAVINGS
SAVINGS ACCOUNTS
SCAM
SECURITIES
SOLVENCY
STATE BANK
TOTAL COST
TRANSPARENCY OF INFORMATION
TYPES OF CONSUMER
UNEMPLOYMENT
UNION
UNREGULATED FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS
URBAN DEVELOPMENT
USURY
UTILITY BILLS
WAGES
WEB SITE
WITHDRAWAL
WITHDRAWAL FEES
WORTH
ACCESS TO CREDIT
ACCESS TO FINANCE
ACCESS TO FINANCIAL SERVICES
ACCESSIBILITY
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENTS
ANNUAL PERCENTAGE RATE
ANTI-MONEY LAUNDERING
APR
ARREARS
ASYMMETRIC INFORMATION
ATM
ATMS
AVERAGE BALANCE
BANK ACCOUNTS
BANK CHARGES
BANK DEPOSIT
BANK DEPOSITS
BANK PRODUCT
BANKING ACCOUNT
BANKING SERVICES
BANKING SUPERVISION
BANKS
BASIC BANKING
BEHAVIORAL ECONOMICS
BIASES
BORROWER
BORROWING
BUSINESS LENDING
BUYERS
CALCULATION
CALCULATIONS
CAPITAL MARKET
CASH WITHDRAWALS
CHECKS
COLLECTIVE INVESTMENT SCHEMES
COMMERCIAL BANK
COMMERCIAL BANKS
COMMERCIAL TRANSACTIONS
CONSUMER
CONSUMER ACCESS
CONSUMER BEHAVIOR
CONSUMER COMPLAINTS
CONSUMER CREDIT
CONSUMER CREDIT PRODUCTS
CONSUMER FINANCE
CONSUMER LENDING
CONSUMER LOAN
CONSUMER LOANS
CONSUMER PROTECTION
CONSUMER PROTECTION LAW
CONSUMER PROTECTION LAWS
CONSUMER PROTECTION MEASURES
CONSUMER PROTECTIONS
CONSUMER RIGHTS
CONSUMERS
CONTRIBUTION
COST OF CREDIT
CREDIT ALLOCATIONS
CREDIT BUREAUS
CREDIT CARD
CREDIT CARD ISSUERS
CREDIT CARDS
CREDIT FACILITIES
CREDIT INFORMATION
CREDIT INFORMATION BUREAUS
CREDIT INSTITUTIONS
CREDIT LINE
CREDIT MARKET
CREDIT MARKETS
CREDIT PRODUCTS
CREDIT REPORTING
CREDIT TRANSACTIONS
CREDITOR
CREDITS
CURRENT ACCOUNTS
CUSTOMER SERVICE
DEBT
DEBT COLLECTION
DEBTORS
DEBTS
DEPOSIT
DEPOSIT ACCOUNT
DEPOSIT ACCOUNTS
DEPOSIT INSURANCE
DEPOSITOR
DEPOSITORS
DEPOSITS
DEVELOPING FINANCIAL MARKET
DISCLOSURE OF INFORMATION
DISCLOSURE REQUIREMENT
DISCLOSURE REQUIREMENTS
EARNINGS
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
ELECTRONIC BANKING
ELECTRONIC PAYMENTS
ENFORCEMENT MECHANISM
ENFORCEMENT MECHANISMS
EQUAL ACCESS
EXCESSIVE INTEREST RATES
FEDERAL RESERVE
FEDERAL RESERVE BANK
FINANCES
FINANCIAL ACCESS
FINANCIAL ACTIVITY
FINANCIAL ADVISERS
FINANCIAL COMPANIES
FINANCIAL CONCEPTS
FINANCIAL CONSUMER
FINANCIAL CONSUMERS
FINANCIAL CRISIS
FINANCIAL EDUCATION
FINANCIAL EXPERIENCES
FINANCIAL INSTITUTION
FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS
FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS
FINANCIAL LITERACY
FINANCIAL LITERACY PROGRAMS
FINANCIAL MARKET
FINANCIAL MARKETS
FINANCIAL MATTERS
FINANCIAL PRODUCT
FINANCIAL PRODUCTS
FINANCIAL REGULATOR
FINANCIAL REGULATORS
FINANCIAL SECTOR
FINANCIAL SERVICE
FINANCIAL SERVICE PROVIDERS
FINANCIAL SERVICES
FINANCIAL SERVICES INDUSTRY
FINANCIAL SERVICES REGULATION
FINANCIAL STABILITY
FINANCIAL SYSTEM
FINANCIAL TRANSACTIONS
FOREIGN CURRENCY
GENERAL PUBLIC
GOVERNMENT INTERVENTION
GREATER ACCESS
GUARANTORS
HOUSEHOLD FINANCE
HOUSEHOLDS
ID
ILLITERACY
INCOME
INCOME GROUP
INCOME LEVELS
INDEBTEDNESS
INEQUALITY
INFORMATION ASYMMETRIES
INSTITUTIONAL CAPACITY
INSURANCE
INSURANCE COMPANIES
INTEREST RATE
INTEREST RATES
INTERNATIONAL BANK
INVESTING
INVESTMENT COMPANIES
KEY CHALLENGE
LENDERS
LIABILITY
LIFE INSURANCE
LOAN
LOAN CONTRACT
LOAN REPAYMENT
LOAN TERMS
LOW INCOME
LOW-INCOME
LOW-INCOME INDIVIDUALS
MARKETING
MEDIUM ENTERPRISES
MICROFINANCE
MICROFINANCE INSTITUTIONS
MINIMUM BALANCE
MONEY LENDING
MORTGAGE
MORTGAGE CREDIT
MORTGAGE MARKET
MORTGAGES
NATIONAL BANK
OFFICE OF FAIR TRADING
OUTSTANDING BALANCE
OVERDRAFT
PAYMENT SERVICE
PAYMENT SERVICES
PENSION
PENSIONS
PROTECTION OF CONSUMER
PROTECTION OF CONSUMERS
PUBLIC POLICY
PUBLIC-PRIVATE PARTNERSHIPS
REMITTANCE
REPAYMENT
RESEARCH ASSISTANCE
RESERVE BANK
RETAIL CREDIT
RETAIL FINANCIAL MARKETS
RETAIL FINANCIAL SERVICES
RETIREMENT
RETIREMENT SAVINGS
RETIREMENT SAVINGS ACCOUNTS
SALARIES
SALE
SALES
SAVINGS
SAVINGS ACCOUNTS
SCAM
SECURITIES
SOLVENCY
STATE BANK
TOTAL COST
TRANSPARENCY OF INFORMATION
TYPES OF CONSUMER
UNEMPLOYMENT
UNION
UNREGULATED FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS
URBAN DEVELOPMENT
USURY
UTILITY BILLS
WAGES
WEB SITE
WITHDRAWAL
WITHDRAWAL FEES
WORTH
Ardic, Oya Pinar
Ibrahim, Joyce A.
Mylenko, Nataliya
Consumer Protection Laws and Regulations in Deposit and Loan Services : A Cross-Country Analysis with a New Data Set
description Consumer protection and financial literacy can contribute to improved efficiency, transparency, competition, and access in retail financial markets by reducing information asymmetries and power imbalances between providers and users of financial services. Financial consumer protection has gained significance in policy debates, especially since the onset of the financial crisis in 2008. This paper presents the results of a survey on consumer protection regulations in 142 countries. The findings indicate that although consumer protection legislation is in place in the majority of countries, these do not necessarily address the issues specific to financial services. There is some evidence that enforcement powers and monitoring capacity are limited in many countries, obstructing the effective implementation of the existing regulations. Furthermore, independent third party dispute resolution mechanisms are not widespread. The paper also compiles comprehensive information on laws and regulations relevant for consumer protection and discusses a number of challenges related to empirical analyses of financial consumer protection to enable cross-country comparison.
topic_facet ACCESS TO CREDIT
ACCESS TO FINANCE
ACCESS TO FINANCIAL SERVICES
ACCESSIBILITY
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENTS
ANNUAL PERCENTAGE RATE
ANTI-MONEY LAUNDERING
APR
ARREARS
ASYMMETRIC INFORMATION
ATM
ATMS
AVERAGE BALANCE
BANK ACCOUNTS
BANK CHARGES
BANK DEPOSIT
BANK DEPOSITS
BANK PRODUCT
BANKING ACCOUNT
BANKING SERVICES
BANKING SUPERVISION
BANKS
BASIC BANKING
BEHAVIORAL ECONOMICS
BIASES
BORROWER
BORROWING
BUSINESS LENDING
BUYERS
CALCULATION
CALCULATIONS
CAPITAL MARKET
CASH WITHDRAWALS
CHECKS
COLLECTIVE INVESTMENT SCHEMES
COMMERCIAL BANK
COMMERCIAL BANKS
COMMERCIAL TRANSACTIONS
CONSUMER
CONSUMER ACCESS
CONSUMER BEHAVIOR
CONSUMER COMPLAINTS
CONSUMER CREDIT
CONSUMER CREDIT PRODUCTS
CONSUMER FINANCE
CONSUMER LENDING
CONSUMER LOAN
CONSUMER LOANS
CONSUMER PROTECTION
CONSUMER PROTECTION LAW
CONSUMER PROTECTION LAWS
CONSUMER PROTECTION MEASURES
CONSUMER PROTECTIONS
CONSUMER RIGHTS
CONSUMERS
CONTRIBUTION
COST OF CREDIT
CREDIT ALLOCATIONS
CREDIT BUREAUS
CREDIT CARD
CREDIT CARD ISSUERS
CREDIT CARDS
CREDIT FACILITIES
CREDIT INFORMATION
CREDIT INFORMATION BUREAUS
CREDIT INSTITUTIONS
CREDIT LINE
CREDIT MARKET
CREDIT MARKETS
CREDIT PRODUCTS
CREDIT REPORTING
CREDIT TRANSACTIONS
CREDITOR
CREDITS
CURRENT ACCOUNTS
CUSTOMER SERVICE
DEBT
DEBT COLLECTION
DEBTORS
DEBTS
DEPOSIT
DEPOSIT ACCOUNT
DEPOSIT ACCOUNTS
DEPOSIT INSURANCE
DEPOSITOR
DEPOSITORS
DEPOSITS
DEVELOPING FINANCIAL MARKET
DISCLOSURE OF INFORMATION
DISCLOSURE REQUIREMENT
DISCLOSURE REQUIREMENTS
EARNINGS
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
ELECTRONIC BANKING
ELECTRONIC PAYMENTS
ENFORCEMENT MECHANISM
ENFORCEMENT MECHANISMS
EQUAL ACCESS
EXCESSIVE INTEREST RATES
FEDERAL RESERVE
FEDERAL RESERVE BANK
FINANCES
FINANCIAL ACCESS
FINANCIAL ACTIVITY
FINANCIAL ADVISERS
FINANCIAL COMPANIES
FINANCIAL CONCEPTS
FINANCIAL CONSUMER
FINANCIAL CONSUMERS
FINANCIAL CRISIS
FINANCIAL EDUCATION
FINANCIAL EXPERIENCES
FINANCIAL INSTITUTION
FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS
FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS
FINANCIAL LITERACY
FINANCIAL LITERACY PROGRAMS
FINANCIAL MARKET
FINANCIAL MARKETS
FINANCIAL MATTERS
FINANCIAL PRODUCT
FINANCIAL PRODUCTS
FINANCIAL REGULATOR
FINANCIAL REGULATORS
FINANCIAL SECTOR
FINANCIAL SERVICE
FINANCIAL SERVICE PROVIDERS
FINANCIAL SERVICES
FINANCIAL SERVICES INDUSTRY
FINANCIAL SERVICES REGULATION
FINANCIAL STABILITY
FINANCIAL SYSTEM
FINANCIAL TRANSACTIONS
FOREIGN CURRENCY
GENERAL PUBLIC
GOVERNMENT INTERVENTION
GREATER ACCESS
GUARANTORS
HOUSEHOLD FINANCE
HOUSEHOLDS
ID
ILLITERACY
INCOME
INCOME GROUP
INCOME LEVELS
INDEBTEDNESS
INEQUALITY
INFORMATION ASYMMETRIES
INSTITUTIONAL CAPACITY
INSURANCE
INSURANCE COMPANIES
INTEREST RATE
INTEREST RATES
INTERNATIONAL BANK
INVESTING
INVESTMENT COMPANIES
KEY CHALLENGE
LENDERS
LIABILITY
LIFE INSURANCE
LOAN
LOAN CONTRACT
LOAN REPAYMENT
LOAN TERMS
LOW INCOME
LOW-INCOME
LOW-INCOME INDIVIDUALS
MARKETING
MEDIUM ENTERPRISES
MICROFINANCE
MICROFINANCE INSTITUTIONS
MINIMUM BALANCE
MONEY LENDING
MORTGAGE
MORTGAGE CREDIT
MORTGAGE MARKET
MORTGAGES
NATIONAL BANK
OFFICE OF FAIR TRADING
OUTSTANDING BALANCE
OVERDRAFT
PAYMENT SERVICE
PAYMENT SERVICES
PENSION
PENSIONS
PROTECTION OF CONSUMER
PROTECTION OF CONSUMERS
PUBLIC POLICY
PUBLIC-PRIVATE PARTNERSHIPS
REMITTANCE
REPAYMENT
RESEARCH ASSISTANCE
RESERVE BANK
RETAIL CREDIT
RETAIL FINANCIAL MARKETS
RETAIL FINANCIAL SERVICES
RETIREMENT
RETIREMENT SAVINGS
RETIREMENT SAVINGS ACCOUNTS
SALARIES
SALE
SALES
SAVINGS
SAVINGS ACCOUNTS
SCAM
SECURITIES
SOLVENCY
STATE BANK
TOTAL COST
TRANSPARENCY OF INFORMATION
TYPES OF CONSUMER
UNEMPLOYMENT
UNION
UNREGULATED FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS
URBAN DEVELOPMENT
USURY
UTILITY BILLS
WAGES
WEB SITE
WITHDRAWAL
WITHDRAWAL FEES
WORTH
author Ardic, Oya Pinar
Ibrahim, Joyce A.
Mylenko, Nataliya
author_facet Ardic, Oya Pinar
Ibrahim, Joyce A.
Mylenko, Nataliya
author_sort Ardic, Oya Pinar
title Consumer Protection Laws and Regulations in Deposit and Loan Services : A Cross-Country Analysis with a New Data Set
title_short Consumer Protection Laws and Regulations in Deposit and Loan Services : A Cross-Country Analysis with a New Data Set
title_full Consumer Protection Laws and Regulations in Deposit and Loan Services : A Cross-Country Analysis with a New Data Set
title_fullStr Consumer Protection Laws and Regulations in Deposit and Loan Services : A Cross-Country Analysis with a New Data Set
title_full_unstemmed Consumer Protection Laws and Regulations in Deposit and Loan Services : A Cross-Country Analysis with a New Data Set
title_sort consumer protection laws and regulations in deposit and loan services : a cross-country analysis with a new data set
publishDate 2011-01-01
url http://www-wds.worldbank.org/external/default/main?menuPK=64187510&pagePK=64193027&piPK=64187937&theSitePK=523679&menuPK=64187510&searchMenuPK=64187283&siteName=WDS&entityID=000158349_20110118134022
https://hdl.handle.net/10986/3308
work_keys_str_mv AT ardicoyapinar consumerprotectionlawsandregulationsindepositandloanservicesacrosscountryanalysiswithanewdataset
AT ibrahimjoycea consumerprotectionlawsandregulationsindepositandloanservicesacrosscountryanalysiswithanewdataset
AT mylenkonataliya consumerprotectionlawsandregulationsindepositandloanservicesacrosscountryanalysiswithanewdataset
_version_ 1807156786717786112
spelling dig-okr-1098633082024-08-08T15:49:37Z Consumer Protection Laws and Regulations in Deposit and Loan Services : A Cross-Country Analysis with a New Data Set Ardic, Oya Pinar Ibrahim, Joyce A. Mylenko, Nataliya ACCESS TO CREDIT ACCESS TO FINANCE ACCESS TO FINANCIAL SERVICES ACCESSIBILITY ADVERTISEMENT ADVERTISEMENTS ANNUAL PERCENTAGE RATE ANTI-MONEY LAUNDERING APR ARREARS ASYMMETRIC INFORMATION ATM ATMS AVERAGE BALANCE BANK ACCOUNTS BANK CHARGES BANK DEPOSIT BANK DEPOSITS BANK PRODUCT BANKING ACCOUNT BANKING SERVICES BANKING SUPERVISION BANKS BASIC BANKING BEHAVIORAL ECONOMICS BIASES BORROWER BORROWING BUSINESS LENDING BUYERS CALCULATION CALCULATIONS CAPITAL MARKET CASH WITHDRAWALS CHECKS COLLECTIVE INVESTMENT SCHEMES COMMERCIAL BANK COMMERCIAL BANKS COMMERCIAL TRANSACTIONS CONSUMER CONSUMER ACCESS CONSUMER BEHAVIOR CONSUMER COMPLAINTS CONSUMER CREDIT CONSUMER CREDIT PRODUCTS CONSUMER FINANCE CONSUMER LENDING CONSUMER LOAN CONSUMER LOANS CONSUMER PROTECTION CONSUMER PROTECTION LAW CONSUMER PROTECTION LAWS CONSUMER PROTECTION MEASURES CONSUMER PROTECTIONS CONSUMER RIGHTS CONSUMERS CONTRIBUTION COST OF CREDIT CREDIT ALLOCATIONS CREDIT BUREAUS CREDIT CARD CREDIT CARD ISSUERS CREDIT CARDS CREDIT FACILITIES CREDIT INFORMATION CREDIT INFORMATION BUREAUS CREDIT INSTITUTIONS CREDIT LINE CREDIT MARKET CREDIT MARKETS CREDIT PRODUCTS CREDIT REPORTING CREDIT TRANSACTIONS CREDITOR CREDITS CURRENT ACCOUNTS CUSTOMER SERVICE DEBT DEBT COLLECTION DEBTORS DEBTS DEPOSIT DEPOSIT ACCOUNT DEPOSIT ACCOUNTS DEPOSIT INSURANCE DEPOSITOR DEPOSITORS DEPOSITS DEVELOPING FINANCIAL MARKET DISCLOSURE OF INFORMATION DISCLOSURE REQUIREMENT DISCLOSURE REQUIREMENTS EARNINGS ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT ELECTRONIC BANKING ELECTRONIC PAYMENTS ENFORCEMENT MECHANISM ENFORCEMENT MECHANISMS EQUAL ACCESS EXCESSIVE INTEREST RATES FEDERAL RESERVE FEDERAL RESERVE BANK FINANCES FINANCIAL ACCESS FINANCIAL ACTIVITY FINANCIAL ADVISERS FINANCIAL COMPANIES FINANCIAL CONCEPTS FINANCIAL CONSUMER FINANCIAL CONSUMERS FINANCIAL CRISIS FINANCIAL EDUCATION FINANCIAL EXPERIENCES FINANCIAL INSTITUTION FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS FINANCIAL LITERACY FINANCIAL LITERACY PROGRAMS FINANCIAL MARKET FINANCIAL MARKETS FINANCIAL MATTERS FINANCIAL PRODUCT FINANCIAL PRODUCTS FINANCIAL REGULATOR FINANCIAL REGULATORS FINANCIAL SECTOR FINANCIAL SERVICE FINANCIAL SERVICE PROVIDERS FINANCIAL SERVICES FINANCIAL SERVICES INDUSTRY FINANCIAL SERVICES REGULATION FINANCIAL STABILITY FINANCIAL SYSTEM FINANCIAL TRANSACTIONS FOREIGN CURRENCY GENERAL PUBLIC GOVERNMENT INTERVENTION GREATER ACCESS GUARANTORS HOUSEHOLD FINANCE HOUSEHOLDS ID ILLITERACY INCOME INCOME GROUP INCOME LEVELS INDEBTEDNESS INEQUALITY INFORMATION ASYMMETRIES INSTITUTIONAL CAPACITY INSURANCE INSURANCE COMPANIES INTEREST RATE INTEREST RATES INTERNATIONAL BANK INVESTING INVESTMENT COMPANIES KEY CHALLENGE LENDERS LIABILITY LIFE INSURANCE LOAN LOAN CONTRACT LOAN REPAYMENT LOAN TERMS LOW INCOME LOW-INCOME LOW-INCOME INDIVIDUALS MARKETING MEDIUM ENTERPRISES MICROFINANCE MICROFINANCE INSTITUTIONS MINIMUM BALANCE MONEY LENDING MORTGAGE MORTGAGE CREDIT MORTGAGE MARKET MORTGAGES NATIONAL BANK OFFICE OF FAIR TRADING OUTSTANDING BALANCE OVERDRAFT PAYMENT SERVICE PAYMENT SERVICES PENSION PENSIONS PROTECTION OF CONSUMER PROTECTION OF CONSUMERS PUBLIC POLICY PUBLIC-PRIVATE PARTNERSHIPS REMITTANCE REPAYMENT RESEARCH ASSISTANCE RESERVE BANK RETAIL CREDIT RETAIL FINANCIAL MARKETS RETAIL FINANCIAL SERVICES RETIREMENT RETIREMENT SAVINGS RETIREMENT SAVINGS ACCOUNTS SALARIES SALE SALES SAVINGS SAVINGS ACCOUNTS SCAM SECURITIES SOLVENCY STATE BANK TOTAL COST TRANSPARENCY OF INFORMATION TYPES OF CONSUMER UNEMPLOYMENT UNION UNREGULATED FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS URBAN DEVELOPMENT USURY UTILITY BILLS WAGES WEB SITE WITHDRAWAL WITHDRAWAL FEES WORTH Consumer protection and financial literacy can contribute to improved efficiency, transparency, competition, and access in retail financial markets by reducing information asymmetries and power imbalances between providers and users of financial services. Financial consumer protection has gained significance in policy debates, especially since the onset of the financial crisis in 2008. This paper presents the results of a survey on consumer protection regulations in 142 countries. The findings indicate that although consumer protection legislation is in place in the majority of countries, these do not necessarily address the issues specific to financial services. There is some evidence that enforcement powers and monitoring capacity are limited in many countries, obstructing the effective implementation of the existing regulations. Furthermore, independent third party dispute resolution mechanisms are not widespread. The paper also compiles comprehensive information on laws and regulations relevant for consumer protection and discusses a number of challenges related to empirical analyses of financial consumer protection to enable cross-country comparison. 2012-03-19T17:59:58Z 2012-03-19T17:59:58Z 2011-01-01 http://www-wds.worldbank.org/external/default/main?menuPK=64187510&pagePK=64193027&piPK=64187937&theSitePK=523679&menuPK=64187510&searchMenuPK=64187283&siteName=WDS&entityID=000158349_20110118134022 https://hdl.handle.net/10986/3308 English Policy Research working paper ; no. WPS 5536 CC BY 3.0 IGO http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/igo/ World Bank application/pdf text/plain